Can you tell the difference.......

@Barb42 (4214)
United States
February 11, 2009 1:07pm CST
Do you think you could tell the difference in someone being themselves or play acting? Here on the Internet, we don't really 'know' a person as we would were we friends living in their hometown. Unless we have met the person, we usually take them on face value. 'Fess up! Most of us believe what we read here. Some people have admitted they never tell their age, so therefore, they aren't truthful. I don't mind people knowing my age because that is just what I am. But, if I wanted to, I could piece together a story that would intrigue the most suspicious person on earth and some would still believe what I had to say. There are people out there that think everyone is honest because they are. I am a very honest person; therefore I don't lie. But I do know that there are some people who live lying as if it were the gospel truth! They have become immune to their own lies and think that the lies are the truth. It is their truth - not the real life they live. I've always thought that lying would catch up with me one day and I had rather be truthful as to have to handle the outcome of lying. I want people's perception of me to be exactly as I am. Oh, I know some will always perceive us to be something entirely different than we are, but that's okay. But, if you try to deceive by portraying yourself falsely here on Mylot or the Internet, who is the wiser?
2 people like this
13 responses
@katsmeow1213 (28716)
• United States
11 Feb 09
When I was younger I used to live a lie. I lied to everyone around me except for those who knew me best. I mostly lied to people at school. I wanted to sound more interesting than I was, and sometimes would create fantastic stories. Some of the kids I knew in school thought I was in a serious relationship with a much older baseball player, because at the time, that's the sort of life I wished I'd had. Well my lies did catch up with me. I realized I was telling different people different lies, and figured eventually those lies would be found out, although I don't recall if they ever were, I don't think people were as interested as I thought they were. Anyways, I haven't lied in years now. I mean maybe the occasional fib or something, but for the most part I am what I say I am. I no longer try to make myself sound more interesting, because I'm interesting enough as I am, and to be honest, nobody else is really all that interested in hearing my fairy tales. If someone else on here is lying, well, it depends on the story. I think if it were something completely fantastic, like if you tried to tell me you were actually Britney Spears, yeah, I wouldn't believe that for a second. But you really can't tell, and why would it matter? I don't care if you're 100 or 15, I'm not THAT interested in your personal life, so there's no reason to try to lie about it. Know what I mean?
2 people like this
@Barb42 (4214)
• United States
11 Feb 09
I do like to know with whom I am talking. But to know all their personal history is nothing to me. I want people to be likable. They don't have to have the best life of the century, be rich, or know lots of celebrities. In other words, be themselves. We don't have to make up things to be interesting. When I was a teenager, too many people knew me for me to ever lie about anything. I had lots of girlfriends and they all knew all about me. To lie would have just made things worse. I guess I've just always been honest and would love for everyone else to be that way, but I know they aren't. The worse thing to me, though, is for someone to lie that I know personally isn't telling the truth,and for them to do it in front of me! I feel like calling them down! I also retain facts about things happening, and it makes me angry to have someone lie about a situation and think I wouldn't recall what happened then. I've seen people in real life interject themselves into a situation when I knew they weren't even there - they just remember being told about it and they made it into their own story.
1 person likes this
@ravend (658)
• Malta
11 Feb 09
People lie on the internet because their reality is harsh to face and admit, its good to make people believe that we have a life different than the one we do. :)
2 people like this
@Barb42 (4214)
• United States
11 Feb 09
I had rather people know me as who I am than believe a lie about me. We don't have to give the entire details of our life on the Internet to be truthful. And we don't have to make up lies to be liked. I always feel secure in the knowledge that I don't have to conjure up a lie to cover up another lie I might have told you. Life might be harsh, but we don't have to talk about that. There are lots of subjects to explore without getting over into lying, I think. That's just my opinion.
1 person likes this
• United States
11 Feb 09
I can not tell the difference right away. However, those people who are here for over 1 year usually give themselves away by changing their cover story. I admit to being surprised at who some of the phonies turned out to be. No, I won't discuss who I think is not real, they would just deny it. As for myself, my name is easy to obtain from my website, and I am who I say.
1 person likes this
@Barb42 (4214)
• United States
11 Feb 09
You are right, red. But, as time goes along and they say different things, you begin to get the full picture of who they really are. I would never confront any of them, but we know they exist. As for me, I'm like you. I have a blog and a website that's been around for years and people could easily find out who I am and what I'm about. It's all spelled out there in black and white, if they want to go find it. I don't hide behind anonymous like so many do now days.
• Regina, Saskatchewan
11 Feb 09
This is actually more of a complicated subject than it first appears. For example, I'm sure that many people here perceive ME as being slightly crazed and very funny. I'm not crazy in any way, and offline I'm not nearly as funny. Does that mean I am portraying myself as someone I'm not? No. I'm a writer, and it comes easily to me to write the way I do. It's a side of me that comes out more in the written word than the spoken word. We are many faceted as people. An arena like mylot brings out a facet of me that 'real life' doesn't do as easily. Other places on the net where I write, you wouldn't even know it was me. But those are places where my 'playful' side are not the purpose of those sites to bring out. Again does that make me dishonest in what I write? Again no. It is just another side of my personality, my interests or my beliefs. To be pigeonholed as this or that kind of person is confining and actually dishonest on the part of the pigeonholer. But no matter what I write or where, I believe there is a strong vein of the core person I am that always comes through and that's what 'readers' of our words need to see in order to keep them from jumping to erroneous conclusions of our honesty or worth.
1 person likes this
@Barb42 (4214)
• United States
11 Feb 09
Sparks, thinking back, I should have said 'living a lie on the net' rather than play acting. I don't think your writing is conveying anything other than you are a writer. I write, too, although a different style. But you let people know the true side of you and you are blunt when you get upset. People who lie can't remember the last lie they told and it's hard to keep anything straight. Maybe those people are just living out a fantasy; who knows. Your 'story telling' is like a fiction book, has nothing to do with lying about your own life. I love your story telling; it's intriguing, funny, and exciting. I don't know enough about you to know how you are in real life, since I've never met you. But your personality comes out in your writing and in your emails. I write on a blog and my website, as well, and I don't talk there as I do here. But I never lie. My blog has all kinds of subjects that I am compassionate about and you'll find the real me in them, as well. I believe it would be the same way with you.
@Humbug25 (12540)
11 Feb 09
Hey there Barb42 I am one of those people who believes everybody on here is telling me as it is. I too do not lie about my age or who I am, what you read is what you get with me. I am too old to try and keep up pretenses or to play any games. I just don't have it in me to be dishonest like some people. I think a lot of my friends on here would be shocked if they heard that really I was an 18 year old guy from Australia!!!
1 person likes this
@Barb42 (4214)
• United States
11 Feb 09
Okay, Humbug, I'd have to ask first how old you were when you came to mylot to have 3290 posts at age 18. I know what you mean. I think it takes a little out of a person when you lie. I'm not saying come spill your guts here on mylot but be honest with people. You don't have to answer questions you don't feel are appropriate for you to answer to be honest. Just tell them it's off limits. I'm too old, too, to keep up with the pretenses if I were to claim I was something I am not. It just doesn't come easy for me to make up stories.
@Barb42 (4214)
• United States
12 Feb 09
Nancy, I agree with you to a point. If you read a person's comments and discussions day after day, you get a good sense of where the person is coming from. And you can also detect whether they are truthful or not. They will say something that didn't set with something they've said before - in other words they lied and forgot what they had said. I haven't run across anyone here like that, but I've heard others talking about it. I don't dwell on it since the people I talk with from day to day all seem to be themselves. However, until we meet them in person, we probably will never know for sure.
@Nancy312 (282)
• China
12 Feb 09
To be honest,i can't tell the difference from people being themselves or acting on the net.After all,net is a vitual world,we do not know their talks are from their true heart or not.Although ,with the advanced technology nowadays,people can meet,talk and play games with each other easily from different countries for one topic or interesting.We are still not clearly about their characteristics and temper ,etc. Even in our realistic world,people always make friends by their first impression,then get on well with each other,then with their long time contact,they will familiar with each other. For me,i always be careful to make friends,espacially to make true friends.
@cynthiann (18602)
• Jamaica
11 Feb 09
Hey Barb, When you get to be as old as I am you do not lie. do you know why? It is because we would not remember the lies LOL. I am honest and tell the truth - not just because I try so hard to walk the talk as a committed Christian. Some people have questioned my posts but all these things that I have posted to do with my family are true. I have led a very odd and life as an adult in a third world country. to qualify that I should have said - in the bush, in a third world country. I came from college in London to growing bananas in the Caribbean and living on an isolated farm behind God's back. I could never be false about myself. Here I am girl. Warts and all. Blessings
1 person likes this
@Barb42 (4214)
• United States
11 Feb 09
I hear you, Cynthiann! I don't know how old you are, but I'm way up there, too. I learned in my EARLY days that honest is the best policy. Lying would never have set well with my Mother, especially! I taught those same things to my children. Always be honest and you'll never have to figure out who you told the last lie to, or what you told. You can only recall the truth! Sounds like you have been all around, and done it with the truth! Good for you!
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
13 Feb 09
No, I can't tell and if people are like me they have many different facets to their personality and so we can be different people sometimes. Of course we are who we are but knowing another utterly and completely is difficult in real life so on the Net, I think it might be really hard. Then again, I think if a person has a stable healthy life and lifestyle they might be easier to get to know. So, while I agree that some people role play, I don't necessarily think they are being dishonest and trying to mislead people. I also think there are some who do just that. I've also seen people who claim to be good and kind and loving attack other members with amazing ferociousness. They are easy to pick....lol... and be wary of.
@Jezebella (1446)
• United States
6 Mar 09
On the internet it is hard to tell if someone is genuinely being themselves or acting to be someone else. It is hard to determine who is who and what their personality it really like unless you met them in person. I am like you and I don't really lie. I tend to not tell certain things, for the fact that it is the internet. But I could never lie.
@syankee525 (6261)
• United States
12 Feb 09
with people on the net, you don't give too much information nor do i get close them just for that reason. but there is some i do chat or email with on a regualr bases, that i have known for years. but it's still like ok well. but when it comes to people in person i've learn to read people. so i often i can figure it they are a big act, or lying about things
@reichiru (748)
• Canada
12 Feb 09
I don't like lying much, and I would usually try not to. Only time when I would actually "play-act" is when I'm upset about something and try to be cheerful and not let other people notice. But then it's because I'm having my own problems and want to deal with it myself, that's why I would do that. Otherwise I try to be as honest as possible, I find that if you tell too many lies you'll get yourself caught up in a web and therefore won't know what to do in the end when you're found out. And that doesn't exactly appeal to me as a very interesting way to go. I don't lie about my age, I'm still in high school and don't mind people knowing that (heck, it's even on my blog!), but as for personal life details, I usually wouldn't spill that much on the Internet, I still like to keep some things private for real life. But as for actually telling the difference in someone else, no, I can't. I'm highly gullible and am prone to believing what I read/see (with the exception of what I hear from this one friend who's habit is to tell outrageous lies), so I can't make judgments until I get to know a person really well.
• Philippines
12 Feb 09
we cant really tell the difference. in internet someone might want to have the image of what he really wants him to be but its the other way around. but sometimes there are people who use the internet to express themselves and gain friends and learn from others. it really depends on the intention of that person.
• China
12 Feb 09
the better you know someone, the easier for you to tell if he is lying. It is very hard to tell if someone's lying here on mylot. lying is tiring, once you make a lie, you will have to make more lies to cover it. I don't lying unless it is very necessary.
@Barb42 (4214)
• United States
12 Feb 09
You are right. But, the more people lie, the easier it is to catch them in one. It's so hard to remember all the lies you have told and not tell the wrong person the wrong lie. I'm not worrying about people here on mylot since I don't know anyone here enough to know if they are lying. I trust that the ones I talk with the most from day to day are not lying.
@gelay07 (588)
• Philippines
12 Feb 09
i must admit during my younger years in the internet i did hide my true self but later on as the years passed by and i get older i tend to be more realistic on dealing with myself as well people in the internet but sometimes no matter how sensitive you are to know whether the person you are dealing with is telling the truth or not still it boils down to how much you trust the person. lying has his pros and cons i must say. when you hide your true identity the person tends to get more interested to know you better because of the falls perception you present to that person but when you decide to come out in the open, that's when things changed, the person tend to despise you already and you should face the consequence you made for doing such act.