If you come to live in the US should you be required to learn English?
By shoreboy31
@shoreboy31 (1433)
United States
November 9, 2006 4:47pm CST
OK, the whole question is: If you come to live and work in the US should you be required to prove a practical knowledge of English before being eligible for a green card?
51 responses
@passsionpants (76)
• Australia
14 Nov 06
yes!yes! yes! as should be in all countrys
1 person likes this
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
14 Nov 06
thank you...I thoroughly agree...at least about the part of learning the country's native tongue before being allowed employment or legal residential status there...no matter what country you go to...
@jeepluver (111)
• United States
13 Nov 06
If you are going to live in the U.S. you should have to speak it's language. Which is English.
1 person likes this
@caribe (2465)
• United States
11 Nov 06
I moved to Nicaragua and I have what is the equivalent of a what is a green card in the U.S. and they didn't tell me I had to learn Spanish to live here and I know that the same is true in Costa Rica. I am working on my Spanish but I find it very difficult and English is a much, much more difficult language to learn so if they are trying to learn then that is good.
@caribe (2465)
• United States
11 Nov 06
I feel that they should be trying to learn English if they are in the U.S. There are a lot of classes set up specifically for that purpose. On the other hand it is not a bad thing for anyone to be bilingual and the younger you learn a second language, the easier it is to learn. Most of the those peoples children have totally embraced the English language and many second generation persons no longer even know Spanish. I don't think that is good either. It is great for them to be bilingual.
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
11 Nov 06
Oh I agree it's OK to be bilingual, I'd understand learning spanish only if all the immigrants were spanish speaking people, but they are coming from lots of nations, and they all want us to conform to them...bilingual is OK, but multi-lingual is truly not possible for everyone...
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
11 Nov 06
The problem is that they are coming here and aren't even trying to learn..they are expecting us to learn spanish for them...
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
11 Nov 06
So you're saying that because people from other countries come here, that we have to teach our children Spanish, German, French, Italian, Russian, Afrikaans, etc? Where does that leave time for english, math, science, or anything else?
@mirage108 (3402)
• United States
10 Nov 06
Yes I think anyone who comes to the US to work and live should at least be able to use the english language and yes before they get a green card, they can have an option to stay and work while they are learning, and not be a pre-requeset before comming to the US
1 person likes this
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
10 Nov 06
Thanx...I really feel the same...My girlfriend's ex is Italian, and cannot read nor write english but he can speak it, and his girlfriend is Guatemalan, and knows no english. They are trying to take custody of my girlfriend's 5yr old daughter, yet are not able to help her with her schoolwork. They even make the child watch bi-lingual childrens programming (Dora the Explorer) in order to make her learn spanish (Italian and spanish are very similar) so she can communicate with his girlfriend. I feel it's the girlfriend who should learn english.
@mommyshomeincome (17)
• United States
13 Nov 06
YES, I think it should be a definate. I think anyone coming to live and work in the US, should have to take a test on the English language in order to get a green card or citizenship.
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
13 Nov 06
Well we do test them as far as citizenship is concerned, it's definitely a requirement for it, but so many of them come here and get the green card without knowing english, and then never apply for citizenship. The reason being is because we offer green-card holders all the same benefits as a citizen without having to know the languange.
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
13 Nov 06
Well we do test them as far as citizenship is concerned, it's definitely a requirement for it, but so many of them come here and get the green card without knowing english, and then never apply for citizenship. The reason being is because we offer green-card holders all the same benefits as a citizen without having to know the languange.
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
13 Nov 06
Well we do test them as far as citizenship is concerned, it's definitely a requirement for it, but so many of them come here and get the green card without knowing english, and then never apply for citizenship. The reason being is because we offer green-card holders all the same benefits as a citizen without having to know the languange.
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
13 Nov 06
wow, multi-lingual...that's always helpful when travelling
@catwoman1459 (2971)
• United States
13 Nov 06
yes most definitely. I would not think about moving to another country if I could not speak the language. I like to talk and communicate with people.I would feel lost.
@forfein (2507)
•
13 Nov 06
Thanks for asking this question!!
I have rated you a + for it!
The reason I have read all the posts is to see how many yes and how many no you got.
Surprised me only a few said NO
OF COURSE it should be a requirement!
The Political Correct Crowd here in the UK are making an issue of it!
LISTEN................
"If in Rome, do as the Romans do"My wife and I have a house in Turkey, and maybe going to live there soon.
I am learning Turkish, so that I can communicate with the Turks who are in our village.
1. Because I want to.
2. It is difficult to buy loafs of bread if you cannot.
"Ekmek istiyorum lutfen" (I want a loaf of bread!)
3. It allows me to integrate with the Turks when they want and when I want.
My wife speaks Russian as her native tongue, and it took her ages to learn English. But like she says, she is living here and it is natural for her to speak English.
We are thinking of getting her a British Passport, which means that she will now have to take a test to proof that she knows about the English Culture.
It is imperative that people know about the Country that they have chosen to adopt as the place where they want to live.
Like for example................
Any one here know what "Bonfire Night" is?? on 5th November?
@BeachBaby (815)
• United States
13 Nov 06
Yes.. I believe you should know english before coming here.. it makes it all easier on everyone and they would expect the same of us if we came to thier country to live right??
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
11 Nov 06
Yes..I just learned today from my cousin that they are starting in Kindergarten now...her 5 yr old daughter is being taught it now...
@xvandyx (121)
• United States
11 Nov 06
Are you serious? I didn't know that they are teaching SPANISH in kinder now. That is crazy...is it mandatory?? When I went to kinder my class was bilingual because my mother chose that for me so that I would be capable of speaking 2 languages. But it wasn't mandatory.
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
11 Nov 06
From what I'm told it's part of the public school curriculum...kinda shocked me when I heard it...
@health4uandpets (259)
• United States
13 Nov 06
Yes! I live off the Mexico border in Arizona and there are people that work at our Walmart who speak no English. It is very frustrating when you walk up to ask a question and they say "No Habla English" Since it is a service industry you should have to speak English because I have had to walk up to 3 or 4 workers trying to find an english speaking working in the United States.
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
13 Nov 06
That's horrible, but I do know how you feel, I've experienced the same thing in Border towns in TX when I was a truck driver
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
13 Nov 06
English is already the universal language when it comes to Air Traffic Control, and other things
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
13 Nov 06
I used to visit Laredo, TX quite often and if you didn't know spanish there you were in a world of hurt. You couldn't even shop at Wal-mart
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
13 Nov 06
Very true, now if only we can get our government to see it this way!!!
@mattmc419 (361)
• United States
13 Nov 06
Yes, I think anyone that comes here should have to learn English. If you moved to another country, they would not put up signs and rewrite everything in English just to make it easy on you. They keep their language and live their lives, and you would have to adapt around them and learn their language.
Here in the United States, we over cater to immigrants, and wherever you look everything is in English, and then right below it 10 other languages. People don't learn English for one reason - they can survive without knowing it. And we only play into their hands by providing them with everything they had back home. If it was made into law that they had to learn it, or if everything was in English only, they would have no choice.
@cash365days (420)
• United States
13 Nov 06
spanish will also do. If you know english you will do better.
Green card application is available in spanish also .. :)
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
13 Nov 06
The only reason the application is in spanish is for those who refuse to learn our language when they come here.
@lizziehear (6)
• United States
13 Nov 06
Yes if your going to live here learn the language first. So when you arive in our country you speek our language...
@shoreboy31 (1433)
• United States
13 Nov 06
Hmmm...now theres an idea...give them a test at the border...no english, no entry!!