A little bit of sugar provides lasting pain relief for babies: study

Canada
March 3, 2009 11:38pm CST
[b]"Sugar has a calming effect on babies that lasts beyond 10 minutes, new Toronto research suggests. Researchers at the Hospital for Sick Children, the University of Toronto, Mount Sinai Hospital and York University studied 240 babies and their reactions after half were given sugar and the other half were given a placebo following a painful medical procedure. The research involved measuring the "pain responses" of the babies during a diaper change after a blood test, including recording their heart rate and facial reactions, such as squeezing their eyes shut and bulging their brows. The findings, published Monday in the journal Pediatrics, determined that while babies cried during a diaper change after a blood test, giving them a bit of sugar after the needle appeared to dull the pain. The majority of the babies in both the group given the sugar and the group given a placebo were given a diaper change within an hour of the blood test. The infants given table sugar, or sucrose, had lower pain scores than the infants given placebos. "This study demonstrates than when sucrose is used for pain, it also reduces infant responses to caregiving procedures performed afterward," the study reads. Dr. Anna Taddio, an adjunct scientist and pharmacist at the Hospital for Sick Children and an associate pharmacy professor at the University of Toronto, said in a news release that the research shows the benefits of sugar extend beyond "the painful event" to "other potentially uncomfortable procedures." Taddio said the study is the first to determine the effects of sugar on routine care performed after painful procedures. A previous study by the same research team found that sugar reduces infant responses during painful procedures. That research was published last summer in the Canadian Medical Association Journal. Sugar was considered to have benefits for procedures that last up to 10 minutes, but until the study published Monday, research had not yet determined its effect beyond the 10- minute mark. "Based on the results of the study, sucrose may be recommended for caregiving procedures that follow painful events," Taddio said. Taddio said more studies are needed to determine why sugar can relieve pain and calm infants, and to look at the effectiveness of treating babies with sugar in other situations."[/b] http://www.cbc.ca/technology/story/2009/03/03/sugar-calm.html Wow so I guess when people say sugar makes kids hyper we can now tell them they are not totally right LOL Would you use sugar as a pain reliever?
2 responses
@snowcat46 (2322)
• United States
4 Mar 09
I don't quite agree with this. Remember Mary Poppins? "A spoonful of sugar makes the medicine go down." Babies cry when they don't like something. They do like sugar. By giving them sugar, the doctors are distracting them from the unpleasantness happening elsewhere. It's a standard trick mothers have used over the centuries. (Always did say women were smarter than scientists!) Giving kids sugar, especially when they're older, to distract them from unpleasantness can lead to a lot of problems. Like obesity! I'm a female, and I have a tendency to look for chocolate whenever I'm stressed. Not a good thing to instill in kids! They already have most of those problems! Yes?
• Canada
4 Mar 09
I do tend to agree with what you have said and on the same token the main reason I would not give it to them for pain is because if it were a true pain killer it would be in the pharmacy area. I tend to stick to what I know and I know tylenol works.
@suzzy3 (8341)
4 Mar 09
Only gave sugar water when painful screaming once in a blue moon,beleave me if a baby is in pain it won't be fobbed off by a nice taste sugar works.Then why did they stop crying afterwards,if that was true they would cry all the time so they can get it, babies are not silly they are brighter than us.
1 person likes this
@suzzy3 (8341)
4 Mar 09
Always gave mine sugar water if they had a stomache upset or constipated.That was over thirty two years ago whats new about this.We were told we must not give it when my third child was born supposed to rot the gums,all three of mine had wonderful teeth and bones as strong as you can get.My third son who had sugar water no matter what they said, if it worked I used it.Is fifteen been going to the dentist since he was six months old and never even had a filling perfect teeth.All these experts make me laugh why don't they ask mothers what they have been doing it for years.They did not have to spend all that money they could have asked me for nothing.
1 person likes this
• Canada
5 Mar 09
Thank you for sharing this with us skeptics. The government seems to want to spend the money rather than ask questions. They don't seem to want to help other areas that need the money more. If the government did a lot more asking and a lot less spending our countries would probably be thriving better.