whos your favroite American Idole judge?

Simon is my favorite too! I usually agree with everything he says lol

um i think paula is she is always nice even if the singers are not good.

I would choose Randy also. He seems to see the personality of each contestant and knows how to answer in a way that will compliment them even if his answer is a need for improvement.

Well I have to say Randy. Because he is soft hearted and soft spoken and him and Paula gives everyone a second chance and he tells them what good they did in a song and what they need to work on but he does it gently. Not just that it was awful because they messed up a line or two up or sung off key for a second or tell they did all good and get their hopes up so Randy is my choice.

Simon hands down. He is not afraid to tell it like it is. And most of the time I agree 100% with him.

paula, but simon makes me laugh, he's not my fave cause he can be too mean.

simon...