Do you like the new top 11 and the new rule on American Idol?

I think that it is a good new rule, Because the year Chris was voted off It was a mistake, and he should have won that year. I believe that it was people thought that he was going to make it so they did not vote for him. even though he has been doing really good. and i agree that the ones that went home were the weakest out of the group. My favorites are Adam, Allison, and Danny. I think they are going to make it through to the top.

well... i'll swap michael sarver for jorge... but that said... i'm already ok with the result...

I like the top 11 and I have so many that I consider my favorites. I love Scott,Danny,Adam,and Michael. They are all so talented in their own way and I would love to see any of them win this competition. I am not sure that I like this new rule as it seems that it gives the judges better control over the outcome of the season. I think Lil Rounds would be one of the ones that they would save as they seem to really like her and so I don't see them letting her go home if she is voted off. However, I think that she tries to act like Fantasia too much and I don't like that.

I think the new rule is good sort of. It will save the person, but then the following week 2 people have to go. Most likely all it will get the person with the lowest votes one extra week, it could work out for them as it could just be because of bad song choices, but the competition is so stiff this year and there are so many good singers this year, it might be good to just let the peices fall where they may. I guess I am not really sure how the new rule will pan out. I do really like the top 11 this year. I think there are some amazing singers this year.

In regards to your question... Last week, I was almost 100% it was going to be Anoop and Jorge who were voted off. Anoop must have a huge fan base back in Chapel Hill (it is a music town, after all). I think the save is a good thing but I worry that they might not use it until the last week possible, and then save someone who doesn't deserve to be in the Top 5. Or worse, not use it at all. When Ryan introduced it he mentioned Tamyra Gray, Jennifer Hudson, Michael Johns and Chris Daughtry all might have been saved by this, had it been around when they were voted off but only Jennifer and Michael would have benefited, the other two were in the top 5 of their respective seasons. As for making the performers sing while the judges deliberated - they've always performed one final time after getting voted off. This wasn't any different other than there was one more step involved. My favorite is probably one of the girls. I have kind of laid out a top 5 in my head already, which includes Danny, Adam, Megan Joy, Alexis and Alison, and I really like all of them. All five of them are very much their own performer with a unique style, a unique voice and a lot of presence. Megan Joy sounds a lot like one of my very favorite female vocalists, Zooey Deschanel, so she gets a ton of brownie points for that. Alexis is too darling for words and Alison is freaking impressive for her age, not to mention she reminds me a little of Hayley Williams (mostly in her look, but a little in her voice) and I love Hayley Williams. Lil Rounds annoys the hell out of me. She reminds me a lot of Fantasia Barrino and I wanted to throw my television when, week after week after week the single mom with the forced, unnatural soprano voice kept not being voted off. AND THEN SHE WON!!!!! I really wanted to engage in random acts of violence at that point.

i hate the new rule America vote and that is it end of story. They even used a por example because they said the person could only saved up to 5. Daughtey was booted on final four. but does that even matter if you are good you do not need to win American idol, Kelli Picker, Daughtry, Clay Aiken, Jennifer Hudson, are all successful. Winners like Taylor Hicks and Rubeun Studdard have had minor success. Thanks for bring up the topic. This rule is wrong for whatever reason the person does not get enough votes it is over, not everybody wins, not everyone get a trophy, and we are keeping score. This is not pre-school soccer this is American Idol

I didn't see it last night but did dvr it. I did see that Jasmine and Jorge were sent home. I can see Jasmine not making it. Her voice wasn't at powerful as the others. I do think that Anoop was horrible this week and Jorge is was much better than Anoop. Even though I did like Anoop, he wasn't that great and had a bad song choice. I have to watch now to see the new changes and how it all played out.

I didn't like how Simon told Jorge.."NO" and nothing more...I think he deserved more than that. He made it to the top 13 for goodness sake....he acted like he was a lo count talent who walked in off the street to audition. I also do not like the favortism the judges show to certain people....like if a good person comes up they go on and on and on about their performance and then the person that follows if you know they arent on the favorite list of especially Simons...he tells well go ahead and try but you are screwed and you can't out do that performance...not exactly in those words but that is the meaning and that is not right. As far as the new rule...I think it is a good one because if they truely have talent like some of the past one that have went on to become famous then they should have opportunity to have another chance.

i haven't watched in years. i loved daughtry and he is doing well which i like. i think i stopped watching the year jordan sparks won. it just started going downhill to me. between watching paula drool over every guy and people who couldn't sing moving on, i promised myself i wasn't going to get hooked into it. i heard about kaynye performing. i am confused by that- he can't sing?!

I don't think the new save rule is fair. I think there are 3 girls and 3 guys who are really strong. The others will probably drop off and nobody will care, except for the people on that site vote for the worst. The rule doesn't seem fair. The ones who get voted off will either sink into obscurity, or they will make it big from someone seeing them perform on the show. If all the fans remember to vote for their favorites, there shouldn't be a problem. After all, the name is American Idol, not paula idol or simon idol or randy idol or kara idol. We get to choose!

I dont care about that rules for me rules are made to be broken..XDD