Led Zeppelin VS. Guns N' Roses!!!

Both are great groups... of course older now. I still love to listen to their music here.

I love GnR, but Led Zeppelin is a better band musically, they had a chemistry that I think if GnR would have followed, they would have been alot more successful, especially going into the 90's, but Led Zep all the way!!

I'm not surprised to see that nobody chose gnr. Led Zeppelin is the clear winner here as far as I'm concerned too. I heard (actually read) a comment by Percy, he said. "It is not that we are the best, it is that we are just so much better than whoever is number two". I love this comment, and use it often! It certainly applies here to this discussion rating an average rock band to the mighty Zeppelin.

It's Led Zep man. Jimmy Page is the greatest gutiar player for me. They can make a song start in one direction and end on another. They're just so dynamic in making music. Page and Plant is like the Lennon and McCartney of the 70's.

Led Zeppelin with out a doubt while i love both bands. GnR is in some ways a one trick pony. yea they got the hard rock thing down but they let the high of rock take over and they lost sight of what is real. led zeppelin not only excelled in rock but were able to transcend folk blues jazz bluegrass and even include many orchestral elements to their songs. with GnR yea they had slash but for they most part they had very basic songs due to very basic musicians. but zeppelin had 4 amazing musicians in their own right and put together they were able to truly shine and create original thought provoking music.

Although they are both great bands, it has to be Zeppelin. Zeppelin are one of my favorite bands after all, never heard a song that I didn't like and are just brilliant. and even though I love Slash I think Page is a much better guitarist.

Led Zeppelin, No Question. But personally im not the biggest fan of either band, but their both good.