Do you think Peyton is doing the right thing keeping the baby?

whoa! a fellow OTH fan.. :) kudos! i think peyton should keep the baby.. i mean, we're talking life here too.. if she decide otherwise, i think she'll regret ever doing that.. at least if she decides on keeping the baby, there's still that chance that she could live.. as for lucas..i think he should keep the baby too..i mean, if peyton does die..at least he'll have the baby to remind him of her.. more like what happened to karen and keith.. :)

I love this show. I dont know if Peyton is doing the right thing or not. I am a mother of 2 and I dont know what I would do. But you have to think about this...you can make another baby, but there will never be another "Peyton." But it is TV so they are definately going to keep us in suspense. I think something will happen though to Peyton and then Lucas will blame the baby for it and hold a grudge on it. Then something will probably happen to the baby and then Lucas will open his eyes and start to love the baby. That is what I think anyways.

No, I think Peyton should have the abortion. As much as I LOVE babies/kids and HATE abortions, and think it's horrible, it's to save her life. I personally would never have an abortion even if my life was on the line, because of religion. I'd have a hard enough time killing my own kid, without the possibility of going to hell :\ If you take religion out of the picture, I would have the abortion (ONLY if it came down to saving me or the baby. Never just because I didn't want a baby). But since I don't think Peyton is really religious, I think she should have the abortion. I know that she loves the baby, and feels so protective of it, and it's inside her, and she's got all of those hormones going, and I can't even imagine how that would feel, but she should protect herself. Especially when there is that big of a chance that she could die. I know it sounds a little dumb, considering she's saving her baby, but I think she's being really selfish. Let me explain :P She's not thinking of Lucas. What that would do to him. He tried explaining to her that he can't think of living without her, but she wouldn't listen. I got really pissed while she was talking about how he would be okay, and how he wouldn't be alone because he'd have everyone else, and he'd have the sexy single dad thing going, and all of that. He would not be okay. And everyone else in his life... it just doesn't even compare to the person you're in love with... it's not the same. And how could he take care of a newborn if he's all depressed over losing her? They can have another baby, but Lucas cannot get another Peyton. She'd be gone forever, and he'd have a constant reminder of how and why he lost her. And to permanently lose the person who you're in love with... that's just horrible. And everyone knows Peyton... they haven't met the baby yet, and no one knows it's personality... so I think it would be easier to lose the baby, than to lose the person they know and are attached to. And the baby might not even make it. What if somewhere down the line, she loses the baby and it's too late to save her? He'd have nothing. That would be even worse. I know losing a baby is unbelievably hard... it's a little baby... a new individual, that would look and act somewhat like they do... but I think she should save her own life. Sorry for the rant... I'm a tiny bit upset lol

I never experience being a mother, nor being pregnant. But i think Peyton is doing the right thing, letting her child experience life. Killing your own child is a sin even if it still in your tummy. I can bear seing my child die in my own hand. And its was given to you by the LORD so He has plan for you and for your child. The LORD will not allow something to happen to you and to your child.