How important are reviews for you?
By nekonyanta
@nekonyanta (892)
Philippines
March 28, 2009 9:25am CST
Well, this doesn't really apply solely to the site, but to fan fiction in general, but I was wondering what type of fan fiction writers are you, fellow myLot-ers? Are you the type that doesn't care if he/she gets a single review or a hundred reviews as long as you enjoy writing your story? Or are you the type who demands that his/her fans leave a review or else you won't continue with the story?
I have to admit that during the early part of my fan fiction writing career, I'd say I would be of the latter type - writing stories just for the sake of getting reviews. But then, as time passed, I found that I have slowly become the former type - writing stories that I genuinely enjoy for fandoms that I actually am interested in. I find that I produce better-quality stories that way.
So, which type are you?
3 responses
@oyenkai (4394)
• Philippines
7 May 09
I have never tried writing fan fiction. And I actually don't think I have the definition of "fan fiction" correctly. Is it a story (written by a fan of course) based on an existing story? It's like adding an episode to one story, or suggesting an alternative twist in the existing plot?
Thanks for the response on my discussion!
1 person likes this
@nekonyanta (892)
• Philippines
7 May 09
Hi there. Yes, fan fiction is a story based on an existing story. Fan fiction usually "borrow" characters, settings, plots, etc. from an existing story and use them as their own. It's actually a quite controversial form of literature, considering that there usually is a very thin line between writing fan fiction and outright plagiarism - so much that fanfiction.net, which houses a large chunk of fan fiction posted on the net, has been receiving requests from authors to not add their works as categories in the site to which members could submit their stories. I think that biggest name, so far, was Anne Rice, though I haven't really been active in the site lately to know. On the other hand, some authors actually encourage it (I think I've read somewhere about J.K. Rowling reading some Harry Potter fan fiction and actually applauding it... though maybe I've misinterpreted it so don't quote me on it) since it actually boosts the popularity of their works.
Writing fan fiction is quite addictive and something that one could do for leisure, without having the burden to come up with all elements of a story. I've been writing it since I was in high school, though mostly for anime and/or JPop.
1 person likes this
@nekonyanta (892)
• Philippines
8 May 09
You should. *lol* There are actually a lot of sites and communities that thrive on fan fiction (e.g. fanfiction.net, various communities on Live Journal depending on the fandom). I've seen quite a bit of fan fiction writers actually have their original works published and become professional writers. Writing fan fiction seems good writing practice for aspiring novelists, as well.
@TokaAtef (39)
• United Arab Emirates
30 Mar 09
I am just like you...I started writing about three or three and a half years ago and all I cared about was reviews. But with time, I got more satisfaction from writing a very good chapter, rather than from seeing that the review count for one of my fics reached over 200 for 8 chapters.
But a lot of reviews also boosts a writer's ego ;)
1 person likes this
@nekonyanta (892)
• Philippines
31 Mar 09
Hi there. Well, I guess it just follows that as long as you enjoy writing your stories and give it your best, people are bound to enjoy your stories as well and thus, more reviews. I've never had the... stamina to make it past three chapters, though. Kudos to you. And yes, it doesn't hurt that reviews boost a writer's ego. It feels good to be appreciated.
@Shadenfrauder (355)
• Philippines
9 Jul 09
When I started writing fanfics almost a year ago, I was scared that hardcore fans would flame me for daring to post what I did. So I was mighty surprised when I received reviews finding my stories interesting or even good. However, I still do some freakout party in my head whenever I upload, be it a new chapter or a new story.
In all honesty? I don't mind not receiving reviews much, though receiving them is highly appreciated. Reviews are feedbacks and I like knowing what I did well and what I did wrong, but not knowing them is all good too. So long as I know there's at least one person who enjoys what I write, I don't really mind at all.