passing on genetic disease

United States
April 3, 2009 1:01pm CST
would you chose to have children if you knew there was a good chance of your child getting the disease? what if the disease was a mental illness like anxiety disorder or depression? some people don't look at this as a serious disease but it can be. if you suffered from it and knew what a struggle it could be would you still have a child knowing that it can be genetic and there is a possibility you child could develop it also?
3 people like this
11 responses
• United States
4 Apr 09
That would depend on how bad my condition was and if it not only enabled me to HAVE a child but be able to actually take care of one too! Early in my life my mom was diagnosed with Lupus. While growing up I was always tested but never diagnosed. I always wondered about passing on the Lupus gene to my child; after all, this genetic disorder is passed through the female. Even though there was a chance of passing this disease onto my child I always thought about having one. But I haven't just yet. I would still have a child though. If it was a disease like depression or another mental illness, I wold still have to consider the options for the child. What preventative measures can I take to try and avoid chances of the disease developing? Could I be open about my own illness so that the child can be more educated about what could happen to them? Think about it if you are the child of a parent with one of these illnesses. Do you think that your parents ever wished that you weren't born? Or are they trying to work with you through your illness because they are trying to help you through life...happy that you were born, trying to keep you alive?
• United States
4 Apr 09
good answer. Sometimes when you are dealing with your child's illness, even though you know a lot about it because it was in your family, you still feel a level of guilt almost as if you "caused" it. I know that sounds crazy but being a parent you want to protect your child. definitely being open and educating yourself is the way to go. thanks for your thoughtful response.
• United States
5 Apr 09
thanks for your response but I just wish I could spare them suffering. but no one knows what you are going to have to deal with in your life and there are worse things to deal with.
• United States
4 Apr 09
You do have that level of guilt where you feel the need to take the pain away from the child. You feel as if this was your suffering not theirs. I know my mom gives me that guilt trip all the time, now that I have MS. Unknowingly myself and my sister inherited this from our fathers. But my mom understands everything that I'm going through as far as emotions and certain pains. But she doesn't regret that I was born, even though it means that I experienced some sufffering. Good luck to you with your thoughts on this. But just remember that each time you look in your baby's eyes it was worth everything to share that experience of love with each other....even in the rough times.
• United States
3 Apr 09
Diabetes and hypertension run in my family. I've been a diabetic since high school and only had a small problem with my blood pressure when I was pregnant. There is a chance with each of us that we could pass something on to our children. Depression can be genetic or it can be a product of lifestyle or environment. The good thing is there are wonderful treatments and programs to involve yourself in should you become depressed. There are medications for conditions that make life liveable.
• United States
3 Apr 09
it is just that finding the right treatment is not always easy and seeing the pain your child goes through is unbearable. you are right though, there are things that we can pass on to our children. maybe it is helpful to just be aware of pre-disposed possible conditions.
• United States
3 Apr 09
There are certain diseases such as tae sachs and other kinds like that that worry me. If I was a carrier, I'd get some sort of test done early in my pregnancy and if a child was going to be born with that, I'd likely abort. I've seen a neighbor's child die of tae sachs. It's a painful disease that ultimately leads the child to quit breathing due to muscle atrophy. Imagine being young and not knowing anything but a life of pain.
• United States
4 Apr 09
I know that god has reasons but i agree, why put a child through a life of pain?
• China
4 Apr 09
there are little chances of anxiety or mental disorders passing to the children from the parents. i dont think that an educated parents would prefer not to have a child because these disorders can be controlled from their childhood according to their life experiences. so iam sure that to have a child even there is a chance of getting such disorders...........................
• United States
4 Apr 09
actually there is more of a chance if you have an anxiety disorder for your child to also have one. genetics is one of the reasons along with stress and environment.
@dodo19 (47317)
• Beaconsfield, Quebec
3 Apr 09
I have ADD (Attention Deficit Disorder). This is something that passes on from parent to child. I think that I got it from my father. I know that there is a possibility that at least one of my children may get this, all because I have it. It's definitely not something that I want any of my kids to deal with. But it doesn't mean that I don't want kids. I still do, even though there is a possibility that one or more of my kids may have ADD. And my fiance is also aware of this. But we still want kids. It doesn't really affect our decision to have kids. Now, I believe that some future parents feel this way, but it's not everyone.
@dodo19 (47317)
• Beaconsfield, Quebec
5 Apr 09
Well, I sure hope that it will help. But there are somethings that we just can't predict, things that are difficult to predict.
• United States
4 Apr 09
ADD is not something that you want your child to have but you having it would kind of help with knowing what kind of treatment to get your child.
@snow8515 (169)
• China
4 Apr 09
I'm very healthy as well as my families. And I hope my future child will be healthy, too. However, if I would be suffering some kind of genetic disease and know that it may entail my child, I would not give birth of babies. I don't want my child to suffer such pain as me. I love children. I may adopt a child as mine and let him grow healthily.
• United States
4 Apr 09
that is very smart, of course adoption is an option. thanks for your response!
• United States
14 Apr 09
Well, given MY genetics, I wouldn't, but if I were coded for just depression or anxiety, I'd go ahead and have the kid because honestly, there are MUCH worse things than those. I'd give anything to be "just depressed" again. The kid has to learn to deal with it, anyway. It's one of those hurdle things. Not everyone's life is going to be perfect, and really, they'd better understand that early on or their life is going to get a LOT crummier.
• United States
14 Apr 09
I wish that anxiety and depression was so easy to control as you assume. it is not something that you can just wish away. of course there are diseases that are worse but being "just depressed" is not so easy. thanks for your response.
@albert2412 (1782)
• United States
4 Apr 09
It is my understanding that anxiety disorder is caused by high cordisol and depression is caused by low serotonin. TRiptofan and 5htp helps make serotonin. Taking niacinomide helps make more triptofan. These are nutrition issues, not genetic issues. I really do think that passing on genetic troubles to your children is generally overrated. The Egyptian Pharoahs married their own daughters for 5000 years and I know of no recorded instance of mental illness as a result of this. For some illnesses, genetics do play a role.
• United States
4 Apr 09
I like your point about the Egyptians. Even though there is a genetic predisposition to a disease it doesn't always mean you will get it. thanks for your response.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
3 Apr 09
There are no perfect people. I think if you have a good chance of handing down a disease like diabetes, or heart condition it would be best not that you do not have children but you marry someone where that condition does not run in their family. Now the trouble is that for most of us marriages are not arranged and so we usually marry someone who is familiar with us, either from the same background, or the same area, or the same looks. And in most cases, that person has at least one of our inherited conditions. If I could have fallen in love with someone who did not have the same chances, of at least one of my inherited disease - heart condition, I would have wanted it and I could not get pregnant - Vd = after marriage. But had I not gotten Vd, I would have still tried to get pregnant, because when you have an inherited condition, you know all about it and can best accept it. And I would know about the treatments available.
• United States
4 Apr 09
of course none of us are perfect. sometimes it is not the best thing to know your chances of getting a disease up front. other times it is. I heard about a family with alzheimer's and the father had it and all 3 of his sons. they all developed it in their 30's. the family is active in trying to find treatment and determining the genes that cause it because of the grandchildren. knowing what your future holds sometimes makes you better prepared for it.
@VotreAmie (3028)
• United States
4 Apr 09
If I had a serious disease that can be passed genetically to my children then I would choose not to have kids. I think I will be miserable if I had a kid that had a serious disease all that because of me, I don't want to deal with that my whole life. But depression and anxiety I think nowadays it is manageable with adequate treatment and medicine. That's what I think so in this case I would have kids. Of course I would hope the child would not develop it but in the case they do then at least I would know what's wrong with them and get them the proper treatment. Take care.
• United States
4 Apr 09
knowing what you will be dealing with is definitely a plus. more serious mental illnesses like bipolar are very frustrating and it takes time to get the person treated correctly. thanks for your response.
• Philippines
3 Apr 09
i've heard from a local tv talk show (doctor explaining) that we all are at risk of getting anxiety disorder or depression even though it doesn't run in the family.. Although those that has family history faces higher risk, the doctor said that all of us faces risks of acquiring the said illness since our genes continuously evolve.. which means that you cannot merely tell that once you and your partner don't have a family history of mental illness, your children will not likely develop it. would you know that the genes of your husband is not compatible with yours and the incompatibility could cause to develop an illness in your generation?
• United States
4 Apr 09
that is a very good point. somewhere down the line anything could happen. we don't know what God's plan is so maybe all this knowing is not a good thing.
@Sgurleyd (68)
• United States
3 Apr 09
I have had Bipolar disorder for many years, and am quite sure that my Mom had the same thing, only undiagnosed. It has made my life very difficult at times. Dealing with it on a daily basis is tough. The meds are sometimes terrible. I made a decision when younger not to have kids because I did'nt want to pass it on. Mental illnesses are very real! Hopefully our society will no longer attach such a stigma to them.
• United States
4 Apr 09
Now this is what I am talking about! You know first-hand the struggles you go through. Bi-polar is treatable but it isn't an easy disease to deal with. Today people are being diagnosed and treated but back in the day it wasn't even dealt with. Hopefully strides will be made and it won't be so shameful. It is a disease like diabetes and heart disease and people should be treated the same as sufferers of that disease. I think sometimes bi-polar sufferers have this extreme behavior and that is why there is a stigma to it. It is a huge decision for you to not have kids, you could adopt. good luck to you! thanks for your response.