Cloth or Disposable Diapers.

@CJscott (4187)
Portage La Prairie, Manitoba
April 4, 2009 10:15pm CST
Which is the lesser of two evils? The nice disposable ones that your just bunch up and toss out. They smell bad, who knows what they are made of, but at least once they are out, they are out. OR Do you Prefer to use the Cloth ones? Nice and soft, made of Cotton or wool, with or with out a plastic/rubber reuseable liner. Got to wash them in the washer or by hand. Wastes a bit of water, and you have to smell them twice, I really hate stinky Diapers. SO what do other Mylot Parents think?
3 people like this
18 responses
• United States
5 Apr 09
Im so interested in this subject being a 36 weeks old pregnant mom to be! im planning on starting with both and the seeing wich one is easier to maintain, even tough im pushing for the cloth diapers, but being a new mom i dont know really how much work just taking care of the baby alone is going to be, even though my husband is very helpfull and has agreed to try cloth diapes, but lets see how it goes:D
@mac1946 (1602)
• Calgary, Alberta
17 Apr 09
While doing your test,please be sure to take into account each week,on how much money is being saved compared to buying the disposables. a study I took many years ago,showed that the normal saving for the two years it normally takes from birth to full potty training is 3,000.00 to 5,000.00. Plus the environmental savings as well. thank you for starting with cloth.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
7 May 09
As a new mom, you will really need to make a choice as far as what is easier for you in the long run. You will see what works and what doesn't pretty quickly, and also where you will receive help and where you won't. I am not a cloth advocate but I did go thru diapers for 3 years and bottom line, as much as environmentalists will go on and on about disposables in landfills, there is the issue of time, electricity, water, and chemicals if you decide on cloth. Also, I would change your baby, even a poop-splosion with a disposable but I would be very hesitant to deal with cloth, just because you don't take it off and throw it away. I'm not a big fan of poop no matter the age of the individual who pooped, and I'd rather not have to touch it more than once on the way to the trash can. Sorry. I also wouldn't want to spend any time soaking/washing any extra laundry, so unless you're having a diaper service, that's going to be a tough thing for a new mom. I always felt like I didn't have enough hands, enough hours in the day, and I was tired just getting basic things accomplished, never mind having a spotless house and dinner ready every night, heh. Another thing I've learned as a mom is that keeping things maintained is the important thing, not perfect. As long as you keep things to the level where you can pick up quickly or get out the door quickly at any given time, that's what matters.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
7 May 09
Mac - there is no way I spent 5K on diapers, so I'm not sure who conducted this test. Did they use a test subject who bought the most expensive diapers for the entire length of the study, and whose child didn't stop using diapers until he/she was five? I found some very good quality inexpensive diapers and I bought them in large boxes, I think usually 126 to a box. Sometimes I had coupons or deals so they were less than $14 a box. When my daughter was smaller, they were about 140 to a box. From my figures.... 10 boxes would last me quite awhile. That's what, $140? It's not like I was using 14 diapers a day either lol. Let's say $28 a month... approx $336 a year? Hmmmm. About $1000? TOTAL? Thumbs down to those folks who claims it costs $5000! LOL!
1 person likes this
@xtedaxcvg (3189)
• Philippines
18 Apr 09
cloth diaper - cloth diaper over disposable ones anytime
I think I'd prefer cloth diapers over disposable ones. I believe cloth diapers are more convenient to wear than the regular disposable ones. Also, using cloth diapers is cheaper because all you need to do is just wash them, instead of buying lots and lots of disposable ones.
1 person likes this
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
7 May 09
More convenient? What is more convenient about something you have to keep up on vs just buying a package of something already there that doesn't have to be maintained, washed, etc? That's like comparing convenience from a nice set of dishes to a stack of paper plates when you're expecting 20 people for a bbq. Sorry but I'm taking the paper plates. I do not feel like loading my dishwasher 2 times after the bbq! Not only is that a huge timewaster for ME, that's also a lot of water and detergent and electricity to run it, and then I have to unload it and reload it again... nope. Not a good time.
1 person likes this
@CJscott (4187)
• Portage La Prairie, Manitoba
19 Apr 09
I think in the end it costs about the same. Washing clothes costs money you know.
@CRSunrise (2981)
• United States
6 Apr 09
We've been using disposable diapers with both of our children. I don't know that I could use cloth diapers, altough I have thought about it. I'm not sure that I have patience for them. I'd be afraid of sticking my children with a pin.
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
7 May 09
Definitely disposables. Cloth is a hassle, expensive to buy, expensive to maintain, can cause diaper rash for sensitive babies, nobody I know has time to soak, wash, dry, and fold diapers along with all the other stuff you have to do when you have a baby! Just getting yourself together and out of the house with a baby after you're no longer pregnant is hard. If you put a deadline on when you have to do it, most new moms would try to snap the deadline person's neck Also, other people are not real happy about changing cloth diapers. I know I'm not and regardless of what people who are cloth addicts say, I believe they are nuts. If I were about to pee or poo on myself, I would want something easy that would be thrown away, not something I would wear AGAIN after I peed myself. wtf... Regular laundry and keeping up with it is bad enough. I can keep up with mine fine as long as nobody gets sick. Most people I know have baskets or hampers full of laundry or piles waiting to be folded and put away! If you did cloth diapers, that would be like WILLINGLY taking on another two peoples' worth of laundry on a weekly basis. No thanks! That's like 3 extra loads a week!
1 person likes this
@CJscott (4187)
• Portage La Prairie, Manitoba
7 May 09
And you know what else I only learned like last week. Disposable diapers are Compost-able! So it doesn't even pollute. When you do toss them that is.
• Tunisia
5 Apr 09
My wif use dispoable diapers for our children!
1 person likes this
@sinokirin (900)
• China
6 Apr 09
It really smell so bad, so bad, my daughter use dispoable diapers now, they smell bad when she piss much,i think their smell like chemical material,so,make me worried.My mom decide to use the cotton cloth in summer,the moment she has grown up a little,and can say goodbye to the disposable diapers. I dislike them at all.
1 person likes this
@mac1946 (1602)
• Calgary, Alberta
5 Apr 09
I don't believe I would have anything against disposable diapers for the first year if the parents would only use the garbage cans to get rid of them instead of just tossing them under the vehicles or out the windows or onto someone elses lawn. Then of course there is the potty training.When using cloth diapers and a bit later cloth training pants with plastic panties (no fly opening),most children will train by two years of age,while those brought up in disposables are quite often still in them at 4,5 or even older years of age,they are far to cumfy. 10 years ago,I found the differance in cost for the first two years of diapering was between 3 to 5,000.00,this would be the saving by using cloth and doing your own laundry,a bit less with using diaper service. Thank you.
• Australia
5 Apr 09
When I was pregnant with my daughter, I had the plan that I was going to use cloth at home & disposable out but I soon found out that my daughter only liked disposable & at 23 months old, she's still in them. Money wise, I think they're just as expensive as each other when you add the cost of electricity, soakers, water & laundry detergent for cleaning cloth as to buying disposables.
@Reyah23 (640)
• Philippines
5 Apr 09
We use disposable diapers in my nephew. There are new diapers which is cloth like made. It make very comportable for babies.
1 person likes this
@berrys (864)
• Singapore
5 Apr 09
I think cloth diapers should be more comfortable for babies as some plastic ones cause rash and makes the baby uncomfortable. plus the plastic ones can graze against your babies skin causing heat rash as well. Then again cloth diapers smell rather awful and have to be wash regularly. Money-wise they both cause about the same. But when it comes to hygiene i think the disposable one beats the rest as cloth diapers absorbs all over. like after you jog your entire shirt(if cotton) is soaked. but then environment-wise the cloth one is better. Personally if it was me who decides I would used cloth diapers DISPOSABLE-fresh and clean cloth diapers. Yes the soul purpose of cloth diapers are because they can be re-used. but I want my baby to be clean, comfy and healthy. So I'd put my baby in disposable cloth diapers
1 person likes this
• Philippines
5 Apr 09
I have sisters who prefer the use of plastic diapers because of the less cost of it. i tried to convince them to change it to cloth but there not familiar with it. therefore, they kept on refusing me, but they saw one last night. they might consider it.
1 person likes this
@Niah1976 (739)
• Paranaque, Philippines
5 Apr 09
i prefer to use disposable diapers so that the baby will be more comfortable especially at night. you don't have to change the diaper each time the baby pees. they can have a good sleep as well as the mother.
1 person likes this
@benny128 (3615)
5 Apr 09
disposable ones everytime, they fill up landfills granted but the cloth re-usuable ones need to be washed at a hot temperature so you are still harming the enviroment by having to do hot washes. I tried cloth ones with my first child and was finding the washer was on everyday pumping co2 into the atmosphere and wasting energy. I now use disposable ones, and find that the washer is on 3 times a week instead of 7 days a week, and I can also wash at a lower temp thus saving energy and decreasing the carbon emitted from the energy generated. Plus the cloth ones stank he he he.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
5 Apr 09
I do would like to use clothes during day time. One of my hobby is to wash clothes. I do love to do. With regards to night time, i would like to use disposable ones. Can disturb a good soundly sleep if having to use clothes then. The child would not also experience having those diaper rush. That's why am doing these...lol
1 person likes this
@irishidid (8687)
• United States
5 Apr 09
On my first two children I used disposable. When I had my son the hospital had given up disposables and had begun to put the newborns in cloth diapers. I chose to continue doing this and he remained in them until it was time to potty train. I didn't relish the thought of holding a poopy diaper over the toilet so I opted for diaper service which was great because all I had to do was toss it into the bucket. Once a week the diaper truck brought me nice clean diapers. The only bad thing I found was while the diaper covers were handy with their velcro closures, it was easy for my son to get them off. His favorite thing to do was to climb up on the dressers, toss the diaper into the air and leap. As you can see, I survived his childhood. Barely.
1 person likes this
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
5 Apr 09
With my first child I used cloth diapers because I wanted to save the environment. That didn't last long. The diaper pail stunk and not only was I constantly washing diapers, I was washing that thing too! So, disposable diapers it was for that one and the next three.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Apr 09
I absolutely prefer cloth diapers. They are good for the environment. There are too many dirty diapers in landfills that do not biodegrade. Many of these diapers have waste that includes vaccines for various diseases. Just sitting there. What happens when the birds, insects, animals are exposed to this. What happens when this stuff seeps into the ground and then into our water system. Not to mention what these diapers are made of and how healthy they are for children to begin with. So I prefer cloth diapers for the majority of the time. If, however, you are away from home, I think it is just easier to use disposable diapers. Cloth diapers can still be used but it is easier to use disposables. My final reason for using cloth diapers is that once they are bought they are bought. It sure saves a lot in the budget to just wash them and use them over again. It is a small investment compared to what can be spent for disposables and in this economy that can be sizable.
1 person likes this
@avi1979 (31)
• India
8 Nov 10
You can find very good information about cloth or disposable diapers at http://www.howtomakediaperwreath.com