who is the most unsuccesful american idol winner for you?

Hahaha, poor him but yea i'd have to agree with you...I mean the only time i see him getting famous and all is just during americal idol..I don't know how in the world he got to be the american idol but if he was truly one, his albums would HAVE gone platinum...I mean where did all the fans go? Yuuu huu??

There are a lot of people that were on American Idol with Taylor Hicks that are more productive in this industry then he is. He is the most unsuccessful person that has won American Idol. I never see anything with him or even hear about him. I also never hear anything about Ruben Studdard or Fantasia Barrino all that much either as you hear things about Kelly Clarkson and Carie Underwood. I'm not sure why he made it that way for me, but he did.

i never liked taylor's style of singing, it is still a puzzle for me why he lasted i love elliot... that voice of his never fails to amaze me, even if i listened to his songs like 200 times each hahahahaha

Definitely Taylor Hicks. I actually like him more than I like Fantasia but as far as record sales, Taylor is less successful.

Yea I heard he was dropped from his record label only 9 or 10 months after signing on.