Do you think education can make people less superstitious?

@scheng1 (24649)
Singapore
April 18, 2009 8:37am CST
In all parts of the world, there are still a lot of superstitious people. Superstitons are unlikely to be eradicated. People still feel fearful of Friday the 13th, and often wake up feeling that something bad is going to happen. The number 4 is still an unlucky number among Chinese. If the hourly rate is $4.44, the Chinese will be very unhappy about it. Do you think education can make peoples less superstitious?
1 person likes this
21 responses
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
19 Apr 09
Scheng, strictly speaking it should but it necessarily doesn't. Part of it is due to upbringing and when people who have been fed on a diet of superstition, find it difficult to get it totally out of their system.But education helps them make conscious decisions to rationalise their thought processes and whip themselves to get over this.On the other hand, there are some sections[I have seen them personally--from rural areas where they are uneducated- that would never even contemplate reasoning and would be plagued by fear].So, I would sum it this way Education can help in making people less superstitious;but if they have had a terribly firm upbringing that defied all education they would still continue to be so.-they need to make conscious efforts ;it would not naturally change them.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
19 Apr 09
sorry--'when people who have been fed on a diet of superstition, find it difficult to get it totally out of their system.'--error read-- people who have been fed on a diet of superstition, find it difficult to get it totally out of their system.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
Actually many highly educated people are superstitious. Education is as good as the scientific advancement. Up till 2009, science is not able to explain everything. And when bad things happen to them, let's say they are unlucky for everything they do, then they will become more superstitious and look to religion for answer. Educated people are less likely to be superstitious in some areas. But more superstitious in other areas. Those areas that education and science doesn't provide an answer.
@HelloMickey (1655)
• Hong Kong
18 Apr 09
Hello scheng What do you mean people being supersititious? You call it is supersititious just because you don't believe it? I think people can trust what they like, just like religions. I majored in Physics in college but I even think there are something in the universe can't be explained explicitly. Then why you would think what you think is correct? And people doesn't think like you or believe in something you don't understand is supersititious. I am just saying in many cases, people should not be called superstitious. Being a human, we have already lost so many senses, and they degenerate rapidly. So animals can sense a tsunami and an earthquake but we human cannot. So do you think people have strong sense saying they are psychics? If one doesn't hurt oneself and doesn't affect others, it is alright that they can choose what they believe in. Sharing with others open-mindedly would help each other not doing glaringerrors. So I seldom call people superstitious. ^.^ Have a nice day~
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
There are a lot of examples of superstitions, even I admit that I am superstitious. In one of my jobs in the university, I was working in the new university administration building. This building is situated on a hill and faced the open field. The wind is always strong. The glass door at the entrance was smashed to pieces by the wind a few times in a year. Somehow we felt that something very bad was going to happen. There were a lot of rumors flying around, about how bad the feng shui was, and without the koi pool to mitigate the bad feng shui, people would die in this building. I didn't work long enough to witness any fatal accident. Later on, there was a serious crane accident. But during the times I'm working there, I had the highest record of medical leaves in my whole life. Well, I admit I'm superstitious, I felt fearful when I saw the thousand pieces of the smash up glass door.
• Hong Kong
18 Apr 09
Sorry that I haven't replied your question. I think education somehow helps a bit.
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
18 Apr 09
I think sometimes education can make a person less superstitious but it's the culture that influences them more than education. Here, people are fearful of Friday 13th but I decided long ago that it was my lucky day--so it usually is! Our tall buildings rarely have 13th floors because of superstition. Most people who go into those buildings are educated so I don't think education alone can defeat superstitions.
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
18 Apr 09
You are right. But I find it very funny that even though the 13th floor is not named "13" here, there still is a 13th floor. It's as if we are afraid to name it correctly!
@kassdaw (591)
• United States
18 Apr 09
Yes!!! a random act of events that lead to an outcome that is completely random is not something people need to fear. And yet they still do. My son's was born on a 13th, so what he'll have a bunch of birthdays on friday the 13th throughout his life. People need the education or atleast some knowledge to understand that "carma" doesn't exist. That what ever happens, happens and any one thing can change everything. Breaking a mirror, walking under a ladder, having a black cat run in front of you. It all means nothing. Just random events that began from some other random event. There is no such thing as Luck, whether it be good or bad it doesn't exist. People tell their kids good luck or it must be your lucky day. Parents need to educate their children on this. That is where it all begins.
@kassdaw (591)
• United States
18 Apr 09
But it is because people have that fear that makes the event or accident more likely to happen. If you try your hardest to avoid something that you are deathly afraid chances are, if it is something you could encounter everyday doing normal activies, you will encounter it. If someone is so worried about driving in a specific area because of previous accidents they are more likely to be distracted by the thought then paying attention to car that is T-boning them or the car that just drove up their tail pipe. Fear causes more accidents and bad encounters then not having the fear at all. If you notice, those who have a thing against Friday the 13th always have a horrific or bad day because they are so worried about the day of the week and number it is assigned then what is really going on in the world.
@blanne (173)
• Philippines
19 Apr 09
I think it still depends on what education feeds us. I mean, my parents are educated, but they are still superstitious. I believe that the right information can make people less superstitious, and it also helps that we are surrounded with people that are realistic. I think what contributed to my parents being superstitious is that my grandparents were superstitious too. So as long as what education teaches are the facts, then it could probably make people less superstitious in a way.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
I am also very superstitious, but not the same kind of superstitious that you see in those Africa tribes. At least I will consult a doctor to find out what's wrong and take proper medication. I will not consult witch doctor. Only when all medications fail, then I will go to the chinese mediums. My neighbour's son been running a high fever for more than a week, nothing could bring down the fever. She finally went to the Chinese medium in the temple to seek guidance. Apparently the boy (being very young) was playful and played with those items that people offered to god. So the fever was caused by god punishing him. After some prayer and drinking the "holy" water, the boy recoverd. Sometimes things like this cannot be explained by education. When doctors are not able to cure and offer no solution, all the superstitions come into play.
@prinzcy (32305)
• Malaysia
18 Apr 09
Superstitious can be eradicated within certain people when they required more education in their life. Sometimes, superstitious belief were rub on us by our custom and that is hard to ignore. In my custom, it's more like things that we should and shouldn't do, we have no belief in numbers. So we don't care less of number 13 or 444.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
18 Apr 09
You are right to bring out the custom thing. You are staying in Malaysia. Even you will notice that the Chinese pray a lot during the Hungry Ghost festivals and the government is not stopping them. It's partly custom and partly people in the government also pray. Even the stories of Malay bomohs are frightening. I do not know how true but dare not offend them in case all the stories are true.
@prinzcy (32305)
• Malaysia
18 Apr 09
Ah, those bomohs? They're quite true actually. Not every bomohs are bad though.
@psyche49f (2502)
• Philippines
19 Apr 09
Yup, definitely because education liberates one's mind from ignorance, superstitious beliefs, but should also strengthen one's spirituality and morality...that's the greatest contribution of education to humanity.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
Agree with your viewpoint on liberating our mind from ignorance. But the second part is about strengthening spirituality and morality questionable. The value of spirituality and morality differ from country to country. It seems that the people in Nepal are more spiritual minded than people in the west. So the educational factor may not be the factor behind morality and spirituality.
• Philippines
19 Apr 09
I don't think education can make people less supertitious. I have friends who have post graduate degrees yet they are still very supertitious. It's part of one's culture.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
Ya, true, last time I worked in the university, even Professors and the university management, who supposedly are the smartest persons in the country, are superstitious. In our Chinese culture, the hungry ghost month is a month to avoid a lot of things, like wedding and shifting house. One department in the university decided on a particular morning to shift to new office building, it caused a lot of stress, but some decision makers suddenly realised that the next time was the start of the hungry ghost festival.
@twinklee (894)
• India
19 Apr 09
all doesnt lie in education alone...its your confidence that speaks volumes of you & the more you think you are capable in your own ways...i feel that superstition will not be there in your vicinity.......
• India
19 Apr 09
ya definitely education is one basis through which one can eradicate superstition from everywhere. Just people should understand that there is something meaningful happening behind these things and that it is not just due to some numbers alone .
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
That is provided that education can explain everything that happens. Up till this year 2009, nobody claims to know everything and has explanation for everything. Hopefully when mankind improves in the search for the truth, people will understand and learn more and become less superstitious.
• China
19 Apr 09
I don't think so. Yeah, Education can give us knowledge and skill,and so on .But the Superstitious is the conception of people.It difficult to change it.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
Maybe less superstitious, but education is not able to completely get rid of superstitions. Many Chinese, no matter overseas or mainland Chinese, are still very superstitious in date selection. If want to build a building, choosing a good date for laying foundation, is still very important. Even if the builders do not believe in it, they still follow, just in case the building collapse, nobody can accuse them of not choosing a good date.
@bird123 (10643)
• United States
18 Apr 09
Fear is the result of the unknown. Any knowledge removes such fears.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
The problem is that we are unable to know everything about the universe. So the fear of the unknown that leads to superstitions will always exist till we are able to know everything.
@mira91 (985)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
Well maybe it's true for some people but i can't seem to relate education and superstitions together. Because i still know some people who've had bachelors and honours and are still superstitious of stuff...I guess it's just a way of life, it's somethin that affects us and so i don't know if being educated could eradicate those thoughts..^_^ Just what i think..
@flowerday (322)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
hihi..i feel that education can only make people less supertitious to a small extent..i know of many highly educated people who are extremely superstitious and i also know of many lowly educated people who are not superstitious at all.. i feel that what affects one's superstitious level is one's upbringing, environment and one's own beliefs... if you are brought up in an superstitious family, directly or indirectly you will be affected.. if your culture is of an superstitious nature, i guess you will have to be superstitious in order to blend in.. and lastly but most importantly, it is up to your own beliefs..no one can force you to be superstitious..
@Asylum (47893)
• Manchester, England
11 Oct 15
In theory having a better education should make us less superstitious because we understand the world around us better. However, in practice I have known very well educated people who are superstitious, which rather seems odd to me.
@springs (923)
• India
18 Apr 09
Yes,it makes less superstitous.If the people are uneducated out of 1000 ,999 will be superstitous,and if they are educated out of 1000 ,more than 500 will be less superstitous.The number may increase too.500 people can make others less superstitous.Like wise education reduces the superstitous.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
19 Apr 09
haha, love your example. Agree with you that education can somehow reduce superstitious among the population. Perhaps not completely eradicated. I heard that seamen are notoriously superstitious, and many of the seamen are highly educated (at least technically). They will prohibit bringing bananas onboard, for reasons that nobody really knows.
@happy2009 (330)
• China
19 Apr 09
Yes of course!
@marguicha (223874)
• Chile
18 Apr 09
Education has to do with beliefs to some extent. But supersticions mean diferent things in each culture. Probably what I feel is superstition, to another human being can be a part of his religious beliefs.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
18 Apr 09
Interesting observations. I find that older people are more superstitious than the younger people. Do you think so? Even when the older people are highly educated and hold high positions in the government or company, they are still superstitous. Younger people generally do not believe that bad luck comes to them because of black cats or broken mirror or whatever.
• India
18 Apr 09
yes I certainly believe that education can eradicate superstition though it make take some time. We will have to make people aware that superstition is nothing. I am from India and India is a very superstitious country. but things have greatly changed here because of education. Most of the people that live in cites are really superstitious. but where education has not reached like villages of India, there superstition still continues. education may not eradicate it fully but at least makes people aware.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
18 Apr 09
Educated people are superstitious too. It's just not too apparent. I do not know about the construction industry in your country. Over here, the laying of foundation, is a very important event. The company will choose an auspicious date to lay the foundation. All these are arranged by educated management team. If there is any workplace accident and workers die, then the company and the grieving families will engage religious leaders to pray at the place where the accident takes place and to "cleanse" the area.
@allknowing (137961)
• India
11 Oct 15
If superstition is connect to religion then no amount of education is going to change people.