Jesus Christ died in India!
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
India
May 8, 2009 5:13am CST
I am sure a lot of you have heard of this. In a nutshell, for those who haven’t…
There are many who believe that Jesus’ missing years (adolescent to 30s) was spent in India learning yoga and meditation and ancient Hindu & Buddhist scriptures in the Himalayas. He didn’t die on the cross but was still alive when brought down. He rather controlled his breathing thru meditation while on the cross and after being kept in the cave, his body was treated with aloe and myrrh and with due care, he was OK by Easter…this is thought to be his resurrection. Immediately after this, he fled Jerusalem with his family and thru the silk route/spice route, reached his old places in the Himalayas where he preached till old age and is buried in Kashmir in northern India.
There are plenty of websites dedicated to this on the net where you can check this out (I personally saw this first in a newspaper and looked up the net). How many of you out here think this is logically possible? I am rather intrigued by this info and would like to have any other inputs any of you might have on this.
2 people like this
10 responses
@Frederick42 (2024)
• Canada
9 May 09
I am not sure about that. I do not think it makes much sense that he should have fled to India after his survival on the cross. It would make sense that he would flee before the cross itself.
If you make further study about Jesus, you would come to the conclusion that we do not know anything about the man called Jesus. Nothing is written about him while he was alive. There are too many similarities between some of the pagan gods and Jesus as portrayed in the gospels.
There is no evidence which says that Jesus spent his time in India or that he went there after his crucifixion. There are sites which say he went to Egypt and learnt everything there. This could be possible, because Egypt in those days had a rich civilization and spiritual philosophy.
1 person likes this
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
9 May 09
What you say holds much truth...Egypt in those days was kind of THE centre of all things in those regions, and Jesus was brought up in Egypt in his childhood (as sndcain has illuminated me) so it would have made sense for him to go to Egypt in his teens to learn trade or whatever. Also the discontent brewing against him was definitely in the open, so he could have fled before crucification. Regarding post-crucification, India or some unknown place could be the choice if he wanted to stay incognito.
What's confusing to me really is the fact that if you see the evidence, the people of Kashmir region are distinct in features from the rest of us in India (it is said they are from Jewish origin, some of the lost tribes of Israel)and Jesus went there to continue with his mission towards the Children of Israel.
Secondly, the tomb referred to has its direction in the Jewish tradition of burial rather than the surrounding Islamic direction of tombs.
BUT is it possible that if someone of Jesus' stature is buried there, its got so completely lost in history that even we, in India, dont know of it much? Or is it possible coz Jesus was not such a big stature to the people here in those time as its known that his cult spread mainly thru his disciples,long after his 'crucification'...or maybe it was known till the spread of Islam in Kashmir after which tomb lost its fame or was deliberately ignored?
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
10 May 09
Yes, I know about the Ahmedias, they are a separate sect unto themselves. What I am talking about however, is the migration of Jesus immediately after crucification and his settling in Kashmir valley (where supposedly some of the lost tribe of Israel were staying), spreading his teachings to them and dying at a ripe old age. Fascinating to say the least!
1 person likes this
@srganesh (6340)
• India
8 May 09
Yes!I too have heard about this.And some claim there are evidences to prove this to be true.But nobody have taken steps for it.If it can be true,the whole religion of Christianity will be at stake.
I learned that Jesus' preachings are influenced by Indian philosophy.That's why he was far from the old testament.For example,old testament claims a tooth for a tooth or an eye for an eye,the new testament speaks of showing your next chin when getting a hit in the first.Well,I expect this discussion will be on fire.Cheers!
1 person likes this
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
8 May 09
Don’t know about being on fire Ganesh, but seriously I was taken completely aback when I came across this and the way the evidences are provided on various sites in the net, you would be compelled to believe it. That’s why I started this discussion as I want to know from my friends out here, many of whom are very knowledgeable and logical on religious matters.
2 people like this
@becdmd (704)
• Philippines
8 May 09
I don't think it's possible, it's just like a story from other people without knowing the truth...One thing to be sure of Jesus is 100% human and 100% God so He cannot stay here on earth that long...He's mission was fulfilled then has been resurrected after 3 days, he's in Heaven now...and will be coming soon...there is no reliable source than the Holy Bible!(^_^), Making a blasphemous story will disrespect the deity nature of jesus.
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
8 May 09
I sure hope I haven’t offended you…I do not intend to make this a blasphemous post, I just want to see what my fellow members think, I am as intrigued and confused by this.
@stargirl85 (218)
• United States
8 May 09
I can honestly say that I have never heard this story of Jesus before. I do love to hear any new stories that come out. The historical part is what gets me what if this happened or that. If the story you are telling is true it changes alot, and makes for interesting conversation thats for sure. Personally I tend to believe the bible and stick with what it says.
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
9 May 09
Yes, I too am interested in the historical part, rather than the religious one. I started this discussion coz its intriguing to me too, and I wanted to see if any member can give any new inputs on this.
@ClassyCat (1214)
• United States
9 May 09
2nd Timothy 4:3,4
3. For the time will come when men will not put up with sound doctrine. Instead, to suit their own desires, they will gather around them a great number of teachers to say what their itching ears want to hear.
4. They will turn their ears away from the truth and turn aside to myths.
@AngryKittyMSV (4317)
• United States
8 May 09
I am Catholic (but not a very good one). I've never heard this theory before, but it is a very interesting explanation for his "missing" years of his life.
It is a very interesting and even plausible theory, but it would present a crisis of faith for billions of folks to entertain the idea that he didn't die for our sins and get resurrected.
I am interested to see how others respond to what you've put up here for consideration. To believe in this theory is to dismiss the accepted idea that the Bible is the true word of God, and without the resurrection, a huge chunk of Christianity would fall into question and those who explore the idea would be considered blasphemous.
Great discussion topic!
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
8 May 09
Marianne, I am absolutely and totally confused. The incident itself is so fascinating and fantastic, it seems something out of the realms of belief and non-belief. And the way the sites support their views with documents and evidences and historical anecdotes of travelers to those Buddhist caves where supposedly age old scrolls are kept with records, and then the Shroud of Turin…giving very scientific explanations as to why the Shroud is yet another proof that Jesus was brought down alive…simply mind blowing so I though let me blow all your brains too, why only me…let’s see that the mylot poll says
Regarding religion…nothing to worry, I am not a very worth Hindu either!
1 person likes this
@AngryKittyMSV (4317)
• United States
8 May 09
Maybe we should get together and become Buddhists (but not very good ones).
@fizanali (478)
• Pakistan
8 May 09
I think this story is absurd , though I'm not a christian but I can see that this story looks quiet false as it is the human nature to change facts and make things look dramatic and controversial.
Being a Muslim I have firm belief that Jesus will come back once again to this world and that he will be a normal man who will prove the Christians that he is not son of God but a messenger of God. His coming back would signify the end of times and the coming of the day of judgment.
So I don't believe the story you are telling because Jesus has not come back to the world yet.
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
8 May 09
OK but he is supposedly buried in Srinagar, Kashmir a Muslim majority state in India and his shrine is revered and protected by the Muslims there with the complete knowledge of who he is.
1 person likes this
@fizanali (478)
• Pakistan
8 May 09
But that's just a supposition you and I both haven't seen this in real or on TV and even if I had seen his shrine there protected by Muslims then still lots of doubts would remain because I've seen some Muslims and they believe anything you tell them.
I would only believe such a story if some one of high repute comes up with a lot of authentic evidence to support that Jesus is buried in Srinagar. Even then I won't believe the part of him being resurrected there because yoga and coming back from deep meditation are not resurrection.
@oyenkai (4394)
• Philippines
11 May 09
I have heard of this "theory" from my sister who heard it from someone else but I never thought to actually read up on it :) I do believe that one of the reasons why researchers thought of this as probably was because of Jesus' teaching on "do unto others what you want others to do unto you" which was very similar to an Indian Philosopher's teachings - some people think that Jesus was his pupil.
However, actually mediating on the cross to survive it is very unlikely. I've seen several features on the crucifixion and it's much worse than how most people understand it. It's one of the most horrendous torture devices and I am yet to see someone try it for himself and meditate in order to prove that it's actually achievable to surpass it.
Thanks for the response on my discussion!
@jazel_juan (15746)
• Philippines
9 May 09
wow really? but then it does not matter to me, i have my faith on where it is supposed to be. thank you anyways for the information,
@coolcoder (2018)
• United States
8 May 09
I think it's a load of garbage. Someone is once again trying to destroy Christianity, or at the very least, turn it into an insignificant cult, just one among many other insignificant little cults. It's disgusting.
Let someone say this about another faith such as Islam or Judaism, and all hell will break loose.
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
9 May 09
I'm sure Christianity is a very true and deep-rooted religion and has stood the test of time...so it wont be just relegated to any insignificant cult just like that. People who believe will always believe and people who seek will always do so...its the truth of all major religions.