an English question

@dufresne (137)
China
May 14, 2009 10:25am CST
In the sentence "Many years later, he was working as a high-ranking executive at Citibank and I phoned him to ask a small favor, to find somethng out for me.", would you think there should be a "for" between "ask" and "a small favor"?
2 people like this
3 responses
@cannibal (650)
• India
14 May 09
Not necessary. In fact it works correctly both ways! Like again, I'd say that if you're involved with some real, hardcore, formal, official English I'd suggest you to go with 'ask for a small favor' because, 'ask a small favor' sounds slangish or verbal sometimes. I'll give you a similar example. It's similar to the use of 'that' in the following: "She said I was right" can also be written as: "She said that I was right" ( But please note that 'that' here is supposedly a pronoun and for in your eg. is a preposition. So lay stress on how they sound. And they sound perfect in both cases!)
1 person likes this
@cannibal (650)
• India
14 May 09
Whoop!! I guess there's a goof-up! ('that' is actually a conjunction, probably a coordinating one)
@dufresne (137)
• China
14 May 09
Never mind. Actually I've found out, but I don't think it's a big matter. Don't be so hard on yourself, take it easy.
• United States
14 May 09
in proper english,you might want to add it,but in everyday usage it's really not necessary.
@katsalot1 (1618)
14 May 09
There could be, but it isn't necessary, especially as it is a quote of someone talking.