If Islam and Christianity came from the same God, why are they so different?
By moon317318
@moon317318 (692)
Pakistan
May 20, 2009 10:47pm CST
From the beginning of mankind, God has been sending His messengers to give mankind true guidance from God. Thus, Islam believes in all the prophets of God, before Muhammad (including Abraham, Moses and Jesus); and all the Books of God, before the Qur’an (including the Torah, the Psalms of David and the Gospel of Christ). No other religion does this.
Islam categorically states the existence of the One and Only God, Who is the Creator and Sustainer of the whole universe. This fact is stated in the Torah, the Gospel and in the Qur’an. Yet, the Christians of today follow the pagan idea of Trinity, introduced into Christianity by Paul of Tarsus. The unequivocal statements of all the Old Testament prophets, as well as Christ, about God, completely square with the idea of God presented by Islam.
If you consider the prophecies about a prophet-like-Moses, given in Deuteronomy 18: 18, Isaiah 42: 1-17, and about the Comforter, the Spirit of Truth or the Paraclete, in the Gospel, according to John 14 and 16, you can see clearly that this prophet could be none other than the last prophet of God, Muhammad (peace be upon him).
A study of the progressive guidance of God, through Judaism, Christianity and Islam, will clearly prove that Islam, as taught by Muhammad, is the culmination of that progression.
Consider the teachings of Islam: one god, one human race, one religion; belief in all the prophets of God, which is the ground of its tolerance; belief in the accountability of man in the hereafter. Besides, one can see the emphasis it lays on justice, equity and brotherhood in social life; and on purity, sincerity and the spirit of sacrifice in individual life.
Consider the intense practicality of Islamic teachings, its compatibility with science and technology and with modern times. Also see that it is the fastest growing religion now, in spite of all the adverse conditions and the most hostile propaganda against it.
As for the difference in the teachings of Christ and the teachings of Muhammad: The mission of Jesus was limited to the Children of Israel, as the Gospels themselves state it. For example in Matthew chapter 15, verse 24: Christ told his disciples: “I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel.” Christ’s mission was mainly to teach the Children of Israel of the meaninglessness of their literalism in their adherence to the letter of the Law if they ignored its spirit.
The Jews had become a very harsh people; for that was what they could learn from the strict teachings of the Law as taught by Moses. Jesus came to teach them compassion, love and mercy. Muhammad came to strike a balance between the two ways; his mission was to complete the religion of Islam, as he was the last prophet. So in Muhammad’s teachings, you can find a blend of the Mosaic Law’s strictness and Jesus’s mercy, as well.
That is the “middle path”. Muslims are described as “ummatan wasatan”, a balanced society. This is part of the perfecting of religion, since the complete religion would not be only mercy and sacrifice. It is practical and viable; it is a way of life, a complete way of life.
Jesus is reported to have said: “… but I say unto you, that ye resist not evil: but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also.” (Matthew 5: 39) “But I say unto you, Love your enemies ……” (Matthew 5: 44) These are beautiful ideals, but hardly practicable. How many Christians can turn the other cheek? Or love their enemies? They use cluster bombs to destroy innocent people who might, one day, possibly become their enemies. This is why Voltaire said: “There was only one Christian, and he was crucified.”
Muslims are not just directed to fight. It becomes their duty to fight in certain contexts; like when your sister is sexually attacked in front of you! “Resist not evil!!!” Think of it: not resisting evil, will be the greatest encouragement for evil in this wicked world. Well, as I said, Islam is a practical religion. It enjoins upon its followers piety and devotion; prayer and fasting, charity and sacrifice; purity and sincerity; love and mercy.
On the other hand, it asks its followers to stand out firmly for justice, even if it is against their own kith and kin. Justice should be done to all, whether they are friends or foes. To ask us to love the enemy is to ask us to do something impractical. Still, we are commanded to do justice to them, to all. This in a nutshell is Islam. And Allah knows best.
2 people like this
12 responses
@goldeneagle (6745)
• United States
21 May 09
The main difference is Islam and Christianity is that Muhammad is still rotting in his grave, while the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ is resurrected and is now in heaven...
2 people like this
@larrynicholas (404)
• India
21 May 09
I personally feel that the only difference is that the muslims still follow alot of the old testment and refuse to accept that Our Lord Jesus Christ is the son of God. It is the same with the jews too.
Alot of the prophets of us christians and the ones that the muslims believe in are the same. To name a few is isac, abhraham and some others.
So that is were the difference lies.
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
22 May 09
First get your basics correct:
Its "First of all" and not First a fall
Also its "Peace be upon him" and not Please be upon him
@CJscott (4187)
• Portage La Prairie, Manitoba
21 May 09
I would say, history, and mistranslation have a huge role to play in this. I understand that checks and balances were put in place to prevent change in the Quran, but not in the Bible. So that is why there are more Christian Sects, then there are Muslim Sects, but do bear in mind that fact that there are Sects at all, demonstrates my other point. Different people, read, and relate words differently, some can get others to see from their point of view, then a following develops, then a guideline for behavior, etc etc, until we have religion. That is my view. In the End, it will not matter who is right, and who is wrong. It will matter only whether or not GOD/ALLAH, which ever name you give him, believes each person individually to be righteous or not. Cheers.
1 person likes this
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
21 May 09
But how do you define the 'enemy'? Just as all coins have two sides, all conflicts have two sides, too! No man can watch his female members of society being raped...he will attack and try to defend whichever way he can, one doesnt need Islam for that!
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
22 May 09
No matter how much I read about Islam, I will never agree with the violence part of it. I am a born Hindu and firmly believe in the principle of forgiveness, even for the enemy. Hinduism identifies with no enemy coz our actions determine our afterlife, human beings are in no position to judge who is right and who is wrong. Also tolerance is another basic principle of Hinduism, we accept and respect all religions and we don’t think it is our duty to fight or discriminate against all those people who are not of our faith. Hinduism has no agenda for conversion…we firmly believe that truth is to be sought by individuals of their own free will, truth cannot be imposed on others. So if you are a Muslim, fine, I have no issues with you, I give all the respect to your beliefs, but you will have to introspect and see if you can give the same respect to my beliefs.
@cet1987 (209)
• Malaysia
21 May 09
of course no man can watch his female members of society being raped.. that's on principle.. Islam is a perfect religion ( in my opinion)and Islam is the way of life.. you should study Islam very deep.. it consist of akidah, ibadah and akhlak. if you can understand these principle then you will see the beautiful of Islam.
@Mikaela_taz25 (1842)
• Philippines
21 May 09
THat's one of the main reasons why we are still fighting with each other because of the difference of these religions and some on both of these sides are extremist and refuse to tolerate or get along with the other. I hope one day that all people who worshipped these religions would learn to get along if not submit to the other. we came and worshipped on GOD after all.
@moon317318 (692)
• Pakistan
22 May 09
[b]well apart from all these difference , there are thousands of Similarities between Islam and Christianity...
[/b]
@DanBen (346)
• India
21 May 09
I would love to respond to this topic of your, but it's hard for me to summarize my views. Read the following link(s) and see if it answers your queries.
http://muslim-canada.org/islam_christianity.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_and_Islam
1 person likes this
@Chiang_Mai_boy (3882)
• Thailand
21 May 09
If your post was not plagiarized from here http://www.readingislam.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1123996015476&pagename=IslamOnline-English-AAbout_Islam%2FAskAboutIslamE%2FAskAboutIslamE I would respond to it. Since it is plagiarized I won't bother since it will be removed anyway.
@justinus (1104)
• Karawaci, Indonesia
21 May 09
Hello, young man, I am christian (catholic), I do believe that God is the same every where all the time. Only peoples or human has difference perspective to God (sorry I dont meant I would like to debate about faith but rather want to post my interesting topic, because as more than 3 years myLot member I posted only less than 400) that's the main problem if it present between peoples among religions. As far as I know Moslem dont agree that Jesus called as God but only Allah is the only One God. even Jewish refused Jesus as prophet and sent him to Roman empire although according Islam, Jesus did not send to crucified but God the Almighty replaced him with thief. (I will not quote any word of Bible of Al Qouran, it will take a lot of time for this public online "discuss"). To me the difference between Islam and cristian is only : about description of God and Allah teaching, marriage, as you told christian stressed to love, Islam to stressed justice BUT there a lot of same or similar story betwee cristian and Moslem. Let's say about the 25 big Prophet : Adam and story about Kain an Habel, Moses, Noah, Ishak, Jacob, Abraham, David, Solomon, Joop, Yusuf etc., they all was told with the same story, didn't them ? Only becuse prophet Muhammad was born later after Jesus then Mohammad story is not quoted in Bible. Yes, why, these SAME story ending with the difference, why did not most cristian and Moslem focus to these same teaching, we can have our own reason. But based on the same Prophet story, I am sure Cristianity and Islam was came from the SAME GOD, only people perspective is difference, it doesn't matter to me, and to you too I wish. Thank you and very sorry if there any not proper words. I love you.
@naka75 (795)
• Singapore
21 May 09
They are different because the believers or we human beings perceive them to be different. If the so called almighty power is almighty then it could just create perfectly obedient human beings then we don't have this issue. But it would also mean the god is inhumane if he created human beings that are not allowed to have different thinking and feelings that relate to our lives and environment we live, the people we relate to etc. I'm a Buddhist, if you ask me do I believe in God, I'd ask you it depends on what do you define God to be? Since in the western and middle eastern world, God has different definitions, I'd rather liken God to be an all encompassing law governing everything in the universe, whether living or insentient matter, or what you would call omnipresence. When we human beings view in this way in the realm of entire universe, how superficial is our differences that lead us to senseless war and violence. Fighting for justice is novel, but as religions are born out of human beings to serve fellow human beings, it will become self-contradictory if it is used as a justification to kill human beings because the religion says so. The question is does standing up for justice makes us better, wiser, happier human beings or does it plunge us deeper into abyss of evil, the evil of hatred towards fellow humans, the poison in us that is not even the fault of God, but it has been with us all along since the day we are born.
What Buddhism teaches me is the advice "kill the need to kill", which means we have to kill the inner darkness or the evil in us by bringing out the inner goodness of human beings for a greater good. Yes there are definitely differences between each major religion and they will not go away, nor any one party can impose their views on the other and no one human being is perfect. Differences are not important, what is more important is do we allow these differences to destroy us all or we harness them to become more understanding and harmonious? As a Buddhist, we are welcome to study into other faiths and also open our doors to welcome our fellow men and women to hold inter-faith dialogue and exchanges, because we all know the last thing we want to see is war that will lead to endless sufferings and never ever solve any problem, not to mention the differences between the religions. If Buddhism can take a step foward, why not others? I'm sure God will encourage you to do so and give you courage. Palms closed in reverence.
@venmarz13 (735)
• Indonesia
21 May 09
Are you moslem?Im moslem.As long as i know islam and christian is same in god before.When there is any new agreement(i dont know the name exactly)it should different now they(christ) is think that yesus is they god.An moslem is think that Allag is the only god.And Allah is so different with jesus.Allah is not human,plant,planet,star,sun,or every thing that Allah was created.You get that?So You are wrong if NOW you tell that both of them have the same God.I think christ wil not accept it and also moslem will reject it too.So i think,let people choose that.
@tundeemma (894)
• South Africa
21 May 09
there is one God no doubt who created both christians and muslims but man has always wanted to please himself by creating unneccassary tension within ourselves, we always want to differ in our thinking and making the whole process of relision looks like God is so far, God is very close to us and we need to worship him not fighting each other over unworthy ideas
@uoriej19 (34)
• Philippines
24 May 09
OK.. let us compare religion with literature. Literature is handed on from generation to generation through the word of mouth. Religion on the other hand is passed through teachings. Literature becomes slightly altered as it is passed. I think that's the same principle with religion.
Religion also goes through evolution, downfall and uprise. Just like the adaptation principle of evolution. Religion also adapts somthing as it passes through different culture. And now this is the result of that adaptation, 2 exactly opposite religion which is rooted from one.
What we are sure right now is that God made his promise with Abraham, to become the father of nations. Through him, Christianity and Islam(through his son Ishmael) were created.