Why would anyone eat that?

United States
June 25, 2009 9:18pm CST
A previous post got me to thinking about how we came to eat some of the things we do. Run a mental movie, and see if you can imagine why somebody looked at an oyster and thought it might be good to eat. The same goes for its cousins, the clam and the mussel. I can't imagine picking up any of those and thinking of food at all! Why would someone see a crab scuttling along in the water and decide to rip off its hideous armor to find the great reward inside? Lobsters, and especially spiny lobsters, do all they can to drive us away, yet we savor every morsel. Would you have thought it was food if you were the first person to pick one up? What about frog legs? Or caviar? Most fish are ugly and slimy and nasty-looking, too. I understand about meats of various types, since an animal might have fallen in the fire near a cave and just smelled too good to resist, but most seafood smells about as horrible as it looks! Add all the foods you enjoy, and can you really imagine how anyone would have been the first to eat most of them? Kiwi fruit, anyone?
5 people like this
14 responses
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
26 Jun 09
I think it was a matter of survival as to why people thought of eating the things they do. Don't forget chocolate covered ants, I think I've had one or two of those before. I'm not sure why anyone would want to eat some of the things that they do. Hmm, sorry I can't think of anything else, food wise, that is nasty to eat. Kiwi Fruit is good though, I haven't had one of those in a while. Have a wonderful day / night / whatever time it is there mylotting.
2 people like this
• United States
26 Jun 09
Kiwis are a great example! There was a time when they were called Uglifruit!
3 people like this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
29 Jun 09
Ah yes! I've heard of uglifruit! I never realized that kiwi and uglifruit were one in the same! Thanks for that insight! Learn something new everyday on here! lol!
@urbandekay (18278)
13 Jul 09
Run the same movie with people eating eggs raw and all parts of animals raw; Perhaps no longer so surprising? all the best urban
1 person likes this
@urbandekay (18278)
14 Jul 09
Well, I guess if you are hungry enough you will eat anything; starving people have been known to eat grass all the best urban
• United States
14 Jul 09
The question remains, my friend. Why would somebody do that whenever the first person did it? Joanne
@polachicago (18716)
• United States
26 Jun 09
Imagination is a big help. I am vegetarian by choice. It makes me happy. I don't have to think about pig or cow on my plate, I rather pet them... I don't want to mention other animals, wings are for fly not fry... Kiwi? any time...I love all fruits and I am mostly fruitarian.... During the summer time I eat mostly fruits and some Raw veggies... I wish people use their imagination before they eat... Survival is the other side of the story, but we don't have that problem in most countries, except people who die because of limited access to water and any food... HUGS
@polachicago (18716)
• United States
26 Jun 09
when did you have chemo?
• United States
26 Jun 09
Hi, Pola! I admire your veggie choice. I was a vegetarian until chemotherapy made me dangerously anemic and I was ordered to eat red meat as part of my therapy. It was hard for a very long time. I kept picturing the animals' faces and those big eyes!
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Jul 09
It's been almost 10 years, but anemia still causes me a lot of problems. I had surgery Monday, and they kept pumping the oxygen more and more heavily, and made me stay longer, because my "weak blood" wasn't getting oxygenated enough. Not fun! Now I just can't wait for the stitches to come out. While they're still in there, I can neither talk nor eat, and I'm really tired of juice!
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
26 Jun 09
Alright a food topic! Right up my alley! OK, throughout history, people have gone through times of great starvation. Drought, blight, pestilance, etc. During those times, people get despirate. They try to eat anything that doesn't try to eat them first. And sometimes, even stuff that tries to eat them first (shark, crocodile or alligator) to survive. I have had or seen recipes for the following: Locusts and honey (Based on the Bible Cookbook) bee lava soup ( Native American Indian tribe cookbook-forget which tribe or tribes, but has to be Woodland Eastern Indians, other than clothes, don't have tribal books from other areas) bug juice-the real bug juice made with red ants (Some survival camp book I found at the library) Most books from other cultures or survival books have all kinds of stuff to eat that you would never think of eating. People must get really, really hungry!
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
27 Jun 09
I think the locusts and honey would be rather crunchy. If the locusts we cooked, dried, powdered and blended in with the honey, I could probably do it. Just don't tell me and let me see what they look like and I'll be fine. The bug juice one, you strain all the bugs out. Supposed to taste like lemonade. But the bee larva soup, I think there's no way to keep me from being really ill just looking at that one. My Dad and brother got drunk one night and ate chocolate covered ants. They didn't remember doing it the next day. I asked them what they were like and couldn't remember.
• United States
26 Jun 09
To us, that seems so terrible! In some cultures, though, these things are goodies!
1 person likes this
@thea09 (18305)
• Greece
30 Jun 09
Living in a place where the staple food is olives often sets me thinking how people discovered to eat them. When they are on the trees, even when ripe, they are inedible, very bitter, no one eats them. To make them edible they have to be soaked in salt water which is changed regularly for forty days - who discovered this, who had forty days and patience enough to know that this was how the olives became edible, how did the word spread. I can understand that in the areas here where little grows apart from olives that wild greens were eaten, and snails, but who actually found out how to make an inedible fruit edible. Fascinating subject this one.
• United States
6 Jul 09
That's another part of this -- how did we know the first time somebody cooked or marinated or pickled something that it would be good?
@thea09 (18305)
• Greece
6 Jul 09
Exactly.
@airakumar (1553)
• India
1 Jul 09
There are variety of eatable foods on the earth which we can eat. There are many fruits and vegetables as well as seafoods also which looks ugly but they are very beneficial for health. That why we would eat it for good health. Kiwi fruits looks ugly but it taste well. I like it. Try it you will like it too.
• United States
6 Jul 09
I LOVE kiwis and all the seafoods I mentioned. I just can't imagine how the first person who decided to eat ugly things made that decision. In some parts of the world, things are eaten regularly that people in other parts of the world have never even heard of, so it's not as if we were somehow born with the knowledge that this was food and that wasn't!
@writersedge (22563)
• United States
26 Jun 09
Bee larva, not lava, sorry.
@schulzie (4061)
• United States
26 Jun 09
Wow! I know you are in Florida as I am and you don't like shellfish!?! I hate seafood, I don't eat fish. I especially can't stand the thought of eating shellfish, oysters, clams, muscles, lobsters, shrimp, anything like that. I always think that lobsters and shrimp look just like insects. I am not too keen on eating cockroaches and the like and I equate lobster and shrimp to cockroaches. I guess the first people that ate these things must have been extremely desperate. That is the only thing I can think. I personally would rather eat grass than a clam or lobster. Yuck! Have a nice day and happy myLotting!!!
• United States
26 Jun 09
shulzie, I LOVE shellfish. I just can't figure out why anyone would have discovered they were so delicious!
@leenie50 (3992)
• United States
26 Jun 09
Hi Jo, My first thought when you started talking about the different seafoods and why anyone would eat them, makes me think that it may have first been eaten by people that lived along the coast and fished for food as a part of their survival. And it slowly became a delicacy to new comers. But like you I can't help but wonder how and why anything was first tasted and eaten. Hugsssss leenie
• United States
26 Jun 09
Those shells aren't easy to open. I wonder if I would have thought to try! XOXO
1 person likes this
@savypat (20216)
• United States
26 Jun 09
I often wonder who was the brave soul that first ate some of the things we eat. Mushrooms are my first question. So many are so deadly poison and others have terrible side effects, how did they ever figure that one out?
• United States
26 Jun 09
Somebody apparently went scrabbling around in the dirt to discover potatoes and other root vegetables, too. I can't imagine what would have made them eat them!
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Jun 09
As I said above...they observed what the animals ate. But I saw a documentary once that showed what might have happened when certain plants that cause hallucinations were eaten. Now that's food for another discussion. ;)
@billzehua (573)
• China
26 Jun 09
seems that one's mouth's functioning is directly linked to his mind, if you have ever lived near the shore living by fishing for years or dacades or for your whole life,how you can resist them since they keep coming into your eyes... but have you ever heard of people eating infants,that gotta be more gross
• United States
26 Jun 09
Shellfish, for the most part, just look like stones. What would have made anyone work hard enough to get those shells open and find food there? I really hope there isn't anyone in the practice of eating babies!
1 person likes this
@candy2306 (576)
• India
26 Jun 09
hi, i guess human are very curious creatures! they like to try something new all the time as they get bored so fast. one who lives in jungle get meat and hunt for meat and one who lives by sea gets seafood and fish for one! So it's a survival thingy. If you were sent to desert (ex:place that you've never been to), and you need to eat for living. What would you do? Say 'NO' to desert lizards which is the only thing you can survive on? Once you start eating it, others who's with you will eat it too! after a decade, you get it grilled lizard instead of raw! Life has to go on and people forget how 'eewww' a lizard could taste!
• United States
26 Jun 09
A friend told me lizards are a common and delicious dish in Central America. But why would anyone think clams or oysters were any different from other stones found on the shore
1 person likes this
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
28 Jun 09
My opinion is that we have been misled as to the early history of our race. Mankind did not start out ignorant and animal like in his thinking. I believe that we have digressed rather than progressed.Man has lost much of the knowledge he once had. By observing nature man probably had aquired much understanding about his surroundings...you seem to be really worried about the clams and oysters...lol. So just imagine a tidal pool full of the little creatures...when tide is low, you see them there - open to catch food for themselves and viola', you wonder if these living creatures who eat...can be eaten. As for plants...observing what the animals ate...will give you security that it was safe for you to eat. Observation of nature gave mankind the knowledge he needed to survive. Just ask the Native Americans and other indeginous peoples of the world who have developed great understanding of they physical world and even apply it to their spiritual place in this world.
• China
26 Jun 09
even I was thinking this question these days when I saw people eating insects. so sick when I saw them. i can't imaging how i can put a insect into my mouth....but my brother tell me that long ago ,it is also same to eat crap and tomato. maybe after a long time, most people will accept the insects as a delicious food.
• United States
26 Jun 09
I've read a number of recipes for various insects, which are commonly eaten in some cultures. I don't think I would like to try them, but you never know what you might do if you're hungry!
1 person likes this
@kruxius (204)
• Portugal
15 Jul 09
Eating animals as been the most normal thing for the human being! Since the age of caverns we humans started to hunt animals that age it was just an instinct that persons were developing themselves trying to find new things to eat and survive... Most of the sea food comes from the seamen that were searching for new lands and exploring this world, so they have to eat something mainly they were fishers and they were able to eat any fish but some of them just do not survive to that life, eating sea food can be really healthy but at the same time really dangerous. That men just do not cook their fish they eat it like it is, can you imagine someone making fire n a boat? Maybe it's not a good idea! There were places were just not a single animal appears so if it's near the sea the persons who live there must have to fish or if it's here any fish they have to find other way to survive there like eating bugs plants anything they just try anything to survive. So from that age people were just looking for ways to survive and expand their knowledge, today we just explore the good and bad things they found out it's just that all about exploring. There is no need to eat the things the ate on the past ecause today is really easy to choose what we want to do and have. Be happy, nice topic! myLot 4 life :D
• United States
15 Jul 09
Excellent response! I really can't figure out things like clams and oysters or mussels, because they just look like rocks in the ocean. Why would someone have thought to open them up, or to eat the ugly things inside. I'm glad they figured it out, because they're so delicious,
@kruxius (204)
• Portugal
15 Jul 09
Yes it's true but not all the beauty and smelly things are good to eat sometimes the most ugly fat and bad smelling things have like super nutrients and vitamins and some times they are really tasty :D