Are dogs smarter than cats?

@toonvk (267)
Belgium
June 30, 2009 3:16pm CST
My cat gives paws, waits in every door opening until I say she can enter the room, only takes a poo or pee in their special cat toilet, etc... Do you think dogs could do that too? Do you think dogs are smarter than cats? Tell me all about it
1 person likes this
7 responses
@tonyllenium (6252)
• Italy
30 Jun 09
i don't know but i think that is not a dog is smart than cat or the contrary but simply they are different as the way they will have a behaviour or interect with you as well! So normally i like more dogs than cats in general but i don't think there is one smarter but just different way to interact with people and live their lives too!!
2 people like this
@toonvk (267)
• Belgium
30 Jun 09
Good point you have there. Thanks for posting
• India
30 Jun 09
Ya my dog knocks on the door to get inside. He gets me the news paper everyday. He also poo and pee in the toilet. Don't you know most of the handicap people are given with trained dogs to help them in there daily life. Have you ever hard a cat is given to handicap. So what do you think now who is smarter. I will say dogs are smarter.
1 person likes this
• India
30 Jun 09
I am saying that dogs are utilizing both power and brain. Let me make you understand when the find news paper they know that i need it so he takes it and gives it to me whether i am in bed room or in lawn. You say poo and pee in toilet are smartness then why can't knocking at the door is smartness. By the way what you have written now in this discussion my dog does it all and also other things.
1 person likes this
@toonvk (267)
• Belgium
30 Jun 09
I'll just say cats can't carry newspapers or open doors. They're not big enough. Power and brains are two different things
@OConnell87 (1042)
30 Jun 09
my dog lets us know when he needs food or water, and when he wants to go outside. He knows the drawer in the kitchen which has his leads and treats and gets really excited when you open it. He understands sit and paw before he gets a treat and before we answer the dog he knows to sit on the bottom of the stairs and calm down before we let him greet a visitor. he puts himself to bed aswell if i'm up late quite a character
1 person likes this
@toonvk (267)
• Belgium
30 Jun 09
seems to be a very smart dog. I'd love to have one like that
• Canada
2 Jul 09
Dogs r a little smarter than cats, or cats r just to independant. Dogs will do more than cats to get attension and affection. You can train a dog to go 4 a walk, a cat on a leash for a walk for more than 5 minutes is a choir. Dogs can be taught to do their thing on your property only, like my dogs, Bouviers, working dogs. Dogs can learn and do more than cats, obediance training, guard training, tracking and a few more.. Cats / dogs hunt / track / and numerous other things.. P.S I really luv cats to Himalayans / Siamese / lions / tigers / linx / bobcats and bears . That's another story.. REMEMBER ALWAYS LUV YOUR DOG / PET, THEY WILL ALWAYS LUV U..
@toonvk (267)
• Belgium
7 Jul 09
You're properly right. Thanks for the answer!
@Rafayel (54)
• Sri Lanka
3 Jul 09
i realy think both of them are at a even keel.my dog never leaves my side while i'm at home. She also knows when its time to eat, and when it's time to sleep (din mean that to rhyme). What my dog hates most in the world is a bath and if i have a horse in my hand, my dog will be in the next neighbourhood. But overall, my dog thinks i am master, and should never displease me. Where as my cat, is a different story.my cat is never home except on weekends and at eating times. Which show that he knows to tell time^^. What my cat hates most in the world is my younger brother, and trys its beest not to be seen with him. they realy do out do them selvs, but since i prefer dogs, i say thats dogs are smarter, coz they know how to be family.
1 person likes this
@toonvk (267)
• Belgium
7 Jul 09
That's a good answer. Thank you for that. Have a nice day
• United States
1 Jul 09
Smarter is a pretty ambiguous qualifier. I think dogs and cats have different kinds of intelligence.Is empathy a form of intelligence? Compassion? Ability to think about others? I think cats are very logical creatures - they figure out how to get what they want, how to use the litter box, where they can be, what they can get away with, and how to trick people into giving them things. Dogs, however, legitimately want to please you. They actually like you and will figure things out because it is in their nature to please their master. Dogs also develop a sense of selfless loyalty and compassion. Dogs may not have the same, manipulative logic as cats, but they are quick learners because they want to figure out how to please you. They learn because of empathy, not just for self-betterment. Believe it or not, I'm a cat person, but I think that empathy, compassion, and open-mindedness are more important than clever manipulation. Dogs and cats have different types of intelligence - dogs have a more advanced social intelligence.
@toonvk (267)
• Belgium
1 Jul 09
Wow that's a great view you have there. Thank you for posting, It's a nice answer.
• United States
30 Jun 09
As with people, I think it depends on the individual. As Tony stated, it's more a matter of how they think, dogs are eager while cats are lazy. How dose the joke go? A dog thinks "this person feeds me, shelters me and loves me, they must be god." a cat thinks "this person feeds me, shelters me and loves me, I must be god."
1 person likes this
@toonvk (267)
• Belgium
30 Jun 09
Haha didn't hear that one before! Thanks for your post, have a good day