splenda? Please explain!!!

United States
July 5, 2009 12:51pm CST
Okay, I admit my complete ignorance on this topic! I have been trying to eliminate sugars out of my diet entirely. I want to only have natural sugars that are like actual real fruit and items such as that! (Maybe we could label it "virtual" sugar or something! lol!) Anyway... I hear it over and over that splenda is made "from" sugar.... I don't get it... doesn't that make it MORE processed rather than less? I try to stay away from processed foods altogether, but some times that is not possible... help me out here please!!
3 people like this
7 responses
@rsa101 (38166)
• Philippines
6 Jul 09
As far as I know Splenda is a kind of artificial sweetener that is being recommended to those that has sugar problems like diabetics are. They are preferred by others that hate Aspartame as alternative sweeteners since Aspartame is known to have those side effects. But with Splenda they calim they use a different ingredient that came from natural sweeteners so they are safer to use than the sweeteners that contain aspartame.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Jul 09
I won't touch anything containing aspartame! I try to stay away from all arificial sweeteners if it is at all possible! I don't go for the "sugar free" labels as that usually means that there is a load of garbage in it instead! My question about splenda has to do with the statement that it is "made from sugar"... to me that sounds much more processed and as someone already pointed out sugar is also processed..... ugh! Moving on to honey and maybe Stevia!!!
@rsa101 (38166)
• Philippines
7 Jul 09
Yes they say it came from sugar itself but is less harmful than sugar itself which means it is a bit friendly to those that are diabetics. And since it came from sugar it is slightly natural with the exception that they have been processed further to be safely taken in by diabetics. As for Stevia and honey they are also said to come from natural processes too and is said to be safe for diabetics too.
@rsa101 (38166)
• Philippines
7 Jul 09
Yes they say it came from sugar itself but is less harmful than sugar itself which means it is a bit friendly to those that are diabetics. And since it came from sugar it is slightly natural with the exception that they have been processed further to be safely taken in by diabetics. As for Stevia and honey they are also said to come from natural processes too and is said to be safe for diabetics too.
@yugasini (12893)
• Secunderabad, India
6 Jul 09
hi macdingolinger, let me know what is your problem,if it is with sugar,you can also use "Stevia" a sugar alternative try it
@yugasini (12893)
• Secunderabad, India
6 Jul 09
hi macdingolinger, thanks for the response/comment, neither i have diabetic nor Blood Pressure, i have responded your discussion,that all recomended for your only so take care of your health and take advice of doctor and do accordingly, happy day
@ClassyCat (1214)
• United States
6 Jul 09
Here's a link on the dangers of Splenda: http://www.holisticmed.com/splenda I have a really bad reaction to Splenda, and Stevia. I use an all natural liquid sweetner called Agave (pronounced ah-gave-a) Nectar. It has no after taste and is even safe for diabetics. Because it is a liquid, it mixes well with one's tea, coffee, or pours easily over a bowl of cereal. It is quite sweet though, so you won't have to use a lot. Another highly recommended sweetner that is all natural is called Xylitol. It too can be used by diabetics and has no bad taste to it. Some of these sweetners are a bit more expensive, but you use less, so it all works out, and they are far better for you than sugar - even brown sugar and or honey, with higher glysemic indexes. Love my agave nectar!
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Jul 09
Thanks to both of you for your responses... yeah, it's looking like my best bet is to go all natural and use no sweeteners at all! What caused your reaction to Stevia? Do you have other allergies? I know I cannot drink teas containing thistle or nettle because of other allergies!
@ladym33 (10979)
• United States
6 Jul 09
Splenda is made from real sugar but it is much lighter and less grainier than real sugar. My guess is they process it more by crushing it up more to make it lighter, at least that is how it feels. I think it has the same concept as whipped cream cheese, if you whip it up more and make it less dense it has less calories per serving. I could be wrong though, it wouldn't be the first time. , but I think if you to see it and touch it you might tend to think I at least make some sense.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Jul 09
I'm not sure I buy the concept that is is just ground finer than sugar!!It is more processing and cannot be anything good for you!
@Barbietre (1438)
• United States
6 Jul 09
Look all those who think splenda is evil cause it has the chlorine compund, they also better not use table salt NaCl, another chlorine compound.Many natural things are chemicals. Water is h2o, hydrogen and oxygen. And sugar is NOT natural by any means, it has to be processed also to get to that state. It starts out as sugar cane and then is then processed further. Read this link http://www.essortment.com/all/processmakings_rzkc.htm I use liquid stevia, it is less bitter, also I use a sweetener called just like sugar made from chickory root http://www.justlikesugarinc.com/
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Jul 09
I am looking further into Stevia... I hadn't heard of the sweetener made from chickory root.. I'll look into thatalso! Thanks for the links and the good information!
@commanderxo (1494)
• Canada
8 Jul 09
Johnson & Johnson's "Splenda", is a chemical replacement made from real sugar, called Sucralose. There are numerous pros and cons, as to the level of toxicity this product has. Results are speculative at best. My best suggestion is to use what's already natural. There's nothing wrong with using bleached (white) sugar, made from the natural "brown sugar" cane, providing it's used in moderation. Just don't over do it. A teaspoon full, is more than enough. Remember your basic biochemistry? The body converts sugar(s) into energy, even WITHOUT the aid of adding sugar externally. Indeed it does! This "sugar" is stored within the muscles from the foods that you eat. Whether you add sugar to your diet or not, your body already has its own supply. It (your body) will ONLY use this muscular sugar, when there is no other supply being introduced. However...it DOES use some of it along WITH other external sugars introduced, thereby creating somewhat of an "overdose". This is why some people can appear hyper at times. If you're really worried about the amount of sugar intake, then do as you say...eat NATURAL fruits instead, and only partially ingest the other store-bought stuff. Using it for baking? That's O.K. But like I say, if you're worried about how much you use, say in your coffee or tea each day, then use another alternative such as a packet of LOW calorie...Sweat "N Low, or some other similar low calorie brand name(s). cdrxo
• Canada
9 Jul 09
Ohhhhhh no! Bad girl. And you were doing so well, too. mmm, mmm, mmm. (wagging my finger) ;-D cdrxo
• United States
8 Jul 09
Thanks for the response! I think you are right about white sugar at least being somewhat less processed than other substitutes. I think I will begin to use more of the brown or raw sugars! I keep thinking that but those reese's cups are do darn hard to give up!!!
1 person likes this
@thea09 (18305)
• Greece
17 Jul 09
Hi macdinglolinger, I have never heard of splenda! If you use it as a sugaring agent in drinks just stop adding the sugar full stop, after about a week you will not be able to abide the taste of sugar in your drinks. I add sugar to very little, just to some cakes I bake. I've become pretty addicted to honey though which I eat everyday in Greek yogurt. If you don't use processed foods sugar is pretty easy to avoid. I've taught my son that pop drinks are nothing but sugar so should be avoided as they dehydrate you and he knows that they are more fattening as full of empty calories than an actual meal: he's happy to stick to water with the odd fanta as a treat when we are out.
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Jul 09
I do avoid the carbonated - highly sugared - drinks! Occasionally I will have one but very rarely! I have been cutting back on sugar consumption overall. I also try to completely avoid processed foods as they contain so much junk and less nutritional values! They usually have tons of sodium in them too!
• United States
5 Jul 09
LOL....dont feel bad, I am trying to cut down on the sugar in my diet as well. I have been substituting REAL honey in as many places as I can. You can buy real honey at most health food stores and at organic grocery stores. I use splenda in my coffee at work, but I know that splenda, nutrasweet and equal are not the best for our bodies. Try brown sugar as a substitute as well. Brown sugar has not been processed like white sugar. I use it in combo with the honey when I make sweet tea at home. I also use sugar in the raw. the best subs are the real honey and the brown sugar. Hope that helps. :)
• United States
5 Jul 09
Real honey and brown sugar are my choices! I am still not seeing how splenda is better than sugar... it sounds more processed! I do not use sugar substitutes... ever! I am just trying to safely get to my 50's! thanks for the response