Is genetic memory real? Do we carry within us the experiences of our ancestors?
By debrakcarey
@debrakcarey (19887)
United States
July 22, 2009 12:50pm CST
I am asking this question because today I spoke up on a discussion and posted some strong feelings I have always had about the treatment of the Native Americans. Then my next discussion to respond to was about Celtic music and I realized that I have very strong feelings on this too. My mother's mother was from Ireland and my father's mother was Native American. Are their experiences buried deep within my psyche? Are my strong emotions tied to these two discussions coming from what they exeprienced in some way? I am wondering this because though I have many interests about all human culture and history, these two seem to be the most emotional and passionate for me. What do you think?
3 people like this
9 responses
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
22 Jul 09
I believe that a person grows up and hears things around them that shape them. However, I also believe that as people often say "It's in my blood". I believe that people who have had ancestors that for instance, were slaves, or who traveled to America when it was first formed, or who have gone through hardships, these people's experiences and emotions, and dedication and sweat, have been poured from generation to generation. Have been imbedded in the blood.
Like different races have different ailments, some so similar, some so different and some the same. Those that are different, shape the race, shape the people, and cause them be different, to be known as different...
I guess, I've lost my inspiration, but I hope you understand my meaning.
1 person likes this
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
22 Jul 09
Perhaps you are right. I am not genetically linked to my mother's step father who was Jewish...but I have a very strong emotional connection to the Jewish/Israeli experience as well.
1 person likes this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
22 Jul 09
That goes with shaping and hearing, and believing. It's fun to find things out about yourself you never realized. I like to just sit and think about things like this.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
22 Jul 09
Me too! I used to think I was real weird like that...but good to hear someone else thinks about strange concepts.
1 person likes this
@cobrateacher (8432)
• United States
22 Jul 09
Hi, Dabrak!
I believe the genetic material we have in our genes contains elements of the experiences and attitudes of our forebears. There's so much more to us than our physical beings, it just makes sense tat emotional and spiritual information is on those strands of DNA along with the physical!
@cobrateacher (8432)
• United States
23 Jul 09
Sometimes, I think the mysteries make us all that much more interesting.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
23 Jul 09
Contemplate this...the brain is a physical organ made up of fatty tissues, chemicals and various proteins....we can measure its makeup and weigh it. It can be empirically studied. Yet...all those physical elements of its structure contain the 'mind', which science has yet to 'locate' and when attempting to 'measure' can only hope they are doing so correctly.
Yes, there is much more to us than the physical. Life continues to be shrouded in some mysteries...despite our efforts to understand it.
1 person likes this
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
23 Jul 09
I believe that people are connected to their ancestry,their roots, in one way or another no matter how far removed they are by generation placing.
Some persons of course could not care less from whence their family originated but I believe that for the most part people are curious about their roots. It is natural to feel some sense of hurt or pride triggered by the experiences of our ancesters.
Whether it was enslavement, gold mining, the wid west, native indians, aborriginals or jews, we tend to connect with the experiences our ancesters went through.
Our curiousity leads us to find out about our grand and great grand parents. We connect or seek to understand their way of life,their music and their value system. I believe that somehow even one of these becomes a part of us.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
23 Jul 09
Perhaps it is merely the propensity towards a given interest that we inherit?
It works that way with degenerative diseases. Some people can smoke their entire lives and never develope lung cancer, yet someone who never smoked may develope it. Our DNA is an amazing thing. Who knows what it contains. I look forward to further knowledge being made available since our entire genome has been unraveled. As a side note...Dr. Fransis Collins who worked as one of the heads of this gigantic undertaking...believes in Intelligent Design. He wrote a book called The Language of God. I recommend it highly.
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
22 Jul 09
I think it's just natural to be able to relate to things that we are familiar with and to have an interest in things related to our ancestry. I doubt that it has anything to do with genetic memory, but who knows?
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
23 Jul 09
Well I do believe there are things out there that we don't understand. Maybe this is one of them.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
23 Jul 09
There have been some things that there was no possibility of it being something I was familiar with physically. But, I am realistic enough to say that I am not sure of my hypothisis. lol You know me....I am a little weird at times.
1 person likes this
@tomjoad (551)
• Philippines
23 Jul 09
i haven't heard any scientific studies about genetic memory. i'm pretty sure it's just a misconception and in my opinion there is no such thing. maybe these strong feelings that you have are manifestations of what you believe in. each person has beliefs handed down from their culture, tradition, and religion. i could be wrong but probably you care for the welfare of the native americans because you have a strong affiliation towards them. as you have mentioned, you have a native american blood running in your veins. i believe these strong feelings that you have are manifestations of your experiences and not manifestations of your ancestors experiences. well, feel free to disagree! i did learn a new term today.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
23 Jul 09
Due to divorce I was not even aware I had Native blood until I was 17. Yet, I had an affinity for drumming (tried to make my own drum when I was 8) and for other 'earthy' activities since I was able to remember.
Same with my Irish 'roots'. I read a book at about age 25, "How the Irish Saved Civilization", which gives descriptions of many 'customs' and 'folkways' of the Irish and repeated said to myself...That is why I do that!
It is interesting to note....due to being born late in life to my parents, I never met my biological grandparents. They had passed by the time I was born. And due to my parents divorcing...any traditions my family had were basically lost in the upheaveal. In fact, my mother is also half Italian and our day to day life reflected more of those traditions than Irish ones. (food, mannerisms etc.)
I don't know if I believe this hypothisis or not...lol. But it is an intriguing one.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
24 Jul 09
Thank you. If my heart is 'good' as you say...it is because I have seen suffering and instead of allowing bitterness to take root, I have tried hard to grow love and compassion. Thank you tomjoad.
@tomjoad (551)
• Philippines
24 Jul 09
wow so many mixed blood in there! thank you for sharing your story. well, i guess i could say as a young child you were more aware of your surroundings than most girls at that age. i guess that's the reason why you're concerned about people today. you have a good heart!
@heartbeats1010 (206)
• India
23 Jul 09
I do believe that some sort of memories remain within us and that has defenitly got link with the genitic order of a person and in turn with the ancestors or parents. So that doesn't mean a major portion of the memory is descided by the genetic order.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
23 Jul 09
Of course not all memory is genetic. But the ability of our minds to 'remember', to have memory is genetic. Have you ever seen or read about the savants who can remember huge amounts of facts, photographic memory? And they have linked IQ with having strong memory skills. And I wonder if 'past life memories' are indeed evidence of reincarnation, or really genetic memory we have of our ancestors? Lots of questions, huh? This topic really makes me think! Thanks for your response.
@sweetashoney (3597)
• United States
22 Jul 09
I believe sometimes that we do. Take for instance, there are times that I have went some place and its like I have been there before. Even though I have never seen the place before in my life, or no one has ever told me anything about it.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
22 Jul 09
Maybe it is genetic memory that causes the experience of 'reliving a past life'?
Perhaps we do not come back as someone else..but experience the spirit or the memories of an ancestor?
What an interesting concept.
@xXTrizzleXx (186)
• Jamaica
23 Jul 09
Hello debrakcarey,
This topic has caused me to sit down and think of things from a biological point of view.
Genetic information is transmitted to us from our parents, and by extension our forefathers during copulation, by the combination of maternal chromosomes and paternal chromosomes when the zygote is formed. These chromosomes contain the actual genetic material - DNA.
I enjoy viewing the way that DNA stores genetic information, as intricately simple - a paradoxical term if you will. Basically, certain regions along the DNA strands code for the production of a protein. These are the regions termed genes.
Now if the genetic information is passed on to us, from our mother and father, then it is quite logical to think that we are capable of producing identical proteins to the ones produced by our parents (I say identical, because the processes of transcription and translation in protein production are very precise). As proteins take on structural, hormonal and most importantly enzymatic functions, it is also quite plausible that these proteins can be used to build structures and compounds, similar to those present in our parents.
Hence if one were to imagine that certain regions of the brain can be modeled in a similar manner to one's mother for instance, and that due to the enzymes and hormones present, similar chemicals can be produced, then it is quite plausible to believe that memories, experiences and emotions from our parents may be in fact possibly transmitted genetically. However this postulate would have to assume that memories are simply the interactions of nervous impulses and chemicals within the brain that are processed by the regions of higher intelligence in the brain, producing memories, feelings and emotions.
After all, how many times have you heard someone say something like, "He gets his courage from his father!" or "She is just as soft-hearted as her mother?
Anyways, these are just my late night ramblings, meant to be taken with a grain of salt. I thank you for providing such a stimulating topic and wish you happy myLotting!
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
23 Jul 09
How did all this material...learn how to be 'alive'? Where did it learn how to 'read' the information in the genes to recombine? Where did all this information come from? Yes, very stimulating topic.
We do inherit basic personality elements from our ancestors. Not to stereotype, but it is well known that ethnic groups share many personality traits and even though it is thought that they come entirely from without, the culture and so on....I believe that it is both culture and genetic.
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
23 Jul 09
Thank you sweeten....they used to believe that if the mother experienced trauma during her pregnancy, the baby would be 'marked'. We discarded that 'myth' until we learned that the mothers hormones do indeed shape the structure and 'leaning' of the baby's mind and later mental development. Two books by Bryan Sykes; 'Adam's Curse' and 'Seven Daughters of Eve' go into this if you are interested. They are not religious books despite their titles...they are based on genetic science.