Do you speak from the heart,or tell people what they want to hear????

United States
August 10, 2009 5:51pm CST
Hey there everyone,a friend of mine just asked me for advice and i contiplated what i should say and how..on one side i didnt want to break her heart..and on the other she needed to know the truth..soooo as gently as i could i spoke from the heart,and told her what i thought..and in the end she appreciated what i said even though it hurt her for a few mins..she was ok..soo what about you? do u speak from your heart or just tell them what they want to hear?
1 person likes this
9 responses
@jugsjugs (12967)
11 Aug 09
I always seem to be like an agony aunt to people and i used to be very honest about what i thought and at the time i did not mind them asking my opinion at all until one day i needed a bit of advice and well they could not make the time for me with my problem so now i just say i do not know or its up to you.
2 people like this
• United States
19 Aug 09
yeaa i understand where ur coming from..everyone and i mean everyone has always coem to me for advice..i give it staright up as i can without hurting as much as i can like i have said,..,and as for teh jerks that ignored you and left you hangin..i wouldnt ever help them either again..thats just rude and mean..and selfish!! soo good for you and your decision! ty for replying!! April
• United States
11 Aug 09
I think when we ask for any advice to a friend or anyone else, we do so with the intention to tell us what we want to hear. Because we know that the truths hurts. So when it comes to me to give advice I let them know that if they want I can say what they want to hear, but I always try to go by telling what I think about the situation.
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Aug 09
wow..that was just wowww..everything u said i was nodding my head..its true so very true..but sometimes i just cant tell them what they want to hear and tell them what they need to hear..and am i a hypocrit for just wanting to hear what i wanna hear..not what ppl actually think? lol..thats what i want when i ask for advice..its weird..maybe we shoudl just ask u want sugar coated or the real truth..and then go from there so there prepared it could get hurtful..ty for responding..:) April
@kykidd (6812)
• United States
10 Aug 09
Well, I don't think it is good to be dishonest with people, although I don't like to hurt anyone's feelings either. We just had this discussion with a few friends over the weekend. We determined that if you ask a question, and it is about something important, you're going to get the truth. If it is something like, do you like my new shoes, and it doesn't hurt anyone, who cares. I hope this makes sense to you. An old expression might be somewhat helpful "If the truth hurts....". Good luck to you and your friend!
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Aug 09
it made total sense to me hun..and i agree with you 100%..its hard to find a half way between honesty and feelings..and circumstances..i would never say something to hurt anyone..so when i have to give my opinion..i really think it out..ty for responding hun!! April
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
11 Aug 09
hi cloud kicker speaking from the heart is the most honest way of giving advice, telling someone you like just what they want to hear really doesnt help much. Its best to be honest with your friends and loved ones, even if it means hurting them a bit because anything else is self defeating.if you are going to help someone, then do it.I am here because,.as my son himself said, my best friend gave my dear son a verbal kick in the pants,we were in a bad situation, little moneyand we were homeless, I am 82 with diabetes and a lame foot.he was worried about my health and us being on the street.my friend said firmly you are your moms guardian, get her into a retirement home as she cannot sleep on the street. I didnt want to do it but we had no other alternative. life isnt always fair, in fact seldom so we did what we felt was right. she spoke from her heart and we really didnt want to hear that.
• United States
19 Aug 09
well u have such a wonderful friend..kinda like a guardian friend sent from up above.,.i really believe that and in ur situation u were in dire need of help and a real push in teh right direction..but there are siutations that sugar coating is best too..i think important truths shoudl be straight up and smaller probs can be sugar coated..well alot..ty for responding..April
@ruperi (138)
• India
11 Aug 09
I love to talk what people want to listen, by which I can understand their nature. Then only I can operate them according to me. I tell people truth wahtever they do on face. But in friendsliness. not like unnecessary involving in another chat. I like to tell people on there face, instead of their back. If I tell them they are good they become happy. and I love to see smile on peoples face.
1 person likes this
• Trinidad And Tobago
11 Aug 09
It depends but i always try to speak from the heart. Telling someone the truth is always the best option all it is said that TRUTH HURTS.
1 person likes this
• China
11 Aug 09
I only hurt by others,do not hurt other people,so pathetic ah!
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
11 Aug 09
For me I will just try to twist the sentence just to tell them the truth of my heart. Sometimes if you don't tell ppl won't know what do u think. Do you agree with me...
1 person likes this
11 Aug 09
I usually try to tell the truth but not tell it in a way that would hurt someone else's feelings. The truth will hurt but it's worth knowing rather then getting fed a lie or false statement.