Do you give your child anything he/she wants ? Do you think it makes them weak ?
By voldrox
@voldrox (7191)
India
August 22, 2009 2:59am CST
Do you give anything that your child asks for, like as a birthday present or for that matter when they start demanding something and crying over it... i have to say as a child i demanded and cried for so many things, but am glad my parents didn't always satisfy me, i realize it now, i demanded for things i just wanted and not needed, i am glad my parents have been really nice with me and at the same time they have seen to it that i didn't get dissappointed, well that puts me into question.
.
.
.
Do you think you are making you child weaker by providing him/her with anything they ask for, it maybe out of your love but have you ever felt that you might be making your children weaker by letting them have anything they need... i hope you get what i am trying to say here... i would definitely love to hear from you in this matter...
.
.
.
Do you tend not provide your children with the toys they often demand, you can also share your opinions if you don't always provide them with the things they want, and how do you control your children at such times, i would like to know.
.
.
.
anyways happy a nice day all of you
thank you
1 person likes this
10 responses
@mrshughes (352)
• Philippines
22 Aug 09
Hi! I have a son of 3years of age. His on a "buy me" stage at the moment. Im trying not to give him everything he asks..coz i beleive if u give them all what they wanted they will never know how to appreciate things in life. But having said that, most of the times he gets what he wants.
I grew up with nothing in life and i know how it feels when i want to buy something and i can not have it coz my parents cant afford. It was very hurtful. I felt i was never loved as a kid.
Thats why in regards with my son...i work hard so i can give him more and better future in life. And whatever he asks most of the times is granted.
I dont want to give him everything he asks for...but i how can i say no baby u cant have it?!
Im just glad his more interested on papers and crayons. He loves to draw monsters!
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
22 Aug 09
Hi mrshughes
Oh I see you have had a little different childhood experience, you say you didn't receive what you wanted as a child and i am sorry you ought to interpret that the wrong way just because your parents didn't have that much money to give you everything you wanted but i am sure that they loved you but just couldn't help because they didn't have that much money to please you as a child, you see that is why i believe children should be taught the importance of money from the earliest of stage to let them realize they should not have everything they wanted, just find a way to make your kids realize the importance of money, i don't have ideas on it but you can have a look at some of the posts above or some of the newer posts, i know it might be hard for you to say no to your kid but you have to learn how to say so... it's good that your child is more interested in drawing with crayons, i think you might find a funny way to give excuses to your child on how important money is, or you can always tell short examples as stories... i wish i could be of more help but... all i can say is let your kids know the importance of money and everything rest will fall in place... your son is very lucky to have such a loving mom, and all the right knowledge will just make all things perfect and i am sure you will do it.
.
.
.
thanks for being honest, have a good day all of you!
@mrshughes (352)
• Philippines
22 Aug 09
Thank u very much...yes i will try and do so...i guess i spoiled him too much. have a good day to u also!
1 person likes this
@joyce959 (1559)
• Philippines
22 Aug 09
WEll, my husband and I are lucky coz our 2 sons are not the type who ask or demand what they want from us. Basically we just provide them what they need, decent clothes and shoes to wear, but not necessarily signature clothes and shoes. We give them cellphones but not the later or new type. When they were young we provided them with toys. When they graduated from high school and the old one in college we gave him a gift that he likes so much to have but that is more of a prize for finishing his degree. I told my young son if he make good in school, I'll increase his allowance and he did.
Always giving in easily to the demands of our child will make them somewhat spoiled brat and they will get hurt if they will not get their wishes. So better not to give in easily. We should make our child realize that not everything comes easily and they will have to work harder to attain or get something.
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
22 Aug 09
Hi joyce
I have to say, you guys are so lucky to have such nice children, i am sure many parents wish they could have such children, they just made it a lot more simpler for you guys and you needn't even explain to them... you all are so lucky... yeah it was pretty the same case with me, i mean i did demand as a child but my parents seldom bought me branded clothes when i was small and now when i am older i realize how nice my parents have been to me when i was smaller, i so much adore them and am sure your kids adore and love you much as well:)...
.
.
.
thank you for sharing and have a good day all of you!
.
.
you guys are really lucky i will say it again
@smart44 (510)
• Philippines
22 Aug 09
we didn't give them anything they want if its not necesarrily to give or not important. We need to explain to them that not all the things will be given to them. They need to have an extra effort to get what they want. For example they need to pass the exam or they need to be more studious and pass the semester so that we can buy what they want but it should be important to them. Yes sometimes it makes them to be weak in the sence that they will keep in their mind that they can easily get what they want so we avoid it and need an extra effort to have such things . they need also to work from themselves so that they know the important of being industrious and make it a habit that need extra effort to work on what they want to have.
@voldrox (7191)
• India
22 Aug 09
Hi Smart
You are absolutely right on this one, that way they will learn that getting things out of life isn't easy and they have to work on it to get them, i am sure your kids will appreciate you when they stand on their feet, your kids are lucky to have such nice parents as you, keep up the good work
.
.
thanks for sharing and have a nice day all of you!
@xichen7 (153)
• Philippines
23 Aug 09
My son only one years old. He can't speak many words, but he knowa how to use his "weapon"--crying. When he want to do something or get something, he will cry if you don't satisfy him. Because he is too young to persuade, so when he cry we always satisfy him. I think in the future it is not a good choice to always satisfy him, it will make them weak. He will think he can get anything when he cry. I consider it is better let my son know if he want to get something, he must do some work for that first. I will tell him a truth--no pains, no gains which is never changed.
Happy mylot!
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
23 Aug 09
Hi xichen
Well i understand, your kid is quiet young now, as time passes by you will someday need to explain him the importance of patience and hard work, obtaining things desired in this life is not so easy and you will have to let your son know that(of course later )... and am sure you will just do great!
.
.
thanks for sharing and have a nice day all of you!
@nathanmani1946 (49)
• India
23 Aug 09
hai defanently this thing spoil the child. they start asking small things at the begining which leads to other big things. as we start giving like this we cannot control our child which makes us not to have control over our child, In due course when they reaches higher age they will hide things which are illegal reulting their life. Ofcourse this nay be common to western country. but not to India
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
23 Aug 09
Yes nathanmani
I agree children shouldn't grow up getting all the things that want and not need, that way they won't appreciate the hard work one has to do to achieve things in life, they should know that not everything can be achieved so easily, they also might become lazy by the time they grow up because they have been getting all the things they wanted as children, so they should be made to learn the value of money and hard work from the earliest of stage.
.
.
thanks you for sharing and have a good day!
@kitty42 (3923)
• United States
22 Aug 09
What a great topic, growing up we did not have much, this is funny cause me and my brother and his wife were talking about this the other day, anyway growing we did not have much and I always said when I grew up and had a child I would make sure my child did not have to feel they way I did,well I spoiled my daughter I gave her everything I could, my daughter grew up to be a remarkable woman, she has a son who she spoils as well, not as much as I spoiled her, but my daughter has really expensive taste but she works hard and she buys the things she wants, so I don't feel I made her weak, she is very strong and independent, I spoiled her but taught her to be responsible, when she first had her son for the first year I did everything for him, everything, but after that year I told her she has to do what is needed for him, I will help but I will not do it all, and she has been doing it, and I am so proud of the woman my daughter has become,my grandson does not want for anything she tells him no, but he usually gets what he needs if not from her then his dad or his dads family.
So with that said, I think it depends on the situation, some kids are just rotten, my daughter was never like this, there is always a certain way to do things and if you have a child that is demanding of these things then you need to let that child know, this is not how you will get the things you want because I don't have to buy you these things I do it because I want too, not cause you think I have too. great post sweety. smoochesss
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
22 Aug 09
Hi kitty
Thanks... i honestly don't know where this topic popped up in my head from, thought it would be pretty nice one to discuss and i have to say it is showing colours now:)... Well as in your case I have to say you never ever spoiled your daughter in the first place as you taught her to be responsible, i know you are very proud to have such a great daughter and she loves you for the person you have made her into... i am glad for you all... you must also be happy that your daughter is doing the right thing too, i am also sure that your grandson will be given the right lessons on responsibilities from your daughter.... thank you for sharing kitty, have a nice day you all and keep enjoying mylot
@kitty42 (3923)
• United States
23 Aug 09
Well thanks for your wonderful response, I guess when she was younger it looked like she was spoiled too others, she has turned into a wonderful woman, I am so proud of her as well as the mom she is turning into, we have our little spats since we are both opinionated, she says I ask her too many questions, lol I said I am your mom if I want to know something how else will I know if I don't ask duh lol, over all she is one the best, love her
1 person likes this
@Sreekala (34312)
• India
22 Aug 09
Hi voldrox,
You have really nice parents, be proud on them. I never provide everything to my kids when they demanded something. If I say ‘no’ it will be like that, my elder son really knows the same but then also he try to cry because he thinks that his father may listen. If his father knows that I already denied the demand then he won’t allow the same. Children should understand the value of money and if we provide everything according to their demand it may spoil them. I will clearly explain why I should deny his demand. He is only eight years old and I think he can understand what I am trying to convey.
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
22 Aug 09
Hi Sreekala
Thank you :)
I adore my parents for the effort they had put in for me to realize the importance of money and you are also doing the right thing, keep up the good work... when your kids grow older i am sure they will appreciate you both for instilling in them the importance of money, they might not understand now but am sure they will grow older to appreciate and take pride in having such good parents as you.
.
.
thank you for sharing Sreekala and have nice day all of you!
@alicia812 (646)
• Australia
22 Aug 09
No. My five year old daughter knows how to save coins and
buy herself something that she wants. I told her that I
cannot buy her everything that she wants whenever she wants
them because we have other more important things to spend on.
Luckily she understands my point and whenever I give her a
coin to save she is happy to put it in her purse. I think it
is important to inculcate the value of being thrifty in our
kids. At the end of it all, the values they keep in them
and execute will benefit them the most.
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
22 Aug 09
Hey alicia that is a cute way to come up with i have to say, your daughter is understanding, it's nice of you, she will start to realize the importance of money at a very early age and it is so good to have kids learn some important things from a very young age.. especially if it's the case with money, kids should realize that money doesn't come easy and we can't provide them with everything they demand for, you and your daughter are very lucky
.
.
.
thanks for sharing alicia and have a good day, both of you!
@Zhizho (1350)
• Indonesia
22 Aug 09
Hi voldrox.I don'y do that to my son.He was two years old now.I try to educate him that not all he wants could be given.I think,yes it will be make our children weak and spoiled.Have no work to get something.Just explaine and don't forget to face his eyes when you explaine it.Make a commitmen that she/he will get something but give a challenge.Such as,he must save money or get good grade at school.
1 person likes this
@christmas_ (121)
• Singapore
22 Aug 09
shouldnt do it...because this will pamper the child and spoil the child..
its not good
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
22 Aug 09
Hi Christmas
Yeah i have to say it does pamper a lot when you give them everything they ask for, we should let them realize that money is a very valuable thing and should not be spent just for the purpose of having some thing to enjoy.
.
.
.
thanks for sharing Christmas and have a good day!