Chicken or egg, which one came first?

Malaysia
September 1, 2009 5:35am CST
I know a this question of dilemma can be googled, and there are several theology, and theories behind it. People believe in science and evolution will choose differently compare to those believe in other theology. I will choose the chicken came first. What do you think? Please share..
9 responses
@redhotpogo (4401)
• United States
1 Sep 09
being that all life starts off young, as a baby i'm going to go with egg. nothing has ever started off as an adult and as it grew got younger.
• United States
1 Sep 09
yep. for all we really know the first chickens had live births.
• Malaysia
1 Sep 09
yea, you might be correct. buy the end of this discussion, i'm going to count how many votes go for egg and how many votes go for chicken :) after all, none of us can be really really really sure :p
• Malaysia
1 Sep 09
**sorry typo 'by the end' hehe
• India
1 Sep 09
It would have to be the chicken and a rooster because you need a chicken to fertilize an egg and if the egg came first there is just one and therefore no fertilization happens so there for its simply the chicken.
• Malaysia
1 Sep 09
Great theory from you.lol, I think maybe you want to say.. hen + rooster = egg have a nice day =)
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
1 Sep 09
U have a point there. Non fertilized eggs dont yield chickens!
• China
1 Sep 09
Of course a chicken came first~~because it probably evolved from some other animals~~I guess
• Malaysia
1 Sep 09
Thanks skyboy for posting here. Great guess.. but it neither evolution nor creation theories, but it still chicken. lol. Go for chicken. Cheers =)
@janebeth (2032)
• Philippines
2 Sep 09
hi angel, i think chicken came first, as what i have read on the bible GOD made the animals directly and not the eggs.. like the monkey, lion, snakes, birds etc.. like the time when Noah put all the animals on the ark and as what i have observed they are all animals by pair and no eggs after all. so it really proves that chicken came first and then eggs.. janebeth.
• Malaysia
3 Sep 09
hi janebeth, i agree with you, i believe in bible (God's words) more than science (human discovery) =)
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
1 Sep 09
I already had this discussion. But still - the answers given to me by two children (yes under 15 geniuses) were - the 12 year old said - chicken because whatever was bird that existed before chicken from which the chicken evolved eventually was not chicen. The younger one said egg. When I asked him why - he said u didnt specify chicken's egg. U just said egg. So there were other animals that had eggs much before chicken came into picture. How do u count or discount that??? :-)
@Eternus (27)
• India
1 Sep 09
hahah egg ,,i am sure ,, Even before chicken dinasaurs laid eggs ,,There was egg long before chicken lol jUZZ KIDDIN
• Malaysia
1 Sep 09
hi eternus, thanks for posting here. From top to your posting, we have.. Chicken = 5 votes Egg = 3 votes We see how this chicken or egg goes =)
• India
1 Sep 09
Hi, I think chicken would have come first. As only chicken can give eggs there is no point egg would have come first.
• Malaysia
1 Sep 09
Hi sunstar, if someone believe in evolution, there is a point for egg come first. It just depends on what we believe in. May be when the end come, the truth will be revealed, the chicken or the egg wins =)
@Lucky09 (1763)
• Philippines
1 Sep 09
I believe in the theory of creation so i would say that chicken comes first. Although evolution can be considered with this, but how can the egg be hatched without the help of a chicken? The egg would surely be rotten(LOL).^^;
• Malaysia
1 Sep 09
hi lucky, I believe in creation too. Your 'rotten' egg is just funny. According to evolution: non-chicken produce a true-chicken.. I don't want to laugh at this, else there will be a lot of scientists and their supporters come and flame me later. **I may not good in Science, but I have faith in God :)
• Ireland
1 Sep 09
ok look at it this way what are the chances that the egg could hatch on its own give itself food and water and survive to make ah nothing cause there'd have to be at least 2 of them 1 male 1 female like so my vote is with the chicken
• Malaysia
1 Sep 09
thanks n7phoenix for sharing here. yea, my vote go to the chicken too =)