Confused with relationships.......
By dbutheking
@dbutheking (2347)
India
September 8, 2009 8:03am CST
Hi friends,
Last week i attended my sister's marriage. Lots of relatives came to the marriage. I know most of the relatives, but i don't know some of the relatives. I know them bit i don't know how i was related to them.
One of my relative came to me and ask me whether i know them. I replied with shy that i don't know.
Then he tried to explain me how i am related to him.
He told as follow,
My grand mother's sister's daughter's daughter married the person who is the brother relation ship with the person and also he told that he is married to my sister's cousin sister....
I was really confused..
Then i asked him, how i relate to him. He told that he is brother-in-law. He was related to me in two ways. My brother came and explain in the second way and he explain my brother that i was related in this way too...
Are you confused with the relationships anytime?
Do you remember all the relationships you have?
Do you have contacts with your relations?
How often you go to your relation's house?
How many of them are your close relations??
Have a great day..
15 people like this
48 responses
@jellymonty (2352)
•
8 Sep 09
My father's brother is my sister's nephew who is the cousin to my mother's aunt and is also an uncle to my grandmother's cousin whose son is my daughter's niece...
yep that's definitely a ball buster right there...
3 people like this
@jheLaichie (4438)
• Philippines
8 Sep 09
a ball buster indeed jelly my friend...
and dont let me read this... it is making me more and more confused!!!
jhelai
1 person likes this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
I got the Head ache after reading this.
I don't even want to read it twice.
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
Yes, they are just the beginning to refresh our relationship.. We need relationships in our life.
Have a nice day.
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
8 Sep 09
Gosh dbu! Ican't work that one out straight after lunch...
but I have a question for you.
If a couple marry then divorce, do they still remain related to their ex-spouce's family?
2 people like this
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
8 Sep 09
Hey don't worry about the drop, it happens every day when admin removes all the repeated topics by new users where I repond - it will soon get back up again...
watch this space
1 person likes this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
I too noticed that while commenting in the knight's discussion. So, sad. But i know mysD is not going to bother about it...
Hmmm.. That question is more confusing than the relationship i mentioned in the description.
2 people like this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
Because i didn't see anyone got divorced as far as i know.. Just heared via news about the others only.. I didn't got any info about the divorce on any one around me in my locality as well as in relationships..
2 people like this
@neildc (17239)
• Lapu-Lapu City, Philippines
10 Sep 09
hi db. i know what you mean. sometimes, with a lot of relatives in one occasion gathers, you will not even who he or she is a relative. the best thing to do with it is just call them "kuya" or "tito for a male relative or "ate" or "tita" for a female relative. that's how we do it here in our place.
2 people like this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
10 Sep 09
I guess you ask me to call them uncle and aunty right??
May i know what that language is and what their meaning is??
Have a nice day.
@thea09 (18305)
• Greece
8 Sep 09
Hi dbu, by one chance relationship I am permanently stuck with alleged family members that no one can ever clearly explain to me why we are related. Try this one on for size and see if you can work it out, don't worry it's a short chain but does not make sense to me.
My son's godmother has a husband who has a brother who has a best friend. Why am I now considered related to the best friend. I can understand the papers which show I'm now under Greek law related to my son's godmother and thence her husband, I can even accept that said husband's brother is now also related to me, alone with the other three brothers of the husband, but why the best friend of the husbands first brother?
@thea09 (18305)
• Greece
8 Sep 09
Alice believe me it's more than an informality once these people have their hands on you.
Jhe, it's really not at all confusing if you just accept that for some reason you've got a whole bunch of people declaring themselves family and insisting you join their family dinners.
A godmother dbu is - the bit I've just deleted here as what was I doing, this is a topic of my own. You'll just have to wait and see but it will be showing soon in the new interest of 'Greek life style' which is already up and running.
1 person likes this
@jheLaichie (4438)
• Philippines
8 Sep 09
oh! dont make me confuse more thea dear!!! lol!
jhelai
1 person likes this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
Hi thea,
Yes, we consider our husband/wife's sister or brother as relative.
Best friend of the first brother is relative? May be friendship is also a relation right?
Well, i would like to ask you something, What is godmother? Sorry, i don't know...
Have a great day.
@ChrysanTflower (1607)
• Indonesia
8 Sep 09
Hi dbutheking
This thing often happen to me too, especially when I attend party from my father's family. I really dont' know most of them, there are hundreds of mhy relatives and some of them I never talk before. I find it's difficult to remember each name and face when there are no longer communication with them. At first, I ask about the relationship too, but then I found it's useless! I won't be able to remember someone who never talk to me before and I know will rarely or never communicate with me after.
I have two grandfather. One of them married twice, so I have 3 grandmother, 1 of them my step grandmother. Each of my grandmother have 8 or 9 children. Some of them married twice again, so I have step aunts. Some of them married once and have average 3 children, and some of them already have a granddaughter HOW can I know all of them? They spread anywhere and I don't think I can recognize if I meet one of them accidentally on the street,,hehehe. I rarely go to that kind of party, it makes me tired. Try to chat with unknown people and my parents sit in other parts of the room because have different "status" compared to me. Even the place to sit is arranged too. I don't like those kind of party. Only if it's placed near my home and I'm not busy I will go, even I only stand in that situation for maximum 3 hours.
I only close with family from my mom's side, because they are not too many and none of them married twice or more. They only have 1 or 2 children too, and all of them live in the same island with me. Most family from my father's side live in different island..
Have a great day too
2 people like this
@ChrysanTflower (1607)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 09
I'm 17 now and I have 2 granddaughter! I have grandmother who is 1 year YOUNGER than me! I met her 3 days ago and was really surprised, this child is my grandma.. Well, nice to know I'm not the only one who feel this weird situation. It's strange, my grandma share to me about her boyfriend.. she still quiet childish..
Do you feel happy or not with huge family like this?
1 person likes this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
9 Sep 09
Ofcourse, even in this confusion, still i like large relationships...
Hi grandma
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
Yes, it is very confusing... Don't know how we are related to the person whom we didn't talk before. Also, it is difficult to memorise all relationships. You have a huge family..
Can you imagine? I have a grandsons at the age of 20 without even marrying?
Some of my niece are elder than me. Some of my uncles are younger than me.
Have a great day.
@horsesrule (1957)
• United States
9 Sep 09
Sometimes having relatives is very confusing! I have one brother who married a woman, his second marriage (first one ended in divorce). The woman, his wife, has a daughter who is my brother's step-daughter. My brother loves her like a daughter and she loves him like a dad. The girl got married and had a baby. So then, what is my relationship to that baby I wondered. I was calling the girl, my brother's step daughter, my cousin but that is wrong. She would be my niece. Okay, so what about HER baby, I was thinking it was like a second cousin or second niece. Then someone told me no, the baby would be your great-niece. I don't think so but I have no idea. So yes, I can understand how your relatives relationships would be confusing or too complicated. I know mine sure as!
2 people like this
@horsesrule (1957)
• United States
9 Sep 09
I just don't know what the relationship would be. I thought second niece but someone told me great niece so I am still just as confused as ever!
1 person likes this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
11 Sep 09
So, it is endless confusion..
I wish you to conclude that confusion soon lol
Have a great day.
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
9 Sep 09
Hi horserule,
Really confusing. What was the conclusion? Is they your second cousin or second niece or great-niece??
Have a great day..
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
Oh! Then there is no confusion for you...
So, you have very few relatives?
Have a great day.
1 person likes this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
So, as they are too far, this type of situation will happen very rarely, so no confusion
1 person likes this
@zed_k4 (17589)
• Singapore
9 Sep 09
I get the point in your discussion here; sometimes when I relate to my own life, I myself am confused with certain status relationships in my family. Too complicated to go through. The idea is to get along well with one another, and a friendly encounter on the rare or regular occasions that we are able to get together. My best advice to myself and I think you can use this as a guide too: Don't try to figure it out, just go with the flow..
2 people like this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
9 Sep 09
Hi zed,
You are correct. If we try to figure out the relationship it is really confusing. Just let it go on its flow.. That's right...
Have a great day...
1 person likes this
@ladym33 (10979)
• United States
9 Sep 09
That would be really confusing. My family is not that big, I am sure there are distant relatives I don't know but I will probably never see them. I have one brother and one sister and 4 cousins on my mom's side, and 2 cousins on my dad's side, and 2 step cousins on my dad's side. Each of them have kids. They live in a different state than I do so I have met some of their kids but there are a couple that I have not met. I see one of my cousins once a year he comes here to visit. The last time I saw my other cousins was 3 years ago. I do occasionaly write to one of my cousins, and one of her sons who is closer to my age, because my cousin is about 10 years older than me. I have one living uncle on my mom's side and 1 living uncle by marriage on my mom's side, I saw him 3 years ago too, and then there is my parents, that is pretty much all the family I have left. Except for my two nieces and 2 nephews, and then there is my husband's family which is bigger than mine.
2 people like this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
10 Sep 09
Hi lady,
I remember all of my immediate relatives, i have only one sister and one cousin from my mom's side and having 10 cousins from my dad's side.
I know them all and not confused with them.
I only confused with little distant relatives who is not in the regular contacts..
Have a great day.
@CynergyDiva (805)
• Canada
8 Sep 09
Yes the explanation you were giving got me confused too.
I have to say I've never had a situation like this in my family
xoxo
Cyne
2 people like this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
You don't have the experience?? So, you know all the relationships very well. Is it?
That's great..
1 person likes this
@CynergyDiva (805)
• Canada
8 Sep 09
No it's not that I know all of my relations. I just never came across one that would confuse me like that
xoxo
Cyne
1 person likes this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
You are going to confuse like me soon
Have a great day..
1 person likes this
@jheLaichie (4438)
• Philippines
8 Sep 09
oh! so confusing indeed specially with all the relationship words roaming around. lol!
our family is a big one also and i can still make it to my grandfathers relationship to us and our grandmothers and everything else, that is with my fathers side. while on my mothers side, i am not that too well known. but i love knowing why i am related to such people and persons and how we could just all connect to each other!
jhelai
2 people like this
@jheLaichie (4438)
• Philippines
8 Sep 09
oh so same here my friend! and well by now i am asking more about my mothers side and i guess i can connect some of it.. but others are still quite confusing as it is!
jhelai
1 person likes this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
Me too! I know most of the relatives who are related to my father. But mother side relatives are confusing. Because mother's relatives are too far from our place. That is the reason that i don't know them all...
Have a nice day..
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
In my place uncle can be expressed in two ways and aunt can be expressed in two ways.. Just imagine how many types of relationships i have. So, confusing than you...
@Ruby722 (796)
• China
9 Sep 09
Wow.I am dizzy and confused.What a complicate relationships you have Lol.I try to figure out this.It's really need take time.Haha.Well.In my memories i don't have many complicate relative.I belive that i can recongize them.So i think it's a little kind of awkward if someone thought that you know him/her
2 people like this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
9 Sep 09
That's great. So, you recognise all your relatives. So, all your relatives stay little closer to you right? My relatives stay little longer so only don't recognise at all. Also, we have a huge family tree and many relationship...
Have a great day.
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
8 Sep 09
I have the same issue. It's confusing like mother's cousin's son's grandson blah blah blah.
I just think that okay, you're a relative. Period. Even if they tried to explain, sometimes I still don't get it because there are so many people in the family that I haven't even met. So if they say, I am the son/daughter of ______, I still wouldn't know. I just go, "oh okay".
2 people like this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
That's right, we have very few chances to meet them again, so we don't need to bother about it much..
Have a nice day.
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
So, Even without understanding what they told,you just acts like understanding them. Am i correct?
That's a nice technique. But if we tell them truly atleast we can know some relatives well...
Have a great day.
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
8 Sep 09
Well, I don't "act" like I know them.
I just think, okay so they say they are family. Chances are, I wont get to meet them again because I don't really meet with extended family members. They're not very nice people (most of them in my family).
If I do get to meet them then I just say hi and hello. Just be polite but that doesn't mean we become close.
1 person likes this
@scarlet_woman (23463)
• United States
8 Sep 09
my close family i have no problem with-it's the cousins i get confused with.
the one part of the family there were 14 kids,72 grandkids and a few great grandkids,so exact order gets muddled after awhile.i usually have to guess by last name how they're related.
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
haha.. we can remember 14 kids, but 72 grand kids and great grandkids? We need a computer to store all the relationships. What about the 72 grand kids's wife and husbands, their relatives,etc., Grow very huge. It is confusing..
Have a great day
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
8 Sep 09
hi bdutheking oh I get confused once people tell me they are my'second cousin then someone else said I am your second
cousin once removed, and here I was still trying to find'out'what
second cousin meant as for removed that lost me completely.'I
havent got many relativesleft and am only close now to my
son and one cousin.
2 people like this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
So, you have very few relationships left? so sad..
Relationships are more confusing at these occasions and make us
What is second cousin means?
Have a great day.
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
8 Sep 09
I have a pretty good handle on it. But I'm not actually in touch with too many distant relatives. We used to have a lot of family parties, but we've moved away from most of the relatives, so we don't see them that often any more.
2 people like this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
So, having more family parties will keep in touch with them and have good contacts.. moving away from the distant relatives and don't see them often means no confusion and nothing to bother about them too...
Have a great day.
1 person likes this
@akuler (3531)
• Malaysia
8 Sep 09
Hi dbutheking,
I always confused with this relative relationship source. I had a lot of people that knows me because of my parent and they always told me that they are related. The place where my parents live, almost everyone in the village are related. They prefer to married with someone from the same village and that why this family relation keep strong and stronger.
But the young generation would prefer to travels and have married with someone from the other villages or states. The relationship will be more boarder and this will make some confusing when someone totally strange to you claim that they are related to you.
By the way, I believe we are all sons and daughters of Adan and Eve. So, we are all related after all.
2 people like this
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
Absolutely, we are all relatives..
So, all of the marriages are taken place inside the village. So, as all of them are nearer you have no troubles about your relationships as you are familiar with them from the birth itself.
Have a nice day.
@pjsr18 (340)
• Philippines
8 Sep 09
I do not know all of my relatives. Sometimes, I would just be surprised that a person would came to our house and my mother would tell me that that person is my aunt, uncle or cousin. I really am not very familiar withmy relatives since all of them reside in the province and we are residing at the city.
I just go to province whenever I have time or during vacation. I love going there because it has fresh air unlike in the city. I have contacts with some of my relatives and I am close to some of them. I would want to know them more, though.
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
Yeah, if we explore all relatives we are still confused. I also surprised to see someone coming to my house who are not familiar and my father/mother told it is aunt or uncle..
Have a great day.
@dbutheking (2347)
• India
8 Sep 09
Yes, when we go to the functions or native place, we meet many relatives and ask us who are we and they introduced to us.. Little confusing but we can know some relatives..
Have a great day.