Children's schooling and future careers vs. Parents

@SomeCowgirl (32191)
United States
September 8, 2009 9:26pm CST
Well a discussion to the today's top discussion category made me think of this. Do you think that parents who choose the electives their children take for them, without letting them pick them out for themselves, are hindering their children's future career? Electives can be just for fun or for future careers, most of them electives teach children basic knowledge that they could later turn into a career. My question is, if a parent makes a student take an elective that the student is not interested in, and doesn't give them choice of any elective, does that hinder them in the future? What age is too old for the parent to pick the elective? 6-12 grade offers electives, though elementary school did in a way, I can't say how that worked or works though... Would you want your mom or dad or guardian to pick your electives out in HS? Did your parents do this? Have you done this? Are you going to? My parents nor grandparents forced electives on me unless it was in elementary school. I picked out all of my electives through school. My fiance and I don't have children yet, but when we do we will not force an elective on them we don't think is necessary. Even then we will guide them and give them our suggestions. So what do you think?
7 responses
@hellcowboy (7374)
• United States
9 Oct 09
This is a really good discussion baby,and I am sure that a lot of different people have different opinions when it comes to children's schooling and parents,I am sure that some parents think they should choose the classes for their children while others might think that is is more beneficial for children to choose their own classes,and I know that everyone is different,my parents did not make me take electives that I did not want to take,and when we are parents I know we will not make our children take any classes that they do not wanna take because it would be wrong,but we will guide them and help them make good choices,I love you with all my heart and soul,have a great day,good luck with all of your mylotting goals,and Happy Posting.
1 person likes this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
9 Oct 09
I know that your parents never made you take electives you didn't want to because that is not the type of people that they are. I know that we also will not make our children take electives that they don't want to take because we know that it's not right for us to do that... though I agree we will guide them and help them make right choices.
• United States
10 Oct 09
It is never right for any parents to make a child take anything they do not want to do, but it is okay to suggest something to try and help them,and you can also give them a little push into it,but you should never force no matter what the circumstances are,I hope I will be a good father one day,and I know you will be a great mother,I love you with all my heart and soul,have a great day,good luck with all of your mylotting goals, and Happy Posting Baby.
@marguicha (222364)
• Chile
9 Sep 09
I don´t think a parent should ever force an elective on a child, no matter what age. Schools seek electives that kids of that age can choose form. It´s wonderful if the child has a good parent-son relation so that he can ask their parents what they think. But the ultimate choice is theirs. After all, when we get older, we look back and ask ourselves "what would I change of my life". It´s wonderful if you can say that you wouldn´t change a thing. But if you can´t say that, let it have been your own choice.
1 person likes this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
8 Oct 09
Very Wise Remarks! Yes the child should be able to choose, after all the electives help them decide and shape a future career! If they are forced to do an elective then it's almost like forcing them to do a career they do not wish to do.
@katsmeow1213 (28716)
• United States
9 Sep 09
I think a parent in most cases does know what their child is best suited for, what the child's skills are, and since they have more knowledge of the career field than a high school student, the parent may be better suited to point the student in the right direction. That is of course assuming the parent isn't he^^ bent on getting the child into a particular career for their own reasons. For example, some parents decide when their child is born that this child will be a lawyer, or doctor, or something like that. They spend the child's whole life preparing them for this chosen career, and the child may not be suited or interested in said career. Then you have a parent like me. I only want my children to be happy and successful. I want them to have a rewarding career and not have to struggle financially. Those are basically my only hopes for each of my children. But I know my children's skills and weaknesses. My oldest child would not make a good doctor or lawyer, but his dream is to become a professional athlete. I'm supporting this and allowing him into any sport he wishes, but at the same time I know how unlikely it is that he'll get into professional sports, so I'm helping him to keep his options open and getting him to try other things as well. Not all high school kids realize that their dreams and goals may be too difficult to achieve. That doesn't mean we should tell them to give up, but we should make sure they have a back up plan, whether they want it or not!
@lawana_f (326)
• United States
9 Sep 09
he only elective that I insisted all three of my children take was a foreign language, because most colleges required it to get in. Two of my three children went for the early graduation plan in Texas where if you finish high school in three years instead of the normal four years they will pay part of your tuition at any state college/University after that. I encouraged them to take all of the duel elective courses that they could even though we had to pay for them, but if they did not feel comfortable taking that class I did not push it. One of my children had a full year of college and 2 years in college english when she graduated high school. It is only because we moved that the other children did not get to take these classes as they were not offered in the new town.
1 person likes this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
8 Oct 09
Pushing a child so they can succeed, especially when it comes to an elective they may not want to take but would help them get into college is a good idea... though I don't believe in pushing anyone to do something that your passionate about but they aren't. It seems to me you pushed them towards a good goal for their sake!
@taogang (103)
• China
9 Sep 09
I agree with you ,and the same to you ,My parents did not select the electives for me,I did it myself.I chose the university and my major subject myself,because that is my interest.We should select our career by ourselves,interests make our career...
1 person likes this
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
8 Oct 09
That is exactly right! I appreciate your opinion but am sorry that I did not get back to you for a while...
@sender621 (14894)
• United States
9 Sep 09
I think both children and parents should take an active part in choosing school electives. Approval or disapproval by both parties is important. Children should not be allowed to take whatever elective they want without a parent's consent. As well, parents should not demand a certain elective choice. Encouragement and support is a vital part of education for a parent or a child.
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
9 Sep 09
My oldest daughter is in highschool and has some great choices for electives. I wouldn't force her to take any but we do talk about what she's going to take. I think it's important for her to make some of these choices because it is her future that this is all for. She wants to go into the medical field so some of her electives have been focused on that. She has decided to take an art class which I think is great too.