Rice or Potato

@aylim14 (501)
Philippines
September 11, 2009 5:55am CST
Which of these two do you like more, rice or potato? I live in the Philippines and the staple food here is rice, so most if not all restaurants/food establishments have rice in their offerings; however, there are stories of rice shortage here in the Philippines, and in other Asian countries as well. I do not know about the Western countries if they have these type of problem. And i also know that potato is becoming a popular substitute for rice, especially in some Western countries (am i right here?). So, what is your opinion regarding this matter? and what if we really have a shortage of rice (for the rice lovers out there) because rice is harder to grow and cultivate unlike potatoes. What do you think?
4 people like this
44 responses
@KaraKATAD (246)
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
hi there aylim14! I live in the Philippines too and I believe that rice is a great staple food especially here in Asia. And in the US it is not that the potato is just recently becoming a substitute for rice but they never really ate rice in the first place. So they didn't replace rice at all, they were just different because they like things like potatoes and bread. I don't think there is a shortage of rice at all. have you ever gone to the grocery and seen no rice for sale? No.
1 person likes this
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
Yes i know, i have not experienced rice shortage as well; however, there are news of it. Well, at least so i heard. Maybe in the rural areaS? oh yeah, i remember now. Yes, we do have rice shortage here; it's just that instead of being an exporter of rice (as we were before), we are already importing rice from our neighboring countries. I do not know exactly how much rice we are importing, but we are supposed to be the ones who does the exporting, not the importing because of the vast fields we have here in the Philippines. But one thing is for sure, if rice were scarce, what would happen to us rice-loving Filipinos? Would we settle for potatoes? Mashed potatoes? french fries? How about an out of the box idea, potato-rice? would we be able to settle for it? Would it even come close? I do not know. and i am not prepared to find out.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
Last time I checked, it was a lie created by the government to cover up gloria's mess ups in the recent years. And I don't think we'll ever run out of rice. really. No matter how high they jack up the prices we're going to buy it. And actually in the rural areas because rice is expensive, they usually eat corn meal that's boiled like rice if they can't afford it. and this isn't recent, they've been doing it for ages.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
If you would bother to research on the internet or at least LISTEN to the news, you would know that there is no rice crisis. It's been identified as fraud many many months ago, so don't worry your head off. Really now, this was an issue HOW long ago? It's not affecting anyone now. The real issue at hand is POVERTY and CORRUPTION.
@xParanoiax (6987)
• United States
11 Sep 09
I like both, but probably thanks to my culture (I'm american) I'm very partial to potatoes. Shortages in asian countries affect us in the western world too, though, because we hardly grow or make anything commercially for ourselves (here in America at least -- you hardly ever see advertizements for American-made anything, unless it's weapons). The only difference between a rice shortage felt here and one felt in the Philipines though, is that for people there...it'd seriously impact supply of food there, and for us it'd just mean one less food is available on the shelves of our stores and in our restauraunts (which mostly serve potato dishes anyways). Now, if there were a potato shortage for us, the people in the Philipines would prolly hardly notice and people'd here be astonished and prolly upset.
1 person likes this
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
12 Sep 09
yes, i think that would be the case. But, unless im mistaken, what's really imported there are their meat?am i right? since you there have more grazing farms than fields..i don't know, im not quite sure with that. anyways, thanks for the wonderful insight. Just hoping that there won't be any shortages of rice and potatoes, both here and there.
@peavey (16936)
• United States
11 Sep 09
I probably eat more rice than potatoes, but I like both. Since they're both high in carbohydrates, I don't always eat either of them.
@peavey (16936)
• United States
12 Sep 09
Part of it depends on what type of rice. I nearly always use brown rice because there isn't as much food value in white rice. Brown rice is processed slower because there is more fiber in it.
• United States
11 Sep 09
Both are quick-energy foods Ay, although you notice more energy from the potato than you would rice, rice tends to break down easier than a potato leaving you feeling full for a lesser amount of time than a potato (which usually leaves you feeling full for most of the day).
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
thanks for sharing your insight. yes, they are both carbohydrate-rich foods because they are starch? i just forgot which of them is easily broken down by the body, meaning one of them is metabolized faster.
@celticeagle (166970)
• Boise, Idaho
12 Sep 09
Which would I rather eat more potato or rice? I love potatoes. I am from Idaho for heavens sakes. LOL Famous potatoes and all that. No, potatoes have more nurishment I am sure. I love them mashed with lots of butter and maybe some sour cream. I like them baked with sourcream and chives. I like them cut up and made into hashbrowns or sliced and baked with Season all on them. All of these are delicious. Now rice is good and I enjoy it but potatoes has it hands down.
@celticeagle (166970)
• Boise, Idaho
14 Sep 09
One of the best ways is to slice them french frie style, sprinkle your favorite spice and then bake until tender on a greased sheet in the oven. Tasty. Not sure what else you wanted to know.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
12 Sep 09
thanks for that wonderful recipe. maybe i'll try that one of these days. but, most Filipinos will disagree with you there with what you said about the potatoes because here, rice is "god". No arguments, just opinions. btw, how do you crush and eat your potatoes? boil them or through the oven?
1 person likes this
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
14 Sep 09
anything you could spare..:) maybe just message it to me because i think posting of recipes is equivalent to spamming here. anyways, its really good. i'll try what you suggested the day after tomorrow. thanks for the tip.;)
1 person likes this
11 Sep 09
Well, in some of western countries, potato is much more popular than rice. Maybe because the climate doesn't want rice below it. I sometimes notice when buying rice in western country. Right on the package you can easily read 'Imported from (mostly east asian countries)'. But I notice that people from western countries now also eat rice rather than potatoes. If the rice no longer exist, then potato can be the substituent.
12 Sep 09
Well, planting rice is not as easy as we plant another vegetables or fruits (for example). And we have to bear in mind that planting rice is something which takes a lot of time ALSO with high risk, either success or failure. I strongly agree that in some of western countries, potato is much much more eaten rather than rice. Having such a big big field doesn't mean planting rice is an easy thing to do. Again, it also depends on the weather and so on.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
12 Sep 09
yeah, i agree with what you've just said. it doesn't matter if the field is vast, there are a lot of factors present too. climate, type of rice, variety, soil fertility, and proper irrigation. So i guess we really cannot assume those things unless we conduct a study of our own on the subject, which can be really really hard.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
12 Sep 09
is that true? i don't know, but i think it is ideal to grow rice there because of the vast fields you have, unlike here in the Philippines, we cannot afford to have those fields because we are an archipelago, so there is a lot of islands, small islands and big islands, so if we dedicate a huge portion of the land, there won't be cities and regions here. but, if we do not have rice, what would halso happen to us? what a predicament we are in..
• Pamplona, Spain
12 Sep 09
Hi aylim, There is a change in the quality of Rice they are selling even though it comes in the same kind of pack and everything. No rice shortage here however the rice has steeply risen in price too. Potatoes are used here an awful lot too in equal amounts. Most of the Spanish love Rice in Paella and potatoes as chips lol. So rice and potatoes are consumed more or less in equal amounts. Rice and potatoes are greatly popular because of their low price. When I say low price it means that all other things most things are expensive. Rice, Potatoes are affordable for most people.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
12 Sep 09
yes, i agree. here, there are also a lot of varieties sold, and for different prices too. Oh, your from spain. hola! i really became a fan of the Spanish culture because of a language elective i took when i was in college. say, how do you cook your paellas there? i would like to know since the Philippines was once colonized by Spain so some traditions still do exist. and one of them is the paella. And yeah, they are cheaper than other products. But, prices are getting higher every now and then, so there really is no cheap things for sale anymore, just as what i read.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
13 Sep 09
actually, i have never been there before. But my professor stayed there frequently and told us numerous stories there. Having four seasons, the way people live, talk, work, and many other things. I'm not good with Espanol because i was only able to study the basic ones and already forgotten most of them because of no practice. Yeah, listing them here would be endless, and illegal? im not sure if that's the term but in the rules of myLot, posting of recipes are not warranted and could be a cause for warning, i think. correct me if im wrong here. anyways, to answer your question, soy bien (i'm good?) hehe..i forgot which verb to use already. y tu? espero que esta bien tambien.
• Pamplona, Spain
12 Sep 09
Hiya aylim, Hola que tal? yes I live in Spain. I´m English with double nationality Spanish and English. Many ways to make Paella for example the Paella from Valencia is made with shellfish, chicken, and red and green peppers, Paella from Barcelona is mainly seafish, lobster and shrimps and cods head and also the green and red peppers. Rice has so many variations as you know. Glad you enjoy Spain maybe you can get to come over again. Meantime there are plenty of Rice dishes Paella all over the Internet. As listing them here would be never ending don´t you agree? Bueno Chica que aproveches la cena. Enjoy your supper take care now.
@Eisenherz (2908)
• Portugal
14 Sep 09
Potato is already the most common thing to have along meals in the civilized countries. And my opinion is that it all comes down to taste, but I'm glad that the taste of the majority is also the same as mine. I don't care for how they cultivated since I don't plan to become a farmer or anything...so that has no influence whatsoever over what I'll choose to consume.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
14 Sep 09
i wouldn't want ti think that you meant anything negative with what you said that potatoes is the most common things to have along meals in the civilized countries. I would really appreciate it if you would clarify that. anyways, yes, it really depends on the majority of the people who wants to eat the food.
@harmonee (1228)
• United States
14 Sep 09
Almost all the eating establishments here in the States serve potato as a side or part of the dishes. It's cheap and easy to prepare in many different ways. I like potato better, but that might just be because I was raised eating it. Do they grow potatoes in the Philippines or do they have to import them? If they import it, it's probably much more expensive to use them.
@taztheone (1721)
• India
11 Sep 09
Rice & potato - Rice
Since I'm from south India, I prefer Rice than any other dish, but plain rice cannot be eaten alone! it needs some dish along with it right? Because I'm a non-vegetarian, I prefer non veg dishes. Potato is my favorite dish among veg dishes. So a combination of rice & potato would be great Happy Lotting
@agv0419 (3022)
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
I prefer rice than potato as a Filipino I'm not satisfied if I don't eat rice. I can easily get full if I ate rice than any other source of carbohydrates like potato or bread. My meal is not complete if there's no rice. It is a bad news for us that we depend on import unlike before that we are the one exporting rice to other neighboring countries.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
yes, i do agree. whenever i eat with my friends or family, rice should be present; otherwise, i wouldn't have that sense of satisfaction of getting full. like when i eat pasta as compared to the same volume of rice, i won't feel that i am full despite eating a large portion of the pasta; but still need to eat rice. and yeah, potatoes by itself is already good. so if you can just prepare it in another way so as to make it look more delicious-looking and mouth-watering, that would be really a great dish.
• China
13 Sep 09
first, i like rice to be my staple food, and it's really so all the time until now. refer to the lack of the rice, i think first we need to save as possible as we can. second, to find substitute, in my mind, the wheat and corn might be the perfect ones. third, get help from the science to cultivate rice better, and so on.
• China
14 Sep 09
to get over the bad habit is not really easy, but we still need to do it. just do it beginning from ourselves and the ones around us. and then, i believe it will be better and better slowly.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
13 Sep 09
yes i agree that we should find a substitute to rice. Though there are a lot out there that already exist, it is hard to really get over a habit that has been there from generations to generations.
• Indonesia
14 Sep 09
Hi aylim14 I'm Indonesian and I prefer both.. It depends on what dish. If I eat steak, I prefer potato than rice. I admit that I can eat potato faster than rice.. Potato can be eaten just by itself, I mean, you can eat it just by boil or fry it. I think it's quiet difficult to eat only plain rice. Even fried rice need to be added some spices, sauce, egg, meat,etc.. Potato is simpler than rice. But I like to see rice field! It's so beautiful. I think rice make me feel more full than potato and it can combined with many dishes.. If I'm in a hurry, I prefer potato, but If I wanna enjoy my meal, I will prefer rice
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
14 Sep 09
thanks for the response. yes, i think that potatoes can be eaten by itself while rice cannot. But i think rice cooks faster if the potatoes are boiled or baked. Im not sure though, haven't tried boiling potatoes yet, only fried and baked them.
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
no problem with substituting rice with potatoes. when i was younger, i had gone through this experience where there was shortage of rice and rice was expensive. i remember my mother cooking sweet potatoes altogether with rice. that way we saved on rice. and it was delicious! although i like rice, during exigencies, it doesn't matter anymore what substitutes rice as long as u can save urself from hunger.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
yup, its true that you have to save yourself. We do not have the luxury of choosing what we eat or what we can eat, especially during those hard times. thanks for your comment too. and btw, did you like it? back then when you were still younger, when your mom substituted potatoes with rice? that's nice, she must be a great cook to have thought of that alternative.
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
yes, very delicious!
• United States
13 Sep 09
I live in the States and love a wide variety of food and enjoy cooking it even more. I was taught by my mom to eat and to cook healthy. I Prefer potatoes over rice because the natural flavor of potato is enhanced by cooking. If you deep-fry the potatoes they will be unhealthy and you will probably taste the grease not the food. If however you pan fry or even bake the potatoes you will have more control over the amount of grease you add.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
14 Sep 09
Yes i definitely agree. Its better to bake potatoes than to fry them. Just that, sometimes, convenience matters more than what is supposed to be or what is healthier. Since frying it only takes at most 10 minutes, while baking it would normally take at least 30-40 minutes just to make it soft.
17 Sep 09
Potatoes! Potatoes every time. To me, rice is rice. There is not muc you can do with it - either eat it on its own or serve it up with curry! Okay you get those rice-stuffed products but I have yet to discover their wonders. For me it has to be, and always will be, potatoes! There is just so much you can do with them though, isn't there: croquets, smilie faces, baked, boiled, mashed, chips, crisps, wedges, roasted. The possibilities are almost endless! The only downside is the fact that they are very heavy carbs and are not exactly the best of foods to eat when on a diet! Other than that, if we were going based purely on taste factors, I could eat them all day!
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
18 Sep 09
well, there are other ways to cook rice too. there is the one using the rice cooker. Another would be the conventional pot which you subject to heat either through charcoal or stove. You can also steam rice inside a bamboo to give it a bit of smokey flavor. And of course, a rarely used method call the pilaf where you cook the grains with the solids (e.g. spices) first before adding the liquid (e.g. stock). Lastly, porridge (or "lugaw" in the Philippines) is one of the most popular type of cooking. Although it is somewhat similar to the pilaf method, it is still another type of cooking since it (unless i'm mistaken) originated here in the Philippines. Not to mention all the different things you can partner with rice. Garlic either roasted or simply cooked goes perfectly with rice; thus, the garlic rice. There are also popular Filipino style rice product called the "bagoong rice." Other end products using rice would be the fried rices of the Chinese people that includes numerous vegetables including peas, corn and many more. They would also include shrimp, pork, beef, fish, and anything else you can think of. btw, correct me if i'm wrong here, but aren't croquets a type of cocktail (small finger food) made with bread? not sure though.
• United States
13 Sep 09
Rice - This is a picture of Rice in a pot.
I like rice better. I am not really sure why but I do. My mom makes a really good brown rice that I really like alot. I like all kind of flavors of rice too. I like to put soy sauce on my rice. I also like rice with some kind of cream sauce mixed in with it.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
13 Sep 09
yeah, but putting too many soysauce in your foods can cause you gallstones and that's not good. So everything in moderation. Sorry for the unsolicited advice. btw, what do you mean with the cream sauce?what are its ingredients?
@whyaskq (7523)
• Singapore
12 Sep 09
I am not a rice person, so if there is no rice, it is still fine with me. LOL. Between rice and potatoes, I would prefer potatoes since they are more tasty but I think rice is a healthier choice.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
12 Sep 09
yeah, thanks for that insight. although i cannot really verify which among the two is healthier and has more benefits, but one thing i do know. We are not choosy people. We can eat whatever is there in front of us, whether it be a rice meal, a potato meal, or both. Now, that's what's great about food.
@kmaram (2533)
• Philippines
12 Sep 09
Hi there kababayan, well rice for me filipinos used to eat that more than anything. If happened that we will have shortage for rice, i can take potato as exchange for rice, i also love potato so i dont think theres a problem with that for me,keep on mylotting
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
12 Sep 09
hi there. Yeah, and i gues it won't really be a problem for us FIlipinos anyway, because we can easily adapt to any situation that is presented to us. plus, there are other ways in which we can sustain our life. It is not limited to eating rice only. We were just used to eat that is why it is very very hard to change that. From time immemorial, rice has been our staple food and i think it will still be for many more years. Unless, God forbid, something really drastic happens to the rice supply here in the country and all over the world.
@mariposaman (2959)
• Canada
12 Sep 09
potatoes are actually quite popular in North America particularly in the northern areas because lots of potatoes are grown here. I live in Ontario Canada and there are lots of potatoes grown here, not too far from here, as well as in other provinces. I used to use potatoes almost exclusively but in the last little while I have learned how to cook rice properly and find it very versatile, partly because of the number of dishes you can make with rice, and partly because it keeps so well. Potatoes tend to spoil quickly if you do not store them correctly, but there is no substitute for a plate of french fries with ketchup, or a pile of mashed potatoes with lots of gravy.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
12 Sep 09
yes i know. fries and mashed potatoes are the most popular forms of potato dishes here in the Philippines (at least in my opinion). That's why if you would read at the top portion of this discussion, i was shocked when one member said they could do at least 15 dishes from it. well, maybe that's just how the way it is. we have our own specialties and different products that we are really good at. Like here, since rice is our staple food, there have been already a lot of rice dishes that can go alone by itself, even without a protein serving(or ulam in Filipino). Sinangag (or fried rice), bagoong rice, yang chaw fried rice (chinese style, at least one way to prepare it), and the ever popular lugaw (porridge, am i right?) and many other dishes. There are also different methods of preparing it. One would be from a rice cooker. Next would be the conventional pot subjected to heat. There are those which are cooked inside a bamboo stalk. And pilaf is another way of preparing it.
@olepmis (840)
• Philippines
13 Sep 09
Whichever is available rice or potato. It is important that we have something to eat.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
13 Sep 09
Nice answer. Yeah, in the end, it really boils down to having something to fill our stomachs and get the nutrients that our body needs.
@xyniece (77)
• Philippines
12 Sep 09
its just getting used to it, for me i use to take rice before, but now i eat bread for breakfast and vegetable for lunch and a cup of rice and meat. get used to it.
@aylim14 (501)
• Philippines
13 Sep 09
isn't that punishing yourself? hmm..how long did it take before you get used to this kind of eating habit? because, cravings are not even the question when you're used to it. it's the mindset of the brain that every time you see a plate, there should be a white thing there, which is rice. So, you could share us how you did it.