The Constitution - to follow or not to follow, that is the burning question!

United States
September 13, 2009 4:38pm CST
I believe that we as a People, have a system of government which receives its limited power from the People, and that the government must adhere to the principles laid down in the original document - the Constitution. Discuss with me why this is important, and why we must not stray from the Founding Fathers wishes; also, why must our government limit its power to only those established in this document, and leave the other powers to the People? Should we follow its mandates, or are we to shred this important building block of America?
1 person likes this
3 responses
• Australia
15 Sep 09
Hi Tanker. As you know, I do not like to comment much on American politics, firstly because I am an Australian, and secondly because I know very little about the American system, which seems extremely complicated compared with our simple system. I know little about the American constitution. However I have been a secretary in numerous clubs and groups over the last fifty plus years, and I always considered part of my duty to ensure that every action was in line with the constitution of the club or group. The constitution was always the supreme authority. Every constitution I've known has, as part of its contents, the means to change the constitution if the need arises, and I presume the American Constitution has this. The Australian Constitution can be changed, but it isn't easily accomplished (and shouldn't be). Surely, the Constitution of any club, group, company or government MUST BE the supreme authority and must be followed. I am sure there would be steps written into the Constitution for action if the Constitution is NOT followed. But who is responsible to ensure this?
• United States
25 Sep 09
Yes, as my dad used to say, 'Who is watching the watchdogs?' Too many times in recent memory we have seen the ones in charge (i.e. the government) overstep their authority and land on someone's rights and viciously tear them to shreds. Case in point, when Elian Gonzalez was forcibly removed from his aunt and uncle's house to be sent back to Cuba. The law states that if a person from another country comes in by water, and touches American soil, then that person has all the rights of an American - they can not be expatriated to the country they came from, unless they go through due process! And another, when you are required to make restitution for something, such as a fine, or child support, and yet no one shows legal paperwork through the courts (which is required) and yet, you still have to pay the penalty or support, even though you never had your day in court! We are to follow the Constitution, which is the supreme law of the land, and not deviate from its directives. So, how can we just allow the ones in a position of power to override the document, and breach its words? When the wolves are in charge, they will do everything in order to fulfill their lusts against the sheep in their charge! Even circumventing the law, and doing everything illegal!
1 person likes this
@debrakcarey (19887)
• United States
10 Apr 11
Now more than ever we need those who speak up about the destruction of our Constitutional Republic. The reason we need to stick to the Constitution? It should be obvious to any American who values their rights to free speech, or any of the other inallienable rights we have had given to us by the Creator. Without the protection of this document, we have no recourse to stop those liberties from being taken from us...except our will to fight like our forefathers had to fight. And we may not win so easily this time.
@PeacefulWmn9 (10420)
• United States
27 Sep 09
Hi Tankermone. My personal opinion is that the US was founded on very sound principals, some that have now been basically "over-run" by dozens of ammendments to the original document. Part of this is good...change requires some of these "updates," but part of it I do not see as positive. For instance, originally, the "separation of state and church" was to protect one's right to worship freely as one saw fit. Now, though, people have turned that original protection around and used it to try to keep God, prayer, and any form of religion out of as much as possible. I think we've suffered a lot of downfalls and issues in part because we have strayed too far from the principles of the founding father's and the original constitution. Karen