A Big Hullabaloo Over The Pledge Of Allegiance
@AngryKittyMSV (4317)
United States
September 15, 2009 11:40am CST
I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
When I was a kid, we said the Pledge every day at the start of the schoolday. Kids whose parents did not want them to say it had the option of sitting or standing quietly at their desks or leaving the room for a moment. It was no big deal and they weren't ostracized for it. In Jr High I remember the first day of school before the pledge there was an announcement that it was not mandatory to say it (that's true) and kids who chose not to may sit or stand at their desks quietly for the few moments while everyone else recited the Pledge. Those who objected to the "under God" part, simply didn't say that part, just paused until those four words had finished being said and then resumed the pledge. No big deal, nobody was ostracized for it.
Every now and again there is a big hullabaloo in the media now there are some that think a Miranda style warning should be issued prior to reciting the pledge. WTF? And there are some schools that require a not from the parents to exempt a child from the pledge, again, wtf? Why can't they just do as the schools I grew up in do, and at the beginning of the year quietly and with no big fanfare let people know that they have the option not to say it for whatever reason and it's not a big deal.
MOST kids in the schools I went to still said the pledge every day, but the kids who didn't suffered no consequence. Even though I beleive in the Pledge, one day I was not feeling well at all and thought I was going to faint, so I sat quietly at my desk while the pledge was recited and it was no big deal.
The article below goes into some detail about much of the noise being made over the Pledge of Allegiance feel free to read it and share your thoughts.
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,550063,00.html?test=latestnews
2 people like this
2 responses
@jwfarrimond (4473)
•
16 Sep 09
Actually, as a Brit, I'm baffled as to why you feel the need to recite this every day. I've always thought that patriotism is more than the recital of words or the waving of a flag. The country is more than the collection of politicos who happen to be in power at the moment, governments change, flags change, the land does not change and it's the land that we fight wars for, not governments or flags. (puts on steel helmet and ducks into slit trench to avoid incoming friendly? fire)
1 person likes this
@AngryKittyMSV (4317)
• United States
16 Sep 09
No fire here, friend. We start saying it as children when we are far to young to even know what it means, it is memorized just as we memorize the ABCs. And kids butcher moth pretty good, like "lmnop" as one word and there was an old episode of the Rugrats cartoon that had an adorable butchering of a section of the Pledge, but darned if I can remember it now.
As an adult the words mean a lot to me, and as an OLDER child they did too, but as a little kid, it was just a thing we all did.
I beleive in my country and in showing respect for the flag of my coutry, but I agree with you that we as a people in our country (mine or yours) we are so much MORE than those symbolic things.
I'm not quite smart or well educated enough to provide an adequate explanation as to WHY we say the pledge or start as children, maybe one of our more learned mylotters will have some enlightenment to offer.
1 person likes this
@jwfarrimond (4473)
•
17 Sep 09
Perhaps it's because of the way in which your country started as a collection of disparate peoples from all over the world. Your founders must have thought, (correctly in my view) that it was necessary to have a formal pledge of allegence in order to foster a sense of national identity. And altough there is no comparable requirement here for school children to recite something like that every day, immigrants are required to make such a pledge as part of the citizenship ceremony.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
15 Sep 09
hi angrykittymsv much ado about nothing as Shakespheare said and'that is how I feel about the pledge of Allegiance.I say it the way it was written and let others do as they will . i have always said it the'same way so not am about to stop now. my religious beliefs are'my own and not to be shared with others. we need to quit with this silliness and get back to other moreimportant things.
1 person likes this