Should rapists be quanrantined or executed?

I think they should be castrated, and THEN quarantined. Something more should be done, to protect these poor kids who fall victim to these animals. I was watching something last night, about a young woman, who was raped and murdered by a gang of five men...it was heartbreaking, like five animals, with a victim. Somebody's daughter, and they treated her like she was nothing!! Something needs to be done, to get these animals off our streets forever!

[b]Bad as rape is, I don't think it quite rises to the level of an offense deserving execution...but I could go with banishment/quarantining. That way, they could live, but normal people would be safe from them. I think this ought to be done for sure to child molesters! They can rarely be turned, & the honest ones among them admit it. And they could start with the people (that man AND WOMAN!!) who stole that 14 year old girl, or Polanski, heck, the news has been full of them & other perverts more & more in the last few years. Maggiepie "WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"[/b]

Personally I am in favor of capital punishment and that must be regularly handed to rapists, more so in cases of Child rape. One should inquire well into the case collect evidence, fix the guy, doubly make sure that he is the guy and simply send him to the gallows. If we do not punish him by Human Law, then he will be forced to take the long blind route of Karma. The shorter route of handing down Capital Punishment is good for both- the rest of the society and the rapist.

I think the rapist who rape and killed should be executed as he show no mercy to his victims need to be executed. While those who rape but not killed their victims must be rehabilitate for their psychotic perverted behavior as they may changes with proper counseling and medication. i do believe even bad people have their own goodness and they just need an extra times to discover it to repent their sins becoming a good person and not menace to the society. All is capable of giving another chances..

No, suchi60, not executed nor quarantined. rapist, murderes and all similar should be adopted and send to live in same house with the people who cry out loud "they did wrong but life is sacred since the moment of conceiving". But not forever, no sir, one week, then rotate them to other families with same belifs. Why rotate ? Well, if they stay more than a week with a "right to lifers" family, they may persuade those to help the rapist/killer to do next "job". (sarcasm mode off) Now serious .. quarantined is a permanent risk they escape .. castration won't solve the problem, them problem is not physical, is mental, they can develop a "pleasure" by raping with something else, projecting them sexuality to something else (in them sick mind is possible, it has happen) ... A deserted island where they should be droped and there could be a nice training area for special troops .. this way they can be somehow usefull for human society prior to dissapear. BUT !! (there's always a but ..) Prior to that, all should be in chains and for 1-2 years they should be kept on sort of bycicles and forced to treadle 12-16 hours a day to produce electricity.

executed definitely....no argue!

I think they should be executed. That would get them off the street and cut down on the cost of housing them in prison for years and years. They certainly should not be allowed back in Society. They took life, therefore theirs should be taken as well. They don't deserve to love!

As long as they're proven guilty of their crime... Then it would be better for them to be in a quarantined, not jailed, not in any type of camps, they would be confined alone in small rooms with a bed and toilet only... We would not be different from them if they would be executed.

I say castration would be more suitable for them.