Do you think online degree is as good as traditional degree?
By scheng1
@scheng1 (24649)
Singapore
October 21, 2009 10:15am CST
With the advance of technology, it is possible for us to study online for a degree course.
However, many people still feel that online degree is not as good as traditional degree, even when the online degree comes from the same college as traditional degree.
Actually I dont see there's a difference, since the person taking up online degree is most probably a working adult with many years of experience. Working adults obviously do not need so much attention from the lecturers. Many finance graduates taking up CFA course, which is the highest qualification in finance, are using online studying method or even self-study.
What do you think? Do you think online degree is as good as traditional degree?
4 people like this
20 responses
@ahgong (10064)
• Singapore
12 Nov 09
I guess if you look at the information learned, it would be the same. This is assuming that the criteria used for marking the exam scripts of a online degree is the same as that of a traditional degree.
It is not so much the paper qualification. It is the mindset of the people who perceive the differences between the two that makes the difference.
Some people just cannot accept that on online degree should command the same respect as a traditional one.
@ahgong (10064)
• Singapore
13 Nov 09
Ah... you have a point too. It is really tough to want to embark on something when you are constantly required or needed in other family commitments eh?
And the distractions from them will make it tough to concentrate at home.
Sigh... I must find a way to muster enough energy to take up a part time course as well!
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
12 Nov 09
Actually it's more tedious to study online. I wonder how many people can study when the whole family is watching TV.
Actually many colleges have moved away from exam based system to coursework based system. Some colleges have both courseworks and exams, I think if the colleges used coursework system, then the online degree is the same as the traditional degree, provided the students dont hire people to write the courseworks for them.
1 person likes this
@zed_k4 (17589)
• Singapore
21 Oct 09
Online degree is awesome, personally to me. Normal degree is a bit different because there are lecturers involved.
I think if one has the intellectual and intelligence, like in a sense not needing so much supervision, sticking to online learning is the best choice.
@zed_k4 (17589)
• Singapore
23 Oct 09
I know, I know.. ha...
But it's just boring to go to school; if for me, at least.. I'm not good with schedules and stuff.. I will tend to want to break the rules..
I find the own time, own target kind of thingy more disciplined for me..and I can stick to it better. So online learning for me...
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
22 Oct 09
Hi Zed, I'm quite surprised with your remark! Since everyone knows that UniSim (SIM) is offering many undergrad online degree, with goernment support.
Online degree does not mean that there are no schedule or interaction with classmates.
UniSim arranges for tutor for each student, and the professors are available for discussion and chats. Plus there are many classroom tutorials available for students who want to do the assignments together.
There is a clear schedule for submission of coursework, tests and whatever. The advantage is that the students can watch the video of their professors giving lecture many times.
Many online degree courses require students to hand in weekly assignment, I think this is the part more stressful. Normal degree is better, can play throughout the semester, and worry about the exam the night before.
1 person likes this
@randylovesdar (4932)
• United States
23 Oct 09
I agree Zed. I had done the traditional university and the online university. Between the two I love the online university better. With the online university you tend to get individualized attention and more interaction with your classmates. I am doing a graduate program online and I like it a lot. I am learning a lot and there are students who are in the field who can share their experiences.
1 person likes this
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
23 Oct 09
Hi Sally, many online degrees have on-campus components.
I guess certain branches of medical studies can have partial online studies, and since most medical students have to do a year of housemanship, there is little risk of ill-qualified doctors.
Business related course, psychology courses and others can be conducted as full time online degree courses.
@borhan (1338)
• United States
22 Oct 09
The subjects which needs some practical orientation as well as physical activies, generally not welcomed by online campussing. But the only theoritical based subjects, i think cannot be a problem while conducting online study modules.
But still the online degrees have not attained full acceptence.
@nzalheart (2338)
• India
3 Nov 09
Hello Scheng1, how are you doing. I hope you are still active on mylot. I just checked my mails of mylot folder and got a feeling to say hi...
And about the topic you mentioned, as you have mentioned it depends on the person. For me in the present context online degree is not good yet. I prefer the traditional one. But as you have already mentioned, it is very much good for those who are working plus studying. It can be as good as traditional degree. The difficulty on the process is that sometimes it is very difficult to understand something and we may get stuck. Computer based learnings though gives answer without any reluctance for the thousands of times, but gives the same response.
I have lost the habit of writing and can't write more...
Happy mylotting...
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
5 Nov 09
Hi Nzal, nice to see you pop up again! I think you are not suitable for long holiday, you get very lazy in holiday, that's why you can write when you are studying for exam, and so lazy when you are having the holiday.
I guess it's the cultural thing also. Many Asians just cannot accept taking online degree, unless they are working with computer all the time.
Most Asians still prefer face to face rather than online communication, even in friendships and shopping.
@Canellita (12029)
• United States
22 Oct 09
I know people who teach online and there are many creidible instirutions that offer online courses and distance learning has been around for many years but I am not 100% behind the online degree concept.
I wouldn't want someone providing a specialized service to me who had earned their degree this way. Some things require hands-on, in person participation.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
24 Oct 09
Hi Canellita, if you are talking about first degree for technology and medicine field, then there is no way a person can complete the course online. He must have certain on campus hours for the lab or practical.
Actually many doctors and nurses get the master degrees through online or distance studies, since they have working experience and they have access to conduct clinical trial to support their studies.
@Canellita (12029)
• United States
26 Oct 09
I suppose it is different with advanced degrees since there is so much writing involved and a shorter time period, etc.
@lindiebiz (1006)
• Canada
22 Oct 09
i really want to get an online degree to see the difference between it and the traditional method, however i agree with you, it is ideal for working adults, i dont see why a young person should pursue an online degree because the experiences you get in college are lifelong experiences
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
22 Oct 09
Perhaps the young person has no extra time, or extra money. Perhaps the young person is already a single parent, or wants to live on their own, so they have to work full time to pay their bills. There are many reasons people forego traditional experiences. I'm not saying it's better, just that what fits one doesn't fit all.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
23 Oct 09
Hi Lindiebiz, some young people do not know what they want, so they rather work for a few years before taking up a degree course.
By then, it's hard for them to quit working for three years just to get a degree in college. it's better for them to study online and working full time.
Bosses generally prefer fresh graduates to graduate with traditional degree, but they dont mind their existing employees taking up online degree.
@scarlet_woman (23463)
• United States
22 Oct 09
by all intents and purposes,it should be,you do the same work,just don't utilize a campus..but i know for a fact some jobs in my area won't accept that form of accreditation.it's not entirely fair,because home studies is the only way some people have time to get a degree.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
24 Oct 09
Hi Scarlet, I think it's more on the bias of the bosses rather than the job requirements.
After all if the existing employees upgrade with online degree, the company will recognise the degree and promote the employees to a level held by degree holders. So I think it's really a bias.
@youless (112481)
• Guangzhou, China
22 Oct 09
Although today we can learn by many ways. And actually we have learned so much via the net. However, I still think that the online degree is not as good as the traditional one. As it seems that online degree is not widely approved everywhere. People still prefer to the traditional degree. Perhaps it seems much more formal.
I love China
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
24 Oct 09
Hi youless, Asia countries are less open to online degrees. The only way to overcome this is to take online degree for first and second year of college, then travel to campus to complete the degree course.
At least you can honestly say that you attend the graduation ceremony and you complete the degree in the university ground.
@Bluepatch (2476)
• Trinidad And Tobago
22 Oct 09
Hardly. Its like those correspondence courses of past times. They were good. I took a few. But nothing like the real thing in a real school. In a university you have all the appendages of a university and that counts for a lot. Ask any student, especially the successful ones. An online course is like a corrspondence course. It might be good but nothing like the real thing.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
24 Oct 09
Hi Bluepatch, online degree course is far better than correspondence course.
You have live chat with the lecturer, and the fellow online classmates. You can view the video of your professors teaching numerous times. There are weekly assignments, and tutors to assist in the assignments.
Plus the discussion forums to ask and argue, and access to the libraries and research tools.
The few things missing are the partying and the sports.
@iakulchen (615)
• Singapore
23 Oct 09
While I do think that it's possible for an online degree to be seen as something equal to a traditonal "offline" degree, I don't think that is going to happen anytime soon. It's not that people don't put in the same amount of work in an online degree, it's that there are online degree courses which aren't actually that, which give the rest of the perfectly legitimate courses a bad name. You mentioned the dog with the degree in one of your replies. A couple of months back, some cat in the States graduated with a diploma from an online course in a simliar situation.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
24 Oct 09
Hi Iakulchen, I think in Singapore context, those graduates of UniSIM will prove the success of online degree programs.
UniSIM has face-to-face tutorial for students who can make it to campus. And they are encouraging many retirees to take up online degrees. I doubt that is workable. It's hard for retirees to swallow the concept of online degree.
I think many employers will view degrees from Singapore universities differently than those accredited by overseas university.
I wonder who will employ the cats and dogs degree holders?
@aliks071 (12)
• Indonesia
22 Oct 09
hello, well I think online degree is tougher than conventional one. since we have to discipline ourself to manage our time for studying and joining online forum. Even harder when we have a day job. Choosing the credible online college/university could be a tough job too. Usually we get online degree because we want to cut the cost for transport and accomodation.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
24 Oct 09
Hi Aliks071, I agree with you that online degree is tougher. Many online degree courses have weekly assignments, much worse than studying for traditional degree. At least I can relax for the whole term and worry about examination the night before.
I doubt I will enjoy online degree, simply can't imagine having weekly assignments and examination.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
24 Oct 09
Hi Weizen, it's a sooner or later thing that online degree will overtake traditional degree in terms of stupid enrollment.
Online degree is good for international students as well as working adults. For us in Singapore, the choice of degree courses is limited. That is why many people have to study overseas.
Online degree can save time and money for people who want to take up courses from foreign university.
@randylovesdar (4932)
• United States
22 Oct 09
My husband and I are currently seeking degrees online. He is going for an Associates Degree then his Bachelors Degree in Communications and Business. He already works in radio and wants to open his own station. I had graduated from Brigham Young University-Idaho with a bachelors degree in Education and am now pursuing a Masters Degree in Psychology. There is no difference between an online education and a on campus education.
If one is willing to put time and money into education then I feel that it is more important to be successful rather than worrying about wich one is better.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
23 Oct 09
Hi Randylovesdar, I think online education is more challenging, since you basically have to push yourself to log into the website and study.
It's great that both of you are taking up online degrees and can encourage each other.
I hope that the employers will value online degree as highly as traditional degree. After all, sooner or later, all colleges will have online degrees.
@complexkid (48)
• United States
22 Oct 09
Now days, there seems to be a multitued of online accredited schools out there. I think that they are probably just as good as going to school as long as it's an accredited school. To find out if it is, just ask. Also you could get in contact with your local colleges and make sure they are legit and that the credits are transferable, they will be happy to tell you I'm sure. The bottom line, just be careful of which college you seek out. Some are great and some are a scam. Good luck with your future!!
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
24 Oct 09
Hi Complexkid, I think it's great to have online degree courses, especially for those international students who want to save money on overseas study.
I guess the students can take online courses for two to three years, and complete the last year on campus. That will be the best of both worlds.
Maybe twenty years from now, the popularity of online degree will exceed the traditional method of teaching.
@Asylum (47893)
• Manchester, England
11 Oct 15
This really depends on the individual who is taking the degree. As long as that person learns the amount of the subject that is required then it should be just as useful.
To be fair someone studying online will be far less distracted than someone in a classroom with friends around.
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
21 Oct 09
You need to do just as much work with an online degree as with one you physically attend the school. Most of our colleges here in the states are offering online work because people have to work to be able to afford college!
There are some fake degrees that you can buy, I think these are what have set the alarms off. If you take the courses through an accredited college it shouldn't be a problem, one that everyone recognizes. I've taken several online courses and could probably get a degree with a few more intensive months of work if I could afford the tuition. The colleges I dealt with are well known so it would not be a problem getting it accepted by employers.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
22 Oct 09
Hi Dragon, I agree with you about the degree mills.
One reporter here was very naughty, she signed up for the fake degree for her dog. After she gotten the degree, she took the picture of her dog with the degree, and put it in the newspaper.
I guess online degree is tougher, since you need more self-discipline to continue the course.
It's great that many colleges are offering online degree, and I think ten years later, the online degrees will be more recognized throughout the world. I think more students will prefer online degrees too, they can save costs on commuting and accommodation
@tdemex (3540)
• United States
21 Oct 09
In my last few positions I did some hiring for the company. Most companies don't recognize these degrees yet! Unfortunately they don't want to take the time to investigated the certificate or hassle with getting the info from the issuer! Also I think it may be because older people call the shots and are not in tune with the changes taking place in the global communities! But with the younger people coming into more and more HR positions this going to change! tdemex
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
22 Oct 09
Hi Tdemex, you just need to have one Minister telling the world that he takes up online degree, and then the whole country will accept the change.
If the students taking online degree manages to secure scholarship, the employers will view him differently too.
I guess the recognition of online degree worldwide is possible after another ten years, after those "older" people retire!
@natmo_10 (25)
• United States
21 Oct 09
Well I can't really say at this point, would like to hope that an online degree is just as good and beneficial as a traditional degree.
I'm not able to go to a traditional college/university, without paying out of pocket, due to defaulted student loans. I have since brought those loans out of default status, and have since tried to apply for Financial Aid, to no avail. So my only other choice is to partake in distance learning/online schooling. I have checked out a couple accredited schools and upon receiveing the credits would they be transferable if I'm able to get into a regular school.
I am looking to advance professsionally as it seems that furthering my studys would at least get me remotely there. I have pondered on this same question time and time again, and really hoping that it would and is as good....
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
23 Oct 09
Hi Natmo, it's good that you have considered taking online degree course, and that you have done the due diligence.
I think those colleges that allow you to transfer the credits to traditional degree in college is good. This shows that other colleges recognise the degree. I think you can take the online degree at a slower pace, build up the credits while you are working. Then when you have enough credits, and enough money, you can study on-campus to get the degree.
In case the employers do not value the online degree, you can honestly say that you complete the degree course in campus.
@lefthooklacey (53)
• United States
21 Oct 09
An online degree in my experience can be actually more difficult to obtain. If you get a degree online in certain concentration, the workload that you have to complete during the semester is greater. This is the way that the teachers' make sure that you're staying on-task and involved in the course.
That being said, I think that there are some courses that are better completed in a classroom environment. There's a lot to be said for interaction with other students during the learning process of the material. Sometimes another student might ask a question in a way that you might not have thought of.
So my answer to your question is that I think it depends on the subject as to whether or not an online degree is as good as a traditional degree.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
23 Oct 09
Hi lefthooklacey, actually the discussion board and instant messaging are better for discussion than in the classroom.
In classroom environment, most students are so hesitant to ask questions. Yet these are the ones who enjoy discussion forum.
Plus in classroom environment, you tend to forget the questions easily. At least in dicussion forum and instant messaging, you can scroll back to read the questions and answers.
There is no difference in interaction for knowledge, whether online or offline studies.
i wonder why many people still think that online degrees are standalone, when there are many online courses with active cyber-group participation.,
@mrfdg1972 (3237)
• Philippines
21 Oct 09
i dont know about online degrees, well as much as posibble, i would stick to the usual take home study course. it cost less and you also study at home. And you get to meet your professor from time to time for evaluation.
@scheng1 (24649)
• Singapore
22 Oct 09
Hi Mrfdg, actually online degree is far better than the "take home study course", because you get to interact with the classmates and professors practically everyday through the online forum and instant messaging system.
The online degree usually have an online lecture, where you can watch the video of your lecturer teaching, and if you have any question, you can chat with him via the instant messaging system.