What was the worst advice you ever gave?

@laydee (12798)
Philippines
November 4, 2009 7:04am CST
I know that as a woman, I am capable of giving unsolicited advice. I know it's reality but something it's my nature of wanting to help which causes confusion and problems in the end. One particular advice that I could probably say the 'worst' is when I told my friend to say 'yes' to the man who was courting her. It was because she's been in and out of relationships quite often and I thought that since she obviously had poor judgment with men, she should try to take a step back from the 'common types of men she's dating'. On that occasion, she has been saying 'no' to this guy and I told her to just take a shot at it. Eventually she did. After a while, she came back to me telling me that she got pregnant, had a miscarriage and the guy left her. She wasn't actually blaming me, but I felt it was my poor judgment that allowed my friend to be in such a predicament. What was the worst advice you ever gave? How did you make amends for it?
8 responses
• Netherlands
4 Nov 09
Hi, the worse advice I ever gave was for someone to go for it. Go for it in the sense that they should betray their loved ones and do what it is that is in their heart. For that moment in time the person was truely euphoric and up for anything. But in the long run the person unfortunately became a rather miserable individual. I feel sorry for him, it was about his ex and his current girlfriend. But what was supposed to happen? I mean, if he was miserable with his current girlfriend and always thinking about his ex, why waste another moment and go for it? So going for his ex? I think it was still a good decision on his part, but still not he best advice I have ever given considering the amount of people who got hurt during the process.
1 person likes this
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
5 Nov 09
Come to think of it, we're jut the 'devils advocate' and it wasn't us who made the deed, right? I mean, I'm not excusing myself for the bad advice but the fact that they're adults and they have the last say in decisions doesn't point the finger to us 100% right? hehehe..
• India
4 Nov 09
hi laydee! i do understand when you see others in predicament because of your advice. it happened when i advised my cousin about adventure trips and camping. i suggested that jim corbett national park offers good camping,so u can have good fun for weekends. i never realised he would act upon my advice so religiously and convince all of his batchmates (batch of 30 students) for the trip.they all did this overnight without checking all the facts .booked a big bus and went straight away there to find out that those camps needed to be booked in advance.when they went for the jungle safari their vehicle broke down and they got stuck up in the mid of the jungle most of the time.so they were bit disappointed when they were back.and finally it traced out that it was me who had suggested the place.they had more share of misadventure(LOL)....
1 person likes this
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
4 Nov 09
Oh my gosh! Your cousin didn't even check it out first? He just took you word for it! ahahaa... Well, if they wanted to camp, then being in the middle of the jungle is the best experience of camping! hahahaha..
@trruk1 (1028)
• United States
5 Nov 09
Way back, about 1966, a casual acquaintance related an idea he had for a new business. I told him it was a terrible idea and gave him a lot of reasons why it would never work. His crazy idea? Put gambling casinos on riverboats. I hope he paid no attention to me.
@VVroom (255)
• Romania
4 Nov 09
I think you should not worry too much about your judgement being 'poor'. There is no good OR bad. There is good AND bad all together. There are opportunities which we are using in life for getting knowledge. In order to know about something, usually we first experience the good face of that something. In order to know something ( not to know about, like in the previous case), meaning to achieve the full understanding of that 'something', we need to experience also the bad face of the coin. It is said that pain and suffering ( the bad face of the coin) is the most efficient tool to get full comprehension of a situation. The ultimate goal of our existence is to gather information, to get knowledge. So... I think your friend had an experience, which is exactly what life wants from us There was a lesson at the end of the experience. The point is not that you advised her to enter into a 'bad' experience. The point is IF she understood her life lesson, out of that.
• China
5 Nov 09
I once suggested my brother to re-test the university.It is my fault.The way in life,everyone will make mistakes.
• Philippines
5 Nov 09
I once gave an advice that was not allowed by Mylot (read: violent) and I got blocked out of mylot since then. And i think every account that I had with the same email address gets blocked. I sort of pissed mylot of big time there. That was me not thinking.
1 person likes this
@LisaGuo (241)
• China
5 Nov 09
Hi Laydee,don't blame yourself.You did give the good advice you though.You're not mean to hurt her.On the other hand,your friend is an adult too.I don't believe you're capable to change her mind if she decided to ignore that man. You're a good and kind woman.
@rjvb26 (2518)
• Philippines
5 Nov 09
Hi! this post is a very interesting post, i am a guidance counselor, we usually guide and help people with their problems but not advice because if you advice someone and something not so good happens it will be the fault of yours. In guidance and counseling advising is a big no - no, advising is almost like you are the one deciding for the life of that person, which is a really bad thing, the only thing that you should do is give some options, opinions, questions that you think is best for his problems that will enlighten him/her, you should let others decide for themselves not you decide for them because they have their own mind and body. I am sure even you, you do not want others to decide for you, you do not want others to make a decision for you that will make you in the wrong path of the world. That goes when giving a guidance to a friend or relative. And by the way if we people make/made decisions we should not regret it. Always remember! Decide for yourself not others to decide for you! So in the end if something goes wrong there will be no regrets and no blaming of others. Poor judgments and decisions makes things worst, you should not give advice specially when things are very complicated. I hope you already learned from your mistakes. I am not saying what you just did is a total mess but i just want you to be careful next time and learn how to help others with their problems in a proper way, helping is not bad it's a good practice of being a good person, but before helping, think, learn and understand first the nature of the problem and how you will throw the right and proper words to your friends, relatives and etc.