who is good irfan pathan or R Jadeja?

Definetely Irfan. how can a person compare irfan and jadeja. Irfan far better bowler and also far better batsmen also.

yes of course Irfan will come back. These are just temporary glitches every player faces inn his career and Irfan has experienced such similar setbacks before as well. He is very grounded and does not get too carried away with all the adulations he receives from cricket fanatics. He knows ups and downs are a part and parcel of any sportsman's life and is strong enough to bounce back very soon! Just wait and watch.

I do not think we can compare a new youngster with an experienced pro. The key thing to look can be what Irfan was at that stage in his career and where Ravindra Jadeja is. Irfan had achieved much more by this stage in his career and then had tapered off. I guess he himself has lost confidence in his bowling as well as Dhoni. As far as Jadeja is concerned the key to his being successful or failure is going to be his temperament. In the past series he showed poor temperament which lost India two of the matches. If he can learn from the experience and then build on it, then he can be an asset to the team. Irfan for me has to start getting his swing back to be in the team. Cheers! Ram

I think Yusuf Pathan is better than Iran, or RJadeja.. He is a hard hitter of the ball also a quick off spinner... But its very sad to him he has not getting any promotion in his batting order. He is batting at number 6 at that time India is in a stage of 50over or India is in a tough stage...

certainly irfan pathan can be brought at this moment or crisis so that india can perform better

It is not fair to compare jadejawith pathan.Pathan is much better player than R jadeja.He is a genuine all rounder.

How come you can compare two people from different stream. Irfan phatan is exp. guy, a good medium pacer, batsman also (in short all rounder) and Mr. R Jadeja is a newcomer and a spiner and batsman. How can you compare him with Irfan pathan on the basis of 1- 2 matches. He has to achieve so much.

Temperament wise, Irfan is much better than Jadeja, he can bat very well and a good 40 runs regularly come from him.As far as his bowling is concerned, he is no better or worse than the ones playing for the side. Munaf Patel and Ashish Nehra cannot bat or field, Irfan can do both and thereby is a definite candidate for selection ahead of these two according to me whatever the form of cricket.Jadeja on the other hand needs grooming and maturity. The talent is there but he has to acquire the temperament to play at the highest level.

ifran pathan does produce some seem movement on any kind of track and he bowls with some good tricks on the other hand R jadeja as a left arm slow bowler bowls exactly on the stumps like "you miss buddy i will hit" so both are good players i think we can replace ishant sharma and put ifran pathan this could be a better choice

yes ,irfan is better than jadeja

i hope he comes back.....