Do u get confused between in's, on's, at's, etc.
By vanny
@vandana7 (100280)
India
November 14, 2009 1:22pm CST
I am not from any English speaking country. And my primary education was in local language, because of which my foundation in English is rather shaky. :) I am here to learn both the language, as well as expressions, apart from knowing others views of course. So far, nobody has pointed any mistakes. :( But I wish u all would. :) And I wish u all would let me know whether u all also make mistakes in using these words?
5 people like this
27 responses
@jwfarrimond (4473)
•
14 Nov 09
You do pretty well for someone who is "rather shaky". As for the difference between those words, you can be AT home and sitting ON a chair IN your kitchen. Does that example help at all?
1 person likes this
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
14 Nov 09
I am English but I have the same difficulties with those words (and others). English is complicated nad I can't remember all the rules.
I forget things like 'different to'/'different from' and never know which is correct.
Then I had a giggle at the previous response and I wonder...
if the chair that I am sitting in is near a window, then am I 'in the window' or 'at the window'? If it was a shop window I suppose I would be in it but what about a window in a house?
1 person likes this
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
14 Nov 09
I became aware of how complicated English is when I stopped using it on a daily basis after I moved to Italy. Not using it has nmeant that I often get stuck in the middles of a sentence and am undecided as to which word is correct. In Italian the rules are simple and it is much easier to learn. This is why I really do admire those Lotters who come here and post with what appears to be ease, even though it is not their language.
Hey jw, you didn't clear my doubt though did you?
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
14 Nov 09
Hi Diana :) That is exactly the problem I have. I try to recall other sentences in which the same objects are used and all the prepositions (I think you all call them that - I didnt formally learn English grammar - he he) associated with it, and I find that confuses me some more. :) Thanks for letting me know that even people of English origin face such problems. But one thing, expression in English is far simpler. In my mother tongue, it is so easy to have misunderstandings, because of the usage! For example, u all dont differentiate in the way u all mention a laborer or a boss (except royalty, of course). But here, a worker is still addressed in a different way. If accidentally somebody uses the form of address for a laborer for the boss or neighbor, things get sour. :) This is what happened in our building a couple of days ago. So I was just appreciating English as a language. :) Thanks for responding. Have a good day. :)
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
16 Nov 09
Hi Vandana!
You are undoubtedly fishing for some compliments. You have a very command over the language and you can give many others run for their money. In fact, I am trying to learn from your expressions. It does not matter much if during the initial period, you medium of study was local language; you have mastered the language very well as of now. I also keep committing silly mistakes when I write my responses and I really feel bad about it. Like you, I would also welcome suggestions to improve my language. I can give you small suggestion that you can use ‘you, instead of U in your posts.
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
16 Nov 09
Hi Vandana!
You may be fishing for compliments from other than those whose native languauge is English.
It is good that we both are trying to learning from each other. I fully agree with you that we keep committing some inadvertent errors because we tend to rely on others and feel that they are using the correct English.
There is always scope for further improvement and we can always learn.
Deepak
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
16 Nov 09
Hi Deepak, :) Fishing for compliments from people who come from native English speaking countries! Is it possible? :) I can definitely get away with flying colors in front of some of my countrymen, but getting away in front of those who can spot the errors in fraction of seconds! How wrong can you be? :( You are trying to learn from my expressions, and I am trying to learn from yours. :) Actually Deepak, there are instances when we pick a wrong usage primarily because we constantly hear it from somebody we think is better than us. Likewise, that person would have picked from somebody they admire. But the point is, it creeps in our language and becomes a permanent feature there. I'd like all those whose English is better than mine to help me eliminate those flaws. And that includes you. :)
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
16 Nov 09
Hi Deepak, I will gracefully accept the compliment that you seem to be hell bent on pushing down my gullet like some bitter capsule. . But more because it is embarassing me now. . Your vocabulary is really good. Though words like inadvertently are there in my vocabulary as well, I rarely use them, and therefore, when I really need them, they are like little kids hiding in some corner of my brain, difficult to find. :) I guess, I need to read a lot. :) I confined myself to essentially job related subject. :( I am lucky, I got a couple of good friends who will be helping me from now on. So I can safely say, mission accomplished as far as this discussion is concerned.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
14 Nov 09
hi vandana7 let me help if I can, when you use in is like this the boy got in the car but he stood on the sidewalk.He was at his grandmother's house. so when somebody or something is entering somthing we use in ,she got in the car, he went in the hall. butif you place something atop a table you would say I put the book on the table. If you are at a certain place you would say I am at the corner of Brookhurst and Lemon st.I think you are doing very well so keep on posting and speak English to others as much as you can.vandana you will soon be really good at English as you are very intelligent.
1 person likes this
@jwfarrimond (4473)
•
14 Nov 09
THE means you are referring to something. THE box. THE table. UP though is a sort of word with many uses. Look UP, pick UP, gobble UP (to eat very fast) There are many other examples that can be given.
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
14 Nov 09
Hi Hatley, thanks for the clarification. Yeah, it makes a lot of sense now. Can you also clarify when we should be using "the". And as I mentioned und jw's discusssion box, whether using the word "up" with a word like "gobble" is necessary? And thanks for the compliment. I wish I was intelligent. I am just an average person.
@mariposaman (2959)
• Canada
14 Nov 09
We are not supposed to criticize anyone's English here because this is an international site and a lot of the posters here are not native English language speakers.
@mariposaman (2959)
• Canada
15 Nov 09
While I sympathize with your plight, myLot is not the forum to correct other people's use of the English language, in fact it is forbidden by myLot.
http://www.mylot.com/o/guidelines.aspx
[i]DON'T
Post discussions, responses or comments criticizing members for bad/broken English or bad spelling. Everyone is welcome at myLot, we have users from all around the world and they are welcome regardless of their proficiency with the English Language.[/i]
I will however point out that the use of the letter u for the word you is not proper English. It is only used as a substitute when texting messages in SMS due to a restriction in the number of characters in order to save space.
@mariposaman (2959)
• Canada
15 Nov 09
I will tell you that I am a native English speaker. The an, at and on words are no problem to me as I use them every day. As mentioned, a lot of the language is learned in phrases, not individual words.
You also have to remember that English is not one language. England has been invaded by many peoples, all of whom left behind parts of their language. England then in turn spread their imperial empire around the world, gathering enven more words from foreign countries. The Vikings, Angles, Saxons, French, Spanish and Romans either invaded or influenced the English. English further borrowed, and continues to appropriate things from other languages, like the colour "kahki" from India and "tsunami" from Japan.
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
15 Nov 09
Hi mariposaman, I agree criticising might sound offensive, but guiding will not be. :) I assure u I am open to that, so whenever u come across any mistakes that I make, please make it a point to correct me. You all are not going to laugh at me. But once I am in my social circle, and they are all quite highly educated, if I make any blunders, they will be laughing on my face, or behind me, or may choose to correct me in rather condescending way. Would you, as my friend, like me to be ridiculed like that? I guess not. :) So help me out. :) For example - I think I made a mistake in the first sentence - guiding will not be. Isn't it? If it is not, then I am ok. But if it is, please let me know when I should be truncating such words. :)
@tamron123 (276)
• United States
14 Nov 09
Don't feel bad! I get words like were,where,ware mixed up and to,too or no know in some sentence. Since was a recent mistake in one of my articles. I still not sure if its sense or since.
1 person likes this
@jwfarrimond (4473)
•
14 Nov 09
Were and Where is one of my points of confusion as well. I often mix them up and use the wrong word for the context. Much to my sisters disgust - she has no such problem
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
14 Nov 09
may I help I have a BA in English. were is past tense of was so you would say were you at the house yesterday? Where is asking where something is or someone is or something is, so where is von store from here? YOu go to something, but if you are going with someone else you might say I went with James too. No is opposite of yes,it is a negative like no I will not do that. Know means you have knowledge of something like I know my times tables pretty well. hope this helps.
1 person likes this
@stvasile (7306)
• Romania
15 Nov 09
In school, the languages available for me to study were French (from 2nd to 12th grade), Russian (from 2nd to 8th grade) and English (from 9th to 12th grade). When I went to high-school (9th grade) I already knew English pretty well, from what I've picked up from TV.
I don't have any problems in using short words or problems like "thank's" instead of "thanks", but I don't criticize other people for using them incorrectly, as I know I probably make mistakes too that I'm not aware of. Some people (like you) want to be corrected, such as to improve their English, while others are bothered by being constantly corrected. Since I usually don't know who wants to be corrected or not, I prefer not to highlight their mistakes. For example, I hate it when people do texting on myLot - like you using "u" instead of "you", but that's everyone's choice...
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
16 Nov 09
Hello Spartan. :) Not only are you highly accomplished (French, Russian, and English - wow ) but even the discussions that you respond to are well above my intellectual level. :) I am not that highly educated you know. So I guess, I should feel honored that you accepted my request for friendship. :) Coming to this topic, mylot doesn't allow criticism, but mylot doesn't say don't guide them either! :) Don't tell me you are going to cross swords with me for that. LOL. Suppose I do make a mistake (and I make one too many), and you come across it (you don't have to read through all the discussions everyday just to locate my response), you can correct me, whenever you happen to read one of my responses. So that such correction does not lead to other people coming into the box and taking the discussion topic elsewhere, you could try including the part where I erred in your response, and use the correct English. Now, if you highlight (bold) only that bit, I would get the message loud and clear, and others wouldn't think it is criticism, or correction, would they? :)
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
16 Nov 09
I hope I got the message across. :( Now you would have realized what is my problem. :( .. where I erred in your response... kind of thing. Problem is, I am aware that I make such mistakes. :( And I don't know how to express myself any better. :( And as to using SMS language, I think Internet is flooded with information. English is one language where we can cut down on letters and bring down the memory usage (which I am sure is exhaustive). If I type the word you, I use three letters, and therefore the code needed to store that must be much more than what may be required to store just the letter u. Therefore, I thought using SMS language for regular words or usages such as by the way (BTW), oh! my god! (OMG), etc., would be ok. We are, after all, already using etc., i.e., ok, and so on in regular language. But I've realized that some of the mylotters, including you, are not ok with it. So I will elaborate those SMS words from now on. :) And sorry for such long posts. I just want people to help me out. :)
1 person likes this
@stvasile (7306)
• Romania
16 Nov 09
I don't know what you mean when you say I respond "discussions above you intellectual level"... it's been a while since I responded to some scientific or religious debates that might be considered a bit more difficult, but that's not the issue here.
The fact that I don't like it when people use texting, or SMS language, as you put it, is only related to my personal belief that this kind of typing denatures the English (or any other) language, in such a way that the people will fail to know how to use the correct language... It's everyone's option either to use this type of writing, and my option not to take the discussions using it, if it bothers me too much. I am not in any way insulted or annoyed by it - I just disagree of its usage.
As of the information storage problem... come on... you can't be serious about it... There's so much rubbish on the Internet that I think the space used by writing correct language is well used and not wasted in any way.
I'll try and keep in mind your request of signaling your own mistakes such as to help you improve your English - I don't mind helping people learn things as I have much to gain from other people that help me learn new things too.
@vijayanths (7877)
• India
17 Nov 09
Vanadana, we are sailing exactly on the same boat. I am here with one of the objectives to improve my written English.
that is why I blog regularly ( you may visit my blogs when you find time)
I am sure this site helps us in many ways, so I will never stop my posting here.
@vijayanths (7877)
• India
17 Nov 09
Vandana,
Blog is the short form of web log. It is a like a website. Usually people use it like a personal diary. They can share their thoughts to the world through their blogs. Only difference is the latest post will be seen in the front page of the blog.
I have written about 125 articles in my blog.
If you are interested you may visit my blogs here;
http://vijayanths.blogspot.com/
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
17 Nov 09
Yeah, mylotters are so tolerant! I am touched by a couple of them. They've gone out of their way to guide me, as you would ahve noticed. And one of them even volunteered to check all my previous posts and let me know where I was going wrong. That would've been a big exercise! 1000+ posts! So I suggested that she look at it prospectively instead of retrospectively. :) She agreed. Where can you get such help? And honestly, I dont know what is blogging! Can you explain it? Even Yugasini wanted to know what is blogging all about. :)
@kdhartford (1151)
• United States
14 Nov 09
Well, considering that there is a school of thought among linguists that a language should be written as spoken, I would say that you just need to work on it. English is a pretty easy language to learn, but difficult to master. Notice how all the native English speakers disagree about grammar; then you will understand the issue. My advice to to practice speaking and writing, you'll do better!
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
14 Nov 09
Easy to learn! I am forever confused about these words. :) I do try to read, and watch a lot of English movies. But I am not sure, I have the right words always. :) For example, right now, I wanted to write "I am forever confused on these words", then I thought that didnt sound right, and therefore, I chose a more innocuous way out. What then would be the right word in that place?
@Maggiepie (7816)
• United States
15 Nov 09
[b]Actually, your command is pretty good, & I've taught ESL (English as a second language)! If you request me as a friend, I'll critique posts for you, if they aren't that much longer that the one you just posted. (I do have other things to do! [em]lol[/em )
Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"[/b]
@Maggiepie (7816)
• United States
15 Nov 09
[b] Oops! Sorry--typo! "...if they aren't much longer THAN," not "THAT."
Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"[/b]
@Maggiepie (7816)
• United States
16 Nov 09
[b]That would be fine. But you really have nothing to worry about; it's hard to tell you're not a native speaker most of the time!
Maggiepie
"WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?"[/b]
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
16 Nov 09
Hi Maggiepie, that is such a sweet offer! :) Unfortunately, I've started writing longer posts (frankly only to improve my expression skills). What I had in mind was that whenever you come across my posts in any of the discussions that interest you, and you feel that I need to be told something, please dont hesitate in coming to my discussion box, and writing any response including the phrase where I err. Please highlight that with the mylot code (bold). That way, nobody can really call it criticism - which is against mylot rules, and I could still get your valuable guidance, without letting the discussion go astray. Do you think this is possible? Oh! I have too many doubts. :( So I can certainly do with a lot of guidance.
1 person likes this
@catdla1 (6005)
• United States
14 Nov 09
Hi vandana! I think you do a terrific job here, and I can't remember a time when I didn't understand what you were trying to say. Great job and keep going. English is not an easy language to learn, a the more you use it (and read it) the easier it becomes. Please give yourself a nice pat on the back for what you have accomplished!
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
14 Nov 09
I have to second that!
Vandana does a brilliant job - I make more mistakes!!!!
May I just offer a tip?
Instead of typing 'u', why not typ 'you' which is correct English and will help lengthen your posts.
Might make more cents too - or sense?
1 person likes this
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
16 Nov 09
As far as I know "in' is generally used before the names of countries and large cities, or before the name of the place in which is one is at the time of speaking.
"On" is used with the days of the week or months. "At" is used before the names of small towns and villages, or in speaking in a distant place...
Or it depend also on what particular terms we used to express. I think this is confusing but whatever it is. Here in mylot not actually give attention on such particular things.
I don't know someone if they are much concentrate to master their grammars here before writings any particular discussion?
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
16 Nov 09
You can master your English here. Because most of the members here are from the foreigner and they taught us to talk for their language. Even do most of the people here did make any correction in our errors if there be? We can practice our English because of day to day use it as our main sources of writings discussion.
Because I believe practice makes us perfect and experience is the best teacher. Therefore, I would say that to learn is to use it...
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
16 Nov 09
Yeah aerous, people in mylot are not paying attention to the language, they are just trying to make sense out of what we are writing, and responding accordingly. :) I am interested in mastering English, if I can do that of course. :) Oh! I know, at this stage of my life, it serves no purpose. But consider it as a hobby. :)
@Slewis77 (47)
• United States
15 Nov 09
English is one of the hardest languages to learn. You are doing just wonderful. And yes, English speaking people make mistakes all the time. We even do it on purpose because we think it is "COOL"! If you wish, request me as a friend and you can shadow me!
Best of Luck. :)
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
15 Nov 09
Hi Slewis, though I agree that English is a tough language, there are several plus points. It is not very easy to misunderstand each other when you use this language. The language itself is very polite unless you deliberately choose to use bad words. Sadly this is not true about my mother tongue. People have one misunderstanding too many with it, because there are some words that are used regularly for menials,and other words are confined to other people. If accidentally somebody uses the words wrongly, what happens is not very pleasant. :( That is why, I feel a bit safer with English, even though it is not my language. :)
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
16 Nov 09
Hi Slewis, I've asked jw so many doubts by now, he must find it annoying to answer. :) So I am taking the liberty of asking you one. :) "take away all or major parts of the profits", or "take away all or major part of the profits". Which of the two is correct? I know somebody jocularly suggested that I am fishing for compliments, but now that you know the kind of doubts I have, you possibly realize that I genuinely have doubts, and I want to improve. Please help me if you can. :) Thank's. :)
@dongwei877 (54)
• China
15 Nov 09
Confused by the term badly..I'm definitely annoyed by it since my high school.But now I'm influnced by an advice from A.J ,an expert from USA. In his opinion,we should listen to real english repeatedly.The content should be understandable in order to build fluence.So if you like ,keep my advice and learn together!
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
15 Nov 09
Yeah, actually I learnt quite a bit of English phonetically, by watching movies and television programs. :) But I have this bad habit, I get lost in the story, and then things dont really register in my brain. :) I even tried listening to the audio recordings for transcriptions as they would give me a better idea about the words. Generally, a drawl covers up such words making us miss them out, isn't it? :) Thanks for sharing the clue. I will definitely follow it. :)
@dongwei877 (54)
• China
15 Nov 09
yeah,sometimes I got lost in the movie either.hope both of us can learn english well! We need encouragement but not correction in the process of learning english which will do harm to our fluenc!
@bhanusb (5709)
• India
15 Nov 09
Vandana same condition is for me also. I am very much confused in using preposition.English is not our mother tongue. So we have to face trouble when we translate our expression. As a member of myLot I learned something about English from my friends.
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
16 Nov 09
In my case, I think I am confused about the usage of the language. I hear something very frequently such as the word "anyways", in Hindi television serials. I was accustomed to using it as "anyway". I suppose the younger generation knows English better than me, because they watch more English movies, more television serials, and are in jobs that bring them in direct contact with English speaking people. Apart from this, I have never been able to forget that my primary education, i.e., right up to the 5th standard was in Hindi medium, because of which the only thing I know about English grammar is the spelling of grammar.:) So I do admire many mylotters out here.:) I also cannot follow some of the jokes that these people share, which I classify as expressions. We too have our own way of expressing I guess. So I feel I am missing out on those. I want to master all that and enjoy everything, including arguments:), to the fullest. And I want to be able to express myself correctly so that people do understand what I want to say, and not understand it in a way that I didn't want it to be.:)
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
17 Nov 09
Oh! I am always confused. If you'd read what I've written under some of the above posts, you would have realized how many mistakes I must be making! Some of these people have agreed to help me out. That should help. :) Hopefully, in a couple of years, all my mistakes would be a thing of past. :)
@gunjanpri (603)
• India
16 Nov 09
good endeavor, friend. you can learn easily, if you are more active on mylot and write as much as possible. In fact you can start a new topic for discussion, on Learning English language and get more support from other mylotters. we are all here to help you happily.
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
16 Nov 09
Hi gunjanpri, thank's for your support. It feels good to know people have no objections in trying to help others learn. :) Hope you will be helping me correct my mistakes as and when I make them. But just in case, so that there are no arguments raised by other mylotters, and the topic of discussion doesn't get sidelined, please leave your suggestions in an inconspicuous way, for example you could integrate the correct version of the phrase in your response, and highlight that. I will understand. Thank you for being open to the idea. :) Have a nice day. :)
@gracefuldove (1668)
• Malaysia
15 Nov 09
You communicate well in English. There are some structural issues in your writing but it is minimal.Just remember that we learn a language through use of phrases and not through single words.That is why, the majority of Chinese who reads the dictionary by heart cannot communicate or improve their English. To polish up our English, we must speak more and of course read more. Getting a tutor to show the signposts is very important,though. Otherwise,you will develop fossilised mistakes!
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
15 Nov 09
Hi gracefuldove, please guide me regarding those structural issues. Yes, I wanted to bring that up as well. :) I know that problem does exist. Let me cite an example and get a clarification at this stage itself. For example I write "If the telephone is to be used by business purposes, it will be used more often, and it will also be be misused." Then, should the words "it will" appear twice? That doesn't sound ok to me. Well, I think you would understand what sort of problems I do face. Would you mind being my friend, and guiding me? I am sending a request. If you feel that is asking too much, you can decline the request. :)
@victoriousm (86)
• United Arab Emirates
15 Nov 09
These words are called prepositions. They describe the position of the noun or pronoun in relation to the other parts of the sentence. For example: John is in the car. The car is the noun and the preposition 'in' shows John's position - he is inside the car. Other examples: John is sitting 'on' a chair. He will call 'on' Monday 'at' 3 pm. Other examples of prepositions are 'into', behind, with, against, of, between, next to, and many more.
@vandana7 (100280)
• India
16 Nov 09
Hi victoriousm, thank u for taking time to help me. Can you clarify why it is not John is sitting on the chair, and why is it John is sitting on a chair. The difference between "the" and "a". Why is it there? :( These are some of the places I can really be confused. :(