Is obesity a choice or should it be considered a disorder?
By kjess77
@kjess77 (40)
United States
November 20, 2009 11:23am CST
With all of the talk about health care reform in our country, one must pose this question. The amount of people in this country who are considered obese outweigh (please note the pun) the number of people who are average or underweight. Anorexia and bulimia are widely known disorders that are considered mental disorders. They have treatment rehabs and many health care providers provide help in paying for the treatment of these disorders because they are considered not a person's "fault" or that they are "uncontrollable".
Now I pose the question, what about obesity? Is it not also a weight issue that stems from low self esteem or trauma in one's life? Should it not also be considered a mental or physical disorder that should be treated by medical coverage and therapy?
But many feel that being obese is a choice, and that if we have heightened taxes to pay for universal medical care, we must provide services for people who have chosen to be overweight and thus have many more health complications. Some feel that we are paying for their "choice" of laziness.
Where do you stand on the issue?
3 responses
@goldeneagle (6745)
• United States
20 Nov 09
There are different things that can lead to a person becoming overweight. Certain medical conditions can cause excessive weight gain. While I have not researched the issue, I think trouble with the thyroid gland is one such instance. In these cases, obesity could be called a medical disorder.
However, many of the cases of obesity in this country could be prevented. Too many Big Mac's and other fast food meals, as well as common overeating, can easily lead to obesity. According to the McDonald's website, a basic Big Mac value meal, which comes with a medium fry and medium coke, totals up to 1130 calories. Another popular meal combo is the Double 1/4 pounder with cheese. This meal deal, with a medium fry and medium coke totals 1330 calories. For breakfast, a bacon-egg-cheese biscuit, hashbrown, and medium coke totals 780 calories.
Looking at these facts, and considering that most people require LESS than 2000 calories per day (a 24-hour period) it is easy to see how our tendency to hit the drive-thru for a quick meal during our busy day can lead to obesity. Most people eat at least two meals per day, if not three meals per day. A quick lunch at McDonald's can provide over half of the calories needed by most people in ONE MEAL. Now, combine that with the fact that most people eat 2 more meals throughout the day (not including snacks from the vending machine or the gas station), and with the fact that most people get very little exercise (and certainly not enough to burn off the 3-4 THOUSAND calories they consume in a day, and it is easy to see why there are so many fat people in America...
The health care costs caused by overweight people in our country are as enormous as some of the people themselves. I can easily see how this problem is only going to get worse unless people start to make changes in their lifestyles...
@goldeneagle (6745)
• United States
22 Nov 09
go to the McDonald's website and check out some of their nutritional info...you will be amazed
@bird123 (10643)
• United States
22 Nov 09
I have noticed more and more people are overweight. They can't seem to lose weight either. I am wondering if food manufacturers aren't putting something in the food to make us hungry. The more we eat; the more money they make. Example; there is a potato chip that tastes great but when you stop eating them, you start to crave them. Makes you want to eat the whole bag. I stopped eating potato chips because of this. It would be nice if some scientific study could be done.
@baltimore13 (53)
• United States
20 Nov 09
I thimk obesity is a choice unless the your doc saids that theres a problem. There is no reason for some of the obesity in the world. there to many gym in the world for people to be fat.