Pros and Cons of Abortion
By Leo
@d_e_v81 (360)
Singapore
November 28, 2009 3:07pm CST
Ok another touchy and highly debatable topic.
Have they become part of our modern lifestyle? Is it ethical or unethical? Do you agree that it should be legal? More then thirty countries have made it legal. Some countries have put a partial ban with the woman being allowed to abort in the first trimester. Other countries have put a complete ban to it. Religious views aside, what do you think?
10 responses
@maximax8 (31046)
• United Kingdom
29 Nov 09
Personally I am pro-life and so I wouldn't ever have an abortion. For me it would be morally wrong. If I didn't want to keep my baby I would have him or her adopted. Then I wouldn't be killing my baby but give an adoptive couple that chance to have my baby. I think of aborted babies as being the missing people of the world and maybe some great ones are amongst those.
In my home country abortion is allowed up to 24 weeks pregnancy. For pro-choice ladies that pro is that an abortion can be done up to 9 weeks pregnancy with a pill. That is called a medical abortion. A con is a later abortion must be done surgically. A con is the baby will be in considerable pain whilst he or she is being killed. Number one is the head and it is a con that it must be crushed.
In most other European countries the abortion time limit is 12 weeks but in the UK 24 weeks is terrible cruel. In some countries where abortion is illegal back street abortions do take place which is awful.
@maximax8 (31046)
• United Kingdom
2 Dec 09
I think that life begins at conception. Looking in a book I saw diagrams of a baby at each week of pregnancy. In a movie called the Silent Scream they filmed an abortion. It was a highly disturbing. I don't think that the baby deserves to be aborted. People die in war like soldiers but babies are dying without being able to live in the world. They think they are safe in their mother's womb and then the abortionist kills them. I am pro-life. I think the UK should reduce the time limit to 12 weeks. There could be some special rules for ladies whose lives are in danger.
@angelsmummy (1696)
•
29 Nov 09
I hate it that its 24 weeks, babies can survive outside the womb from around 24 weeks. In some cases the nurse has to hold the baby while they die :(
@d_e_v81 (360)
• Singapore
30 Nov 09
Thank you both for your responses. I guess there have been arguments on whether abortion at one point during the pregnancy is more ethical then another. For instance the 12 weeks where it is just a cluster of cells or the first 24 weeks where the baby already develops a heart beat. Why would anyone want to wait so long before deciding to having it aborted? Isnt it better to abort when it is just a cluster of cells?
And your missing people analogy is creepingly sad. Yea...perhaps we have lost another gandhi, or theresa...but pro life arguments are debatable as well...
@angelsmummy (1696)
•
28 Nov 09
I really dont want to reply to this as I will probably get rated negatively but I am willing to take this risk (just about).
I personally dont agree with abortion for social purposes, for example a woman is too busy to have a baby or doesnt want to lose her figure. I agree with it in some cases though for example if a woman gets raped and falls pregnant, if you know your baby is that badly disabled it will have a very poor quality of life and reasons like that. At the end of the day I have friends that have had abortions for social reasons and even though they are still my friends I make it clear to them that I dont agree with what they have done. Yes it may be a cluster of cells but that cluster of cells is a tiny little life growing in your body. You created that life and you are going to take it away because you dont want to get fat.
@d_e_v81 (360)
• Singapore
28 Nov 09
Yes well, social purposes is a valid argument to some extent...in the instance when you know the baby is going to have a poor quality of life. Some scientists argue that the small cluster of cells is technically not aa human yet. but getting aborted cos u dont wanna grow fat in preposterous!
@angelsmummy (1696)
•
29 Nov 09
I guess its just peoples beliefs everyone has their opinion. With the tags everyone can put them in for example I used the tag abortion, some people just add tags without replying and repeat discussion is in their as this has been discussed many times before, may have been reported so be warned this may get deleted
@dreamer5916 (4)
• United States
3 Dec 09
as a child i was raised that abortion was wrong. you would be sent straight to hell if you ever got an abortion. i was told all the negative outcomes. i was also told if you get pregnant before you're married or if it's out of wedlock then it's also wrong. when i was 19 years old i got pregnant. it was stupid and irresponsible. i came to realize how my life would change. my boyfriends mom said i had to "take care of it" and if i told my parents i would cease to have a home or a family. it tore me up inside and i was so stressed. at first i couldnt even tell my boyfriend. eventually i told him and he wanted to keep the baby and so did i. when we told his mom she said i would have to "take care of it" because she wouldnt help us and i knew my family wouldnt either. even if they didnt kick me out, they would never let my boyfriend see the baby. i eventually got an abortion and it was the hardest thing i ever did. but i didnt want to raise my baby homeless and alone. after i did i went straight to my preist and confessed. i felt horrible. in my heart i know it was wrong and i knew people would say that i was evil and a murderer. that what i had done was unethical and it hurt so bad. i was in tears the whole time and was so afraid of what he might say. he told me to live my life as christ-like as i could. i had confessed my sins and he said that was the first step to forgiveness. i know what you will all think. and i want to say that i dont care. but i do. i now talk to my preist every week about how im doing and am actually working on getting a degree so i can start a family. im sorry that you all think so badly of me. but i feel like my baby had a better chance with God than with an irresponsible mother like myself.
@d_e_v81 (360)
• Singapore
4 Dec 09
Your story is sad but unfortunately it is happening to many women around the world. I dont care how others view you or treat you but Im going to be the last person who is going to judge you. We all have our reasons for our actions and the emotional guilt you go through only you know of. I don't think it is fair for others to judge you.
@krkavsy (191)
• India
29 Nov 09
Well nowadays there are also the pills available for aborting a baby but it is not good for a woman as she may not be able to give birth to the child again if she has aborted the baby many times. If a woman gets pregnant before marriage then how will she face the society? If abortion has to be banned then the man has to marry the woman if he has raped her or made her pregnant for a woman does not get pregnant by herself else he should be convicted. Many women fear to file a case on that man who deceived her or raped her for they have to think twice before doing that! She has to be daring to take such a step.
Women are treated as underdogs. If abortion has to be banned then even eve-teasing has to be banned and women should be encouraged to lodge a complaint if she comes across that.
@krkavsy (191)
• India
1 Dec 09
Eve-teasing begins with offering friendship to an unknown girl and then physical contact. This is a controversy that whether a woman will be happy if she marries a rapist or not but the question is that why one should be punished if both are at fault? and there is a possibility that the man might change after seeing the baby.Women are physically weaker than men. It is not that she does not defend so she cannot be blamed if she gets pregnant before marriage. If the man who has raped the woman can take pleasure from her cant marry her then he does not have any right to ruin her future. He does not have any right to ruin her life.
In Saudi if the same thing happens then he has to marry her else he will be killed.
@d_e_v81 (360)
• Singapore
30 Nov 09
The man has to be forced to marry the woman if he raped her? Is this only in your country where the law is applicable? Is this really a good idea to let the guy who raped the woman to marry her? will she be happy to spend the rest of her life with the man who raped her?
And what is eve teasing? I dont get it...
@drakeblueeyes (4)
• Singapore
28 Nov 09
As you mentioned before, it is not easy for women to make this decision. They can undergo psychological trauma and guilt in the future. With so many consequences why would anyone wanna make it legal?
@chadog (22)
• Philippines
29 Nov 09
You can further discuss about it but the most reason that people do abortion is because they wanted to escape the fact about unwanted pregnancy. But the bad thing about it is not only you break the law of mankind but you also break the law of god as well ... "Thy shall not kill"
@krkavsy (191)
• India
3 Dec 09
Yes if a woman is married and gets pregnant then she should not kill but if she gets pregnant before marriage then she has three options:
1. Abortion
2. Finding a father for the child
3. Keeping the child and facing the society.
I feel that she should find a father for the child or file a case on the person who made her pregnant.
@d_e_v81 (360)
• Singapore
30 Nov 09
Its a moral dilemma that most women face but they have to somehow weigh the ros vs the cons in order to justify their actions to themselves. of course pro life people will have their own arguments but eventually, it is the woman's life so i think she should have the right to decide what to do. I dont believe in God but I do believe there was some sort of explanation about free will in your bible right?
@weasel81 (2496)
• Australia
29 Nov 09
i think it was cosmo mag this month in australia, had a thing on abortion. about a couple getting the pill from overseas, or something and they are both now facing potential jail time from it. i'm not for it, unless there is a medical reason or rape. i know i couldn't have gone through with it when i found i was preg with my son. this debate will go on for yrs, and it will come back to the persons choice on what they do.
@drakeblueeyes (4)
• Singapore
28 Nov 09
Besides, abortion can be detrimental to health also ranging from sepsis, infection, rare but even deaths and risk of recurring miscarriages. All these have to be taken into account before a government makes it legal right?
@drakeblueeyes (4)
• Singapore
28 Nov 09
Well, most women with unplanned pregnancies, if they choose to give birth anyway, will decide to keep it. So I see it as a form of murder anyway. A growing embryo is considered human once it has a heartbeat. this happens usually by the 21st day.
@d_e_v81 (360)
• Singapore
28 Nov 09
Well that is just one view to the matter. I see you have responded to my post by posting several times however I will just respond to your posts on this single message cos it is difficult to keep track. A woman i guess would need to consider several factors like the delivery of the baby and taking care of it forever after that. All these will be difficult without any help from a partner or family support. If she is not working thaatz a triple whammy. What if the mother has HIV or something? would it be fair to still deliver the baby? would it be fair for the baby? You mentioned about post abortion trauma. how about the trauma one has to face in raising up a child, especially if you know the child is going to be handicapped or carry the disease passed on from the mother? If it is not made legal, there will be a lot of illegal pregnancies cropping up with unsafe practices. at least now we are assured the mother has the appropriate medical care and some centres even offer counseling. I guess there is no easy answer that is why i started this topic to see mylotters views. Im just ticked off it got tagged as 'repeat' discussion.
@drakeblueeyes (4)
• Singapore
28 Nov 09
I think that it is irresponsible for one to end up in a situation where she shas to decide if she has to kill an unwanted pregnancy or not. I know it is a tough decision but what landed her in that situation in the first place?