fat cats
By jb78000
@jb78000 (15139)
December 1, 2009 4:19am CST
and other animals. some animals will eat too much if given half a chance and it is very sad to see overweight animals. i remember staying with friends in a small town and there was a man with a grossly obese dog, he'd wait with this dog for a bus every evening and half the passersby and all the bus drivers would give this poor animal snacks thinking they were being kind. i think this was inadvertant cruelty - i think my friends intervened eventually, this dog was beginning to have difficulty walking.
most of the pets i've had (cats and rabbits) have only eaten what they needed and left the rest but there are some individuals whose diet really needs to be monitored. i have a couple of rats at the moment and they get a constant supply of rat mix (because they don't actually like it much so only eat it when they are hungry) but i limit the amount of tasty things they get because they would definitely overindulge in things they like. spherical rodents die early and have all kinds of health problems.
so do you have pets who overeat if allowed to? and what would you do if a friend was overfeeding their animals?
5 people like this
20 responses
@MJay101 (710)
•
1 Dec 09
I think it's sad to see pets that are obviously obese - and yes, I'd say it counts as "cruelty". (Don't even get me started on dog breeders who strive for some absurd notion of aesthetic perfection that causes an entire breed significant pain...)
Having said that, one of our elderly cats is a little porky. But I think that's okay; his days of climbing up the curtains and chasing seagulls are sadly passed! Now he is in his cattish retirement: sitting in front of the fire, only rising to squeak for bacon every now and then... (Well, it's not so bad! )
@snafushe (791)
• Canada
1 Dec 09
My cat used to be the fattest cat, like literally putting Garfield to shame. I realized after moving from the city to the country that alot of it was his surroundings. He didn't want to go and hunt or adventure in the city because of all the danger and noise. Plus he was depressed because he hated his surroundings so much so all he'd do was eat and sleep. Poor kitty. Now hes all slim and muscle and I barely have to feed him because he's too busy outside hunting for mice & birds! I think if your friend was overfeeding them you should alert them of the health risks for the animal, and recommend a change of diet and possible some more exercise.
@cloudwatcher (6861)
• Australia
1 Dec 09
We've had pets over the years and they weren't overfed or fat. The dogs were farm dogs, (blue cattle dogs)so they were very active.
The only "pet" I have at the moment, apart from my pet rock that a friend gave me, is my hubby and he is well fed but not overweight.
1 person likes this
@bestboy19 (5478)
• United States
3 Dec 09
There are four cats that live with us. Two belong to us and the other two belong to our neighbors, but prefer staying with us and eating our cat food. One of our visiting cats eats like a pig and never gains weight. I seldom see her sister eating anything, though she seems to want whatever the other cats are eating, and she's a porker. Both cats have regular vet visits and are perfectly fine. We have no idea why one is so fat and the only so tiny.
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
7 Dec 09
I think they are like people. To see me eat you'd think I should weigh 300 lbs. I am prob around 95ish right now. I do work out or TRY to work out consistently, especially if I know I will be attending lots of things that involve food or baking desserts or celebrating holidays....
However, I think it comes down to metabolism and also your genetics. I had five cats at one point - well they were my ex's cats. They were all related. The mom cat was a tiny dainty motherly cat. One of the 'babies' was HUGE, not just BIG but a porker and with totally different coloring. She was probably 13 lbs, I think he was 25 lol. There was another baby who was also tiny, she looked just like a siamese. I swear she ate more than the big one. She would also SIT in the food bowl in order to keep the rest of the cats out of the food until SHE ate her fill. Yeah... they were characters... those cats.
@jb78000 (15139)
•
3 Dec 09
i've also seen cats decide on their owners a few times. when i was growing up a cat belonging to friends decided to move to us. another time a kitten next door moved in on us for a couple of years then decided to move in with some other people further down the street. i think the cats that have adopted you must have different metabolisms, or perhaps one is more active, anyway if the vet says they're fine then there is clearly no problem. people are similar - i've compared what i eat (rather a lot i'm afraid) to people who are heavier AND more active and it has to be our bodies process differently...
@voldrox (7191)
• India
2 Dec 09
fat cats uh huh, well i used to have a cat many years ago, i always fed it the amount it required, yes you are right giving all the time is like inadvertent cruelty - it will be like it will die if won't eat anything for a day... well we always fed the cat when we used to eat, the cat would come and brush herself on my leg and beg for food, it would pleadingly look at me and i would be like - ehh let me eat first and then your chance would come .. hmm as rude as i sound here i was not, i loved my cat.. after i would finish my eating i would give it the appropriate amount and just sit to watch it eat, hmm maybe i am not that mean after all mhm... okay she used to leave crumbs at times but she seldom gets anything extra apart from her meals, we did not want to make it a habit to give her extras i bet the cat could have cursed me sometime
@jb78000 (15139)
•
2 Dec 09
it is hard to resist them when they start asking for treats but making sure treats are treats and not a habit is a good idea. my pets at the moment start bouncing up and down whenever i start cooking but they only get a little later on. they do look pathetic but they'd be a lot more convincingly hungry if they weren't jumping up and down right in front of a full bowl of dry food. anyway your cat sounds like she was a well loved and treated kitty .
@Louc74 (620)
•
1 Dec 09
Where I used to live, there was an absolutely gorgeous cat who used to hang around outside the local shop, and roll over to show his belly to anyone who passed who might give it a rub!Lol! He was lovely, and I'd always stop to pet him.
But his belly actually trailed the ground. I'd never seen anything like it! I don't know if it was down to the owners totally over indulging him, or people going into the shop giving him tidbits, or a combination of both, but poor wee soul!
My cat, Poppy, has put on a bit of beef over the last year, but she still has the shape she should have, and is quite muscular under her "layer", and she's 9 now, so just slowing down a bit. But if it became a health issue, I'd definitely start buying the lite cat food.
1 person likes this
@zed_k4 (17589)
• Singapore
2 Dec 09
You are right, Jb..I think there should really be some sort of responsibility on the part of passer-bys as well as pet owners.
The pets and stray animals should not ever be overfeed because just like humans, there might be complications.
@mommyboo (13174)
• United States
7 Dec 09
My best friend had a dog that was getting too fat and she took him to the vet and the vet suggested that she ration his food. He was actually beginning to waddle and she was concerned about his hips. She had to be very careful about keeping the dog food in the garage or outside the back door where the dog couldn't get it - when it was in the pantry, he figured out how to get the door open and he chewed a hole in the bottom of the bag and helped himself. Also one time we had taken the kids somewhere and we grabbed takeout for them for lunch. Instead of having them eat in the car (they were younger so they were kinda messy), we brought the food back and made them plates. We put the boys' chicken nuggets and fries on the counter but we put the girls' food on the small table. The dog came tearing in through the garage and went over and ate her daughter's lunch. I was able to rescue one of the plates but not both. Her daughter cried because the dog inhaled her food!
Eventually he did lose the extra weight and became healthy again but he was never a dog you could just feed extra scraps or allow to eat until he was full. He would never be full..... he was just like a person who was prone to obesity. If you controlled his intake, he was fine. If you let him have free reign, he got fat.
@minx267 (15527)
• Hartford, Connecticut
1 Dec 09
My animals have food down all the time and they don't overeat.
My 14 cats are all a healthy normal weight. I have a couple of dogs that are maybe a few pounds too heavy but it is not from overeating their food.. because that is usually available to them.. but the extra pounds are from snack and treats and people food. They love that stuff and between me and my roommate, they get to lick our bowls or she gives them cookies not knowing that I already did. But they are still quite active running and jumping in the yard, so I don't worry about it too much.
@jb78000 (15139)
•
1 Dec 09
it is interesting that omnivores, animals that eat a variety of foods, such as dogs, rats (and us) seem to be more susceptable to the lure of tasty things than those with more specialised diets. there are cases of cats and rabbits becoming overweight but much less common. i think if your pets don't eat too much of their food then letting them have constant access is definitely the best thing to do. btw your dogs sound fine, a few extra pounds i don't think is something to worry about.
1 person likes this
@my_name_is_coco (4333)
• Philippines
12 Dec 09
we have 4 cats.while they're not overfed,they're not really skinny.they have some extra meat on their bones.they're not too fat.I guess it's because they just sleep the whole day.they don't really go out and play.
@sunny68 (1327)
• India
1 Dec 09
i do not have any pets right now but there was a time when i had an aquarium. the fishes seemed to be always hungry. luckily i was informed beforehand to ration the feed. the way they rushed towards feed sometimes did made me take pity on them and put some extra feed but occasionally and not regularly. i have also noticed that obesity is a problem with pet animals and not free animals. perhaps it is linked to availability of food and physical movement of animals...
@jb78000 (15139)
•
1 Dec 09
i'm not sure about fish - i think one of the reasons you are not supposed to overfeed them is because left over food will rot in the water. anyway with all animals the occasional extra treat is ok, just don't overdo it. i think you are right about the reasons some pets get fat - we are the same, some (not all) of us will overeat and store the excess when there is plenty of food (especially tasty food) available. this makes sense in situations where this doesn't happen very often (which is the case in nature) but when there is always loads of tasty food just there it could lead to problems. especially as this is coupled with sometimes very sedentary lifestyles.
@Picquarian (724)
• United States
18 Jan 10
I am very careful that my dog only eats dog food. I don't let him eat anymore than he needs.
@risaree (23)
• United States
2 Dec 09
Its just like parents who overfeed their children. They think they are being good and caring parents and they probably are. But you have think of their health also. The same thing for pets. They will eat everything that you put in front of them. But you have to set limits because they are obviously not going to. And take them for walks so they can burn off their energy. It is sad to see these pets that are so overweight, they can't walk or even have a hard time breathing.
@Jennifer_lee_88 (589)
• United States
2 Dec 09
I feed my 4 cats wet food at least once a day and i leave water and 2 different kids of dry cat food out (in 2 different places in the house) 2 of my cats are normal weight and 2 are kind of chubby.
I feed my dog people food (i'll make her some of what ever i'm going to eat) and a can of dog food a day. I have tried every kind of dry dog (and cat) food for her and she refuses to eat it!
@jb78000 (15139)
•
2 Dec 09
hey, that is one fussy dog. my pets get as much dried food as they want but they definitely prefer people food, which i limit because they would certainly get fat if given as much as they ask for. if you think 2 of your cats are a bit on the plump side then just check with the vet next time you go for another reason. they're probably fine.
@Jennifer_lee_88 (589)
• United States
2 Dec 09
Yeah i know shes wicked picky... even some people food she refuses to eat. Shes a good healthy weight. shes a pitbull so she has all those wrinkles/ rolls of fat on her neck. shes so cute
My cats aren't like fat but 2 of them do have a little belly!
@Capsicum (1444)
• United States
1 Dec 09
I have always told friends this ,Is why they make dog food.It only makes sense,If people only new, how our foods have bad effects their furry friends .I doubt anyone would do it intentionally,But a lot of times like owner like pet. The worst thing,I hear is its just a little...It is indeed on the grounds of abuse ,but comes with ignorance and love.What's a person to do ? Some must just live and learn sad as it may sound,at the expense of others animals included.
@nova1945 (1612)
• United States
1 Dec 09
I have a fat cat, and he is my best friend. He never gets people food but since we have two cats, it is difficult to feed the younger (slimmer) one without having him sneak in to raid her food dish. Sometimes she even requests food just to give it to him.
But Buff is 7 years old and does'nt climb and play as much anymore. His favorite things are eating and sleeping. He is 23 pounds and solid (no fluff) and quite healthy.They both have dry food available all the time and share a 3 oz can of wet food for "dinner" so no real difference in diet. I have tried picking up his dry food at night but it just makes him more agressive at stealing Cricket's food later, so there is just not much we can do about his overeating habit.
@LetranKnight25 (33121)
• Philippines
2 Dec 09
hello Jb,
I don't mind having a Fat cat since he may not be able to out run me when he's at that weightbut of course, with that i want my cat to be fat because i want them to be healthy as well. my cat is normal weight but i noticed a few loose pounds since he's only eating cat food now.but i do believe having a fat cat leads to complications and probably life shortage.
@olisaur (1922)
• United States
1 Dec 09
I think obesity in animals and humans is kind of a taboo thing- being called "fat" is always an insult and frowned upon, and the message of feeling comfortable in your body is advocated, but being overwieght is biologically bad for you. There are some people and animals that just have more fat cells in their bodies, and are prone to being bigger whether or not they like it.
@jb78000 (15139)
•
1 Dec 09
i won't get into the issue of obesity in people, however with animals i think i disagree with you. letting your pet become obese through overfeeding or too many treats is a form of( accidental and wellmeaning i know) cruelty. it makes the animal physically very uncomfortable, causes lots of health problems and reduces their lifespan. you are responsible for dependent animals and this includes caring for them properly. the dog i described earlier was so overweight he had difficulty walking because the owner (and others) didn't realise that giving the poor thing lots of treats was not really the kindest thing to do.
@chriszh22 (432)
• China
2 Dec 09
For cats, I like to see them overweight, that's super cute! For dogs, as fit as possible. People describe woman as cat and man just like dog here. I know fish is very greedy for food. Even eat to die.