What is the grading system that is most familiar to you?
By merlinsorca
@merlinsorca (1118)
United States
January 21, 2010 10:04pm CST
By grading system, I mean a letter grade (A+, B-, etc.) or a percent grade (100%, 50%, etc.).
So, for all the times you see/have seen school, which grading system was used most often? If you are a student now, or if you were a student a few years ago, or if you have kids that go to school - which grading system is used?
Now, which system do you think is more effective? I personally think that the number grade is good because they show the exact score. In a letter grade, this isn't possible. A 100% and a 99% may both be shown as an A+, so you won't know the difference unless you have it as a percent grade.
Which one do you prefer? What are the pros and cons of them?
1 person likes this
14 responses
@angelajoy (1825)
• Philippines
22 Jan 10
I experienced the percentage grading system when I was in elementary school and high school. When I went to college it became different. We were graded on a scale of 1-5, with 5 being the lowest and 1 being the highest. I can't remember exactly the percentage ranges for every grade, but I remember that 96-100% is equal to 1. I prefer the percentage system because I was able to see my exact grades, which was fairer because having the same grade doesn't mean having the same exact total percentage score. So if I get a 98 and my classmate gets a 96, we would both be graded a 1, which is not fair because I am two points higher.
@angelajoy (1825)
• Philippines
22 Jan 10
Oops, I just made a mistake. I meant that in the "scaling" system, having the same grade doesn't mean having the same exact total percentage score.
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
22 Jan 10
That's right, it wouldn't be fair at all if you had the same "grade" when you actually had the higher score. And when you see that on the report card, it's hard to believe that your grades were handled professionally because all you see is a mysterious 'A' or 'B' letter, or even a 1-5 number. With the percent, the exact number is known, so you could know if you improved from a 95% to a 100%.
1 person likes this
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
30 Jan 10
So, I see that means you have the letter grading system, and the percent grading system too. What do you think is the better grading system? Are you more familiar with having a letter or a number to show your score?
@Biomechanoid (2923)
• Estonia
22 Jan 10
In our country there is a numeric system used. It ranges from 1 to 5, where 5 is the best mark and 1 is the worst one. I am quite content with the system, although I think it may be too general. Still, when we are doing tests, there is also a total score of points provided, so you actually know, how much of your test was correct. I think that percent grade system is still most precise.
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
28 Jan 10
Yes, the systems of 1-5 may be a bit broad and it has some good and bad to it. When it's just a one digit number you can see at a glance what score you are at and you just know if you are doing good or not. But if you want to know more then that's when the 1 to 5 system would not be as effective.
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
22 Jan 10
The letter grading system is the most familiar to me. And it is the one that I understand the best. The other system, it requires me to think about where I am more. With the letter system, I'm like "okay I have a B, so I need to do whatever to get that up to an A". The other systems, it causes me to do a bit more thought than I would like to do for something like grades.
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
24 Jan 10
I understand how it might be easier, how it just gives the overall grade without the person actually needing to take in the numbers. Such as, a B is good and an A is excellent, so you can tell at a glance what you need to improve.
@ziyadahinc212 (552)
• United States
22 Jan 10
Definitely the PERCENTAGE (%) for me. Why? B/c U can't go wrong when U know for a FACT what your GPA is exactly. With 'Letter Grades' it almost impossible to know if U have a solid 4.0 or [3.8-3.9] GPA. The ONLY pro with L/G is people can hide just REALLY DUMB THEY ARE WITH A "C".LOL
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
24 Jan 10
Yes, the percentage system does show the exact score while things like the letter grade wouldn't show the amount. You can just guess what your grade is, but you really don't know anything when you see an A or a B. And I guess also that having a letter grade can really hide what people really have as their grade.
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
27 Jan 10
Yes, but what about before college? Did you have a letter or a percentage grading system back then? And also, which type of system do you think works best? Do you have any preferences for any of the grading system?
@katisaurus (1038)
• Canada
22 Jan 10
I had the letter grade up until highschool and then we got into percentages. I preferred the percentage. For that exact reason that if you got an A+, you wouldn't know if that's a 99% or 100%.. But I think it depends what the grade is on. If you get an A+ on a REPORT CARD, then you don't really know unless you go through all your assignments for that course and see if you aced everything.. But if you got an A+ on one assignment, you can still look to see how you did with answers..
I'd still prefer the percentage system though, that way I don't have to add up my right and wrong answers.
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
22 Jan 10
It's true, the percentage grading system makes it easier because you can know your grade quickly, while for the letter grade you have to do some more work to figure out the exact score. Really, if everyone in the class got an A, unless you look at all the questions, you would never know who has a higher score.
@writer_girl (83)
• Canada
22 Jan 10
In middle school we had the lettered grading system. Which I guess was fine since I didn't pay much attention to my grades then.
Once I hit high school we had the percentage grading and I liked that much better because I knew exactly how I was doing. Like one year I was doing poor in math and then got my mid term report card and saw how bad it was so I pulled my grade up really quickly so I passed that term.
So I preferred the percentage grading. I hope when I have kids they have that all through school.
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
22 Jan 10
I agree with you because sometimes the letter grade is confusing, and you don't know exactly what you have. It's good how the percentage system showed you what you had, so then you were able to try for a higher grade.
Many schools are using this new system, so it is very likely that your future kids will have the number grade, too.
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
22 Jan 10
That's true, it is better because you can be happy about the grade when you see the exact number. With letters, you can get 2 B's on two different tests and you wouldn't know exactly how much better you did. And it would be very hard to figure it out when you have a lot of questions on the test. . .
@janeajozelle (197)
• Philippines
22 Jan 10
They are in percentage before usually i preschooler, elementary up to high school now the grading in college is in letter grade with equivalent percentage. I prefer the percentage they are only once while a letter grade they are grouped so you could not exactly know what your real grade is..
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
22 Jan 10
Yeah, the letter grades do not help much because they are too broad to show the score a person has. A percentage has 100 numbers to use in the score, and there can even be decimals and over-100% scores, so at times it can be much more useful than the letter grade.
@supersalu456 (45)
• Qatar
22 Jan 10
In the kindergarden and middle school it was letter grading for me and that time i knew that i was doing really bad by not studying and enjoying much it was very good (i thought)because we dont have to worry about anything (A+ means outstanding and so on)and it was always C for me and in our country it was remarked good so my parents did not tell anything after 4 standard i started to fail and just fail and got a dozen of scolding from parents,so it was then(my percentage was near 50%) but i had to struggle because in our family it is all about studies and we have to do it so i just had to struggle now(in 6th also the percentage was same and i got so many beatings even more)then in 7 th standard i knew it should be taken seriously and i did just that and i got a 91% now ,thats what iam saying grading system basically doesnot tell anything about the marks only the ten marks which will make you in that grade and on foolish remark,but percentage doesnot do it like that it will tell it exactly and make you very jealous of others mark and very competitive
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
22 Jan 10
I sort of understand what you're saying. . . You mean, with the percentage system people will get very competitive? Because of how exact it is? That might be true but it is sometimes better to know the exact score, and even with the letter grade people can get jealous over others.
@iharidh (308)
• Indonesia
22 Jan 10
We are using letter grade system in our advance education such as academy, university and college. But in lower grade of education, we are using core mark, not in letter, nor in percentage. So, I haven't been introduced yet to percentage grading system here.
However, I have ever attended school which has different grading system. The middle school I attended used 'phrase' grading system. I think it is quite similar to letter grading system, but the letter here was replaced by a phrase. Say, if I got 85 or above of overall score of a subject, so I got 'awesome'. Otherwise, if someone got 75, he got 'very good' and so on. Out of all, it was my favorite grading system after all.
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
23 Jan 10
The phrase grading system seems like an okay system, but then sometimes you wouldn't know the difference between some phrases. Like you wouldn't know whether 'awesome' or 'very good' or 'excellent' is the best one, out of all the phrases.
@faimei (127)
• Philippines
22 Jan 10
I experienced the two type of grading system... the letter grade during Preschool and some subjects in elementary while the percent grade during the elementary up to college.
I prefer the percent grade like what you said they show the exact score and that they definitely show you how it ended up in that grade when you compute all your exams and quizzes. I cannot think of anything that is a disadvantage of this grading system except that if you are failing... you really know what your score is...
The letter grade, i think is used for children. For me, in my younger years, I liked having the A+ because I certainly know it's the highest... it's a grading system that can be understood by little children. The disadvantage is that you don't know the exact grade and who is higher than who.
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
22 Jan 10
I understand what you mean. The percent grade gives people a better understanding of what they got, while the letter grades might be used to make things look nicer, for the little kids. But then again, there have been some higher schools, like colleges, that use letter grades. Of course, letter grades don't show the exact score, even if it is in a college. . .
@shuyin101 (206)
• Philippines
22 Jan 10
back in high school we got this averaging grading system (even in college) where in the value of the subject depends on it's units (overall value).
In High School the lowest grade that you can get is 70. The Passing grade is 75. Any grade that is in the line of 7 is considered poor, 80-85 as average, 86-89 as above average and 90+ is considered excellent. Grades are reflected in report card under those numbers (70-100) though I never saw / knew someone crossed the 97 grade. :D
Same here in college we got averaging but grades are reflected differently from High School. The lower the number the higher the value. Passing grade is 3 below. If you fail you get 5 automatically (there's no such thing as 3.25,4.5 etc). and 1 being the highest. I'd say 3.0-2.5 is considered bad (but not as bad as getting a line of 7 in HS since college is so difficult!). 2.25-2.0 is considered average to high average, 1.75+ is considered excellent! :D
btw I'm from Philippines so I never knew how high those grades are in american movies except that I know obviously that A is a pretty high grade. by the way is there such thing as S grade in america????
@merlinsorca (1118)
• United States
22 Jan 10
Those systems look very interesting. . . A 70 being the lowest? That could make it easier to know where you are without having so many other numbers.
I never heard of the letter S as a grade, I think there are only A, B, C, D, and F.