No wonder Youtube is Ban in China..Hope am wrong...

Philippines
February 6, 2010 7:41pm CST
Hello lotters, I thought they censor other parts of culture from other places that they don't want the Chinese people to harbor or share with. but some how the reason for the government to ban you-tube in china is somehow disturbing. It seems that there's still some degree of dictatorship in the Government when it's supposed to "People's Republic of CHINA" and not Government's Republic of China. My point is, if can they just handle the truth and tell the people and have a dialogue so that such terrible incident wouldn't repeat itself. rather than preventing people from china seeing it. Chinese who's living where youtube is allowed has SEEN it, so no more keeping it from the populous. Here, just to put an end to my rambling. Not a referral Link. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u7Mf9j8co70 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yyj-3S_ulvI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJBnHMpHGRY Have a nice day.
1 person likes this
7 responses
@kaylachan (69229)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
7 Feb 10
And I thought the U.S. was crupted o.o Of course I can't say I'm not suprised. Though why ban anything at all? People will find out eventually. At least that's the way I see it anyways. I'll have to watch those videos if I actually allow myself time to do so. I've been busy scraping by to make money wherever i could. Which looks promising I might actually be able to accumlate savings which would be a plus for me.
2 people like this
• Philippines
7 Feb 10
Hello Kaylachan, Well, every government has it's own taint in corruption but it's about the censorship of the truth but i guess some truths are too awful that if it's too much exposed then it would split the country into two just like what's happening in Iran. so many protesters.
@danitykane (3183)
• Philippines
7 Feb 10
hi LetranKnight25! what's up with them banning youtube? Another form of dictatorship, I guess. I feel sorry for their people who were given less opportunity that they don't deserve. The first video where that "guy" bravely faced the military tanks made me think how hard it was for them to fought 1989 dictatorship. Imagine that? He literally stopped 3 tanks? I wonder what happened to him after that? He was popularly known as "the tankman" on youtube, right?!. Do you have any idea what happened to him afterwards? Anyway, there are so many issues revolving China, the Media and it's freedom of speech. I was shocked to see the other day on a cable documentary about a girl who is an internet blogger and was arrested (house-arrest) because of her articles and videos raging about china's policy. It's crazy! Hope there will be no dictatorship such as these in the future and I hope that there will be huge a transition when it comes to politics in China. It's 2010 now and not 1989...oh... I'm sad.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
7 Feb 10
uhmmm okay! I got your point. And thanks for the enlightenment. and don't want to argue with your perspective and objective opinion. Like what you have said every country has their own laws to follow. So, it is not chinese fault to be treated such way because, it is their government's rules and whatever. And China is not alone in this youtube banning thing. Got it.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
7 Feb 10
Hello danity kane, Well, some people in the giving still living in the 80's where you can blocked this and that and just give reason that it's bad here and there and had to be cut down.but same question to the middle east, but worst, not only they banned youtube but not allowing foreigners too.anways, just an awareness i wanted to raise, but am not gonna raise anymore eyebrows
1 person likes this
• Philippines
7 Feb 10
and I can't help but to roll my eyes on that. haha! at least, I can roll my eyes and not being dictated not to do so. haha! It is plain in simple, law is law but freedom is not a privilege nor a choice. It is something that people should always have. And hella weird, my friend is a Chinese who happens to have a business here in Manila and he statically crazy to watch youtube every now and then, and the guy even have an account.lolz... (rolls-eyes again) He was a chinese-dude who happens to find youtube banning hella crazy. Can't blame him.
1 person likes this
@skysuccess (8858)
• Singapore
7 Feb 10
LetranKnight25, First of all, what is your point here when you brought this discussion up? Secondly, being blatantly aware that Youtube is banned in China, you referenced your discussion with Youtube video feeds? No offense here, you are not in anyway being fair or objective on your part and I feel you are just another individual inviting another culture or political bashing session! Since, you have not done much homework on your part to raise the issue here, then let me raise a few issues for you whilst you raise your awareness to another level (higher, of course). I do not think any government including your beloved Philippines for that matter would like to ban any media for no rhyme or reason and as a Foreign Ministry spokesman once quoted to the journalists that the internet "needs to be regulated by law in order to prevent the spread of harmful information and for national security." Prior before the ban, the Chinese government have already been clear from the start about their censorship policy. As an old adage once said: "When in China, do what the Chinese do" and I suppose any one who wants to conduct any business would have to observe the bylaws and customs of that country. I just do not see why the administrations in Youtube could not block these other materials when they can control other stated undesirable feeds from being uploaded in their servers. That which to me is just a matter of extra man hours to resolve the issue. And since, they cannot work and conform within the parameters - banning is just inevitable and begging. You mention about educating but I think you really forgot that Youtube needs to be educated too, as far as learning a thing or two about conforming to the laws of other countries. I feel that they have forgotten in their little cubicle head office in the States, they are actually running a global enterprise which need to be culture, custom and legal tolerant. Do you think China is the only country that banned Youtube? Well, let me enlighten you that this fourth most visited site in the world is being censored by other countries like Brazil, Indonesia, Iran, Morocco, Pakistan, Tunisia, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Thailand, and the United Arab Emirates. Also, YouTube has also been censored by individual institutions within the United States and United Kingdom. So, who do you think needs to be educated more Youtube or the countries that censored it? From what I see, you certainly lacked the homework here and this post just seems to be prejudiced on your part. No offense taken. Lastly, who are we to judge and/or tell a country on how to run theirs when we have enough clutters at our own backyard?!!
• Philippines
7 Feb 10
I understand your situation here perfectly. unfortunately, if our government starts banning sites like youtube it's gonna another PEOPLE POWER for sure. You have a point there too, but some how, the truth hurts for most of us. can you imagine that the media massacre here is also being sold in DVD's which is so cruel. I don't understand it. i don't see china falling apart simply because of this site? do you? it's not just education but maybe it must also considered respect with other people's culture.but some how i feel disturb when they don't see and not aware for what happened in that time. Well, i think i didn't pass the Homework if that's what i see now. but some how i wanted to raise this awareness. I am NOT telling that country how to run their country, it's how they are not going with the trends. i mean, there are also music videos and videos that are also banned in my country. Lastly, there's nothing wrong with sharing information. we had the same thing here in the Philippines, we call it the mendiola massacre, but we didn't forget it, we remember it, no government dare to keep it from us. just a thought. no culture or political bashing here, i think. Censorship, eh? looks like some Governments still want to HIDE something from their people even in this modern age. no offense taken too. am just gonna say this once... am so darn lucky it's not banned here So, was I wrong or what? you explain it in detail, thank you.
1 person likes this
• Singapore
7 Feb 10
LetranKnight25, In all fairness, I believe that Youtube has more problems at their end than anything from bureaucratic governments. If Youtube can be more particular and meticulous with their uploaded feeds, I am sure it will be widely accepted including censorship bodies of any governments. I mean look around I am sure that there are other video hosting sites are accessible all over the world including our countries. Then, we just have to ask the question just why is it so different for Youtube then, right? On the hindsight, if Youtube so much as allow terrorism sentimentalist feeds like Abu Sayaf or Reds into their sites, do you think they will not be ticked off or worst blocked by your country? So, likewise if they are going to thread over the lines of other governments then it will just be natural for them to react. I cannot really say much just how much longer other countries will be tolerant with Youtube especially when they do not seem to be tidying their shift. I hope they could do so, so that the affected countries will lift their censorship in due time. Take care and have a nice day.
• Singapore
7 Feb 10
P.S. Thanks for the BR, here.
@pengbubu (1011)
• China
7 Feb 10
I am a Chinese but I don't know why they forbide it. Maybe I think it's about tiblet. After forbiding youtube, the native media provider website goes very fast, like youku.com, toudo.com.
1 person likes this
• Singapore
7 Feb 10
pengbubu, Just to let you know, Youtube the fourth most visited site in the world is being censored/ inaccessible by other countries like Brazil, Indonesia, Iran, Morocco, Pakistan, Tunisia, Turkey,Saudi Arabia , Syria, Thailand, and the United Arab Emirates. It is also, being censored by individual institutions within the United States and United Kingdom. So, China is not alone in censoring Youtube. Have a nice day.
@machivado (528)
• Indonesia
7 Feb 10
Yes, I think the people in China has a little influence on their government's acts. But on the other hand, they DO have a lot of issues especially in online world.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
8 Feb 10
Hello machivano, that's because they are things that foreign governments are not ready to exposed of. most are not ready to know the truth and will do anything to keep it from being revealed. but if the people agrees then who am i to argue? they kept saying i love china then there's nothing to argue about no more.
1 person likes this
7 Feb 10
I am completely and utterly shocked about this, here in the UK anything like this would cause an immediate public backlash and the media would have a field day. There would be riots, protests and violence
1 person likes this
• Philippines
8 Feb 10
hello crazy, well, the good thing is that it's not banned on the entire country, or that would be outrage. if they can banned it on china, i guess it's not a loss at all.
1 person likes this
@hexeduser22 (7419)
• Philippines
7 Feb 10
Protecting the governments interest is a priority for this country. I'm just glad that mylot is not banned in their country because it does open a venue for new learning and democracy for people living in a communist country like China and North Korea
1 person likes this