Those curly bulbs are all right, but they take longer to light up
By suspenseful
@suspenseful (40193)
Canada
February 26, 2010 6:37pm CST
I am not the one for eco friendliness, I buy the bulbs because they last longer, I am scared of heights so do not have to climb on the chair that often to changed them, and they do not get hot (although my husband persuaded me to get a large package of warm white fluorescent bulbs and maybe they will produce just as much heat as the old incandescent bulbs.) but I noticed that it takes longer for them to turn on then the incandescent ones we used to use and we still use in enclosed fixtures such as those Swedish bulb covering types that are usually found in newly constructed houses.
Now I suppose if going into a dark room, you want the light on immediately and are those who believe in saving the planet any different? Do they not care if the few seconds longer to get the light to shine give time for the burglar to escape or something furry to hide?
8 people like this
16 responses
@joyceshookery (2057)
• United States
27 Feb 10
I am a loyal fan of the curly light bulbs. I've lived in this place since 2006, at which time I converted the whole home to them. The bulbs are still functioning! I'm like you when it comes to changing light bulbs. I end up calling on someone to do the bulb change for me. I'm happy about the switch.
The couple seconds hesitation for the light to arrive after flipping the switch is not a problem for me. I guess I've become used to it. Sure, a burglar could have a nanosecond advantage for escape -- but how often do you need the insta-light gratification? I'd suggest carrying a big flashlight with you, and hit the intruder over the head with it.
3 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
What I am mainly afraid of is a short in the wire. We had to rewire our basement and that is where the main problem is - because the former cheapskates who owned the place, decided to save money by using lamp wire. We also had to add extra switches, so we are a bit concern. All the rheotoric about they will save the planet and last longer will do no good is the reason they take longer is not because of the types of bulbs and that it happens to all curly light bulbs, but if it is that there will be a spark in the wire and when it comes on - there will be a large bang and flash. Oh and I did get a couple of duds.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
27 Feb 10
hi suspenseful they may take longer to heat up but they outlast the ordinary ones for a long time an do cut down on the electric bill
as we used them when we had our own apartment in all the light fixtures, but reallY I did not think they took that long to light up at least the ones we used did not, and we got them on sale too so they were inexpensive and just really cut down on our electric bill. anyway no burglar would get into our apartment cause I kept the only door to the apartment locked at all times, and had no pets either so nothing to scare me. lol lol lol
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
I wonder if it is that our wires are used to the regular incandescent system and that rather then the copper wires we use, we should have the houses rewired. And even though they last longer, sometimes you have to have the light on immediately and there is another thing. If the light takes a few seconds longer, it makes me wonder whether there is a short in the wire. So in those few seconds, I am waiting for the spark to fly.
1 person likes this
@Lindalinda (4111)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
I have not noticed that they take longer to light up. I actually don't like those curly bulbs, I have read that one should not read by their light. I don't know if it is true or not. I do, however, use them because of the cost of electricity. I live in a condo and our maintenance fees have gone up quite steeply because of electricity and water costs.
This past week I was at the National Home Show in Toronto. There was a presentation on L.E.D Lighting. Those bulbs produce cold light, you can get them in harsh daylight, natural light and soft light. The trouble is one bulb costs $ 49.00 right now. But the claim is that you save more than half of the cost of electricity. Is it a fact? I don't know.
It seems the big manufacturers of conventional light bulbs don't want this technology to spread. Again I don't know what is true and what is not. I know though that last Christmas Canadian Tire had an exchange whereby you could bring in your conventional Christmas lights and trade them in for L.E.D. lights at a special price. My son took advantage of this. He likes the L.E.D lights much better.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
2 Mar 10
I heard that those l.e.d lights are quite good.
and you are correct about the reading with the flurescent lights. I have one in my computer room, and my eyes are starting to blink. I would do most in the day time, but I am fighting a cold and losing so most of the time, I was lying down on the sofa.
We do not have that much to spend, and I do wonder if those L.E.D. bulbs work in enclosed spaces like the kitchen light with the fan, and the bathroom light that has a cover over it. For those two spots, I would be willing to spend that much if it lasts much longer than using the same amount of regular bulbs.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
Yes, but I had a couple of duds. Also we had trouble with the wiring in our house 0- had to change some and have no idea whether the rewiring was done all over. I know they used lamp wire in the basement before we put the good wire in. Another thing I wonder if the curly bulbs are not as effective if the house has copper wire. Of course that would mean rewiring most of America and using another type of wire, but if they are determined that we be eco friendly at any cost, I would not put it past them.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
2 Mar 10
The same with us, but supposing those fluorescent lights do not work well with copper and there is another type of wire that causes them to come on in an instant and not take a few seconds as it does now? Then we will get the same notice we got, "do not use plastic bags, bring your own, " and now in many stores, if you use plastic, you pay," then there is "we are getting rid of the incandescent bulbs." Who knows if they plan to do the same with copper wire and use some other type that costs more and don;t worry if there is no danger to using copper wire, they will invent some, just as they did with the incandescent bulbs. (I use both in my house.)
After all saving money is not the reason the eco guys want us to not use as much gas, and convert to wind power, or whatever. I did notice that since the eco guys came to my city, we would put out our recyclable papers and not get paid for it, whereas before we could take it down to a center and get some coins from them.
2 people like this
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
27 Feb 10
I don't like them. It doesn't bother me that they take longer to light completely but I hate the harsh white light they produce. I feel like I'm in an office somewhere instead of my cozy house. Last year I bought quite a few "old" lightbulbs in preparation for their being taken off the market. In some places in Europe you can't get the old style at all because they are illegal!
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
2 Mar 10
We got some of those warm curly lights. I hope they show what I really look like and not with a golden glow because when we had mostly incandescent lighting, I would go outside and almost faint with shock when I saw myself in a store mirror. Also in enclosed fixtures, you cannot use fluorescent light bulbs as they heat up too much.
Another thing is if there is a dud among them, with the incandescent light you did not lose much, but with these, you paid a bit of cash and it costs.
1 person likes this
@cyrus123 (6363)
• United States
27 Feb 10
I've heard that these bulbs do last longer but they are expensive. I can't use them in some of my light fixtures, especially the ones in the kitchen because they have ceiling fans with them. I'm sure they are worth it if you can afford them and if they will fit in your fixtures. Kathy.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
6 Mar 10
Here in Manitoba, they give you a discount. Trouble is we need to change the bulbs before the discounts happen so we are noted for bad timing. One thing I found out is that whereas they work in lamps where you touch the base and the light comes on gradually when you put them in the three way switch lamp, you only have one intensity of light. That is, if you turn the switch on once, it does not come on, if you turn the switch twice it does not come on, but only when you turn the switch on three times. Or maybe they have not invented a three way curly bulb yet.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
My husband put a curly light bulb in our ceiling fan kitchen light. Of course, I seldom turn it on and use the regular halogen light instead. I do wonder what will happen when that one wears out, because my husband did not write down what size and type of halogen ligtht it is and I ah mechanically and electronically disabled.
2 people like this
@Monkeyrose (2840)
• Canada
3 Mar 10
A lot of companies are on the bandwagon of saving the environment and electricity. I've seen a lot of places giving them out as promotions. BC Hydro gives you an online coupon if you buy them.
2 people like this
@danishcanadian (28953)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
I am legally blind, so if I can't find my way around in the dark, what is the point? My mother, sister, and brother-in-law all have lupus, and with my family history I need to watch out for it. I'm told that that kind of light is not good for people who have lupus, because of UV rays, or something like that, so I will never have those bulbs in my home. If they ever stop selling the old ones up here, Hubby and I are going to stock up so we never run out.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
See what I mean? You are almost completely blind and you need the light on right away. I have a husband who has als and if he wants something it is right away. There are people for whom those curly light bulbs are a disadvantage. There are long lasting incandescent light bulbs. In fact, before the curly bulbs came popular, we had one in our kitchen because frankly I am afraid of getting on a chair and taking down that white bulb thing.
I hope they do not get rid of the incandescent bulbs.
We have them in the bathroom and downstairs and besides you cannot put a cover over the curly bulbs.
They heat up too quicklyh.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
6 Apr 10
That long one our sons got when they bought a pool table. It still works after about three years. But then I have other lights in the basement, so do not have to put that one on unless I am looking for something specific.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
2 Mar 10
I used to use the long flourescent light down in the basement, but that was because our sons picked up some fixtures when they bought a pool table and that was included. I do not leave the lights on that long. I am sort of trying to save money.
@reinydawn (11643)
• United States
8 Jun 10
I am big on being eco friendly, so we've converted most of our bulbs to the curly florescent ones. It did take a while to get used to them not coming on as soon as you hit the switch, but now I hardly notice.
1 person likes this
@MrNiceGuy (4141)
• United States
27 Feb 10
They usually take a bit longer to get to full brightness but they should not take any longer to light... How would a bit dimmer light help a burglar escape?
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
Well a burgler is used to the dark. That is where he gets most of his loot. i do not go around in the middle of the night stealing stuff from houses, so I would be at a disadvantage. There is also "what if the reason it takes longer to light is because we got a dud" or "what if there is a short in the wire leading from the switch and flash!!"
1 person likes this
@Monkeyrose (2840)
• Canada
3 Mar 10
I really don't like those lights.
1. They have mecury inside which is highly toxic to people and the enivironment.
2. Most places do not have proper ways to dispose of the light bulbs when they are finished as they have mecury in them. So they end up in the dump poisoning the earth.
3. They are not very bright.
4. If you live in a Northern climate the warmth emitted from regualr light bulbs can actually suplement your heating bill and bringing that down. SO if you use the non-heat bulbs you will need to turn your heat up.
I have a solar lamp instead. I use candles. I often will use my cell phone as a flashlight at night time when making trips to the bathroom.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
7 Mar 10
I do not like them that much as it can only be used in some places. By the way, why were the ones who say that we need to use them, not know about the mercury? I wonder if these are the same who say that we are overpopulating the earth and this is the way to get rid of some of us?
(Speaking as a white person whose collective ancestors of our whole group had been decimated by the plague and other former disasters in Europe so we now longer produce the 10 to 12 children we used to do but are now common in other parts of the world.)
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
I often wonder if I got a dud - we did get a couple, or if it is normal for them to take a little longer. I would also hate it to be because there is a short in the wire. That has happened. We had to go downstairs and go all the way to look for the wire that was disconnected and straighten it out.
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
27 Feb 10
to be honest i too don't much bother about eco friendliness but yeah it is light on your monthly bills, it does take a little time to glow but it is very light on power consumption and is kinda brighter too if you buy a more powerful one, well i don't have problem if it takes a little more time to completely light up. by the way i don't like that orange yellowish glow of the incandescent bulbs plus they don't last as long as fluorescent bulbs.
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
What I am worried about is during the few seconds longer the light does not turn on,I wonder if I got a dud or if there is a short leading from the light switch to the light itself.
At least with the incandescent light bulbs, if they did not turn on immediately, I knew that something was wrong and we had to turn off the switch and then go to the fuse box and check to see the switch was turned on.
1 person likes this
@MrKennedy (1978)
•
27 Feb 10
I too have noticed that they take longer to light up, but other than that, the eco-bulbs are superior to the old-fashioned rounded bulbs in every other way.
They last longer, stay brighter for longer and help the environment
2 people like this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
27 Feb 10
Well you obviously have not lived in a house that was wired incorrectly. All the rheotoric will not do if the reason thee take longer is not because it is how they are designed, but there is something wrong. Besides why not make sure the wires leading to the light be compatible with the light? Most houses I know have copper wire, maybe they need fibre optics to turn on immediately. Why has not someone addressed that angle?
1 person likes this
@mtdewgurl74 (18151)
• United States
28 Feb 10
We haven't bought any of those bulbs yet but my hubby is wanting to buy them, because they supposed to save money and as you say last longer. I guess a few seconds shouldn't be to bad...unless your in a hurry to pee and can't find the toilet for a few seconds longer..or if something happens and you need a light that second. I think our wiring is bad and it needs checked because it blows bulbs like crazy in our kitchen and my computer room the most used rooms in the house. But just flipping the switch can blow them..so until we get that fixed we aren't going to get the expensive bulbs. I guess just thinking of the bills being cut by using them would be worth it some to have to wait those few extra seconds.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
2 Mar 10
Yes, guys do not know what us ladies do through. When you have to go, you have to go. But I know where everything is, now if they keep the toilet seat up instead of closing it, etc.
What I am worried about is the extra seconds the bulbs take to light a sign that there is a short in the wire or is it normal? I remember when we had the incandescent light and if the light did not come on, right that second, that meant we had to go down and check the breakers or the wire.
@jezzmay (1845)
• United States
28 Feb 10
I have the curly bulbs, they where in the
house when I moved in. I was told they
would save on the light bill. My rooms
are dim, the light is not good. I go on
and use them, to save, but I have the
regular bulbs in my lamps. This still
helps when, I need extra light.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
2 Mar 10
I use the regular bulbs in the bathroom and downstairs. We do have a curly bulb in our three way lamp, but that means we have to turn on the switch for it three times.