Who works the hardest,the one who stays home or the one who goes out to work?

@pandaeyes (2065)
March 8, 2010 8:45am CST
I well remember how exhausting it was to be at home with my kids from the time that they were born. There is not enough time in the day when your kids are very small. We must clean them up whenever they need changing,(possibly 6 X 10minutes),provide and feed food 3 times a day (3 X 60 minutes) play with them(3 X 30 minutes)make food for the adults (45 minutes) Clean the house (30 minutes) ,do the laundry (40 minutes) and go shopping (1 hour),bath the kids and put them to bed (1 hour). Every little need must be met and your own soon become second in importance. My husband used to come home and see the messy house and wonder what I had been up to all day while he was earning the money (and getting an hours lunch and 20 minutes tea breaks). I could see he was not in the house, not able to sit and do as he wanted and must follow orders all day but for me it was much harder work being home than it had ever been to go out and do a days work for someone else. So how is it in your home ? Who works the harder the one who is home with the kids, or the one who goes out to earn?
5 people like this
22 responses
@rosegardens (3034)
• United States
8 Mar 10
A farmer and his wife had been arguing about who's job was the most difficult. One day they decided to do each others job. Early that day, both woke up a little earlier even though they were still tired. They were excited because now they could prove to the other who had the most difficult job. Both were happy and went about doing their spouses work, confident the other would say that their job was hardest. He made breakfast, got the kids up, cleaned the house, cooked the meals etc. She went about feeding the animals and preparing the land for planting. After sunset and before the light was completely gone from the sky she went inside. Both of them looked a sight! Both disheveled and exhausted from the longest day they ever had. Their clothing was crooked, he had baby food in his hair and on his clothes and some other food. She looked as though she had been bathing with the pigs all day. Neither one was able to complete the job they had that day because it was too hard. They then began to argue: You have the hardest job! No, you have the more difficult job! until the wee hours of the morning............ The moral of the story: each works just as hard as the other. Wouldn't it be wonderful to be able to trade places with your husband for a day just so he could see what you go through?
3 people like this
@pandaeyes (2065)
8 Mar 10
Nice story. Yes it would have been lovely to swap especially as I have done his job before and I know it is no where near as hard as being home with babies. We sort of did at one point. I had a part time job for about 2 hours a day and he had to have the kids until I got home. They were usually beetroot red and fit to burst so it wasn't long before he decided that he couldn't manage and I gave up the job as soon as our debts were cleared.
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
8 Mar 10
Ah well! fortunately my kids are now grown up 19 and 21 so no worries there but I see a few men taking their kids to school these days,walking up the road with them and I suppose their wives are the ones who work outside the home.
• United States
8 Mar 10
so he does know what your job entails? Even though he only did it for a few hours, surely he must understand 2 hours does not equal a day. What can you do. Grin and bear it I suppose.
@icesmile (7160)
• Romania
8 Mar 10
Hi, good question, in one days i count in 20 years, as mother whenever I was to shopping, how many washed i dishes ,how many hundreds of kilograms of potatoes I cook ... and much more,is not a work difficult, but a job that never ends and never be recognized, no one knows how to work in a home, i will praise. At the same time, I worked outside too, in an office, so i have both kind of work experience.
2 people like this
@icesmile (7160)
• Romania
8 Mar 10
To understand better, I did both kinds of work at the same time, and home and office, and half of these 20 years I was single mom, so everything was working, I worked just me.
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
9 Mar 10
That has to be the hardest kind of work when you are a single mum. You must be a very strong minded person I think. I am lucky that my husband could go out and work and I was able to stay home for the kids.
@pandaeyes (2065)
8 Mar 10
You see both sides! I think you are right ,it is difficult to judge really. I think that those who work at home with their children do work much harder than the other partner realises. Once on TV there was a reality show where the couple swapped places for 2 weeks each and the one who didn't stay home was usually shocked at what hard work it really was.
2 people like this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
22 Mar 10
Well, I've worked outside the home and also been a stay-at-home mom. Both times, I've found it hard for me. When I was working outside the home, I was also expected to do everything that was needed inside the home. All the cooking, cleaning, taking care of kids..everything. And at that time, I felt I was able to relax atleast for an hour at the workplace. I mean the expectations at my workplace was not as much as that at home and I would get a break there...while at home the work was never ending and with little kids, you can't really ask them to wait..or say 'Later'. When I quit my job and stayed at home, I thought I'd get more time to relax...which I think I would have got if the kids were going to school. But we decided to homeschool..and that makes it more work than if I was working outside the home...and no breaks at all. And my little one is 3...so I think for a couple of years more, it will be tough for me. I used to work at a school and so we had fixed schedules for our work...which I had to do no matter what. But at home, I feel I can do things as per my convenience. So, either ways, I was/am working full time. I can't compare who works harder because I don't see what my husband does when he goes out. Earlier, he got to relax when he gets home...but now he also shares the homeschooling part..so he does handle that...though not the other physical aspects of being a parent.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
17 Apr 10
I'll have to agree on that one...the person who goes out of the home atleast gets a rest and a break. And the one at home is right there (in the workplace) ALL the time and there is no break. And the work is never ending. But it also depends on the people in the relationship. I know of couples who do share the burden even when the wife is the person staying at home. The husband understands how tired the wife gets...takes over when he can...or lets her have a good break once in a while. I know a few couples (of course, they are a minority) who does that on a daily basis.
@pandaeyes (2065)
16 Apr 10
I had much the same experience with the homeschooling. I did all the housework and most of the garden work. Hubby gets home quite late and so I would have all the food preparation and the children to taxi to clubs plus working on what we were going to be doing for lessons next day. I didn't work outside the home all the time I had kids except for 6 months when I was a door to door sales woman and that was cripplingly hard work not because of the physical aspect of walking around for hours but because I would come home and immediately be handed the two toddlers while hubby got his work clothes on and whisked away on his motorbike to work(he did shifts at the time) .It was a conveyor belt of things to do with no moment to stop and think. Therefore I do see it as the staying at home person who does the majority of the hard work . Some will say it is the out of house worker but I say a change is as good as a rest and that the one who can remove themselves from their workplace is at least getting a break in circumstance.
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
8 Mar 10
Bot my wife and I have jobs outside home. She has longer hours than I do although sometimes I have to do some work at home. Bot of us give a helping hand when it comes to house chores. I must admit that she does most of it but I do help as much as I can. I am always there to drive my son to private lessons, or scouts or you name it.
2 people like this
@pandaeyes (2065)
8 Mar 10
good on you for helping out too. I used to have to take our kids to all their activities as my husband was rarely home before they were in bed.
1 person likes this
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
8 Mar 10
It's hard to stay at home, isn't it? But there's no better job in the world! When I was married, my husband worked hard. He'd leave around 5am and sometimes not come home until 7pm. He would have lunch breaks, though, and was his own boss. I would say we worked equally hard but my day never ended. While he could come home, plop down on the couch and fall asleep in front of the TV, my day went on till long past the time everyone was in bed. You know what they say--man works from sun to sun but women's work is never done!
2 people like this
@natjohn20 (200)
• Philippines
8 Mar 10
For me the one who works the hardest is the one who goes out to work its because compare to working home, going out to work spends more time and effort behind it and the stresses and troubles that comes to your way when you go out also the danger behind behind it. Working at home has its benefits compare to working outside from the house but it doesn't mean you really work hard at home, no employer can assess you while you are at your home compare when you are at an office, your employer can really assess you whether your working hard if you are away from your home so for me for a person who works the hardest is the one who is going out to work. ^ ^
2 people like this
@pandaeyes (2065)
8 Mar 10
You take the journey to and from work into consideration too I think. I guess it depends how you have to get there. My husband rides to work by motorcycle and it is about 40 miles I think each way which is a long journey before even starting to work.
1 person likes this
• United States
11 Mar 10
Both jobs are very difficult however each one has it own set of difficulties. I thought that when I had my second child that I wanted to stay home and take care of them all day. It only took me three months to decide that I could not stay home with them full time, that put way too much pressure on me. Like you said when your partner comes home they are wondering what you did all day since the house is not clean. I felt pressured to get my oldest off to school come home do laundry, cook clean and take care of everything else before he got back home. At work I am not in the comforts of my own home, I cant take breaks when I want and I have to follow someone elses rules and I constantly think about everything that I have to get done when I get home and I am always thinking about the kids while I am away. So to me both jobs are equally hard. The perfect balance for me would be if I were able to work 4 hours a day and be home the other part of the day.
@pandaeyes (2065)
11 Mar 10
It helps if you can fit work in somehow. I did a door to do shopping catalogue delivery for a while when my kids were still preschool age. My husband had to have them for me while I did it though which was not ideal as he had no patience with them and I found that although I really enjoyed getting out of the house, meeting people and earning some money, I would come home to the aftermath of 2 little kids and the big bad wolf.
@urbandekay (18278)
9 Mar 10
Depends what work the person who works out does, hard physical graft? Hard graft which also requires a lot of thinking? Sitting on your backside in an office. all the best urban
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
9 Mar 10
Well yes it does up to a point. Although there is mental pressure too which can affect even the boss of the company. I remember one of the people who used to live 2 doors away would have her friends in for coffee on day a week. Her children and theirs played as the mothers chatted. Her husband came home in the evening and something obviously had not been done(I think it was gardening related) and he yelled at her for having the easy life and her coffee mornings. She was a very relaxed sort of character but I don't think she worked any less hard than any other person, she had just organised her playing with kids and going for a walk time ,into a time when she could have her friends in too. There was a little jealous going on in there I think.
@irishmist (3814)
• United States
9 Mar 10
Both jobs are equally hard. There are pros and cons to both. Each person is doing a hard job. One is home taking care and raising the children, making sure the home is running smoothly, the other is out making the money, and putting up with day to day demands from everybody, so is the caregiver at home.There is no happy medium. I feel both parties work very hard. And if you are a single parent, you have to do it all with no help at all.
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
9 Mar 10
That is just what I think . The person at work has an obligation in two ways, they must do as they are told, make an acceptable job of their task and are governed by times and rules. They have breaks which help them to keep healthy mentally and people with which to interact (mostly) but they are not their own master(unless of course they are the boss).Then they must bring home the wages to keep their family ticking over. The one at home must think first of the needs of the other people there, then of the person who is out and then of themselves. They also must follow rules but the rules are less directly laid out. They must also produce results that are acceptable both in their children's manners and health, the home and its upkeep and the food and clothes of everyone. Then there is the role of the spouse which both must fulfill assuming there is a spouse.
@ifa225 (14461)
• Indonesia
9 Apr 10
Hmm...everybody have their role to play, we can't say this one harder or that one harder. We all live in a hard world. Even kids have their own work hard just like, in the morning they go to school, then attending the course, doing some home works and so on. But if we do all with happy, i guess we never realize how hard the work that we had been done. Keep working...
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
16 Apr 10
You are right ,it definitely helps if we are happy. I remember at school when I changed to the new school,we all had new uniform and things and no one singled me out for ridicule for a whole term because I fitted right in,in every other way. Life flew by and I loved every moment ,but once the new things started to look old and I had to wear the holey plimsolls and frayed collars and carry a broken school bag, things became their usual hard work selves again. When I started work at 16, everyone was welcoming and friendly and I loved my job and would look forward to going every day,the difference was,no one was looking at my possessions and ridiculing them. So work outside the home for me, was like a fun thing.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
10 Mar 10
My husband and I have had this discussion often. He swears that he works the hardest by going out of the house and making money at his job. However, no matter how hard I try, I can't convince him that I work just as hard as he does, if not harder. You see, during the day I have not only my son who is now three years old, I also have my two nieces for several hours during the day who are three-years-old and one-year-old. I hardly ever get to stop. Granted, the little one does still take a nap, but the two older ones don't and then my daughter comes home from school and I have to help her with her homework. I would venture to say that it really is a toss-up for us.
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
10 Mar 10
Well you must be the manager at home with all those people to be responsible for! I think that would be terribly hard work. Especially the little ones who must be helped to do so much. Really I think the hardest part of parenthood is the bit where the kids need so much hands on help and you are managing with 3 of them. My husband was a bit like that when mine were small. He would suggest silly things like us going out on the motorbike and I would say yes we can balance the kids on the handlebars(I got quite sarcastic). Our garden was a complete tip for years because he couldn't understand why I didn't just go and sort it out. He had been at work already and had come home to relax obviously. Fortunately ,we did get past that trying time and he is a much better dad these days. He does work hard but so did I back then.
@1anurag1 (3576)
• India
9 Mar 10
I think both. atleast you know every time how to handle a child and a child will always be a child. he will not do politics and try to harm you. but outside when you go you will encounter different people with different thoughts and policies which can affect also
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
9 Mar 10
Yes both must interact with others. I think both will have strategies that they have learned, to make their task easier and sometimes I think that when one party sees the other party managing things smoothly, they imagine that means that that person, has the easier task. For example I would make my kids meal at the same time as our own and then plate it up for next day so that I could sit and eat a hot meal in the evening without having to be the mummy all through the meal. That probably looked quite easy to achieve and it is obvious when I think about it now but at the time it had taken me about a year to work out that I could do that and before hand I had struggled to have my meal and feed two little children and keep my calm. My husband when asked to mow the lawn would haul out the mower and remove the grass box and just push it up and down for an hour. It would take me 2 hours because I never thought of taking off the grass box (which needs emptying about every 5 minutes and is heavy).To me it always seemed he could get laborious jobs done quicker because he was stronger and to him it seemed I could deal with the home and kiddies because I was genetically adapted for the mental pressures.
@madteaparty (2748)
• Japan
9 Mar 10
I think the one who works the hardest are the ones who live by themselves like me. We have to work, do the shopping, clean, take care of bills, of the good state of the home, etc. To split the work in 2 can make it be hard in equal ways in the case of a household with kids, at least from my point of view.
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
9 Mar 10
You are right there. Single parents have such an uphill job to do. Also anyone trying to pay a mortgage on one wage is a hard grafter. We had a mortgage but had saved like mad before we got married. It was well worth it . I don't think we could have had our kids as soon if we hadn't had a low mortgage. My sister in law and her husband both worked and had kids . One did a night shift and the other a day job and they were hardly ever in the house together. They divorced a few years back,I think because it is such an unrealistic way to live as a family but some do make that scenario work out.
11 Mar 10
Hi! It would perhaps depend on what kind of job the works outside the house and how many kids are left at home (smiles). But generally speaking,I would say that those working outside works harder compared to the one left at home with the household chores.My reason is that if you're left at home,you could have your own way on doing chores and nobody would be telling you to do something.You're the boss so to say and you don't have to be in contact with people having different kind of personality.It would only be you and the chores.Whereas if you are working at the office or the field,you have to deal more with many people and of course adjust to them.There are also deadlines which you have to catch up and boss telling you to do things.So if I were to have a choice,I would like to be in control of the house.
1 person likes this
8 Mar 10
I always felt that being a stay at home mum was like painting the Forth Bridge - neverending. For the second I got up int he morning to the moment my head hit the pillow I seemed to be on the go and at everyone's beck and call.
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
9 Mar 10
That is how I felt too. My husband would be incredulous if I said I was exhausted. Eventually I did make a decision and 'took' Saturday back for myself by putting on my coat and taking a flask and sandwich and going out all morning. Previously he had organised his hobbies on the weekend but I of course had to have the children so he could do it. Hehe something snapped and he learned a valuable lesson in fairness once he had had them for a few times.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
8 Mar 10
oh hi pandaeyes the one who is at home with the kids, the house, the jobs, the kids, the house, the meals the never ending saga of the life of the housewife.I have been both, and working as a nurses aide in a hospital bathing patients, backrubs, taking vitals, running errands for the nurse, i was busy but I had fifteen minute coffee breaks and a half hour lunch break was not nearly as tiring as a day at home taking care on my two children,the meals, the never ending household chores and no breaks, and meals were short and mostly about the family again. No a housewife doesn't work on an eight hour shift like I did at the hospital, we are on call 24/7 every day ,
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
8 Mar 10
It certainly is a hard slog. I used t say to hubby,will you do their bath or the story and he would look at me incredulously and say he had been at work all day,go and sit down and watch TV while I made dinner. It was so frustrating. As the poster above said, 2 hours is not the same as all day and he just never did understand how long drawn out the day is when you don't even have the break of commuting to change the scene or monotony.
• United States
9 Mar 10
I worked full time, plus for many years, as a nurse. I loved it, and was very rewarded by it. Now I only work outside the home, one day a week, and homeschool, and am a housewife the rest of the time. My husband's job is stressful, and keeps him busy, but when he comes home his day is done. My day begins at six AM and ends at 9 PM. So I guess my day is longer, but I don't know if I would say it is harder. I am in the comfort of my own home. I wear what I want. I do what I want, when I want. I take no orders from others, and there is no one to argue with. Sounds pretty good to me.
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
9 Mar 10
That's true there are some positives about both scenarios. I loved my job and the people I worked with but the kids were a priority for me too. We home-schooled and then the kids went back to high school for the last two years to get their exams for university access. We could have done that from home too but they wanted the security of knowing where the exams would be and when. Also I wasn't really confident about being able to be supportive enough in the subjects at that level.
@kaylachan (69370)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
8 Mar 10
For me I would have to say that it seems like more things get done out of the home then in the home. Of course it depends on the job too. If you sit in an office all day probably it would seem more work working at home trying to keep up, then say if you worked at a fast food restruant when you don't have a "break". But if people worked with each other rather then against, then the "other's person's work" wouldn't seem so bad.
1 person likes this
@pandaeyes (2065)
9 Mar 10
yes I agree with that. It is much easier to do things if there is cooperation all round. I found a lot of the difficulties with being home were mental. I don't mean madness but that it was very stressful being constantly demanded of. Never having a moment to ones self and having very little adult conversation. I used to go for a walk with my kids nearly every day when they were little because it meant leaving the home for a while and seeing and hearing different things and people.
8 Mar 10
I've done both, stayed at home to look after the children until they started school and then worked part-time while they were still young and now work full-time as they're old enough to look after themselves for a short while. I've worked really hard in all three scenarios but I can honestly say that working full-time is the hardest - because when I come home I have to start working all over again until ten for eleven o'clock in the evening. Then I'm up again at six, getting things ready for the morning rush. At least when the children were small, they were in bed fairly early and I could relax for a couple of hours in the evening. Now there always seems to be something that needs doing and I get stressed not only with the hard work but worrying about what I haven't managed to get round to. I can't wait for retirement!
@pandaeyes (2065)
9 Mar 10
You sound like you are a very hard worker! I was going to work at home when the kids were born but I soon discovered there weren't enough hours in the day. I think it may have worked out as a way to become depressed too if I had done so. I am just organising some work for at home now and my kids are grown. I have had the last 3 years really where a job would have been possible but finding something that I like and can do has proved difficult. Before that we home schooled and so I had to be available to supervise and teach and drive but it was nowhere near as hard as those two babies and toddlers had been.
@grkelly (1206)
• Malta
8 Mar 10
I totally agree with you, since i stopped working and became a fulltime housewife and mum I must say that it entails more than a full time job. We do not just work 8hours a day, but even during the night when kids wake up! It is a fullfilling job but I would love it if I was helped a bit. After coming back from a day's work husbands usually complain they are tired but they do not consider that we practically never stop. In my situation I do not get much of a helping hand. Having said that I have learnt that I have to create some time for myself, some time on the internet every day is a great rest for me.
@pandaeyes (2065)
9 Mar 10
The internet certainly is a useful tool for some outside interaction. We had the computers way back but no internet until 1997 when the kids were a bit bigger. I liked to go out into the garden as it meant we would see our neighbours and they chatted to me and the kids. We often visited next door with the very old lady who loved the kids. My husband was really not a man to be a baby or toddlers daddy but he is a very good father to them now they are much older, he seems to get on with older teens . His own mother gave up a career and brought up 5 kids while her husband (same career) worked all his life. He was equally non hands on with the small children but was quite good at being there at weekends which must have helped.