Who will be the next American Idol? A female or one of the Guys?

I'm with you I believe it will be a female and it will either be Crystal or Sioblan. I believe the girls have more talent this year. There are only three guys Mike, Aaron and Casey to me that have really good talent. I thought that Andrew Garcia should have left already because he hasn't been as good as he was on Hollywood week when he did Paula's song "Staight up."

Seems like there's a higher chance that a guy (again) will win season 9 of American Idol. As of the moment, only 2 girls are on the top 6. Although the front runner right now, based on judges comments, is a girl (Crystal), another guy (Lee) is not very far behind and has a high chance of winning too. I, personally, am rooting for Lee. He has an amazing voice.

I am 50-50 on that. I guess it is because almost all of them have not been consistent since the auditions. I also think this season's contestants are less talented than the previous seasons. My favorite contestant would be Michael and Katie. I don't really like the others.

I am a fan of Siobahn- I have a feeling she'll end up in the top 5 if not the top 2. Crystal is pretty talented but don't think America will vote her to the end of the competition. As for the guys, I don't really know. I like Andy Garcia but he certainly lost his "spark" so to speak in the past cople weeks.

i have no idea. i still have any favourite this season and its getting tough week after week. good luck for all contestents and have a wonderful day

I want a girl to win because the girls are really good and because the one who i want to win is a really good singer because the one i want to win is Sioban because she is really good because her range is very high and because when she chooses the clothes she is going to wear she is very very appropriate and isn't bad.

She isn't my favorite, but I think Crystal Bowersax will win. I really like Siobhan Magnus the most of the remaining contestants. I liked Didi's version of Rhiannon the other week. And I don't want to be mean, but DiDi doesn't really seem to have the personality one would associate with the winner of American Idol. I think Crystal will win, but I hope Siobhan does. If not her, then the sweet, lovable Michael Lynche. That's the big guy's name, right?

It is tough this year. I think it is anyone's year. Right now it all depends on who has the most friends. I see Siobhan having tons of friends! She and Didi are on the tops of my list. I really am not all that impressed with Crystal. That's just a personal thing though. Lacey was on the top of my list until last week and while it was sad to see her go; she needs more time to work on her voice. It sounds the same very time. I'm not at all shocked that Tim or Paige are still in it. Tim has improved and shown that he isn't just going to give up. Paige is a really good singer; but she was sick last week. Even Simon said that she sang very well considering she was sick. Out of the guys, I'm giving Andrew one more shot. I think no matter what the out come he will go and make an album. Michael is good. Not really liking Lee. Mostly because to me he sounds too much like artists we already know. Casey will get votes because he is kinda hot. Though he doesn't really look comfortable on stage. Especially during group singing! Katie is not ready personally; but has a great voice. Aaron, while good I don't think is ready to be an American Idol. I think the top two girls would be Siobhan and Didi. But I think it will be Siobhan and Crystal. My top two guys are Andrew and Michael; but I think it will be Lee and Michael. Just my two cents! Sandy

Its a very high chance that a girl will win this season. I can't tell who will win but from what I see its gonna be a tough fight between Crystal and Siobhan as for now, but as the competition gets tougher, you can expect the unexpected, such as dark horses might just emerge or maybe shockers might just happens. If there gonna be dark horses, i think it could be Katie Steven and even Didi Benami. Katie actually have good vocal skill plus the quality of an idol and Didi has got quite a huge fan base plus she too have an amazing vocal which can really make her shine at her very best. So I wouldn't be surprise if anyone of these two girls emerge as dark horses and give Crystal and Siobhan a run for their money.