gather is a waste of time
By snoopyfan
@snoopyfan (1312)
United States
March 22, 2010 7:57pm CST
Hey lotters a few weeks ago I signed on to Gather just to check it out. It claims to be a lot like My Lot. Have discussions and you get paid. I have responded to people and so far I have only had 1 point! I still have no idea how many points you need to get a pay out. A lot of discussions are really silly. I am not joking these are just some of the topics. How Many Resturants Can You Name? How Many Schools Can You Name? What? Then they have one person start 4 or 5 of the same topics. One guy started four different discussions about Sandra Bullock and Jesse James and their split. WHO CARES? I enjoy being on here so much more and I actually can see that I am making money each time I am on here. I am thinking about closing my Gather account since I doubt I will be back on there.
I want to thank all of you for your great discussions, the great debates we get into when we don't agree, and even when we have fun questions they really are fun. Just wanted to let people know stay away from this site a waste of time. My Lot is way better I even told one person on there and they said they were going to check My Lot out. I bet once they come over here they won't be on Gather anymore either.
Peace & God Bless To All The Lotters Here!
4 people like this
22 responses
@LilyoftheThorns (12918)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Gather used to be better. They just recently changed how you earn with them. It USED to be that you earned by being active (like on here). If you commented, rated, talked, posted...you would earn. NOW they've changed it so that people have to comment and rate your stuff for you to earn. Which SUCKS.
@LilyoftheThorns (12918)
• United States
23 Mar 10
I haven't even noticed they used my real name! LOL I thought I had the same username there as I do here
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
thanks for telling me that Lily for sure now I am going to cancel the account and stay here. Do you like the fact they use your real name on there? Sorry I like it here where I can pick a name and then later when I am comfortable with friends than I don't mind saying my real name or sharing a lot of personal info.
1 person likes this
@timhinyy (1653)
• United States
23 Mar 10
well the main thing that bothers me about gather is how you earn is confusing I think all i have is 25 points or something like that and its not like i never did anything on there.
I have put comments on there quite a few times and my points barely move whether it is a short comment or a long one so i have no idea what they want there.
So with the frustration of not knowing how you get the points to add up it makes me like you not want to be on there much as with this site here you can see how much you have and how it goes up each day and i much prefer it be money instead of points it is just so much less confusing that way.
At least when you are on here the discussions are usually a lot more meaningful and not as silly as on there as you mentioned one time there was one about how many words can you make with a certain set of letters.
At least here you can see your earnings add up and you know how much time you have put into it and what you think you should get out of it and on there it just doesn't make sense of how you get paid and for what and even though they have decent prizes.
I just don't know how to get the points built up or what i am supposed to do to get the points to add up so i can get one of the decent prizes and with the points i just do know where I am on there or what I am doing wrong when I am not earning many.
1 person likes this
@AmbiePam (94101)
• United States
23 Mar 10
I have made 50 bucks there. However, in the same amount of time I spent on Gather, I surely doubled that at mylot. I also went four days once at Gather with NO points. I responded, posted, did everything I could. And those stupid post numbers didn't go up.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
When I first started on here I wasn't that active but yes I always saw what I earned. And yes it is very confusing I even read gather faq and had more questions than answers. And the people aren't that helpful as they are on here. I had people request to be my friend odd thing was I didn't even start anything yet and I had three friend requests. I asked one person just that how do you earn points and how things worked on here in a PM. They responded by telling me about some site they are on and even referred me to a survey site I already joined without asking if they could refer me. I like some privacy and respect. Is that to much to ask.
If I were you Tim I would forget the 25 points you have probably already doubled or tripled that amount here.
1 person likes this
@littlefranciscan (18327)
• United States
23 Mar 10
I too found that you don't get too far with Gather..I think especially
now that the gloss of being new has passed.. I am glad that mylot still
pays and much better then Gather.
1 person likes this
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
I thought it was going to be like this site the way they make it sound. I was just going to bounce back and forth between the two. But My Lot is a billion times better one of the few on-line sites that delivers what it promises. I hope My Lot never gets like that.
@zed_k4 (17589)
• Singapore
23 Mar 10
I read some bad stuffs about this site before.. but then again, I didn't really join because it's not a paying site for international members. But I don't mind trying, until I read some bad reviews about it. But there are also those whom enjoy this site much, but I wonder if they are still involved..
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Yes I know there are some people who like it. I checked today and now I have 2 points. I haven't had a lot of people on here tell me good things though. Still hearing more bad than good. Better to stay on here.
1 person likes this
@yugasini (12893)
• Secunderabad, India
23 Mar 10
hi snoopyfan,
first let me know what is gather and you have written closing your gather account,till now i have not hear this words in mylot ,i am in the mylot more than one year,and i have not understand your full posting,let me know more about the thing,have a nice day
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Gather.com is set up the same on here. They say like My Lot get paid for having discussions. To be honest I still can't figure out how to earn points or how I even got the one point on there. People start discussions on there and you can respond to them. If you want to look at it go ahead I just wouldn't recommend joining it. You don't seem to earn anything or it takes a long time to do it. A lotter on here said it took him 7 months just to earn $75.00 on Gather. Now that I have been active on here I am earning and fill I could get a payout every month. I don't think if I was active on there I would earn much. I signed up two weeks ago and am losing interest of even going on there. There are a
few other things on there that make me uncomfortable with the way it is set up. It is a site to pay for discussions and when I responded I didn't get any credit for any of my comments.
My Lot you always get some kind of credit even if you are here for a few minutes or a few hours. It is worth it being here having fun and earning a little extra money on the way.
@yugasini (12893)
• Secunderabad, India
23 Mar 10
hi the lamb lied down and snoopy fan,
thanks both of you for responding immediately,i appreciate your interest in giving responses,that is great in mylot,so i love mylot,my lot is accessible to me,i could not accessible to other social network sites till now,it is very convenient,i have not participated 8 months in mylot due to lack of knowledge how to participate in it,have a nice day both of you
@purplealabaster (22091)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Snoopyfan, you said that it took your friend seven months to make $75.00 on Gather, and you said it like it was a bad thing. Actually, if you think about it, though, that is about what you would make on myLot in seven months, too, if you just make a little over minimum payout each month, since minimum payout here is $10.00. That is neither an endorsement for Gather nor a negative statement about myLot, but I was just trying to compare the payout, and it seems that they are about the same. I think that having a minimum of $10.00 and allowing payout each month makes it seem like we are making more money here on myLot, though.
@purplealabaster (22091)
• United States
23 Mar 10
First, with the kinds of "discussions" that people have described on Gather, it makes a lot more sense why some people come here to myLot and think that they can get away with some of the things that they call discussions on this site. I guess they figure that if they can earn for that kind of thing on other sites, then they should be able to do the same thing here, which obviously does not work.
Second, I know somebody that has been active on Gather for a while. She said that she used to be able to earn between $50 and $150 per month depending upon how active she was on there. Now, she said that it takes her two months to make $50, which is obviously a significant drop in earnings for her. I imagine that is still better than the average person on myLot makes in two months, but I am not sure that most people earned that much on Gather each month, either.
Third, the thing that I like best about myLot is that I earn for what I do, so I do not have to rely on anyone else to earn money. From what I understand about Gather, however, you earn when other people read and rate your discussions, which means that I have to rely on other people for my earnings instead of being able to earn from what I do. Since I can only control how active I am and what I do, I definitely think that the way that myLot calculates earnings is much better.
@purplealabaster (22091)
• United States
24 Mar 10
Actually, here your rating does factor into how much you earn, but it is only a part of the equation (and no, we do not know how big a part it is). If you have a higher rating, then you will earn more than if you have a lower rating. However, I do not think that it makes a huge difference, especially since we only earn pennies each day anyway. The biggest factor for your earnings on myLot is your activity and the quality of your discussions and responses. You are in control.
If I understand it correctly, on Gather, you earn for the amount of views that your discussions and pictures get. If you have a lot of people that view your work, then you will earn more than someone that might be more active but does not receive as many views. Therefore, you do not really have control over your earnings.
That is why I would not choose Gather over myLot. I like to be in control of my earning potential. If I am very active on here, then I will earn. If I was to be very active on Gather, then I would not necessarily earn. That does not seem right to me.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Thanks for listing another reason not to try gather. It doesn't seem right that to earn you have to rely on how many responses you get and your rating. I am so glad they don't do that here not a good idea.
1 person likes this
@AmbiePam (94101)
• United States
23 Mar 10
I told you I liked mylot better! lol It does take a long time to earn points over there. I first joined in 2007 and didn't come back until early 2009. I joined to give a mylot member a referral. There is a Gather member that is on my friend list over there, and she was active in mylot two years before she joined Mylot (I did not know this until late in my "Gathersom"). Now she only does Gather, and says she much prefers it to mylot. She says she has earned twice as much there as she did here. Which could be true. But every time I get a stupid discussion about naming all the C words you can....Good grief, how desperate are they for points?
A lot of people also like that they can ask for referrals from other people. And they certainly can say more mean things over there than here. I mean a lot of people think they see dirty on mylot - who can Gather get worse! There are many wonderful, sweet people on Gather. But I'll choose mylot over gather any day of the week.
@AmbiePam (94101)
• United States
23 Mar 10
One that gets me is a lady who posts 100 pictures of one event, and 40 of them are frame by frame, so they are extremely similar. She is one of the ones who also posts name words that start with 'c'. And when she doesn't get comments on her pictures...she really gets mad. She posts about how she guesses her friends have ignored her.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Yes you did try and warn me. I wonder how many discussions or silly questions this person has to post to get points. It is funny how the same person starts 4 discussions on the same thing and you can see they are doing it in minutes. This one guy had 4 discussions about Brady Quinn being traded to The Denver Broncos. He just changes one or two words in the title like no one is going to notice it is the same thing. And half the time there aren't a lot of people who respond seems they are spending more time thinking of meaningless questions than something interesting.
Yes I have also noticed how mean some of the people are over here. I am staying here on the Light Side Of The Force.
Have a great day!
@richiem (3644)
• Philippines
23 Mar 10
I am a member of Gather before I am a member of mylot.
The reason I left Gather is because they don't pay international members.
The discussions you are talking about are games (like How Many Restaurants Can You Name?) they created so you will comment on their discussions, which means more points for them.
Some of the games there are great like one of them started a poetry contest with winners every week or month.
It is also fun there but they don't pay me so I stayed here in mylot.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Those games are started by the same person I guess that is how they are earning points. I just like it here where you can discuss and both earn and not just help one person earn money. What is the point in helping other people earn money and you get nothing. I am sure you already developed friendships on there so it is more enjoyable for you. I am glad I found My Lot.
@lifeafterdeath09 (2043)
• United States
23 Mar 10
i really agree. gather really is a big waste of time. i shouldnt have even signed up for it. mylot is way better.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
I regretted signing up a few days after I did it. One of my big plans today is closing that account. I don't want to leave it open since I know I won't be back. Glad to see you here.
@machivado (528)
• Indonesia
23 Mar 10
I have joined Gather as well and I believe that site is not a scam but it is really hard to earn point there. You have to work really hard for cents there but the prizes are great though...I agree that MyLot is a lot better than that in many ways.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
not a scam but very misleading if you the way the present themselves and yes I agree it seems hard to earn any points. If you are earning on there congrats on all of your hard work. I just have a bigger list of cons than pros for that site. Doesn't work for me at all. Thanks for sharing and have a great day.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Yes I am even getting more responses from people who have had similiar experiences. I now have 2 points on there. I know I will be spending more of my time here. I doubt I will be there at much or if at all. I work on other things as well such as on-line surveys and mystery shopping. Only so much time in a day to get stuff done. My Lot is # 1 in my book.
@Mysterykt (10)
• China
23 Mar 10
I am a new Myloter.My English is so poor and I want some help.So I search websites from the Internet and I found this.I can say I am a totally fresher here.I want someone to discuss anything in English,and if you don't mind.Please pick up some mistakes in my words and have more talks.Thanks
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Welcome to My Lot. I hope it will help you with English and I am sure in time you will be great in it. I am not always a great speller myself and English is my only language. It is okay if the lotters can figure out my bad spelling they can figure out anyone's. I hope you have a lot of success here people are very nice and always willing to help. Looking forward to hearing from you.
Happy Lotting.
@Mysterykt (10)
• China
24 Mar 10
So sweetie you are~!I will come here more frequent.I have to say this is really a great website for a English learner.Now I spend most of my free time on learning English.Reciting words,watching soaps and come here to scan some topics I interested in etc.But I have so much subjects to learn and I can't take of too much time here.Oh,it's late and I have to go to sleep.However,thank you so in deep for you have made me have more confident.
@abdul12345 (2)
• Pakistan
23 Mar 10
My lot is a perfect place for great discussions and debates.
I have recently started there and I hope I will earn there really.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Welcome to My Lot I have been here for going on 6 months now. I highly recommend this site and hope you have as much fun here as I have. You are not going to get rich but stay active and you can earn some extra money. As you can see there are many topics and a lot of things to do here. Good luck to you and Happy Lotting.
@rhodzptc (1317)
• Philippines
3 Jul 10
Actually some topic are really non-sense same thing happens in other paying social network like expertinn, paymesocial, frenszone, and kalutusan because of this some kind of stupid members who doesn't have a good idea on creating a quality questions or topic. They only want to earn but they didn't know that they are just ruining the sites. Admin and mods cannot clean all those nonsense topic they need help and feedbacks from their members but since no one doesn't care about it and every one is after with the earnings the site itself just turn in to nothing but a waste of time.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
7 Jul 10
Yeah I don't go on their much and right now my internet at home is down again. So it is very hard for me to do anything online. I have to use the computer in the library and that is the few minutes I have after getting off work. Which is why I haven't been on My Lot in awhile. Hope to be back on here soon once our landlord gets his act together.
Thanks for your response. Peace
@Thoroughrob (11742)
• United States
23 Mar 10
I do both sites. I use that site more to get links to coupons and free items. Their new way of doing the points has made mine stay low, but I just do posts that go to the groups that I like. I like mylot for the conversations.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
If it works for you and you can be successful on both more power to you and congrats. I can't even figure out how to start a discussion it is like you have to paste and cut and all of this stuff. Here type and hit enter. It just doesn't work for me. Good luck to you on both sites.
@thesaiyanprince (542)
• India
23 Mar 10
@snoopyfan.. may it should have been the other way around..
when you were on gather and if you had come to mylot.. you'd have found.. mylot to be the best.. but from the best site you cannot go to a lower a grade site.. i can understand it..
happy mylotting..
i barely can imagine a site as good as mylot..
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
I agree you can not go from the best (my lot) to the worst (gather). It sure was a very negative experience that is for sure. I am glad it didn't take me long to figure that out.
@coffeegurl (1467)
• United States
23 Mar 10
i only did one discussion and the person responded well a long paragraph and funny story about Trent lot grabbing her butt during an event she catered lol. But, yeah, i got easily disillusioned over there. I prefer mylot a lot more.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
It sure is misleading over there. I had a hard time just finding a discussion to respond to. Here I keep finding more and more even when I am really tired I will be this is my last one of the night. Get ready to sign out for the day and suddenly there is a new discussion I got to put my two cents in. My Lot is the way to go.
@ybong007 (6643)
• Philippines
23 Mar 10
I subscribed to the site but like i just don't like it there. Mylot is something else. I tried posting to a few discussions there and i get responded to but i really can't get myself to go back to the site and do more. On the other hand, its different from mylot. I want to go visit other sites but nothing compares. Mylot has become a habit i guess.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
Right you get very hooked on here. After I check my email accounts I come over here. Now I have the responses sent to my email so I can respond quicker. I am here everyday seeing what people have to say and respond to great discussions. It is so much fun here and the people are awesome.
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
I would not recommend Gather to anyone. Stay here where you can earn but also meet nice people and have thoughtful discussions. There is a lot more to do here and yes the guidelines on here are easy to understand and follow. Glad to help you out that is why I posted this. If I come across sites that are successful or not I like to pass along the info and let people know. It will save them time as well in the long run. At least it didn't cost anything to join.
@chipesterkhan (2925)
• Philippines
23 Mar 10
i've been inviting lotsa people to mylot and so far the response has been great!
thank you mylot!
@snoopyfan (1312)
• United States
23 Mar 10
I have been telling people about My Lot as well normally I don't tell a lot of people some of the things I work on-line. Just don't want them to say you aren't going to get anything from that. I am sure the more people you invite they will have a great time and invite more of their friends. Keep up the good work.