a 7 year old Russian boy, sent back alone by his adoptive US mother!
By ronaldinu
@ronaldinu (12422)
Malta
April 9, 2010 6:27am CST
I could not believe this story! The mother sent back the child to Russia with a letter claiming that the Russian agencies have lied to her. The mother said that the adoptive agency (Russian authorities) has lied to her and that the boy has behavioural problems. It seems that most adopted children might have similar problems. A colleague of mine who adopted a girl from this country experienced similar problems.
[i]Russia reacted with horror today over the heartbreaking story of a seven-year-old Siberian boy adopted by an American family who was sent back to Moscow alone - because his U.S. mother didn't want him any more.
Little Artem Saveliev was last year taken from a grim orphanage and given a new life in Tennessee last year.
But his adoptive mother Torry-Ann Hansen, a 26-year-old nurse, yesterday put him on a ten-hour flight as an unaccompanied minor with a note 'to whom it may concern' saying: 'I no longer wish to parent this child'.[/i]
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/worldnews/article-1264744/American-sends-adopted-Russian-boy-behavioural-problems.html#ixzz0kbJgEehj
Do you approve with the US adoptive mother's behaviour? What would you do if you were in her shoes?
17 people like this
46 responses
@kprofgames (3091)
• United States
9 Apr 10
I think there is more to this story then what was in the article. Weather that be this woman was completely unprepared for an adjustment period or her expectations were just out there. The statement of the boy that the 'grandmother shouted at him' bugs me too.
I think this woman is dispicable. I know there are children that are adopted from other countries and it doesn't work out; however, to send this poor child alone on a plane and then type a note? A NOTE? Idon't know who this woman thinks she is that a NOTE would cure everything. To send a child on a plane, not telling anyone or informing the appropriate agencies is just complete disgusting.
Personally, I hope she get some reprocousions for her actions. Completely unacceptable!!
3 people like this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
Hi kprofgames/ Hatley I don't know if abandoning a child is considered as a criminal offence. I do think the US authorities must make her realise that what she did is really bad. Even if she was tricked by the Russian adopting agency, sending him alone to Russia was not the right solution.
@kprofgames (3091)
• United States
9 Apr 10
Yes it is but I'm not sure how this will all come out. Tricked? I don't know Ronaldinu, even 'if' she was, she wanted this child for her SON. You don't 'give' back a human being and then say you were 'tricked'. If she had enough love in her heart for the boy then this would have never happened - period. If the boy had behavioral problems you deal with it - he is HER son.
You know there are disabilities out there in children that don't show up till later years. Does a parent just say - Oh well, guess you aren't what I thought you were and then throw them to the wolves.
You don't just 'give them back' because you don't want to deal with it. A REAL parent would love them for who they are, their child!
Sorry Ronalinu, this entire story just burns me to the core!
1 person likes this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
I will keep the mother and ensure she be spanked on her bottom.
A rather heartless act to do. I hope that the child won't have severe repercussions because of all this.
1 person likes this
@kprofgames (3091)
• United States
9 Apr 10
I agree dawn, any child coming from another country needs an adjustment period. Odd surroundings, odd people and a whole new way of life - for a small child even within our own country that can be tramatic, but a frick'en NOTE? Oops, sorry my bad, guess it didn't work out - WOW, this woman needs her head examined.
3 people like this
@kprofgames (3091)
• United States
9 Apr 10
I agree that I would keep this child also because realistically, it takes a good year for a routine to set in and for adjustments to really take place.
3 people like this
@zandi458 (28102)
• Malaysia
9 Apr 10
This woman is really cruel and heartless. This is a serious and sad endings that can happen to any adopted children. She should be banned from adopting children in future. She has jeopardized the future of a young boy by abruptly returning the boy to his country of origin as if he is a commodity that can be taken and returned when no longer in use. I hope she can understand the trauma this boy experienced when he is suddenly detached from her, the only mother that he knows and the living condition he is so used to. He is now left in the hands of strangers who will take over his guardianship which might confuse him more. I think the law for adopting children should be applied to safeguard adopted children to those who fail in their responsibilities as adoptive parents. It is only fair that adoptive parents do not abuse their responsibilities once they adopt children. These children did not asked to be adopted in the first place but since they were chosen by some childless couples to fill the void in their life, they should see that they are being treated humanly and not being discarded like unwanted goods when ever they wish. I am a proud mother of two adopted daughters and I don't understand why this lady adopt only to change her mind in the end.
3 people like this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
I think this adoptive mother was really inconsiderate to what might happen when the boy is returned back to the orphanage. I hope that another loving couple comes forward to adopt this boy. If I was an orphan I would want to be adopted by you and not by this woman in question.
1 person likes this
@palonghorn (5479)
• United States
9 Apr 10
Obviously the girl wasn't ready to become a mother. She should have either done a little more research, as many know that a lot of kids up for adoption have been from troubled homes, abuse, etc. Or she should have made sure that it was what she wanted to do. It's not like it was a table she could just return. The way she handled it was cowardly, at the least. It's hard enough raising kids that age when they are your own. I think she needs to figure out what she really wants and if in fact she really wants to 'parent' a child.
3 people like this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
A twenty six year old woman hardly can be considered a girl.
She is supposed to be mature and knows what she wants in life.
@AnnieOakley1 (5596)
• Canada
9 Apr 10
OMG!
I would have thought that great discussion would have been had between her and the adoption agency and that a representative would have been appointed to either escort him or meet him at the other end. I have heard of people arranging to send their 'unescorted' children on flights before and the airline is aware ahead of time and they 'babysit' for the flight. I would imagine it would be a slight charge for this, but at least he would be attended to more than just an adult passenger. I was pretty resourceful and independant at that age, so I know I would have been fine travelling alone, with the stewardess watching out for me. It is not as if he was completely alone. But admittedly, 7 is pretty young and not all at that age ARE able to deal with it alright. The child would have had to be assessed to be sure, by some authority.
But what concerns me, is did she not discuss this with the proper authorities first.
If she felt that the child had behavioural problems, shouldn't she have consulted some counsellors in her own country to document such?
This sounds very fishy to me and it seems that she did transport him illegally, by what the paper says. There should have been some sort of escort for him.
He will be severely traumatized by this, as well, I am sure. A rejection like that will break his little heart.
It certainly seems like a cruel thing to do. She sort of 'took the law into her own hands' instead of consulting the proper authorities and trying to work something out. I mean, if he was her biological child where would she have sent him back to? Don't you work with problems that your children have because you love them?
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
I think that this woman has still a lot to learn about love and being a mother. I had a similar story first hand experience. A friend of mine who adopted a child from Russia was seriously considering of giving her two year old daughter for adoption because my friend believed that this child has learning difficulties. My wife told me that I was "rude" and acted like a bulldozer with my friend. I spoke my mind with this colleague whom I consider like my own sister. I just told her that not even if you have your own kids, they don't come with a guarantee that everything is going to be fine. I do believe that some people adopt for the wrong selfish reasons and not for the child's own welfare. I do believe that there seems to be a "black market" where lawyers, translators charge hefty fees for their services related to adoption. Paying $30,000 for adoption of a child is not a joke. (That's what my colleague paid at least)... I think that this woman should have gone through the proper channel and not send the child back alone to Russia.
1 person likes this
@cupkitties (7421)
• United States
9 Apr 10
Yah know I don't think if they agency lied of not that thats a good enough excuse. Evidently she didn't adopt him out of love. I feel bad for the kid but he's better off not having her for his parent.
3 people like this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
I think that this adoptive mother should learn what unconditional love consist of. Kids are not born with guarantees and even adoptive children ....I hope that this boy gets over it soon
@polachicago (18716)
• United States
9 Apr 10
I think she should be charged for child abuse. First, when child is changing the environment, it is very traumatic. Second, what language hid she spoke with him? Maybe he was frustrating for having communication problem.
Her note is not acceptable for me. They have good doctors in Russia and she should have an evaluation done in Russia before an adoption.
2 people like this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
I think that the US authorities should take this case seriously and ensure that such case should not occur again. This should be an eye opener for russian adoptive agencies that the welfare of children should be put first before any considerations.
@zed_k4 (17589)
• Singapore
10 Apr 10
I agree too.. a 7 year old is a minor in the eyes of the law.. and should not travel alone for sure.. that's pretty irresponsible, I must say..and should have gone through a proper channel..
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
10 Apr 10
Hi Zed. I do think too that the adoptive mother's actions were rather inconsiderate and irresponsible.
@laglen (19759)
• United States
9 Apr 10
I do NOT approve of this behavior. Before adopting a child, you should have an idea of what to do. For crying out loud, the child was removed from his mothers care at 6 years old! He would remember, of course the kid has issues. 6 year old very rarely are placed in adoption because they are well adjusted. I would have gotten him some help. The biggest thing this poor kid needs is unconditional love. That is the only thing that will help him now. To send a child on a 10 hour flight alone..... total negligence. I wont send my 16 year old alone! I would hope that this woman is NEVER allowed to adopt again. Not even a dog.
@laglen (19759)
• United States
9 Apr 10
I agree with you and I hope all countries will reexamine. That poor child. Now, you know I am not a warm fuzzy person, but I shower my kid with love and encouragement. She is my weakness albeit a wonderful weakness. I would gladly take this child. I have trolled bars and offered to take babies from drunk mothers and drunk pregnant women. I have had a few consider, but then once they sober up, they say no. Til they are drunk again. My heart hurts for this child and so many others that are caught up in adults crap.
1 person likes this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
Hi Laglen I do agree with you on this one and I do believe that the airline company must be held somehow responsible. The child should receive unconditional love. He has already been taken out of his "natural" family and being rejected by his adoptive mother. I hope that the right person comes forward to adopt this child. I do think that this story should serve as a wake up call for Russian authorities to check if the adoption system in their country is safeguarding the interest of children or not.
2 people like this
@skysuccess (8858)
• Singapore
9 Apr 10
ronaldinu,
As I read the whole account, I am just dumbfounded as to how this idiotic mother by the name of Torry-Ann Hansen, could actually be qualified to be an adoptive parent when she is found to be a single parent with a natural son.
Is there some fault in the current assessment system?
I hate to say that I just have to believe that there must be a "big hole" there. I mean it is just blatant that she does not need to adopt when she already has a natural son.
I feel that someone is really sleeping on the job and that this woman needs to have the book thrown at her!
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
I have the impression that what matters most to Russian adoption agencies is making money out of all these adoptions. I have know local families who have paid over £30,000 US Dollars for an adoption procedure from Russia. There is certainly a hole in the system.
1 person likes this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
Hi kprofgames in the article there is a photo of the woman with the boy in question. So she must have visited the orphanage. Whether there is a serious study and evaluation of people who want to adopt, I guess that money talks. Greed is the source of most evil things.
@kprofgames (3091)
• United States
9 Apr 10
The adoption processes in some foreign countries are centered around monies and not the children's best interests, this I agree, but where is the protocal? Did she just pick this boy from a picture and believe everything that was said about him? My understanding is the prospective parents meet with the children and then there is bonding time within the country they come from to see if the child/parent can find common ground before shipping them off to the great unknown.
3 people like this
@dragon54u (31634)
• United States
9 Apr 10
What a horrible, heartless thing to do to that poor child!! The woman obviously didn't want to adopt a child, she wanted a perfect little adult. I hope she's haunted by what she did and I hope the boy finds a good and loving home. Of course he has behavioral problems--DUH!!! Orphanage/no parents/no loving care! What was that stupid, selfish woman thinking?!
Many of the children adopted from other countries do have issues because of the way they have been treated and housed. Nearly any child that someone adopts will have problems if they are more than a few days old.
2 people like this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
Even if they were your own flesh and blood, kids can have behaviour or other problems. No child comes with a guarantee. Not even when you might buy a new car or a product because it can turn to be defective. I do expect that children in orphanage have problems. They need time to adapt to a new country and lifestyle. I don't think that life in an orphanage is a paradise on earth. He must be given time to adapt.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
9 Apr 10
No I certainly do not as thats inhumane and so cruel.If she did not want the child she should have been in contact with authorites to find out what she could do legally and morally . I know I woujld not do what she did if I were in her shoes. I would still want to be good to the child even if I felt I could not care for him.I would contain various agencies unti I found the one that would help me to take the child back to Russia and face the people who started the whole thing. Or again were I that mother I might very well decide I could take care of that child myself.
2 people like this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
Hi Hatley I do share your views. In today's age there are various agencies which can help us deal with behavioural problems. I think that if I am not able to care for my child myself, I will ask professional agencies to step over and take over the child but I would never send a seven year old boy alone back to Russia on a ten hours flight.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
9 Apr 10
I would contain oh my typo, I meant to type I would contact various agencies until I found the one that would help me to take the child back to Russia and face the people who started the whole thing. but being me I would really want to just try to raise the child myself. that woman is appalling.
2 people like this
@kprofgames (3091)
• United States
9 Apr 10
I agree Hatley and good day to you. And this woman is supposed to be a professional? She is a nurse and doesn't have enough common sense to know how wrong this is??? I can't tell you how disgusted I am by this whole story. I would hate to be in her shoes right now because of how her own community must be looking at her.
1 person likes this
@syankee525 (6261)
• United States
9 Apr 10
you know that is so sad. we have family memebers who adoted a set of twins and the boy had health issues. but they didnt send them back instead they dealt with it
2 people like this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
This is really sad! Children are not household appliance which can be replaced if they are defective. Children do not come with a guarantee like cars. I think that our materialistic mentality has put our values upside down.
1 person likes this
@AnnieOakley1 (5596)
• Canada
9 Apr 10
Precisely. If he is now her son, she should have dealt with whatever difficulties came along, just like she would have if she had borne him herself. That is what adoption is all about. You can't just...'send them back', like returning a product you bought at a store.
I also know a set of twins that were adopted, but they only really wanted the boy, not the girl, but the adoption agency wouldn't separate them. The girl wasn't treated nearly as well.
3 people like this
@coffeegurl (1467)
• United States
9 Apr 10
Well, first of all, I can't believe this woman who is a trained nurse would react in such a manner. This sounds like throwing the baby out with the bath water. I'm sure this kid must have been abused or something and is having trouble adjusting to a new country, a new home, a new mother. I can't think of anything a 7yr old child could do that could be so horrible wrong that they couldn't get some sort of help or counseling, especially since this woman has ties to the medical community. This is not a cat or "pet" we are talking about that you leave in a basket with a note tied on it because you are allergic, or can't afford to feed it anymore.
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
Hi coffeegurl, even if the child was not abused. He is in a foreign country listening to a foreign language. He needs time to adapt to the new life, new family, new persons. I think that this mother should have sought professional help before taking such drastic action. If she was unwilling to continue with this adoption she should have sought the proper channels and not sending him alone on a ten hour flight.
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
I hope that something good comes out of this story. I do believe that the current adoption system in Russia should be reviewed.
@coffeegurl (1467)
• United States
9 Apr 10
Hopefully this news story will be an embarrassment to Russia. I hope it is, because that is the only way someone will step forward and claim this child once he gets off the plane.
1 person likes this
@farkirikofar (140)
• Indonesia
9 Apr 10
i think it was a very heartless act. if i was her, i would at least accompany the boy until he arrives safely there. it's just like she doesn't care about him just because he has a slight behavioural problem. i don't think this is the kind of woman that will be a good mother.
2 people like this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
I share your views. She still needs a lot to learn what motherhood is all about. Sending back the child to Russia wont solve the problem. If she really knows what love is all about she must have ensured to receive the necessary help to be able to cope with this child. Sending him back to his native country wont' solve anything.
1 person likes this
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
11 Apr 10
No I do not agree with her, that is so awful
I mean what does she expect, the Child needs to learn to trust, realise he is loved and cared for which I do not believe this Mother did
I mean what is this world coming to, it is awful to just disregard a Child like that, who needs security not more insecurity in his Life
What would she have felt if anything would have happened to the Child?
I hope she can never adopt again as she does not deserve Children
I mean if she had given Birth to this Child and it had Problems, would she send it back then?
This is so terrible and unless People are totally committed they should not even consider having Children adopted or their own
I really hope this poor Boy will find a good loving home and I hope the Mother can live with herself for what she has done
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
11 Apr 10
Hi Ronald after reading the Article I am more disgusted, to me it sounds like it was like a Toy to her she did not like the Toy so took it back to the shop, also her being a Nurse is even worse, as she has no compassion
This Child can be damaged for the rest of his Life through this, because he has been rejected by someone he thought would love him for ever, as for the so called Grandmother, well I believe she had a lot to do with it
I really hope that someone will come along for the little Boy who will love him unconditionally and show him that not all People are bad, that he is wanted and special, it broke my heart to see the confusion and Pain on that little Boys Face
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
13 Apr 10
Gabs I felt the same feeling. I wish I could hug the boy and offer him a home. No matter what his disability or what his social behaviour is. I think that most things can be overcome by love. The boy needs stability in his life. I hope that the proper couple who can show him unconditional love come forward for this child.
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
11 Apr 10
You have raised quite interesting points and I do agree with you.
I think that she dealt with this issue in the wrong manner.
there are several other things she could have not but not sending him back
as if he was an unwanted gift.
1 person likes this
@kun2349 (23381)
• Singapore
11 Apr 10
NO matter what, once adopted, means it's their child.. And with all the necessary paperworks done, she cant deny that she's already the mom of that child! It's not fair for the boy, and he will feel that he's like a ball, being kicked everywhere, except for home
I do feel sorry for the boy, but definitely not the mother!! for it's her responsibility to care and teach the boy on how to behave!!
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
11 Apr 10
I feel that she is selfish abdicating from her responsibilities.
She should have been prepared for all eventualities.
1 person likes this
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
13 Apr 10
It is a situation that I find difficult to comment on. When if first heard about this at first I was disgusted with the woman and decided she was a heartless witch but upon reflection I decided that, perhaps this boy has serious issues which she was not prepared for. Having said that, had she had her own biological child who is to say that he or she may not have had difficult problems? As a parent you cannot return your children if they come out different to your expectations and you love them and deal with them accordingly and with as much love as you can muster. When this lady made the decision to adopt and signed on the dotted line she became a parent and no matter how children arrive they cannot be ‘returned’. I don’t know all the circumstances and perhaps I am not qualified to have an opinion here but to reject and send the poor kid back to Russia alone at the age of seven is cruel...If she felt the child had to go back she should have taken the responsibility to accompany him on the flight although I don't think it would have been enough to make her decision the right one...
1 person likes this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
13 Apr 10
Hi paula27661 most of us here including me has juged this adoptive mother in question. What I despise is not her but her act. I mean let say she is 100% in the right, that she was lied by the russian adoptive agency, that they did not do a thorough examination procedures, I still remained perplexed by her behaviour.
1 person likes this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
9 Apr 10
I hope that this story has a happy ending for the child and a genuine couple comes forward to adopt the child. I hope that the mother gets what she deserves for her actions.
1 person likes this
@mike19 (7)
• Portugal
11 Apr 10
In first place, i think that the US adoptive mother behaviour was not the best attitude to have, the mother should try to get in contact with the adoptive agency, in this case the Russian authorities and try to get a kind of answer to the problems that she descrived in the letter that she send with the child, because we are not perfect, adopted or not adopted, sometimes we have problems, sometimes we need to stop and think.
1 person likes this
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
13 Apr 10
Hi Mike Ido agree that her behaviour was not the best attitude. I think that out of this row with the russian authorities, the child has suffered most.