Do you Criticize?
By mr_pearl
@mr_pearl (5018)
India
April 10, 2010 7:04am CST
Hello myLotters... I am sure, different people have different views upon this point. Do you criticize someone for his/her mistakes? Do you like to criticize? There are some people always looking for an opportunity to criticize and boost their own ego. Yes, criticizing others gives a boost to your ego and it hurts the other person's pride. I have read a few books and articles, which always tell about refrain from criticizing others... I have always tried to follow it...
I want to know what myLotters think about it. I would like to share upon this from whatever I have read... Please share...
5 people like this
11 responses
@dloveli (4366)
• United States
10 Apr 10
I have to admit it I am a criticizer. I am a realist. I dont just walk up to people and rag on them. If they ask me, that's a different story. However there are certain situations that require criticism. Sometimes its better to be honest and hurt someones feelings rather than let a person make a damn fool of themselves. People are all about honesty until you get honest with them. I choose to live honestly. If that makes me a criticizer, then so be it. dl
2 people like this
@mr_pearl (5018)
• India
10 Apr 10
Hello DL... Thanks for your valuable response! I admit that there are some situations where one can't control and it is of no use to keep calm... Some people make such mistakes that one can't just sit and watch those.
Tell me, what do you think about parents criticizing their kids, all the time? Or, nagging wives who make it difficult for a working hubby? Or, nagging teachers!! What do you think about them? Are they right???
1 person likes this
@mr_pearl (5018)
• India
11 Apr 10
Hmm... That is right... Being polite while letting others know about their mistakes can be a lot helpful.. I can add a few more things to it... It is no use to let a person know about his mistakes in front of others. I think, it can be done in a private conversation and with mild manners and soft tone... What do you think about this?
@voldrox (7191)
• India
11 Apr 10
Even i have been hurt sometimes, but that is the right thing i guess, i feel guilty for doing something wrong, and i am also glad to get criticized at times, i mean i feel my friends are being open and honest to me, even i am being to them. If i don't like something about them or something they have done which is not right, i let them know about it but very, very politely, and it is not like i am changing them or something but i am only saying it for the best :), if they realize where they have gone wrong then it is good, i just don't want to make things awkward for them telling them in a rude manner, no not at all, i always wish my friends would understand why i sometimes criticize them.. there... I am saying as if i criticize them a lot. It is not that way.
@eloveriz2004 (499)
• Philippines
13 Apr 10
There are two kinds of criticism, one is constructive and the other is destructive. I go for constructive criticism and it's what I usually use in telling others about their flaws, mistakes and shortcomings with the purpose of teaching them to grow for improvement. I also want to be criticized for my wrong actions or for anything unpleasant about me, but it should be done in a most proper and respectful way. I don't want to offend people as much as I don't want myself to feel the same way.
@mr_pearl (5018)
• India
17 Apr 10
Hello Miss... Yes, I also believe in Constructive Criticism... And I do agree with you that it can work. But don't you think, some people can't take it. Their pride is so huge that they always think they are right... And that is why, no one can tell them that they are wrong... I have come across a few such people... I am sure, you know some too... What do we do with them?
@voldrox (7191)
• India
10 Apr 10
Hi pear, well i do criticize but not in the manner you are describing here, i actually do it to bring their mistakes to their notice, sometimes it is necessary, i do it politely, it is meant to be done that way too otherwise it might seem like we are doing it in our ego, and i only criticize people who are close to me, so that they don't make mistakes again, i just be friendly with them that way and i am so glad they are able to understand what i mean to say to them, even i am open to criticism from my close friends and family members, sometimes we get out of track and criticizing politely can be a method to bring back in to the track in a friendly manner... criticizing in ego is being rude to someone, i would be irritated if someone would do that to me to make me feel low.
@mr_pearl (5018)
• India
10 Apr 10
Hello Voldrox... Thanks for your valuable response...
Well, I agree with you. Criticizm should be for the benefit of the person whom we criticize. I trust you are talking about criticizing mildly, simply make the other person aware of the mistakes that he/she has made... And yet, I have read that anyone who is criticized feels hurt. Don't you think, your friends might feel low? I am sorry for contradicting, but I wish to discuss this to the depth...
1 person likes this
@voldrox (7191)
• India
10 Apr 10
Thanks pearl, yes you are right friend, well there is a way to be polite while saying so, like saying 'if i was you i would have committed the same mistake man.' or something like 'i can understand man, but this is something you have done wrong, it is not just you, anybody would have done the same thing if they were you, this is a mistake but take care friend, you need to be more careful next time, to err is human, everybody does that, even me.' .. I guess that would help your friend understand you are being nice to them and helping them out.
@voldrox (7191)
• India
11 Apr 10
Criticizing doesn't necessarily mean to make others feel low, we can actually be helping them out pointing out their mistakes, even i am corrected from time to time from my close friends, they make me realize where i am going wrong, i guess those who are open to criticism can only help criticize others(in a friendly manner again), it would not make much sense if you would criticize someone when you don't like to be criticized, it depends on the person too. I take criticism in a friendly manner, being criticized by others would simply be a mean thing and certainly would sound different, rude.
1 person likes this
@Cutie18f (9546)
• Philippines
11 Apr 10
I think I do this but only sparingly. I am not the type who criticizes everything and everybody. But I know someone who does this all the time. She has always something negative to say about something or someone. Come to think of it, she herself has a lot of flaws and lapses that we can say she has no right to be criticizing others as she herself is flawed.
@charmeleon68 (83)
• Philippines
10 Apr 10
I am a person who is fond of criticizing others. Yah I know at some point, it is really not good to criticize. But it is really hard to avoid especially when you became used with it. But everytime I criticize others, I also look at myself first to look if theres something that should also be criticized on me.
@mr_pearl (5018)
• India
11 Apr 10
I agree with you, my friend.. But look at it this way. No one is perfect. God didn't make all of us perfect. Everyone lacks some qualities, has some drawbacks. So do we have the right to criticize others, when we are not perfect too? Abe Lincoln never criticized anyone in his political career... A former president of USA said that whenever he was tempted to criticize, he would look at Lincoln's portrait and would ask himself, 'What would he do, in such a sitation?'
Thanks for sharing...
@charmeleon68 (83)
• Philippines
10 Apr 10
Yeah we should really mind those things. Sometimes it really puts people into a quarrel and big argumentation are being made. It really has a great effect to those people who doesn't want to be corrected, or those who have a high level of pride. I do criticize if I found something wrong about them. Its up to them if they would take it the other way or just accept it.
@bluemars (952)
• Australia
11 Apr 10
I think for many people if they are aware of the fact that they are doing it, then maybe there is a change for them to stop themselves especially if they are hurting people on a continuing basis. I think it is important to be think about what people may feel and respect people. If you want to be honest with someone I think there are positive ways of doing it without having to do it in some negative fashion.
@mr_pearl (5018)
• India
11 Apr 10
Hello Bluemars.. Thanks for sharing.. I appreciate your answer. Yes, there are many positive ways to let a fellow know that he has gone wrong- like not explaining it in front of others to him, because public criticism is definitely going to hurt anyone... Can you add more to this list?
@blue65packer (11826)
• United States
11 Apr 10
I get critized all the time! All the time! For good reason's and not so good reason's! I still have trouble with being critized. Most of the time it is good critizem. Alot of times if it is good or bad I feel like I'm being yelled at! I still have insecurity issues! I do critize people at times. Most of the time it has to do with what is wrong with some people. Everybody critizes. Some people just do it to increase their ego and others do it in a good way.
@mr_pearl (5018)
• India
11 Apr 10
Hello Friend.. Thanks for sharing... I appreciate your frankness. It is awful to get criticized all the time, for anything. There was a time when it happened to me too, and after some time, I detached myself from family, friends and everyone and lived a solitary life. Now, things are much better.. But I know that criticism has ruined a big part of my life. I don't allow people now, to get on my nerves and tell me what should I do etc...
God hasn't made all of us perfect. So practically we have no right to insult anyone, by harsh words... Constructive and Mild Criticism can help, though...
Thanks for sharing... Have a Happy Weekend!!!
@louierrific24 (1114)
• Philippines
11 Apr 10
Well, I do criticize people which are close to me and it's not to boost my ego it's for them to improve and be a better individual. I always give out constructive criticism and I always welcome criticism pointed against me.
@mr_pearl (5018)
• India
11 Apr 10
Hello friend... Thanks for sharing here.. I appreciate your frankness. There has been a lot of talk about 'mild criticizm', aimed at simply letting the other person know about his/her mistakes in a gentle manner. Thanks for introducing your term here, 'Constructive Criticizm'.
Do you think, the tone of speech, the surroundings would also play a part in Constructive Criticism? Please share your ideas about it.. .
@louierrific24 (1114)
• Philippines
11 Apr 10
Yes, there are so many factors that will come to play in order for a constructive criticism to have weight. Just as you've said, the tone of the speech and the surroundings. In addition, the authority of the one giving out the criticism must also be considered. Why is he giving out these comments? What are his credentials to give such? Why would I believe him?
Another thing that needs consideration is the mood of the one who's getting the criticism.
@edorms36 (275)
• United Arab Emirates
19 Apr 10
I must admit! I do criticize at some point, whenever there are issues that I know is very disagreeable be it at work or at home, maybe we cannot really refrain from doing so because we are all brought up in very different ways, we have different sets of standards that we follow, different values that we adhere to, so with this diferrences, i think this will be a factor why we do criticize, if this were not in unison to our own standards. Right?!!
@mr_pearl (5018)
• India
2 May 10
I agree with you that there are different point of views upon anything and sometimes, one may disagree with a person. But does that mean that one should go ahead and criticize immediately? I am not contradicting, please don't take me wrong Miss...
Tell me, has criticism ever made you feel good about it? No matter, how wrong you may be, did you ever felt that the criticism meant good? Did it do any good to you? My personal experience tells me that criticism makes one feel that he/she has been wrongly judged or hadn't been given enough time or hadn't been understood properly... That is how criticism works!!!
I would suggest you to read Dale Carnegie's books... He explains these concepts amazingly... Thank you for sharing... Have a wonderful time!!!
@mybigwish (7)
• India
11 Apr 10
ya you r right i think that type of people have to be pationce. this is wrong because no body learn from his mother's stomech. i don't like criticize. compromising does't mean that you are wrong its mean that you value relationship much more than your ego.