All play and no imagination?

@SViswan (12051)
India
April 26, 2010 9:30pm CST
The focus of play is now the object and not the activity and kids tire of their toys pretty soon. I find that kids today are easily bored (even with a hundred toys around them). What happened to innovative play and imagination? Does anyone remember the time when we brandished sticks as swords, or used stones to play tic-tac-toe or hopscotch? Howard Chudocoff, a cultural historian at Brown University, who has researched the history of children's play in the United States, says that children's games today focus on predetermined and scripted ideas. What do you think? Are your kids innovative with toys and play or do they keep begging for more toys because they are 'bored' with what they have?
2 people like this
10 responses
@dpk262006 (58678)
• Delhi, India
27 Apr 10
HI SV! You have rightly said that now a days kids do not play innovative games, as perhaps we used to do. Children are not habitual of playing games on Internet and on PC.
2 people like this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
27 Apr 10
Yes DEEPAK; as such they do not get the time, space and opportunity to play outside and run around amidst good surroundings[with pollution all around].On top of it these computer games is another idiotic diversion.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Apr 10
So instead of prending they are a super hero, they use an avatart on some videogame. It is sad.
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58678)
• Delhi, India
27 Apr 10
OOps! I wanted to say - children are now a days have become habitual on playing games on internet and PC and the innovation is no more there.
2 people like this
@Aussies2007 (5336)
• Australia
27 Apr 10
I think you will find that the parents of those children are doing exactly the same thing. Children learn every behaviour from their parents. Since the parents of today need the very latest technology in order to be happy, so does the children. Those who can afford it, get a new car, new computer, new mobile phone, every two years. And that's only the tip of the iceberg. Digital camera, ipod, wide screen TV, etc. In fact, the parents are more childish than their children. lol
2 people like this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
28 Apr 10
Though I hadn't thought of that angle, hey, you are right! Parents are trying to get the all the new gadgets in the market...even when their old one is functioning quite well. They are like big kids in the toy store...lol
1 person likes this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
28 Apr 10
Aussies 2007
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
27 Apr 10
I do not have a child who can play with toys now but the days of my son playing with toys are fresh in my memory. His, was a collection over a period of time.Right from when he was one , my husband used to get him a book and a toy periodically.He was very creative with whatever he was given.He would never ask for anything because he was a very quiet, adultlike and sensible child.He would be happy with whatever was given and would make the best use of this. He never asked for any new toy out of boredom .However there were two small rubber dolls , one of a wrestler and one of a saint with beard.He used to bang one against another making them fight.They were his favourites and like homefood after restaurant food at a stretch, he would get back to these . He would suddenly be seen with this and never grew tired of this. Later he had an unimagineable number of toys and they used to be strewn all over the floor in a room.I allowed him full freedom with them.Being an only child he spent all his time with toys and books .
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
28 Apr 10
lol..sounds like your son is like my older son. My younger son is very different from my older one but he's creative with his toys in his own way. My point was that the kids didn't really need other people or newer toys everyday to keep them occupied. Of course, my younger one keeps asking for vehicles because he is fond of them...but he learnt to count and read with them...and invents new games almost everyday.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
30 Apr 10
My sons have friends in the apartment. There are groups of boys and girls of different age groups here. Except for the adolescent boys who are a bad influence (more so because of the backing of their parents - 'boys will be boys, you know'), the company is good. I was trying to get the other boys to realize the importance of other games like 'Seven tiles' and '4 corners' and games they can invent. The tweens are excited about this aspect and the teenage boys were also ready for something new and creative....but their parents refuse to budge and force them to play football in the apartment complex where there is no place. Talk about killing creativity! I keep a watch over my son's friends too. But unless it is a really serious issue , we talk about how he can handle the situation better without being influenced by the peer group. If most of their activities are against what I believe in, then I might have to stop him being with the particular group because however mature and responsible my son is, repeated interaction will influence him.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
28 Apr 10
But there is one important thing Snadhya. In our days we ahd friends with whom we could play , who would brandish these makeshift swords and blow whistles out of a coconut green leaflet[or whatever you call it] and play four corners and simpple games.How we loved the company! I must confess that I kept an eagle eye over the company that my son had kept and was watchful all the time lest he falls into bad company.Today, I hear of a neighbour's adoloscent son [13 yrs old] falling into bad company and bunking classes , justifying my extra protective attitude. Coming back to the point, these children do not have the opportunity or time that we had in spending with our friends and as Aussie had pointed out, if people are going to get readymade toys why would children look for makeshift ones?
@drannhh (15219)
• United States
27 Apr 10
Although I do not have children, having been an elementary teacher before I changed to university lecturing, I do follow what is going on with "play" and I agree with your implications that play has changed from something tirelessly creative to boring scripted materialist forms. The activity should be the focus, not the material aspects in my opinion. Good play involves critical thinking and no mindless activity is going to remain interesting for long.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
27 Apr 10
Kaleidoscope  - The game where pieces of different shapes need to be fixed together to form a pattern or design.
When I shop for toys for little children, I get bored even before I've started....a monkey drumming, a seal twirling a ball, a dog flipping over! How long can a child sit and look at these and not get bored? There's nothing to do with them! Unless a child figures the dog wants to jump over the sofa and be 'Super dog'! But mummy doesn't want too much noise and 'playing' inside the home! 'Kaleidoscope' (not the one where we looked at different creations...the game) keeps my son occupied for hours...and he loves creating his on designs not just the ones given in the booklet...and that's something he can do when his friends aren't around. Now that we have stopped the boys from playing football and cricket inside the apartment premises(due to lack of space and damage to property), they have started creating their own games with things they can find outside or in the home. I'm glad they are putting their brains and creativity to good use. The older boys (the teenagers) and their mothers have started complaining. I wish they would utilize that energy to do something constructive...there are so many games they can play with balls in the space that we have.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
28 Apr 10
I'm not against ball games and I agree the kids need exercise...but there isn't enough place within the complex for ball games and we all knew that when we took up our apartments. There is an open ground right next to the complex(not ours but no one's using it at the moment and can be used by the kids to play...another advantage is we can see the kids playing here from our apartments...it's not too far that we need to take them there). I'm just a little irritated that they insist on the games that have been forbidden.
@drannhh (15219)
• United States
27 Apr 10
I used to love to play ball games as a child, and in fact I still do. I guess that is why I go bowling 2 to 3 times a week now that I am retired. Games that involve healthy exercise also stimulate the mind. Sounds like you are doing a great job providing a good environment for youngsters. I imagine you get all the exercise you can handle just keeping up with them!
• United States
8 May 10
First of all, it is the parents choice to give so many toys, when what the child wants in inter-activity with others. Not always with mom, but other children, family members ect. How many books do you read to your children? How do you perk the imagination of a child? It isn't always the toys if they don't have a clue how to. That is taught either by parents, outside influence or if there main activity is TV it will be what they see on that, that triggers their imagination. I chose to limit TV, computer, and game console's as my children grew. They were outside playing, they played with other children. Mom and Dad would get out there and play too. It all works with the development of the minds. If you want your child to succeed in life you need to give them that foundation before they are 5 years old. They learn the most in those first 5 years of life. Give all you can is what my opinion is, to teach them.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
26 Jun 10
Sorry for the delay in my comment. I wasn't notified. But I agree with what you say totally. We need to limit TV and computer and spend more time with young children. Most people use this as a baby sitter nowadays which limits their creativity.
@besthope44 (12123)
• India
28 May 10
Well i feel play by talk..telling stories and asking questions. The power of asking questions will improve their imagination and more knowledge.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
26 Jun 10
So true..thank you for your response.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
27 Apr 10
I think a lot depends on parenting and we could devote more time with the kids that develop a sane and beautiful life ensuring all that matters. Certainly, today the children have a different thinking pattern and gone are our days when we were uninhabited, happy and carefree. They are stressed out, bogged down by projects which require avid internet research. They are unhealthy and letting go of their creativity. Its sad how the system works these days also.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
27 Apr 10
It is really sad that the educational system and we adults are trying to make them 'grow up ' before their childhood is enjoyed.
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
7 May 10
I havent that problem and my grand daughter has a great imagination so much so that otehr grandma thinks she is weird hummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm she has the other grandma no imagination at all only thing she can do it repeat every thing I do and say grrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
@SViswan (12051)
• India
7 May 10
lol....yes, I find that people nowadays think that kids with imagination are weird. They would rather keep them quiet in a corner with some toys that they bore of easily and keep asking for more.
@Lakota12 (42600)
• United States
9 May 10
and if they dont wan tto play then some want to punish the kid grrrrrrrrr
@bird123 (10643)
• United States
27 Apr 10
It's time to play with your children and point them in the right direction.
@SViswan (12051)
• India
27 Apr 10
How many of us do that anymore? And I also feel that we are much more concerned as parents of the present generations...much more than our parents were. I do not remember my parents telling me what to play or spend time with me (beside the occassional board games and dinner and time we spent to talk) playing and guiding in my play.
@beesm17 (107)
• United States
27 Apr 10
I think if you take the time to play with your kids and help build an imagineation that you wont have this problem. My 19 month old can turn anything into a toy. He never gets bored unless he is stuck in the car or cart.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
27 Apr 10
Yes, that's the natural process for a child. But we tend to bog them down with so many toys since they are so little that they expect to be entertained as they grow older.