Is Manila ready for an earthquake?
By TheAdvocate
@TheAdvocate (2392)
Philippines
April 27, 2010 1:54am CST
Did you watch the CNN report on Manila's preparedness for an earthquake? Since I live in Marikina, and the fault line is called Markina Valley Fault Line, I took a look at a map to see if I live near or under a fault line. It seems that the name is a misnomer because it actually runs across Quezon City, Pasig to Makati.
The CNN report mentioned a Japanese study made in 2004 that has not been fully disclosed to the public. The report said that if a magnitude 7.2 earthquake hit Manila, it would damage 38% of homes, 1/3 of public buildings and will cause 50,000 casualties.
Of course, I was scared. I have been researching on disaster preparedness. I was a victim of Ondoy, and I think that with a little more preparation, we could have avoided being victims.
What about you and your family, do you have a disaster preparedness plan? Do you live near a fault line, and if so, what steps have you made to ensure disaster preparedness? Or is it que sera sera for you?
Finally, is our government ready to deal with such an eventuality?
4 people like this
19 responses
@Theresaaiza (10487)
• Australia
27 Apr 10
So far, and thankfully, Bohol has never been stricken with very tragic disasters. Sometimes, even when there are forecasts or threats of a coming calamity, on the day that it is said the calamity will happen, we seem to be spared from it on the last minute.
But I would have to admit that if ever, God forbid, our luck should run low, we are never really prepared for anything. Even when there are threats of a coming calamity, we barely even move a muscle. We just shrug and confidently say that God will again spare us this time.
Thanks for your post because it made me realize how vulnerable we are in case a certain calamity will occur.
1 person likes this
@Theresaaiza (10487)
• Australia
29 Apr 10
A lot of people here have been slowly influenced by the less conservative lifestyle of our neighboring provinces and well that tends to mess up with the religiosity as well. Thanks for the wonderful things you said about our place and its people.
Faith is not enough without works so aside from prayer there must be precautionary measures as well.
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
Bohol is probably one of the most religious places that I have seen. The churches are old and holds a lot of history. Boholanos are very prayerful and will leave everything to God. I suppose if its your time, then there is nothing you can do, and nowhere that you can hide.
@greencard13 (317)
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
We can prepare when a storm is coming but we will always be caught off guard when earthquake strikes. I think our government is doing all they can to prepare for natural calamities such as earthquakes. LRTA conducts an earthquake drill and it is successful. Schools are doing earthquake drills too.
Let us hope this earthquake you are saying will not strike us.
1 person likes this
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
2 May 10
Before an earthquake, I was thinking more along the lines of structurally sound houses and buildings. Although on paper, the requirements for securing a permit and the inspections conducted by the government should ensure safety during earthquakes, we all know that the corruption has blocked an effective implementation of the safeguards.
Post-earthquakes, and in the event that disaster strikes, we both know that the National Disaster Coordinating Council is also a disaster in this area.
@salonga (27775)
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
I think it is good to be prepared for all these calamities but how to be prepared is the biggest question. How do you prepare for an earthquake? If our buildings were constructed as it were in Japan then that is a good preparation but I don't think all our commercial buildings are like that. Most of our homes are definitely not either. Well to me, my only preparation is prayer. In good times or bad times, I don't cease to pray so that the Lord will continuously protect me and my family even in times of disasters. The trouble with us people is that we only go to God when we are in trouble. When every thing seems fine...we set aside God. We must remember that it is only in God's wings could be find the most secured shelter. Only He has the power to save us from all calamities. No amount of preparation is greater than the the mercy of God.
1 person likes this
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
29 Apr 10
That is true. We forget God when we don't need a miracle. And when we do, we demand that it be done in an instant.
The best preparation for an earthquake is proper construction. But we all know that this is the last thing on the minds of developers. Profit, profit, profit...
@strawberrychocodahi (4818)
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
Prepared? much better to say if we are spiritually prepared because no matter what happens to us, we know that God is the one that holds our life and we can be with Him.
No matter how the government is said to prepare the place or any agency is there to assist, if it is called by nature, we cannot do anything nor we can't control it. I am talking about the magnitude of the quake, we will never know how or when is it going to happen and where will it hit. We just need to pray to God for mercy and protection specially to our loved ones.
1 person likes this
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
2 May 10
That is true. According to one report I read, if the earthquake is 8 or more, then no amount of preparation will help us. But for a 7.2 quake, we have a fighting chance if we prepare for it. However, as the report said, Metro Manila is not prepared even for just a 7.2.
@juancarloboss (137)
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
I think Manila City is not yet ready for any kind of devastation like an earthquake.
Look what happen to us from Ondoy experience.
1 person likes this
@Kisha14 (117)
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
I dont think so cause most of the buildings here are still old and most of the people in the squatters area is not aware what they are going to do when earthquake comes. We don't have enough advance equipment to be protected during earthquake.
1 person likes this
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
29 Apr 10
I have yet to see a government plan where they would prepare people from the squatter's area in the event of an earthquake. They probably think that nobody's going to die from being buried under a pile of wood. :)
@chiyosan (30183)
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
we can never be ready for such events when it actually happens to us. believe me, we can prepare, we can train, have a funds ready - but nothing will prepare you for the actual events when it occurs. Just make sure that you are alert, and will not be tensed when it happens - you can save your life and you can also save others if you remain calm and if you think clearly under such circumstances.
As for the government, they can be prepared for it, maybe have a fund ready with them... maybe they can have the troops out already in matter of minutes - but i doubt it. Ondoy has caused so much and the government's rescue efforts was ineffective and let people wait a couple of hours - not minutes trapped in their homes, etc.
1 person likes this
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
That's true, there can never be adequate preparation for an earthquake given that it cannot be predicted yet. What I meant to say was disaster preparedness. In the first place, the study said that we have a lot of buildings which are not structurally sound and will definitely not withstand a 7.2 earthquake. Secondly, despite our experience with disasters, we never learn. Remember the Baguio earthquake? It took several days for the government to start work. And as you said, Ondoy shone a spotlight on the government's inadequacy. I was one of its victims, and we waited overnight for any kind of help. None was forthcoming. My local government did not have enough boats. My goodness, how is that possible when we have a river running through our city? We had rubber boats which could not fight the current.
My point is that we have to prepared for the worst thing that can happen to us. The problem is the government prepares only for rain and not a storm.
@anne25penn (3305)
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
To say that our government is ready for such disasters is like saying that pigs can lay eggs. My brother has asked me to prepare an emergency bag since Ondoy. I live near Marikina and when Ondoy hit, we were like semi-isolated. And in such eventuality or disaster, a lot of people tend to panic which adds to the damage. You can see it in big fires where there are so many bystanders (miron) that add to the firefighters dilemma. Our hospitals are also not equipped for large scale disasters too. Ondoy was one of the wide scale disasters that we experienced and everyone saw how our government responded, which was as we say, a disaster.
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
No, it was not a disaster, it was a COMPLETE disaster!
As we were victims of Ondoy, my family has made several disaster plans if anything should happen like Ondoy. Now we have to add earthquake to our list of disaster we have to prepare for.
@rsa101 (38166)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
You are right about that. With what we are seeing from our surroundings we never are prepared for any disaster that will hit us. Yes, there are some efforts for the government to prepare and equip themselves with emergency kits around but then when were hit like the ones like Ondoy we aren't prepared at all. I guess the best thing to do is for each to brace for what is yet to come. I have attended a seminar for disaster preparedness and even the NDCC that spoke with us accepted that there will really be casualties no matter how prepared are you in times like earthquakes and other calamities that will strike us. And NDCC will always be unprepared no matter how they trained and equipped themselves when the major calamity happen. We can see that with Chile lately and they are one of the most prone to be hit by earthquakes so they have strict building codes and their disaster preparedness is well planned but when they were hit by the major ones they still are unprepared to see the destruction. Although one thing good with them is the citizens seems to be prepared because the casualties are lesser than the Haiti.
In the seminar they pinpointed the places that will be hit bad by a major earthquake, unfortunately Marikina is one of the places mention because it is located on a ground that is classified as soft soil mainly like Makati and some parts of Pasig. These areas when shaken violently would loosen soil and could create liquefaction which is a dangerous thing if you are standing on it.
@rsa101 (38166)
• Philippines
5 May 10
Actually no one is really safe anywhere else in our country if we are struck by a strong earthquake like the ones in Chile and Haiti we would all be helpless like they are in their respective countries. We just have to be prepared for it every now and then because earthquakes are there to come.
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
5 May 10
That was very informative. Thanks!
First Ondoy now the earthquake threat. I think God is telling me to move out of Marikina lest I perish in a disaster. I don't want to move out of Marikina as this has been my home for over thirty years. But for my family's safety, we might have to.
@eileenleyva (27560)
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
First and foremost, pray hard the earthquake with that magnitude does not happen to us. Second, since you say our vicinity is prone to such a disaster, always be prepared. Keep exit doors free from furniture. The 1990 quake had its epicenter in Pangasinan. But Baguio was hit hard and isolated. When that quake shook us in QC, I was comfortable on a sofa. It was so shocking I couldn't move. We can never be prepared absolutely.
1 person likes this
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
I was in school and despite all our drills, we never got to practice them when the earthquake happened. We just sat there wondering what was happening! Although we did file out of the building quickly but peacefully.
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
I may have been misunderstood in this discussion. I think I said disaster preparedness, and so to me, that means how to meet the disasters to minimize loss of life and property. Of course, nobody can be prepared for an earthquake since it cannot be predicted. But they can certainly prepare for the disaster that will happen. Plus, you can mitigate the damage if you make buildings structurally sound. The point of the report is that Manila, although lying along a fault line, has a lot of unsafe buildings.
@nangisha (3495)
• Indonesia
2 May 10
We in Indonesia has face big scale earthquake and few of it caused Tsunami. Tsunami has taken so many victim. I hope our Government more prepare when it happen again, because its something we can not avoid and preparation will save more life. We can not chose where we born and I think we just need to adjust to it.
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
2 May 10
Our countries are both in the Pacific Ring of Fire and so we share the same kinds of issues and concerns. Does your government have people devoted to disaster preparedness and response? How are they doing? We do have a National Disaster Coordinating Council which has regional branches too. Unfortunately, this government agency is not well-prepared and well-equipped.
@mercedlegurpa (955)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
I live in ParaƱaque City and I just hope an earthquake would spare our country from that devastating event. Who's not scared of an earthquake; everybody does. But I believe in prayers. Surely if we pray a miracle will happen. I think that our government is not ready. When did you remember that our government is ready? Ready for election maybe. The answer is positive. Our government officials are only ready for debates, nonsense talks, and grand standings. In the Philippines, the only city or province that does not belong to a fault line is Palawan. We should be ready. It's not que sera sera for me. I pray for my family, for the Filipinos who could not do something to alleviate their misery living in distressed areas and I pray that God will uses His power to punish the corrupt government officials.
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
5 May 10
I hate to add to your list of things that we are not prepared for, but we are also not ready for an automated election judging from the failure of the CF cards. :)
Palawan is not a bad place to go. Imagine waking up to the sound of the waves hitting the beach and the smell of clean air! Hmmmm...
@mercedlegurpa (955)
• Philippines
5 May 10
Yes you are right; I believe that CF cards is a manipulation between the Comelec, Smart and China. Remember it was China who made these PCOS machines. Is it possible that results could be readily available if you manipulate it? What I meant could it be programmed in CF cards? Of course this administration resort to all resources just to make their candidates win. I don't like to vote if this is the case; maybe my vote would go to the other party. I hope God would intervene.
@jpnnetwork (306)
• Philippines
27 Apr 10
I think manila is not ready because as you can see many structure are not so durable and old.. if other big countries can't get rid of that calamity manila will surely too.
1 person likes this
@myliezl0903 (2726)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
hi there! i live in san juan city though its kinda far from marikina fault line still we wouldn't know if we are safe when we an earthquake hit us. nobody knows who are safe so it is better to know much about anything on how to find ways when that time comes. be sure to read relevant things on how to deal on calamities.have a nice day ahead!
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
5 May 10
Yes, nobody can truly say that they live in a safe area especially when it comes to earthquakes. I hope that the government will act on this report and at least ensure structurally sound buildings. San Juan does not have a lot of high rise and probably will take a very strong earthquake to wreck havoc on your city.
@maanrodriguez (604)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
That is really scary news. I know we have been through a lot of earthquakes but personally I have never experienced it. I was either too young or too asleep. I'm not sure if the government is ready for such calamity. Although we did good with Ondoy, an earthquake is still a different thing.
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
2 May 10
You're lucky in that respect. Boy, that must have been one deep sleep! I remember my brothers went to the province a few years back during one election year to help in the campaign of a relative. Anyway, while they were sleeping, an earthquake shook their bed. Our house in the province is reputed to be haunted, and so when the bed shook, they all ran outside and refused to go back in the room. They all slept in the sala. The following morning, when they learned that it was an earthquake, they laughed at themselves. But you know, saranggola, my point is, they were awakened by the quake. How could you not? :) LOL
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
dear theadvocate,
here is hoping that it doesnt come because it would really do a lot of damage to properties and lives.
i guess the government is not at all prepared for the eventualities. what they will do is ask help from other countries. they are so used to doing that during calamities even if it continues to happen every year. unless a leader with a political will, would do something.. then it is going to stay that way..
sooooo sad.
ann
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
2 May 10
I join you in your hope. I was hoping to hear from the candidates their plans for these kinds of eventualities. I do not want to be like Haiti where the residents could not return to their houses months after the earthquake. I do not want to rely on foreign aid to stand up again. I know though that I am hoping in vain.
1 person likes this
@setsuna26 (2751)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
All we can do is to prepare ourselves for the worst scenario. I mean philippines will be more than just a sitting duck if that much of an earthquake will hit the country. Look at those other rich countries that were hit recently no matter how ready they are casualties and damage will be enormous, thats why all that we can do is hope for God's guidance most of the time
@Saranggola (956)
• Philippines
28 Apr 10
When did Philippines ever become prepared in dealing natural calamities? Was there a time that we did?
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
2 May 10
I doubt if we ever were prepared in the past. However, I was hoping that we could learn from the past and at least make a token effort to save ourselves from being another Haiti. I know I am hoping in vain though.