Profiles lacking crucial Information, are you bothered?
By barehugs
@barehugs (8973)
Canada
May 9, 2010 8:23am CST
When I respond to a newbie discussion on myLot, I always check the profile for gender, age,and country of origin. Perhaps I'm nitpicking, but this additional information helps considerably when making a response. Of late, however I'm finding the profiles lacking of this critical enlightenment. Often when there is no personal material offered, I feel handicapped, and just move on to another discussion.
Do you like to have personal facts at hand while responding to a new myLotter's Post?
Are you bothered by a blank profile?
4 people like this
19 responses
@Gemini68nOhio (134)
• United States
9 May 10
Rather i want to participate in a discussion or not, i could really careless about someone's profile. The only time a profile matters to me is if i wanted to meet that person and date/or be friends. I'm only on here to relate to others on shared interests.
2 people like this
@oldchem1 (8132)
•
9 May 10
To be honest this is something that I have never done.
But thinking about it it makes good sense to know just how to reply to a person in the best way by knowing age, nationality etc.
I haven't really checked any profiles yet so can't answer about the blank profile question, but I shall certainly check out profiles in future.
Thank you for the advise
2 people like this
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
10 May 10
The information in the profile states 'location' and not 'nationality. The two are different but many misinterpret that information.
My location is correct and is Italy. Does that automatically make me Italian?
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
9 May 10
Well barehugs I'm with you. some discussions can be responded to easily with out know where a person is from hoe old they are or what country they are from. Then there are discussions that need to be more specific to the discussion and know this information makes it easier to give a better response.
2 people like this
@sid556 (30959)
• United States
10 May 10
No, you are not being nitpicky at all. I've run into the same situations a few times. In some discussions it does help to know the country they are in as their culture makes you a little more emphatic as to why they are thinking as they do. Recently I got accused of being "derogatory" because I referred to a poster as "she". Now I took the time to look at the profile and the gender was not listed. The name didn't really offer a clue so I just went with she. Apparently if in doubt, "He" is the gender to use. I seriously did not know that. I was told that I used poor grammar by using "she" instead. I got straight A"s in Grammar all throughout school and I NEVER heard that one. So yes, I for one do understand where you are coming from, Barehugs.
2 people like this
@bunnybon7 (50973)
• Holiday, Florida
9 May 10
me to. i always like to have at least a slight idea as to who im talking to. maybe im just to open. but i dont understand all the paranoia. I mean, hows anyone going to get me and know my address etc. just by me saying im female, age, state i live. i mean geesh how many thousands females live here anyway? so i think maybe they are hiding something for another reason, not a good reason yes i often will not even friend them here or any other social site
@picjim (3002)
• India
9 May 10
I never look at the profile unless the question is a bit tricky.I prefer to concentrate on my reply.Though as you say a glance at the profile will help us in tailoring our response to the person and his preferences.Initially in any website i'm a bit careful in revealing all personal details as i'm apprehensive of misuse.So i give this benefit of doubt to newbies but there is no reason to withhold information after we have gained confidence in the veracity of the site.
2 people like this
@pmbhuntress09 (1608)
• United States
9 May 10
I only have one problem with that, The site is honest, but how do you know all of the people that may visit your page are? I had to delete my old account because of a stalker, he even knew what town I lived in and where I was because he had an IP tracker on his profile page, he knew my exact address. So its visitor beware.
2 people like this
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
10 May 10
Barehugs are you aware that there are Lotters with profiles stating that they are females but their activity is that of a male and vice-versa? Anyone can enter anything in their profile data and until they are caught they get away with it.
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
10 May 10
It is my opinion after three years of Lotting that the profile information can be very deceiving. You look at a profile and read 'location' and are assuming it to be origin when it is not always the case at all.
You are assuming that all Lotters are honest (not true either) and have stated their correct gender and age.
The only way to know a user is through their words in the discussions I can assure you. Much of the information, if it is there, is correct but a lot is not and to me it makes absolutely no difference whatsoever when I am responding to a discussion.
1 person likes this
@barehugs (8973)
• Canada
10 May 10
I know what you mean, but I will take the information in the profile at face value. It makes no difference to me, (or to the discussion). What ever makes this person happy, is ok with me. We can have a good discussion, although somewhat fictitious, no matter where we are coming from!
1 person likes this
@cupkitties (7421)
• United States
10 May 10
Hmm I don't really think about that. I can usually determine the age of the person by the question thats being asked or by the content of their discussion. There are certain questions or things I might not discuss if I don't know the age for certain but other than that I'll try and answer for what I believe their understanding may be based on what I've read from them.
1 person likes this
@redhotpogo (4401)
• United States
9 May 10
I don't pay attention to people's personal information. I don't need to know it. It does not have an effect on our discussions. I think many people hide it for fear that it might be used against them. That they'll be judged on it. For example someone might say that a person is too young to understand something because of their age, or might have something against a country that someone is from. To have a real discussion you must not think about who the person is, and where they are from, or any personal details. It will just cloud your mind.
1 person likes this
@barehugs (8973)
• Canada
9 May 10
Well, we are on different sides of the fence here! To me it makes All the difference!
Before you can have a real discussion you need to know- the persons gender, age, and country ( cultural background) How many times have you talked to someone in real life, and Had a"Good Discussion," without knowing their age, gender or cultural Background? To accomplish this you would have had to have been blindfolded, and deaf (so you would not have been able to determine their gender, or age, from the sound of their voice!) This My Good Man is simply Crazy! Are you really sure about this?
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
10 May 10
I agree with pogo's views here. Just because location is one place does NOT mean that the user was born and bred in that country at all.
@redhotpogo (4401)
• United States
10 May 10
barehugs- why would you need to know this information? how does it help you?
@pmbhuntress09 (1608)
• United States
9 May 10
I personally have never been into anyone's profile to look, to me its of no interest unless if they want to add me as a friend, then I may or may not go and look. But to me that info is the persons choice to add or not. I don't care to have everyone in the world have my information. Why would it bother me if some of theirs is missing. Its privaye info, that we may want to keep to ourselves.
2 people like this
@prince05 (92)
• Philippines
9 May 10
personally, i am bothered responding to a person's discussion with a blank profile. knowing the profile of that person, somehow would help me understand
why he reacted that way on certain topic or issues..personal background, culture, and experiences the like can affect a person's way of looking at things around him...this is also what i need to grasp and understand fully the message the person is trying to imply.
1 person likes this
@barehugs (8973)
• Canada
9 May 10
We think the same way here! Age, gender, and country of origin and necessities when answering a Post. The responder needs an idea of the cultural background on which to base his response. A teenager girl from China will not grasp the significance of the response if its directed to a senior male from Greece.
@mysdianait (66009)
• Italy
10 May 10
So a user who states their location as China is what? Chinese? Why? They might have been there when they registered but could have been born anywhere at all.
There are many youngsters here who have placed their age as older and older people who pose as younger and that shows in their posts if we take the time to put the two things together.
Profile information is not always what it appears to be at first glance and location is not the same as origin.
@Pigeonrose (31)
•
10 May 10
No, I'm not bothered at all. Anyway, it's everyone's privacy not to publish enough infos about their profile. It's the content of the discussions that attracted me in reading or answering some discussions in mylot not the user's profile at all.
1 person likes this
@mlloyd23671 (28)
• United States
9 May 10
i dont really think that profile information is persay important in regards to answering a discussion. i mean will it determine whether or not you are willing to answer? Or will it change the content in which you are going to write? i feel like if the question is simple thenanswer it... but if not and you don't have the patience to figure it out... then move on
1 person likes this
@jugsjugs (12967)
•
9 May 10
To be honest i never take alook at some of their info but on the od ocassion i will take a peek at the discussions they have started aswell as respond to a few of theirs.I often get friends requests and i do sometimes have a peek like to see their interests to see if they have the same interests as me.I am not too worried about their info.
1 person likes this
@homeshoppers (6166)
• Philippines
9 May 10
since their profile did not affect my earnings then no problem with me at all since its their decision to hide their profile. same as mine, i keep my profile private coz sometimes i tell my personal story here in mylot and its my own way to hide my real identity, not to mylot but to those users who might know me from here in my country as we can never tell, mylot have our profile whether we hide it or not. thats the reason why we also have an option to hide some information about our profile. you can even hide your gender if you want too. its their means of keeping their privacy so we must also respect them. what matter is we are here to share discussion and as long as they're not doing bad things to us then let it be as they might be here to earn, nothing more nothing less.
1 person likes this
@mac_fish (723)
• China
9 May 10
I'm not definitely.
I'd like to leave the personal infor aside and pay my attention to the topic he/she starts and what I'm gonna respond to the post started.
Why do u have to check the private profiles filled in the blanks of self infor before leave ur comments,I donnt think the lacking of such sort of things will influence u to fail ur comments,there are ever no relations between private infor and topic itself.......
Happy mylotting
1 person likes this
@adeena2000 (845)
• Philippines
9 May 10
I am also doing the same thing like you, sometimes you find way how to position your answer to someone that you didn't even know the gender and age. Your response sounds like you are talking to an old man where in fact he was a teenager, Sometimes it's like you are talking to a mommy but the fact is she is single. There is anonymi of character. So what I did, I just answer it in general way.