Do you believe Smartmatic's explanation why some COCs were dated April 29?
By TheAdvocate
@TheAdvocate (2392)
Philippines
May 20, 2010 7:11am CST
Some losing candidates asked Smartmatic officials in Congress why some COCs were dated April 29. Smartmatic said that these were glitches in the internal clock of some PCOS machines. They apologized for the oversight.
On one hand, it is possible that the internal clock were also powered down when the PCOS were turned off after they were tested. On the other hand, aren't they suppose to just continue working just like in computers?
Do you believe that this was a mere oversight on the part of Smartmatic? Is the explanation acceptable to you? Should Smartmatic and Comelec be made to answer for these oversight? Are the glitches so great that the results and the credibility of the election were compromised?
3 people like this
7 responses
@Ritchelle (3790)
• Philippines
21 May 10
gee, i don't know if i can make a smart reply but your topic is interesting so i'd try:
well, if they were turned down the clocks are supposed to be off since these are not computers connected to the net all the time. at least it's a sign that it was turned down. however, this would also make you ask why some computers were turned down then and why others were not (based of course on the fact) that the other computers' clocks were updated. unless otherwise workers of smartmatic were able to update some clocks of the compueters and weren't able to update the others. which somehow compromises their working ability.
1 person likes this
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
21 May 10
That's interesting. So internal clocks of computers are kept in time through the net? I thought all along it was the battery which kept it going.
But following your logic, you have a point. If all the pcos machines were powered down as instructed by Comelec after testing, then how come only a few had this glitch? And further following your logic, why was this minor but important detail left out in the instructions?
Let's not forget though that these PCOS machines were made in China ...
2 people like this
@ybong007 (6643)
• Philippines
21 May 10
If both smartmatic and comelec can prove that the transmission of casted votes from the flashcards are tamper proof then i would consider the dates on the PCOS as mere glitches. We don't really have to go anywhere else, a lot of questions about the PCOS were raised because there are people who thought that there was cheating. What the Smartmatic, comelec and even the people behind every hearing that's now taking place have to do is go the root cause of the problem which is the transmission of votes. People in this country would always find minor problems and make it big by calling for a press conference and enjoy their fifteen minutes of fame in the process in the hopes of using it as propaganda in the next elections. Sad thing is, media even take the bait easily and blow it all out of proportion.
1 person likes this
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
21 May 10
This really proves that nothing is perfect in this world. Although I would like to give Smartmatic the benefit of the doubt, the whole fiasco about the CF cards makes me skeptical this time. Now, these so called "glitches" is the reason why losing candidates are trooping to Congress for their 15 minutes of fame.
With the track record of Smartmatic and Comelec I have my doubts whether they could get to the root of the problem.
1 person likes this
@ybong007 (6643)
• Philippines
22 May 10
I don't know the reasons why comelec awarded the contract to Smartmatic but i think the main consideration was the cost. I can't blame them since it's about time we move a different direction and that's the automation. And they have to do it within the budget we can afford. But in the process, comelec failed to hire a top notch computer savvy person to check how the machines really work. I think comelec relied too much to what Smartmatic says the machines are capable of and in the process set aside the possible problems that would arise. They failed to put checks on the possible scenarios that would arise like claims of cheating. they should let the IT guys do the talking because from what i see, lawyers are not doing any better.
@rsa101 (38166)
• Philippines
20 May 10
Well I think these were serious glitches as it created lots of doubts as to the credibility of the machine. I think this things should have been sorted out before they were delivered. I think now it is getting clearer that this automation has also its imperfections in the system after all. After several days being taunted as the best now the glitches seem to put some cloud over the reliability and ability of Comelec to actually hold automation.
1 person likes this
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
21 May 10
I am still reserving judgment whether the glitches were serious or not. On one hand, as pointed out by Locsin, the dates were suppose to be safeguards so that any cheating can be traced. On the other hand, judging from the CF card fiasco, it may be that there were really issues that were overlooked. Even the Comelec overlooked the UV lamps, so I can see how such things were overlooked. It does not bode well for Comelec.
@aprilten (1966)
• Philippines
21 May 10
I won't say that I believe their explanation but that could also be true because just like our pc it has a default date and time that's why we need to adjust it so we can have the accurate time. What I can't take is how come they overlooked to adjust it to the correct date when it is very important to do that. This is an election and there should be no loopholes otherwise the losing candidates will find every way to protest the outcome.
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
21 May 10
That is true, they should not have overlooked such a seemingly minor but very important detail. The automation was suppose to stop allegations of cheating. Instead, they handed losing candidates another reason to cry foul.
@Aphroditei_5279 (2465)
• Philippines
20 May 10
Hi TheAdvocate! I think it's not a mere oversight. It might be a glitch. But they should have checked that already. How could they not know that the date would be reset when the PCOS would be turned off or restart? It's a bit too simple for such a big company that were praised for their experience in that field. They should give a concrete answer to the Comelec. Because the credibility of the next election would be also jeopardized.But I don't believe in the cheating allegations. Because, in the presidential run, it is so obvious that two very different party are winning candidates. I wish the losing candidates, would be a little bit more constructive in pointing fingers. It's always a she said he said kind of circus. That's why issues are not resolved and lessons are not learned. Because everyone wants to be the hero. And blame this and that. (^^,)
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
21 May 10
Well, judging from the CF card fiasco, I can imagine them forgetting such a simple thing as the clock. That was because of the spacing, and they botched up all 76,000 more or less of CF cards. So its no stretch of the imagination on my part if they indeed forgot this one little detail. Makes me want to roll my eyes.
You're right you know. The credibility of the next election is at stake.
1 person likes this
@Aphroditei_5279 (2465)
• Philippines
21 May 10
Yes, I agree with you there. Maybe they overlooked it because it was so simple. But, yet, they still have to come up with a concrete explanation. So that the speculations will stop. And also all this stir is also putting our next government officials in jeopardy. The credibility of our leaders and the credibility of our country. Will our country ever changed? I don't mind complaining about each and everything as long as solid proofs are provided. Solutions are given. And resolutions and consequences implemented. But sometimes, it's all talk and no implementation. Sometimes, it seems like politicians looks like peacocks or roosters during a "sabong" event. (^^,)
@juancarloboss (137)
• Philippines
21 May 10
I believe to smartmatic's explanation ,it is possible to change the date because the memory of clock depends only to the source of power built in the PCOS machine.
@TheAdvocate (2392)
• Philippines
21 May 10
But as ritchelle (discussion on top) pointed out, how come the glitch did not occur in all the computer?
@mrfdg1972 (3237)
• Philippines
21 May 10
I was very very very much in favor of Automated election but for starters, i wanted it to be accompanied with manual voting to confirm the results, just for 1 time only, and the Commission on Election did not allowed
@mrfdg1972 (3237)
• Philippines
21 May 10
SO is there any hints for Election Fraud, It came from the commission itself. They dont want to check if the actual pcos count tallied with the ballots/votes casted.