Life, Death, Family, and "things"

@olydove (1209)
United States
May 29, 2010 2:16pm CST
Long story short, Family has never known how to be a "family." Mom recently died, uncle had to pay for her funeral. Little brother was supposed to inherit the car. You never disputed that and even said from day 1 you don't want the car. You told your mom not to leave you anything except a special music box because you didn't want any trouble with the family. Family has decided her car will be sold to pay uncle back. You take uncle to the doctor in your vehicle and he says "You take your moms car you really need it" again you say "No I do not want it or the problems it will bring." Uncle is insisting over the next few weeks and asks you if you had talked with older brother about it. You stall and give excuses hoping that older brother will have the car sold or whatever soon. Finally you realize you can't stall uncle much longer so you tell older brother what is going on and tell him again you do not want the car, never even hinted that you wanted it, and that he can have the car if he'd like. Older brother response and says to you "you are the only one that has come up clean and clear here" "how come you got the house and now the car?" "it does look like you are the only one who benefits and the rest pays" You are hurt because you have always looked up to the older brother even though he has kept himself distant from the family, and you respond by telling him again you never asked for anything but the music box, and reminding him whom has been here with mom for the past 4 years and whom has not. Ends up words get exchanged, your "family" is now even more destroyed than it already was. Now the hard part... Your uncles health is fragile he's not expected to live past the end of the year. Do you tell him what happened with your brother, or keep making excuses?
5 people like this
8 responses
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
29 May 10
olydove you brother acted like a jerk, and you bent over backwards to please him and the family. Your Uncle is really pretty savvy and he is going to know if you keep making excuses that there's trouble so please for his sake so he will not fret tell him the truth. Honestly is always the best policy really.Your Uncle already knows that there's destruction in your family so this is not going to be really that upsetting. do not lie to him thats really worrying to older and ill people. be honest with him.
@olydove (1209)
• United States
12 Jul 10
Hi everyone, I have an update but i haven't had much sleep and am very emotional so I won't be updating right this minute. Possibly later today. Yes Hatley I agree my brother acted like a big jerk. Unfortunately I haven't talked to him since all this I'm still very hurt by his actions. Needless to say I told uncle the truth and all has worked out for now. I'll be back with a more detailed update soon.
@syankee525 (6261)
• United States
30 May 10
i think i would keep it to myself because you really dont want to upset him so he can worry about myself. its sad about the brother, yeah i know i am always there to help my dad out, no one else makes the time to help him out. and why i have told anyone except my sister that my dad just gave me lot of money to help us out with our bills since we are disable. you just keep doing the right thing that is what matter, i guess some cant face the fact they should have and could have done more and its showing how grateful your mom was for you being there for her
1 person likes this
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
29 May 10
There is a saying, "You can't pick your relatives." If there is a message in your discussion it is that everyone needs to have a will so that there will be no questions or disputes over material things. Care for your uncle as best you can. Keep making excuses for your brother as long as you can. Family is about love and not about name. Sometimes you have to distance yourself from someone who is blood but who makes your life difficult and painful. I hope you got your special music box. I am only 55 but I have 9 grandchildren. One of them loves a music box that I have in my bedroom and we wind it up and play it again and again. She is two. She is also in my will. No one will get that music box but her.
1 person likes this
@climber7565 (2579)
• United States
30 May 10
I am so sorry about your loss. Sure those kind of issues within family are and must be so delicate and explosive, specially when most don't want to be grown ups to accept their consequences and responsibilities. I say tell the uncle what goes on straight out, why keep him in the dark. Have a mediator resolve it all once and for good.
1 person likes this
@ohiocy (214)
• Malaysia
30 May 10
Indeed a sad and heart breaking event, waves after waves, stay strong though.. If it was me in your shoe, I would lie to my uncle, because that is not something I should concern him with. Then the rest I would seek help through prayer, that is all I can say.
1 person likes this
• United States
30 May 10
I think that you should tell your uncle about the situation. Explain to him that you don't want the car and that your brother wouldnt give it to you even if you really did want it. You should be honest with him, do you really want to take a chance on your last words to him being a lie. Be honest, it will make you feel better!
1 person likes this
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
2 Jun 10
Crazy, was there a will? I wouldn't say anything to the uncle. I don't think he really needs to hear about that stuff at this point.
@leighm88 (97)
29 May 10
I don't think any of us can make that decision for you olydove :( What do you want to do, do you want to tell your uncle or do you want to keep making excuses? I can understand why you want to keep this from him as you want his final months to be peaceful and happy. Do you think there is anyway that this can be resolved? Does your uncle know that your mum intended your brother to have the car? You could tell your uncle that you wouldn't feel right driving it as your mum wanted your brother to have it. I don't think it's very nice that your brother said those things to you, but I accept that everyone deals with grief differently. Maybe it meant a lot to him to have your mum's car, maybe he feels guilty for not being there and that is why he is snapping at you. I think the best thing to do would be to try and resolve things with your brother. Is there anyway that you could take the car and just let your brother use it, and then give it to your brother at a later date.
1 person likes this