Do you agree that television hampers children's reading.

@oldchem1 (8132)
June 21, 2010 6:20am CST
After reading a few of Roald Dahl's wonderful 'Revolting Rhymes'to my grandkids, I pondered on Dahl's little poem called 'Television', if you've not read it , here it is: [b] - 'Television' - by Roald Dahl[/b] [i]The most important thing we've learned, So far as children are concerned, Is never, NEVER, NEVER let Them near your television set -- Or better still, just don't install The idiotic thing at all. In almost every house we've been, We've watched them gaping at the screen. They loll and slop and lounge about, And stare until their eyes pop out. (Last week in someone's place we saw A dozen eyeballs on the floor.) They sit and stare and stare and sit Until they're hypnotised by it, Until they're absolutely drunk With all that shocking ghastly junk. Oh yes, we know it keeps them still, They don't climb out the window sill, They never fight or kick or punch, They leave you free to cook the lunch And wash the dishes in the sink -- But did you ever stop to think, To wonder just exactly what This does to your beloved tot? IT ROTS THE SENSE IN THE HEAD! IT KILLS IMAGINATION DEAD! IT CLOGS AND CLUTTERS UP THE MIND! IT MAKES A CHILD SO DULL AND BLIND HE CAN NO LONGER UNDERSTAND A FANTASY, A FAIRYLAND! HIS BRAIN BECOMES AS SOFT AS CHEESE! HIS POWERS OF THINKING RUST AND FREEZE! HE CANNOT THINK -- HE ONLY SEES! 'All right!' you'll cry. 'All right!' you'll say, 'But if we take the set away, What shall we do to entertain Our darling children? Please explain!' We'll answer this by asking you, 'What used the darling ones to do? 'How used they keep themselves contented Before this monster was invented?' Have you forgotten? Don't you know? We'll say it very loud and slow: THEY ... USED ... TO ... READ! They'd READ and READ, AND READ and READ, and then proceed To READ some more. Great Scott! Gadzooks! One half their lives was reading books! The nursery shelves held books galore! Books cluttered up the nursery floor! And in the bedroom, by the bed, More books were waiting to be read! Such wondrous, fine, fantastic tales Of dragons, gypsies, queens, and whales And treasure isles, and distant shores Where smugglers rowed with muffled oars, And pirates wearing purple pants, And sailing ships and elephants, And cannibals crouching 'round the pot, Stirring away at something hot. (It smells so good, what can it be? Good gracious, it's Penelope.) The younger ones had Beatrix Potter With Mr. Tod, the dirty rotter, And Squirrel Nutkin, Pigling Bland, And Mrs. Tiggy-Winkle and- Just How The Camel Got His Hump, And How the Monkey Lost His Rump, And Mr. Toad, and bless my soul, There's Mr. Rate and Mr. Mole- Oh, books, what books they used to know, Those children living long ago! So please, oh please, we beg, we pray, Go throw your TV set away, And in its place you can install A lovely bookshelf on the wall. Then fill the shelves with lots of books, Ignoring all the dirty looks, The screams and yells, the bites and kicks, And children hitting you with sticks- Fear not, because we promise you That, in about a week or two Of having nothing else to do, They'll now begin to feel the need Of having something to read. And once they start -- oh boy, oh boy! You watch the slowly growing joy That fills their hearts. They'll grow so keen They'll wonder what they'd ever seen In that ridiculous machine, That nauseating, foul, unclean, Repulsive television screen! And later, each and every kid Will love you more for what you did.[/i] Do you agree with the master, has television spoiled our children's reading?
6 people like this
21 responses
@ElicBxn (63643)
• United States
22 Jun 10
I am of the first generation that grew up on TV. I still love to read, but I have to say that there weren't - to quote Bruce Springstein - "57 channels and nothing on" back then, there were, maybe, 4 and there wasn't much on! It also wasn't 24/7 either. AND a lot of the programs weren't so "lowest common denominator" either. We had Playhouse 90 and other good shows as well as "I love Lucy" (that I hated by the way.)
1 person likes this
@hvedra (1619)
23 Jun 10
I agree, the amount of programming for children when I was small was limited. There were three channels and they only had a couple of hours each day dedicated to kids programmes and even then a lot of it was more simple and innocent than we get today. A lot of shows today are like extended toy commercials, there's always a product attached!
1 person likes this
@paula27661 (15811)
• Australia
23 Jun 10
It is not just television these days. I have seen my eight year old daughter who usually loves to read put her favourite book down and get on the computer where she would spend the next three hours. I am an avid reader and I spend a lot of time on my laptop because I write. I introduced my daughter to books when she was still in playgroup and we used to go to story time at the library every week where she would listen to the story, do some crafts and take a couple of books home to read. It is up to me now to get her off the computer or away from the T.V. and remind her of the joy of books! It is our parental responsibility to ensure television time is controlled for our kids.
1 person likes this
@ShepherdSpy (8544)
• Omagh, Northern Ireland
22 Jun 10
There's two apt quotes about TV that I recall off hand.. One of them is "Most Inventions were Time savers...and then came Television"! and the other one is "Television is Chewing gum for the Eyes"... TV has some uses in eduction and entertainment,but plonking a child in front of one "For Company" is a bad idea..It's been proven that developing babies need to interact with a real face and voice to gain the social interaction skills we need..TV does NOT do this,and should not be used as a substitute.
• Omagh, Northern Ireland
23 Jun 10
And then we wonder why there's a burgeoning obesity problem when we're turning kids into couch potatoes from an early age!
@oldchem1 (8132)
22 Jun 10
Too many people nowadays seem to rely on the 'bpx' as entertainment for the kids!!
@choybel (5042)
• Philippines
21 Jun 10
Okay, first of all, I have to compliment the poem, so simple, so clear, and all so true - so fine and so divine (now I'm starting to rhyme ). Yes indeed, I do agree that Television and many other technological gadgets have replaced the once so beloved books, not only for the children but also for the adults, the teenagers, the next generation - the youth. I, too have become enslaved to internet and gadgets while before I used to spend so much time in reading books but now I could barely finish one in half a year. I think that children should be taught to appreciate the fantasy world through reading rather than through the shows in TV, which are mostly, as the poem stated, shocking ghastly junk. I am now, once again inspired to read, and to write poems. Thank you!
@choybel (5042)
• Philippines
21 Jun 10
I'll try checking on that...thanks again...
@oldchem1 (8132)
21 Jun 10
You should read the whole book of Revolting Rhymes, they are really for children but are fantastic. They are Roald Dahl's take on traditional fairy stories [i]I guess you think you know this story. You don’t. The real one’s much more gory. The phoney one, the one you know, Was cooked up years and years ago. . . .[/i]
@megamatt (14291)
• United States
21 Jun 10
In many ways, I think it has. Most children would ignore a good book unless forced to by school, in favor of watching whatever show is on television. Of course, if I am a child these days, I would be mortified with the horrid quality of the programs available. Then again, during my childhood, there was more television available. Of course, I always used to read during the commercial breaks, so I got the best of everything. Still, its horrifying to see how many children think that a book is a chore. They might read more when they are older I think but during these early years, a love for reading has to be established right away. It is sad that more kids will watch Hannah Montana for hours upon hours, but not read a book. Television is good but it should not be your only form of entertainment.
@oldchem1 (8132)
21 Jun 10
How right was Dahl when he said [i]In almost every house we've been, We've watched them gaping at the screen. They loll and slop and lounge about, And stare until their eyes pop out. [/i] Spot on, I'd say!! I was lucky with my older kids that there was only around an hour a day on the TV, in fact when my oldest daughter was born we didn't even have a TV until she was 18 months old!
@airakumar (1553)
• India
22 Jun 10
I agree with megamatt that television has really hampers children's reading in many ways. Excessive television viewing among children has been linked to a greater risk. Child's mind is very sensitive. He learns a lot from nature and his surroundings. It is necessary to gather good knowledge from various sources to make healthy brain. Television is a central media for entertainment as well as developing personality.
@de_toya (2429)
• Indonesia
22 Jun 10
Yes I do agree to you even before I read the Dahl's little poem above. I realize that television will affected bad things to my children and I see it in my boy behavior. He is 4 years old now. Everyday since he was 3 years old, he always in front of television. Start from six in the morning till eleven. Nothing can do since I and my wife are busy in the morning and go to work till half past twelve. No one care and play with him in the morning. Now, it's very hard to ask him learn and he always have his imagination to be his hero in television. He act as his hero and tend to act rude. We are going to send him to kindergarten next month on July in other to keep him away from television and he get many friends there. I hope he may learn there.
@de_toya (2429)
• Indonesia
23 Jun 10
I think so but I have a doubt whether he won't bored there since he is now 4 years old and he is allowed to enter the elementary school when he is 7 years old. He must stay in kindergarten for three years. Oh... that is very long time for kindergarten stage.
@oldchem1 (8132)
22 Jun 10
I am sure that he will love his time at kindergarten, they are very good for children and stimulate the mind
@whyaskq (7523)
• Singapore
22 Jun 10
I cannot deny that children are not addicted to the television once they are hooked onto it. I personally would forgo reading and choose to glue my eyes on the screen instead. The reason is that visual catches my attention more than the letters of the alphabet. The only reading I do is the subtitles if applicable.
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Jun 10
Hi Oldchem when my girls were small we just had standard TV channels BBC1, BBC2, ITV and Channel 4 and there were childrensprogrammes on only on an afternoon for an hour or so and on a Saturdaymorning so yes we read a lot more, these days with Freeview and Skyetc it is 24/7 so I limit my son to his hour a day otherwise yes he would be glued. He doesn't seem to be as interested in readingas the girls as outside all the time being active however we do have a book to settle at night rather than the TV. I think there is far too much. I rarely watch spend most of my time working, doing chores and flitting in between onto here. Load washing machine, answer a discussion, make beds, post a discussion, cook tea, answer a few discussions if oven dish lol. Huggles. Ellie :D
@oldchem1 (8132)
21 Jun 10
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
22 Jun 10
I absolutely agree with him that television has spoilt childrens level of interest in reading but the measure of correcting this problem is rather extrem and not the best. Television is both good and evil. We must never lose sight of the fact the it is the lack of time that parents have to spend with their children which has contributed to them being so engrossed with the TV set, DVDs etc. I have the same challenge with my nephew here and even though he is a smart boy and a top student at school the effects of too much TV and less interest in reading is quite evident. I do not blae it all on the Tv but rather on the amount of time we spend reading to him and having him read to us. Funny I found this discussion now as I have started to spend more time with him and cutting his TV time. There are some really nice educational programs and even comedies on TV which he enjoys watching and we let him. He learns to express himself and explain things even more as we watch and discuss these programs as well as laugh about them. So for me it snot about throwing out the Tv set but rather cutting the interaction time there and spend more time with the children.
@eileenleyva (27560)
• Philippines
21 Jun 10
When my elder child was 3 months old, I opened a book of Snow White and told her the story while feeding her with milk. I saw her eyes follow my fingers as I point to each and every dwarf. Since then, my daughter had been reading all the books she can read. When I introduced the Disney animation on television, my daughter was already 3 years old. She loved The Little Mermaid and we watched it over and over again. But that did not fixate her on the boob tube. So, I believe that children take the cue from us. They won't sit and watch tv if we parents don't want them to.
@oldchem1 (8132)
21 Jun 10
Of course they do, I enrolled each of my children in our local library when they were a few months old and took them every week for new picture books and then they progressed to story books!!
@hvedra (1619)
23 Jun 10
Not just television - which has been around for quite a long time now - but the amount of "on a plate" visual stimulation they get nowadays is phenomenal. Television now has entire channels of children's "entertainment" (mostly extended toy commercials IMO), DVDs, computer games and so on. They don't have to imagine anything for themselves and I find that sad. They also don't have any patience with books or non visual information which means they miss out on so much.
@abj163 (1037)
• India
21 Jun 10
yup it is true that children are avoiding books just because of television and video games.....a book is the one and only thing that can change our mind.....i read book of DR apj abdul kalam last year and my mind got totally changed.....now i have decided to join indian airforce because i wanna do something for my country......but the television cant do this...television cant divert ur mind .......it only destructs u..... happy mylotting
• United States
21 Jun 10
your comment doesnt make any sense. Television is the single biggest propaganda medium in the history of man. I will agree that TV isnt the bet thing for people, but your comment makes no sense
@rosie230 (1704)
21 Jun 10
I totally agree. From a personal point of view I have always been brought up with a television to watch, and although my mother did read to me when I was younger, I never really wanted to read books growing up, it just seemed unfashionable. But now I love reading books, and feel sad looking back that I missed out on reading so many good books, so I kind of make up for it now. My little one, as you know loves to watch some of the programs that are on TV these days, and I do not mind, so much as he only watches a little of it. But bought him a few of those cardboard books a while ago, and he actually loves those more so than the TV. He loves the bright pictures and following words that I am reading to him with his own finger now. Books are so much better for kids I think they learn better and catch on to things quicker, I know that we as parents can teach more than the TV to our children.
@oldchem1 (8132)
21 Jun 10
There are so many channels now tough for children it is so easy for parents to rely on the TV
• Philippines
22 Jun 10
Yes, in some ways it has. Learning through reading was greatly diminished by television. To combat this, i have "imposed" reading in a fun way to my son. 1. Exposure to books as early as my child turned a year old. 2. Reading stories before bedtime 3. Bringing him to bookstores as well as other book exhibits. 4. Encouraging him to "read" to his playmates 5. Encouraging him to exchange stories with his playmates, mostly of which came from the books he read. By doing these things, I have sparked his desire to read books as well to share stories that he read among his friends. He is always fascinated with each page as he stares at the colorful pictures. I believe this is the only way with which I can help my child develop his imagination, creativity, knowledge, by learning through reading and discovery.
@oldchem1 (8132)
22 Jun 10
Your child is really very lucky to have such a good start
@Mitraa (3184)
• India
22 Jun 10
In my view Chem, allowing children to watch TV for a couple of hours daily is advisable! But more hours with TV is really killing of their creativity and useful time that is desired for study and rest purpose! I have seen that TV kills most of study hours, rest hours and playing hours, which creates an imbalance in time and work management among children! Another factor is that children should watch more the study oriented programs from TV. Elders must moniter this! Thanks for this useful topic and also special thanks for the nice poem!!
@cripfemme (7698)
• United States
22 Jun 10
I think that a lot of TV is stupid. However, Sesame Street, the Discovery Channel, and programs like Dora educational and good for children it stimulates the visual cortex. This is different stimuli than you get by reading.
@Jennlk84 (4205)
• United States
22 Jun 10
I definitely do agree. It's so unfortunate. I LOVE to read! I am a teacher currently employed as a nanny. I read with the children I work with multiple times throughout the day. I love seeing the children choose a book over a TV show any day, but unfortunately you don't see it often anymore. I do think the reading programs within schools that encourage so much reading each day is great! That encouragement really helps create the lifelong habit of reading for pleasure :-) It allows children to see "it's not so bad" to use that imagination!!!
@mimiang (3760)
• Philippines
22 Jun 10
it could distract the children but if he reading material is good, they will keep on reading
• India
22 Jun 10
yes tv hampers the reading of children a lot
• India
22 Jun 10
Yes oldchem. It really is a sad thing. I find children sticked to their cushions when watching TV. As an old saying goes " If it wasn't for that the TV and the fridge were so far apart, many of us wouldn't have any exercise " Though there are quite a number of useful programmes in the Tv, we can often find children watching non-sense. well its in our own hands (remote) to change watch we watch. Thanks for the useful post and that poem is really good. You must have a lot of patience to type the whole of it. I really appreciate your effort. Regards, Ash