are they (ariel,luna,cut tari) guilty?

I can not judge their guilt or innocence. But I am sure, those in the video. The video was made was years ago, and they may have regretted that they were doing and wanted to forget. But the video it appears now, and everyone blames them, as if they were the most sacred. What they did was wrong, they deserve to be punished, but they are entitled to be given the opportunity to improve themselves, without having to be punished by the police, they've got their own punishment. Indeed by providing deterrent punishment can make them and so no one will imitate them, but I think they've learned his lesson. While the result of the video that the young generation, young people actually depend on their own. Without the video, the younger generation are familiar with a similar video, so all depends on the younger generation and their parents.

actually i dont know how to say. but i think police and depkominfo must to act hurry to prevent a bad impact this video to many kids and teenagers

According the teachings of their religion they profes is clearly wrong must recieve punishment in the world oif they proven quilty and should be in accordance wit the law of wrong. The effect from this problem they be bad for children, youth and adults

In my opinion if they did it for private collection, legally they are not guilty as long as they keep the video locked in the drawer and nobody sees that. However, I think morally they are guilty. They are all muslims so they know that they may not do it before they get married. Now that the video has been released publicly, they have become guilty both morally and legally. So, the police have the authority to arrest them if it is true that they are the people in the video.

guilty or not, is a matter of judicatory process, which might be proven on the court. however, i think the punishment for them is already here to stay. the videos cost them their name, reputation, career, and so on. however, it'd make me sick when they still ignorantly refused to admit what they did, and even still managed to "play victim" about the situation... what a fake...

I do not have any comments about them. What they did was a mistake, and maybe they are very sorry for their mistakes. They must feel ashamed, angry, tired of facing all the problems they face now. No one wants to talk about something bad. I am sure they really tormented by this problem. hopefully they can get out of this problem and realize all their fault.

The problem that occurs is now increasingly widespread. Who should be punished is still not clear. ariel now been named as a suspect. There are various opinions that appear on the set ariel as a suspect. I am very confused in responding to this case. Since this is something unusual happens, and it never happened. This issue became big because they are artists. I just remain neutral on this issue. I just do not like the person who thinks he is right and feel the most holy people.